News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by heavyset_go on Saturday October 02, 2021 @02:14PM (#28730705)
This is a good example of how innovation, competition and small businesses are being stifled by the anticompetitive behavior of the mobile app distribution cartel.

Consider contacting your state's Attorney General office, and the US Attorney General office. Many states' AG offices have antitrust divisions[1].

The US Dept. of Justice also has an Antitrust Division[2], along with a page that details how and why[3] to get in touch with them:

> Information from the public is vital to the work of the Antitrust Division. Your e-mails, letters, and phone calls could be our first alert to a possible violation of antitrust laws and may provide the initial evidence needed to begin an investigation.

The FTC has the Bureau of Competition[4], as well.

[1] https://www.naag.org/issues/antitrust/

[2] https://www.justice.gov/atr

[3] https://www.justice.gov/atr/report-violations

[4] https://www.ftc.gov/about-ftc/bureaus-offices/bureau-competi...

Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by threatofrain on Saturday October 02, 2021 @04:33PM (#28731841)
It should be noted, as discussed by other HN people below, that there is a good chance that author (edit: not OP) is quite sketchy.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28730865

At the very least, they are not telling their story with an attitude of transparency.

Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by heavyset_go on Saturday October 02, 2021 @06:27PM (#28732667)
> It should be noted, as discussed by other HN people below, that there is a good chance that author (edit: not OP) is quite sketchy.

It should also be noted that this is just an opinion. I don't find it to be sketchy.

Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by busymom0 on Saturday October 02, 2021 @05:30PM (#28732257)
Note that I am the "OP" as in I posted the link to HN but I am not the author or the developer whose story this is about.
Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by pdonis on Saturday October 02, 2021 @03:27PM (#28731267)
> This is a good example of how innovation, competition and small businesses are being stifled by the anticompetitive behavior of the mobile app distribution cartel.

No, it's an example of how small businesses are foolishly making their business model dependent on a company that is known to be unreliable. What should be happening is that mobile app distributors should not be depending on Google at all; alternate mobile app stores should be out-competing them by providing better service to developers. If there is a "cartel" that is making that difficult, it's not the mobile app store gatekeepers, it's the mobile phone companies that are tilting the playing field sharply in favor of the Android phones they distribute, which are tied to Google Play Store, instead of allowing free and open competition in phone operating systems.

Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by advisedwang on Saturday October 02, 2021 @03:34PM (#28731327)
What else is a mobile game dev supposed to do? Ask customers to sideload? Tell people to use f-droid? If they do that they're restricting themselves to a tiny fraction of the possible audience and thereby removing any chance they have of being profitable.
Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by pdonis on Saturday October 02, 2021 @03:49PM (#28731452)
> What else is a mobile game dev supposed to do?

Start a startup to make a mobile app store that out-competes Google. Somebody is going to have to do it sooner or later. Young devs with nothing to lose are the best people to try.

Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by sircastor on Saturday October 02, 2021 @04:17PM (#28731706)
Epic tried to get people to sideload Fortnite, and it was not successful. Epic is a billion dollar company. The right content is not the problem here.
Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by anonymousab on Saturday October 02, 2021 @04:01PM (#28731563)
> Start a startup [...] that out-competes Google

You know, I don't think that "just be better than the trillion dollar incumbent" is a reasonable starting point for any healthy market.

Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by pdonis on Saturday October 02, 2021 @05:23PM (#28732216)
> I don't think that "just be better than the trillion dollar incumbent" is a reasonable starting point for any healthy market.

I'm not proposing this solution because I think it's easy. I'm proposing it because I think it's the only one that has any chance of actually fixing the problem long term. Government fiat won't fix it; it will make it worse, the same way government fiat in general makes problems worse, not better.

Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by patmorgan23 on Saturday October 02, 2021 @06:40PM (#28732751)
Or MAYBE the solution is to enforce antitrust and pro competitive market laws.
Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by 6510 on Saturday October 02, 2021 @07:12PM (#28732973)
Automated replies should not be a thing.

Refusing to disclose the reason why someone gets banned should not be a thing.

Imagine a land lord doing this?

Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by AnthonyMouse on Saturday October 02, 2021 @06:16PM (#28732601)
Government fiat generally makes problems worse because the government is a monopoly and a monopoly has little incentive to do things well because of a lack of consequences for getting it wrong, unlike a business in a competitive market which has to respond to competitive pressure or go bust.

But a monopoly/cartel isn't a competitive market and has the exact same problem.

And antitrust is minimally damaging as long as you restrict the targets to companies that have more than, say, 25% market share. In other words, as long as it places no constraints on upstarts and challengers.

Because at that point, blindly causing harm to the large incumbents is actually good even if it's hamfisted and incompetent, because then the market can fix any damage by transitioning to smaller suppliers not subject to antitrust rules, which is the thing that actually solves the problem. The worst thing they can do is fail to do enough damage to the incumbents to restore competition, which is the same thing that happens if they do nothing.

Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by pdonis on Saturday October 02, 2021 @07:07PM (#28732936)
> Government fiat generally makes problems worse because the government is a monopoly

That's one problem, yes, but not the only one. Good government is a public good, and elementary economics tells us that public goods are underproduced. Or, to put it another way, concentrated special interests have a larger incentive and more concentrated resources to corrupt government, than dispersed individuals have to keep it from being corrupted.

Also, governments aren't quite monopolies as long as people have the right of exit--if you don't like your state's government, you can move to another state, and if you don't like your country's government, you can move to another country. Granted, the transaction costs for such moves are high (particularly for the latter), but many people still do it. That exerts at least some competitive pressure.

> a monopoly/cartel isn't a competitive market

It depends on why it's a monopoly. If it's a monopoly because of special privileges granted by the government (which most monopolies are and have been historically), then yes, it's not exposed to competitive pressure. But if it's a monopoly because it provides better quality and lower prices for its products than any competitors, then it is exposed to competitive pressure--and it's succeeding at dealing with it. That's not a monopoly; that's a win for the free market.

The real problem with a company like Google is that its users are not its customers, so the whole idea of "competitive pressure" in the usual economic sense doesn't even apply. Google has no incentive to provide products that benefit its users, other than the fact that it needs a critical mass of users to be attractive to its actual customers (advertisers and other companies to which it sells data and access to users' eyeballs). What's more, since Google's users do not pay for its products and services, Google has no idea how valuable those products actually are to users, since it has cut off the best source of feedback--what users will pay for.

> the market can fix any damage by transitioning to smaller suppliers not subject to antitrust rules, which is the thing that actually solves the problem

That only solves the problem if the problem is that the smaller suppliers can provide better quality and lower prices to customers. But that's not even the problem with Google; see above. Google's actual customers don't want smaller suppliers, because Google's value to them is precisely its size. Breaking up Google without changing the basic business model would just create huge incentives for its customers to game the system, getting pretty much the same things they are getting now, but just with more maneuvering under the table.

If the government is going to do something hamfisted at all, the obvious thing to do would be to outlaw the ad-supported business model altogether. Make Google, and Facebook, and every other such platform, charge users a fair price for the services they provide, and let users, in a free, competitive market, decide what services are worth their cost. But of course that would be politically insane, because the users themselves don't want to pay for those services; why should they, when they've been conditioned to have them for free for so long? Only weird outliers like me would actually applaud such a move; I'd be happy to pay Google some reasonable fee per month to use search and maps (which are the only Google apps I use) if in exchange my data was no longer sold to third parties. But it doesn't seem to me that most people would agree with that.

Another suggestion I've seen is for the government to force Google, and Facebook, and every other such platform, to open up the APIs for all their services, so anyone could write their own client. That would enable clients to be written that didn't show ads and didn't do all the other tracking that Google's and Facebook's own clients do. But if Google and Facebook are still stuck on the ad-supported business model, again, that just creates huge incentives for them to game the system, creating new hidden back channels for their actual customers to get the data they need while pretending to have a free, open, public API that any client can use. Clients can only hide so much; at the end of the day they still have to make requests to the API, and those requests contain the basic data that the platforms are selling.

> The worst thing they can do is fail to do enough damage to the incumbents to restore competition

No, that's nowhere near the worst case. The worst case is something like locking down the entire Internet, so, for example, a site like this one can no longer even exist.

Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by wombatpm on Saturday October 02, 2021 @08:04PM (#28733323)
Right of exit is a false right. You can leave Hati for a country that is the same or worse, just not better.
Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by AnthonyMouse on Saturday October 02, 2021 @08:44PM (#28733539)
> Good government is a public good, and elementary economics tells us that public goods are underproduced. Or, to put it another way, concentrated special interests have a larger incentive and more concentrated resources to corrupt government, than dispersed individuals have to keep it from being corrupted.

This is true, but is no reason to abandon the attempt to prevent this, because it's still a matter of degree. More to the point, large companies will engage in regulatory capture and try to use regulation to stifle competition regardless of whether individuals try to exert pressure on governments to preserve competition.

> Also, governments aren't quite monopolies as long as people have the right of exit--if you don't like your state's government, you can move to another state, and if you don't like your country's government, you can move to another country. Granted, the transaction costs for such moves are high (particularly for the latter), but many people still do it. That exerts at least some competitive pressure.

By this definition nothing is really a monopoly. If there is only one grocery store within a 999 mile radius, you could say that it isn't a monopoly because you could go to one which is 1000 miles away. It's a monopoly in practice because the cost of patronizing the "competitor" is too large.

> The real problem with a company like Google is that its users are not its customers, so the whole idea of "competitive pressure" in the usual economic sense doesn't even apply.

Even if you accept the framing then in this context the users who aren't the customers are the "product." They're the suppliers. In exchange for eyeballs they get services. The company is still subject to competitive pressure because if someone else provides better services, they lose the eyeballs. In a competitive market, companies have to compete for supply as well.

> Breaking up Google without changing the basic business model would just create huge incentives for its customers to game the system, getting pretty much the same things they are getting now, but just with more maneuvering under the table.

The "spies on you for advertisers" problem isn't really an antitrust problem, because as you point out, a larger number of smaller companies could do the same thing.

But if there were a larger number of smaller companies, they would have to distinguish themselves. One way to do that is to charge for services instead of using ads, which people like you prefer, and then you could patronize that one. Others would provide the service for free with ads, or with ads but ads based only on the search terms without tracking you all over the internet. And then customers get to choose. Right now there are two search engines and they're both of the "spies on you everywhere you go" variety.

> Another suggestion I've seen is for the government to force Google, and Facebook, and every other such platform, to open up the APIs for all their services, so anyone could write their own client.

This is for services with network effects, like Facebook messenger. But services like that aren't the real problem. It's much easier to convince most of your friends to switch to another messenger than it is to get even one of them to switch to a phone platform which is neither Android nor iOS.

And the solution there isn't APIs, it's breaking up vertically integrated companies. If Google Maps, Android and the Play Store were all separate companies then it would be easier to compete with each of them because they would be less tightly coupled with each other. A competitor could replace one of them without having to replace all of them.

> No, that's nowhere near the worst case. The worst case is something like locking down the entire Internet, so, for example, a site like this one can no longer even exist.

Which is the point of constraining antitrust rules to companies with major market share. None of them would apply to a site like this because it's not big enough. And if there was strong competition then they wouldn't apply to anyone because there would be many independent sites, none of which exceeds the threshold.

Destroying independent sites and apps is the risk of doing nothing, because then two corporations get to decide winners and losers for everyone.

It goes without saying that good antitrust enforcement is better than mediocre antitrust enforcement. But mediocre is the more likely outcome, and that's still better than nothing.

Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by jpe90 on Saturday October 02, 2021 @05:43PM (#28732348)
> the same way government fiat in general makes problems worse, not better.

To be clear, you're saying that U.S. antitrust legislation left us worse off, historically?

Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by wussboy on Saturday October 02, 2021 @06:13PM (#28732584)
Or the ban against lead additives. Or against child labour. Or any one of hundreds of massive benefits that government fiat has brought us.
Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by pdonis on Saturday October 02, 2021 @06:45PM (#28732777)
> Or the ban against lead additives. Or against child labour.

Sometimes the government manages to mandate something that happens to be a good idea. But that does not mean that government mandates, overall, are a net benefit.

> Or any one of hundreds of massive benefits that government fiat has brought us.

If you really think there are "hundreds of massive benefits" brought to us by government fiat, I suggest a review of history. You will find many, many more cases of government fiat causing harm than of it doing good. In the extreme, government fiat killed hundreds of millions of people in the 20th century.

If you want more local, individualized information, try asking anyone who has had to deal with a government bureaucracy when it makes a bad individual decision (which happens all the time) about their experience. (My wife and I have had this experience multiple times with multiple government bureaucracies.) You will get a very different viewpoint on the "benefits" of government fiat.

Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by pdonis on Saturday October 02, 2021 @06:39PM (#28732746)
> you're saying that U.S. antitrust legislation left us worse off, historically?

Yes. For example, look up what happened to Standard Oil and Alcoa Aluminum. Both of those companies were providing their products with better quality and at lower prices than the companies that existed after they were broken up by antitrust suits.

Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by klyrs on Saturday October 02, 2021 @06:38PM (#28732738)
Is this a risk that you're willing to take? A handful of kids can (and frequently do) make awesome indy games. But how do you expect them to scale out a competitive software distribution platform, and who's going to pay for the marketing necessary to drive adoption among both developers and users?
Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by pdonis on Saturday October 02, 2021 @06:47PM (#28732790)
> how do you expect them to scale

How quickly does it have to scale? Google itself was a niche product for quite some time before it had to scale.

I'm not proposing that someone try to displace Google all at once. Google took a long time to get to the position it's in now. It will take a long time for it to be displaced, if it is. But you have to start somewhere.

Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by klyrs on Saturday October 02, 2021 @07:47PM (#28733223)
So, I take your non-answer to indicate that this risky career move isn't advice you're willing to follow. Am I wrong?
Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by bobthepanda on Saturday October 02, 2021 @03:37PM (#28731355)
Phone OSes are hard. Tizen was a big play for it and that ended up being a dud. Windows Phone was also another well-funded competitor that fell on its face.

Really, the problem is that phone manufacturers want to be where the apps are, and app developers barely keep it together making native apps for the two dominant OSes. Another competitor would need to make it really, really easy to make apps performant when ported over with minimal work, because the ugly truth is that no one is going to hire a full third team to develop for another OS that's just starting out.

Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by ThrowawayR2 on Saturday October 02, 2021 @04:00PM (#28731557)
> "Windows Phone was also another well-funded competitor that fell on its face."

Google had a hand in that, though, by intentionally blocking interoperability with YouTube and other Google services for WP. Even back then they were willing to play dirty to keep their monopoly.

Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by bognition on Saturday October 02, 2021 @04:17PM (#28731702)
With hundreds of billions of profits on the line this shouldn’t be surprising.

The only thing a business cares about is profits. Everything else is branding.

Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by josephcsible on Saturday October 02, 2021 @03:48PM (#28731431)
> Another competitor would need to make it really, really easy to make apps performant when ported over with minimal work

But this is completely impossible, and Google helps make it that way. Their SafetyNet API lets apps verify that the device is running an official, unmodified Android build, and a lot of very popular apps will refuse to run otherwise.

Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by heavyset_go on Saturday October 02, 2021 @06:44PM (#28732774)
SafetyNet makes it impossible to run most Android apps on Linux using a container-based solution like Anbox.

SafetyNet is also stifling innovation.

Linux/*BSD/macOS can run many Windows apps without emulation via WINE, and those innovations allowed Steam to create potentially billions of dollars in value by making many of their games cross-platform with Proton, and allowed them to create new products like the Steam Deck. SafetyNet precludes ever creating value like that with mobile apps.

Although they use emulation in WSL 2, Microsoft has done something similar with WSL and Linux apps, creating an untold amount of value for not only their platform, but for millions of developers, as well. SafetyNet prevents using something like WSL to run mobile apps on Windows.

For those reasons, you can't build an alternative OS and run many Android apps on them with a compatibility layer, despite apps without SafetyNet working pretty well using compatibility layers like Anbox.

Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by matheusmoreira on Saturday October 02, 2021 @05:34PM (#28732287)
There's no way to fake this? I just looked it up and it seems Magisk is able to fake these attestations somehow. I remember using it to get some mobile games to shut up about my rooted phone. How would rooted devices and custom ROMs work otherwise?

I hate it when these fucking companies use cryptography to control us. Cryptography should be empowering us...

Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by josephcsible on Saturday October 02, 2021 @05:45PM (#28732364)
Magisk can fake them for now, but only because Google still supports some pre-TrustZone phones. On newer phones, you can't fake TrustZone, and eventually older phones will just always fail SafetyNet.
Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by matheusmoreira on Saturday October 02, 2021 @06:40PM (#28732752)
That sucks. If this is what the future holds for Android, I think I'm just gonna switch to Apple already. There's no point to Android if Google insists on destroying everything that made it great.
Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by josephcsible on Saturday October 02, 2021 @07:32PM (#28733130)
No, don't! For as bad as Google is being, Apple is being worse on basically every axis.
Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by matheusmoreira on Saturday October 02, 2021 @07:39PM (#28733184)
Yeah, for now. Android is barely open source anymore, the old apps were replaced with proprietary Google stuff. The Play Store locks everybody into Google's proprietary ecosystem and it can't be legally distributed with custom Androids. Now there's this hardware attestation business that ensures we can't hack our devices and apps anymore. I bet one day we won't even be able to install unsigned apps anymore.

It's all so tiresome.

Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by josephcsible on Saturday October 02, 2021 @03:33PM (#28731311)
The manufacturers' hands are tied. People aren't going to buy a phone that they can't run Snapchat and Netflix on.
Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by pdonis on Saturday October 02, 2021 @03:54PM (#28731493)
> The manufacturers' hands are tied.

By "mobile phone companies" I didn't mean mobile phone manufacturers. I meant mobile phone providers like Verizon, T-Mobile, etc. They are the ones who have wormed themselves into the role of gatekeepers for phone purchases (with government help). If phone manufacturers' hands are tied with regard to what they can put on their phones or what app stores their phones can use, they're tied by the phone providers, not by users.

Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by josephcsible on Saturday October 02, 2021 @03:56PM (#28731518)
Even if Verizon were to back something like Tizen or Windows Phone, how would that fix the lack-of-apps problem?
Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by Retric on Saturday October 02, 2021 @03:35PM (#28731335)
I don’t care about running either on my phone.

I have watched YouTube instructional videos, but I can’t see the appeal of watching a movie on a tiny phone screen. As to messaging apps, SMS and email work just fine but for anyone who cares I suspect they would simply jump to whatever messaging app did work.

Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by matheusmoreira on Saturday October 02, 2021 @03:52PM (#28731476)
> As to messaging apps, SMS and email work just fine but for anyone who cares I suspect they would simply jump to whatever messaging app did work.

Absolutely not. Telecommunications applications have extremely strong network effects. There is no jumping ship to whatever works, people will do whatever is necessary to join the network their social circles participate in. In my country it's virtually impossible to communicate without WhatsApp. People buy phones just to run WhatsApp. I've had Signal installed for years and I've not received a single message there, not even from technologically minded friends who really should know better.

Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by Retric on Saturday October 02, 2021 @03:59PM (#28731544)
WhatsApp only has 500m daily average users worldwide, while being installed on 2 billion phones. Do you expect it to maintain it’s #2 spot for 10 years? None of them have had a run that long.
Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by matheusmoreira on Saturday October 02, 2021 @04:04PM (#28731588)
Does it matter? The fact is pretty much everyone in my country uses WhatsApp. There is no getting away from it. It's so absurdly important ISPs have stopped metering WhatsApp traffic. A phone that doesn't run WhatsApp is a literal paperweight.

Mobile telephony is irrelevant: 98% of incoming calls are automated marketing/scam calls, the rest are people who couldn't call me on WhatsApp for some reason. It gets to the point I wish I could turn it off. SMS is irrelevant: it's mostly 2FA codes, companies using it as a notifications system and phishing.

Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by Retric on Saturday October 02, 2021 @04:10PM (#28731634)
It matters because the segment of population in your country that doesn’t care about WhatsApp is a nucleus of adoption for both the next messaging app and a phone without WhatsApp. Facebook is already hedging it’s bets by owning and promoting the next most popular messaging app.
Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by matheusmoreira on Saturday October 02, 2021 @04:13PM (#28731660)
> the segment of population in your country that doesn’t care about WhatsApp

No such thing exists. At best you have people such as myself who care about alternatives. Those too have WhatsApp installed.

Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by Retric on Saturday October 02, 2021 @04:16PM (#28731688)
WhatsApp isn’t installed on 100% of phones in any country, try to look at actual statistics before making such bold claims.
Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by matheusmoreira on Saturday October 02, 2021 @04:30PM (#28731820)
So what? Those people are essentially ostracized. They don't matter, they never mattered. Also, I guarantee you they still care about WhatsApp, even if the only thing they do is seethe about how dominant it is. I hate Facebook and its data collection yet look at me talking about WhatsApp. I'm actually happy that the people of my country are using something so secure. At least it has end-to-end encryption just like Signal.

Try living in a country where nobody asks girls for their phone number anymore. They ask them for their WhatsApp. Phone numbers are just an old idiotic thing you need to put into your contacts database to get the person to show up in WhatsApp. The WhatsApp word itself has become part of the language as a synonym for message, just like the Google verb has become a synonym for search in the anglosphere. People even compressed it into "zap" to make it easier to say. "I gotta go but I'll send you a zap later." Want to order some food? You want the restaurant's WhatsApp. Those that don't have a WhatsApp contact are losing so much money it's not even funny because it's better than every single food app out there. First day in college? The very first thing you want to do is join your class's WhatsApp group, or make one if it doesn't exist. Actually, you'll want to make two: one with your professors and another without. If you don't do this, you'll be so hopelessly out of the loop you might as well quit. I had classmates who barely had money to buy a cheap phone being forced to do so because they couldn't keep up with classes otherwise. Their phones had literally a single app and that app was WhatsApp.

WhatsApp once refused to comply with a court order to decrypt user messages during a child abuse investigation. It was impossible to comply because they didn't have the end-to-end encryption keys to begin with. The judge got mad and blocked WhatsApp nation-wide at the ISP level as punishment. You would not believe the disruption and outrage this caused. I remember teaching at least 10 friends how to bypass the block with VPNs. Not only was it an ineffective and unpopular measure, it lasted only a couple days before a higher authority undid the judge's decision. In my country, judges are perceived as gods who can do literally anything they want, but WhatsApp is so important it put some much needed humility into them. The judge wasn't punishing WhatsApp, she was punishing every citizen of my country by denying them access to such a vital tool. WhatsApp is so important they replied to the fucking judge in english instead of portuguese. I still remember the judge's pissed off face when she talked about that during a media interview. The nerve, right?

Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by 2cb on Saturday October 02, 2021 @05:17PM (#28732170)
It is similar in the UK as well regarding WhatsApp. Not quite to the extreme you describe, but WhatsApp has 100% replaced SMS. No one uses SMS. It is all WhatsApp. People don't talk about texting they say "I'll WhatsApp you." If you join a new social circle, whether it's personal or professional, the first thing is to be added to the WhatsApp group.

The only thing I'll say about the security aspect though is the on-by-default cloud backups make the E2EE a red herring. Even if you turn it off on your own phone, it is almost certain the person you are talking to has it on. And if you turn it off it nags you to turn it back on after each update, most users will just do it to make the nagging go away, and FB know that.

Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by PaulDavisThe1st on Saturday October 02, 2021 @06:29PM (#28732688)
My family lives mostly in the UK. None of them use Whatsapp. They still use SMS for random messaging, and they use Telegram for coordinated messaging. They range in age from 30 to 78. WhatsApp might be dominant, but "No one uses SMS" is almost certainly an overstatement.
Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by 2cb on Saturday October 02, 2021 @07:08PM (#28732944)
Some people, especially those who have more international contacts, will prefer to use Telegram over WhatsApp sure. It is rare to find anyone under the age of 60 who uses SMS as their primary method of communication in 2021 though. The number of SMS messages sent in the UK has dropped by over 100 billion in the past slightly-under-a-decade.[1]

[1] https://www.statista.com/statistics/271561/number-of-sent-sm...

Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by PaulDavisThe1st on Saturday October 02, 2021 @07:32PM (#28733142)
The page you linked says there were 48.68 billion SMS in 2020. Averaged across the population, that's on the order of 800-900 messages per person per year. Even if the actual SMS usage demographics skews older (quite likely), it's still likely that most people send at least one text per day, maybe more.

Given that the original claim was that "no-one uses SMS anymore", I think that's still demonstrably false. Your milder claim - "rare to find anyone under 60 who uses SMS as their primary messaging system" - seems likely to be true.

Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by Retric on Saturday October 02, 2021 @06:40PM (#28732750)
People sent 50 million SMS messages in the UK in 2020, your social group isn’t the same as everyone.
Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by 2cb on Saturday October 02, 2021 @07:04PM (#28732909)
You missed out some vital context from the source of that statistic:

> The number of outgoing SMS and MMS messages sent in the United Kingdom (UK) fell to 48.68 billion in 2020, from a peak of 150.83 billion in 2012.

> The fall in the number of SMS and MMS messages sent over mobile networks in the UK, coincides with a surge in popularity of apps such as WhatsApp and Facebook Messenger. Globally, WhatsApp added 1.3 billion monthly active users from April 2013 to December 2017, replacing the need for sending SMS messages for many users.

https://www.statista.com/statistics/271561/number-of-sent-sm...

Trust me, yeah someone's grandparents who don't own smartphones might use SMS, but the vast majority of the population does not. The stats are right there.

Also note that number of SMS messages sent is not the same as number of people using SMS as a form of communication. Most texts are sent by bots either for legit things like 2FA codes or less legit things like phishing.

Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by Retric on Monday October 04, 2021 @11:07AM (#28747667)
We’re talking 2 texts per person, someone is sending a lot and junk isn’t enough to hit those numbers. Also, 2 factor identification is still usage.

Now it might not on top by number of messages even if it’s close, but that’s a different question. If you’re going to pick one and only one service to use then texting makes you reachable by the widest possible audience demonstrating it’s still #1 by adoption.

Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by skydhash on Saturday October 02, 2021 @05:45PM (#28732361)
Haiti here. WhatsApp took off because SMS was still not free and the providers were rent seeking. It was either send 10 sms or have 50mb for exchanging messages. People even got to learn how to share the binary when their Play store got outdated. Phone call is still used a lot because 3g networks reception varies and people still buy feature phones. But SMS is gone and a lot of people disabled notifications for it as it’s only used for ads by the provider (and it was a big issue with the government tried to run health campaigns there). The next one is telegram for movies and TV shows sharing (no theater here). So yeah, WhatsApp has a lot of appeal here and no one care about privacy.
Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by matheusmoreira on Saturday October 02, 2021 @06:33PM (#28732709)
Yeah. SMS is not free here either. Probably. I don't even know, nobody uses it anymore. I do remember friends describing "plans" that included some number of free messages or whatever. I also remember the mobile service providers absolutely seething about WhatsApp. They lobbied the government for protectionism against the app that was disrupting their shitty services. Hilarious and sad at the same time. Wish these legacy corporations would just get wiped off the face of this earth so that humanity can make some actual progress instead of keeping these parasites on life support.

> But SMS is gone and a lot of people disabled notifications for it as it’s only used for ads by the provider (and it was a big issue with the government tried to run health campaigns there).

My mobile carrier also thinks it's acceptable to send me ads via SMS. The very first time they did this, I disabled all SMS notifications forever. The government also tried to send me COVID-19 related messages but I only saw them years later when I randomly decided to clean up my SMS inbox.

They have only themselves to blame, really. If they wanted a clean communications channel, they should not have allowed companies to pollute it with an infinite amount of worthless noise. Nobody wants to be subjected to advertising.

Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by ithkuil on Saturday October 02, 2021 @04:52PM (#28731979)
Interesting. What country is that? (sorry too lazy to search your comment history for clues)
Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by Retric on Saturday October 02, 2021 @06:51PM (#28732817)
The so what is dominance gets eroded at the margins. It’s not the 99% who matter it’s all about what a tiny majority who actually care do everyone that really wants to talk to them will install the app that lets them. Then those people are suddenly spending time on another platform and it snowballs.

What’s really interesting is you essentially need isolation to get a steady state dominance by any one platform, but nobody is actually isolated any more. New platforms win not by slowly growing 5 or 10% a year but by crazy exponential curves where 30% more people install in a single month.

Having said that I don’t mean to suggest WhatsApp is going to die in Brazil tomorrow. Their currently is no real need to move right now.

Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by alanlammiman on Saturday October 02, 2021 @05:05PM (#28732089)
In Brazil it is close enough to 100%
Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by Retric on Saturday October 02, 2021 @06:38PM (#28732743)
It doesn’t matter if it’s close to 100% that’s not enough. There’s a huge difference between a solution with and without a seed crystal and the gap is plenty large for the next platform to win and win surprisingly quickly.
Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by josephcsible on Saturday October 02, 2021 @04:00PM (#28731560)
It doesn't matter what will be dominant in 10 years. What matters for phones being bought today is what's dominant today.
Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by Retric on Saturday October 02, 2021 @04:03PM (#28731579)
But we aren’t really talking about today we are asking about what happens when a new phone shows up without it. You don’t need to sell to everyone on day one they just need to erode dominance fast enough that it doesn’t stop adoption.
Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by matheusmoreira on Saturday October 02, 2021 @04:15PM (#28731684)
> we are asking about what happens when a new phone shows up without it

Nobody buys it.

Do Linux phones have access to WhatsApp? If not, there is no point. It will be a perfectly good mobile computer but it will never actually replace the one in my pocket. And that's coming from a programmer who loves Linux. Imagine the utter disdain normal people would have for a phone that doesn't even run WhatsApp.

Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by m4rtink on Saturday October 02, 2021 @05:07PM (#28732102)
Whatsapp used to be openly hostile against efforts for providing native client applications even for platforms they never plan to support themselves. Going as far as effectively attacking open source project developers working the clients - for an example see: https://reviewjolla.blogspot.com/2014/10/got-banned-in-whats...

(Sailfish OS is a Linux based mobile distro.)

Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by matheusmoreira on Saturday October 02, 2021 @05:27PM (#28732233)
That sucks. I hate when companies do this. How would they even know what kind of client is talking to their servers?
Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by m4rtink on Sunday October 03, 2021 @12:39PM (#28738441)
Some sort of undefined behavior or possibly some per build random key that triggers imposter warning if the third party app fails to send the correct key ?

In any case totally evil behavior from their side. Its already bad enough they run totally proprietary centralized service with no public API & ignore any non-mainstream mobile platforms. But when they start banning users of third party clients on those platforms and go after third party client developers with presumably legal treats - that's pure evil, no way around it.

Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by 2cb on Saturday October 02, 2021 @05:25PM (#28732224)
A Linux phone could run WhatsApp if the Linux distro was implemented in such a way that it could run Android apps (remember Android is basically just a runtime on top of the Linux kernel) and since AOSP is FOSS this is very doable and legal.

How commercially successful it'd be is still a different story, but it could run WhatsApp.

Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by josephcsible on Saturday October 02, 2021 @05:29PM (#28732250)
Only if WhatsApp never activates SafetyNet: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28731431
Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by 2cb on Saturday October 02, 2021 @06:58PM (#28732874)
WhatsApp has no motivation to use SafetyNet. For one thing plenty of their users use cheap Chinese phones that aren't actually Google certified (but come with the Play Store anyway) and they know this full well from their analytics.

For another, SafetyNet is used primarily for DRM on streaming services and for banking or other financial apps. Absolutely no messenger uses it that I am aware of (unless you count Snapchat as a "messenger" but that's literally it).

Every FB owned app runs fine on Android devices that fail SafetyNet. No reason to believe that'll change because where's the benefit for FB?

Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by josephcsible on Saturday October 02, 2021 @07:34PM (#28733150)
> unless you count Snapchat as a "messenger"

I do, and it's pretty popular, so I don't think you should discount it so quickly.

Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by josephcsible on Saturday October 02, 2021 @03:40PM (#28731382)
> As to messaging apps, SMS and email work just fine but for anyone who cares I suspect they would simply jump to whatever messaging app did work.

Messaging apps have a network effect. You can't just jump ship from one at will, or you get cut off from all of your friends who didn't jump along with you.

Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by Retric on Saturday October 02, 2021 @03:47PM (#28731425)
They aren’t sticky enough on their own to avoid people just installing the next one. I think I have used 10 of the things at various points but SMS and email are still massively more popular. Remember Yahoo messenger etc?
Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by 2cb on Saturday October 02, 2021 @05:02PM (#28732056)
This is a very US centric view. In virtually all of Europe, for instance, WhatsApp is the go to messenger and no one uses SMS anymore.

In some countries - primarily Russia, but also in Europe e.g. Germany and increasingly the UK - Telegram is also popular, and Viber is popular in African countries, while WeChat is used extensively in China, and so on... people have to use the messenger everyone else is on.

I do use Signal to chat to close friends, and Telegram has become popular enough as a second to WhatsApp that I often use it too, but as others have said it's a strong network effect.

The only other messenger I can remember having the position WhatsApp has was BBM back in the day. But as soon as BlackBerries went out of fashion it was all WhatsApp and has been ever since.

Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by Retric on Saturday October 02, 2021 @06:36PM (#28732723)
In 2020 and the UK alone 50 billion SMS text messages where sent, that’s quite a bit for something nobody uses. It’s very true people send use other platforms to send a lot of messages, but they all lack the utter ubiquity of SMS.
Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by 2cb on Saturday October 02, 2021 @06:46PM (#28732787)
> The number of outgoing SMS and MMS messages sent in the United Kingdom (UK) fell to 48.68 billion in 2020, from a peak of 150.83 billion in 2012. The fall in the number of SMS and MMS messages sent over mobile networks in the UK, coincides with a surge in popularity of apps such as WhatsApp and Facebook Messenger.

https://www.statista.com/statistics/271561/number-of-sent-sm...

Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by AnthonyMouse on Saturday October 02, 2021 @06:01PM (#28732494)
> They aren’t sticky enough on their own to avoid people just installing the next one. I think I have used 10 of the things at various points but SMS and email are still massively more popular.

That works in a different way. Today you have WhatsApp and Signal. 95% of your friends are on WhatsApp and 5% are on Signal. Now let's say Signal starts taking over. In five years it's the other way around. This is possible because you can install them both on the same device during the transition.

If you buy a kind of phone that can run Signal but not WhatsApp at the time when 95% of your friends are still on WhatsApp, that doesn't work. You're not going to buy that phone right now because your friends haven't moved yet and won't for another five years.

First you have to spend five years getting everyone to switch messaging apps, and even then you can only switch platforms if the next messaging app to become popular runs on the new platform, which it generally doesn't, because nobody writes apps for platforms nobody uses and nobody uses platforms with no apps.

The usual solution to this is something like wine that allows you to run the old platform's apps on the new platform. But Google prevents that by encouraging third party apps to have dependencies on SafetyNet or some other Google services or code that the new platform can't easily implement as a result of excessive complexity or legal restrictions.

Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by Retric on Saturday October 02, 2021 @06:28PM (#28732677)
Your assuming the market is homogeneous with you. Someone buys their kids phone X because they don’t care. Now their kids friends are forced to use a different app to talk to those kids. Even tiny fraction of the market can force huge numbers of people to install and use a different messaging app.

The effect is like crystallization even if 99.99999% of a mixture is in state X only a tiny seed is needed because it’s a one way conversion. People have a reason to install app Y, and no real need to use app X over app Y but they do have a reason to use app Y over app X.

Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by AnthonyMouse on Saturday October 02, 2021 @06:36PM (#28732725)
You don't get any crystallization when the people with the old phones can run both apps. The one kid gets the new phone, he convinces five of his closest friends to install that app, then those five people have both apps installed and use the other one to talk to the other billion people on the old app, none of which have any reason to switch.

Meanwhile the first kid could only convince five out of twenty friends to install the new app, and also couldn't run some other apps the new platform doesn't have, and then complains to the parents to return that phone and get a different one.

Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by Retric on Saturday October 02, 2021 @06:59PM (#28732884)
You say that like there isn’t any other popular apps for people to be switching to. Facebook messenger almost as popular for example and it isn’t like this would only happen to 1 family on the planet.

Further people often switch clients even when they have friends on the old platform simply because it’s the new thing. That’s how all the current major messaging platforms took off, none of them are very old.

Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by AnthonyMouse on Saturday October 02, 2021 @07:25PM (#28733067)
You're still not addressing the underlying problem.

People switch to new messengers sometimes, true. But the next one isn't going to be yours unless you have a surplus of luck in addition to skill. The next one is with high probability going to be someone else's.

The real problem is that when it happens, you need the new one to support the new platform. Which it doesn't have any incentive to do when nobody uses the new platform. Convincing the next one to be on your platform is the same problem as convincing the existing one. The transition has nothing to do with it.

Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by Retric on Saturday October 02, 2021 @10:40PM (#28734091)
I am not saying winning is easy there’s probably hundreds of thousands of messaging apps written. I am saying winning isn’t worth nearly as much as people think.

Consider even just adding advertisements is enough to eventually lose the top spot because there is so much competition.

Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by PaulDavisThe1st on Saturday October 02, 2021 @06:33PM (#28732704)
> Today you have WhatsApp and Signal. 95% of your friends are on WhatsApp and 5% are on Signal.

I asked google:

  number of signal users: 40 million
  number of telegram users: 400 million
I know this is not completely central to your point, but it does speak to a part of what you're saying in that the choices are typically not binary.
Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by bobthepanda on Saturday October 02, 2021 @03:38PM (#28731362)
are you representative of most people?

I certainly wouldn't say I am.

Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by Retric on Saturday October 02, 2021 @03:42PM (#28731393)
Considering actual adoption numbers I think I might be representing of most people in this. How many people do you know that actually watch Netflix on their phone?
Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by psyc on Saturday October 02, 2021 @03:48PM (#28731433)
I watch TV/movies almost exclusively on the phone. Not because it’s the best experience, but simply because it’s the only device that is on my person at all times. So it has been years since I thought in terms of going to a screen to watch something.
Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by Retric on Saturday October 02, 2021 @03:53PM (#28731490)
Which is still quite rare when you look at peoples cellphone network usage.

In 2020 the average cellphone user in North America only consumed 11.8 GB per month and the median is much lower. That really isn’t enough to be regularly be watching videos.

Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by 2cb on Saturday October 02, 2021 @05:09PM (#28732109)
Not rare at all if you sit on a train and glance around you. I see people watching movies/TV on phones and tablets constantly out in public. Very common.

It's partly the reason I got a Fold 3. Very good for on the move media consumption.

As for data use, aside from the points already brought up - ability to download for later from Netflix, certain services not counting towards data usage on some plans, etc - Netflix and other streaming services will also know you are on a mobile network and provide a more compressed stream at a lower resolution (720p with lower encoding settings being common) to reduce data usage and buffering.

Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by Retric on Sunday October 03, 2021 @06:20AM (#28735975)
People on a train aren’t a representative sample, nor is every video on a cellphone Netflix. Tablets are of course another story people regularly watch movies on those because the screen isn’t tiny.

Which gets back to the basic point people don’t watch a lot of video on cellphones and Netflix is usage is even lower.

Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by heavyset_go on Saturday October 02, 2021 @03:57PM (#28731530)
Netflix allows you to download and cache videos for later viewing, and some carriers don't count streaming videos on certain platforms against their users' data usage.
Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by josephcsible on Saturday October 02, 2021 @03:58PM (#28731533)
But people can watch videos over Wi-Fi on their phones, not just over cellular data.
Re:Google destroyed our startup by terminating our Play Deve... by skeeter2020 on Saturday October 02, 2021 @04:19PM (#28731724)
maybe if there was any other option. It's not like everyone on Android has a million distribution options. It's the most popular OS in the world and there is essentially one company that makes its own rules controlling what gets onto phones.