News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by kjksf on Friday October 01, 2021 @06:40PM (#28724133)
Road the hell is paved with good intentions.

As much as I support equality and diversity, I'm even more strongly opposed government over-reach. The state shouldn't have a say in who gets a job at a private (non owned by state) company.

As the article state, I hope this will get over-turned by the courts.

This would set a bad precedent. If the state can dictate the kind of person gets a highly coveted job, what else can state dictate?

Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by kenjackson on Friday October 01, 2021 @06:44PM (#28724187)
Federal government already says you can't discriminate.

They aren't saying, "you have to hire this person". They're saying you can't hire exclusively this type of person that currently dominates the top of society.

Given that these boardrooms don't diversify themselves, what is the actual problem with it?

Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by Sebb767 on Friday October 01, 2021 @06:52PM (#28724275)
It's going to be one diverse person at a lot of those boards and they will get the stigma of being the person that was put there because the actual good candidates had the wrong skin color. No matter how qualified they might actually be, they can't escape the looks.

Plus, by making this a factor, you're just kindling actual racism by pitting white males against everyone else. The resentment created by rejecting someone for their gender or color of skin does not subside just because the attributes happen to be white and male.

I get the intention, but fighting racism with racism just doesn't work.

[dead]
Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by sanity31415 on Friday October 01, 2021 @07:12PM (#28724440)
Welcome to 2021 when people think openly disparaging people on the basis of their race is ok.
[dead]
Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by MaximumYComb on Friday October 01, 2021 @09:05PM (#28725091)
Are they in that position because they are white, or are they in that position because they were born in privileged families? My country has had predominantly white, male Prime Ministers. What's even more remarkable is that every single one of them over the past 20 years went to highly exclusive private schools. The sort of private school that costs more than a good portion of adults earn, i.e $40k per annum.

When you disparage an entire group based on skin colour and gender, you're being a racist and sexist. You're being highly offensive to the majority of white men who weren't born with silver spoons. If you look at the most successful tech founders you'll see a pattern of them being born into wealthy families with educated parents. 50 years ago, most wealthy and educated families were white, which is why you see so many of these founders today. For example:

Mark Zuckerburg - parents were a psychiatrist and dentist. They literally hired software developers (in the 1990's) to tutor him.

Bill Gates - father was a prominant laywer, mother was on executive boards. Access to computers before they were even a thing.

Sergie Brin - Father was a professor, mother a NASA researcher. Private schools.

Larry Page - Father had a computing professor, mother was a computing instructor. Private schools.

Bezos - wealthy family (Grandfather was regional director of the US Atomic Energy Commision).

Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by dekhn on Saturday October 02, 2021 @09:49AM (#28728559)
larry went to a public high school, as did sergey. neither family was wealthy.
Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by MaximumYComb on Saturday October 02, 2021 @05:00PM (#28732036)
Does the US have public Monterossi schools? Here in Australia they're all private and expensive.
Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by dekhn on Sunday October 03, 2021 @01:34PM (#28738898)
Yes, there are public montessori schools. larry went to a montessori school when he was younger. They are not prohibitively expensive. Sergey's parents were dissidents.

Any argument made that Larry or Sergey had exceptionally monetarily copious upbringings is merely false; they had fairly middle class upbringings by parents who idolized math and science. They both parleyed that through public colleges to positions at Stanford.

Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by thiht on Saturday October 02, 2021 @04:44AM (#28727094)
Thank you for this.
Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by kenjackson on Saturday October 02, 2021 @08:37AM (#28728117)
I’m not even talking about just the wealthiest. How many white firefighters ever question if they got the job because they were white? White people rarely question the accumulated privilege that got them to where they are.
Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by bitshiftfaced on Friday October 01, 2021 @08:25PM (#28724844)
In general, people may more likely believe they got where they are based on merit when they're higher up on the totem pole. That makes sense to me. Where you lose me is when you say that someone's skin color makes them have even more of a tendency (and to say that "of course" that's the way it works).
Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by kenjackson on Friday October 01, 2021 @08:51PM (#28724993)
The poster I was responding to was noting that white people would look askance at blacks on the board, but I assume not whites. Both are at a high position, it only one group would be looked down on for any sort of privilege granted them. It is a function of race. Not an inherent function of being white, but rather the culture that allows white people to always believe “I did this myself”.
Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by bitshiftfaced on Friday October 01, 2021 @09:11PM (#28725131)
> Both are at a high position, it only one group would be looked down on for any sort of privilege granted them. It is a function of race. Not an inherent function of being white, but rather the culture that allows white people to always believe “I did this myself”.

How is "looking down on for any sort of privilege" a function of race? I thought it was a function of the asymmetrical nature of the privilege.

Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by kenjackson on Saturday October 02, 2021 @12:11AM (#28725895)
Yes, the asymmetry’a axis is race.
Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by sanity31415 on Monday October 04, 2021 @06:32PM (#28753054)
No, it's class. Race is what the privileged use to distract attention from that.
Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by sanity31415 on Friday October 01, 2021 @07:36PM (#28724594)
The merit of your statement disparaging people based on their race? Such statements are without merit.
Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by kenjackson on Friday October 01, 2021 @08:06PM (#28724755)
Who have I disparaged based on race?
Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by haswell on Friday October 01, 2021 @08:21PM (#28724819)
> No. They think they're there on merit, because well --- of course, they're white.

You leave no room for the possibility that people in such positions are self aware, or even capable of understanding the broader context. I suspect this is what folks are reacting to.

Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by kenjackson on Friday October 01, 2021 @08:48PM (#28724970)
The statement doesn’t apply to every white person, but enough that it never comes up that whites “get looks” due to their privileges.
Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by t0mbstone on Friday October 01, 2021 @10:44PM (#28725483)
You don't solve racism by tearing down people, regardless of their color or privilege. You solve it by lifting up those who are disadvantaged.
Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by salawat on Friday October 01, 2021 @08:54PM (#28725007)
It's rather amusing you assign the frequency of certain types of thinking to skin color.

Do you think people who are black think "damn, I love chicken/watermelon/grape drink/stealing things/being violent! Do you think people of Asian descent are all good at math?

Like I don't even understand how you can be so blind to the self-referential inconsistency here.

Also, for the record? If you can talk the talk, and walk the walk, or at least demonstrate some aptitude at getting the job done so the person hiring you can be reasonably comfortable they aren't just bringing on an anchor; that is infinitely more likely to factor into getting you a position than skin color.

t. Have Hired and fired

Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by kenjackson on Saturday October 02, 2021 @08:17AM (#28728013)
I do think certain lines of thinking are tied to skin color, for white and black people. Not because they are inherent in the color of skin, but because society created the norms for this kind of thinking based on skin color.
Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by pdonis on Friday October 01, 2021 @06:58PM (#28724333)
> They aren't saying, "you have to hire this person". They're saying you can't hire exclusively this type of person that currently dominates the top of society.

No, that's not what Federal anti-discrimination law says. It only says you can't refuse to hire certain people on the basis of a protected characteristic (of which race is one, but not the only one). It says nothing about refusing to hire certain people for other reasons that don't have to do with a protected characteristic.

(Btw, corporate boards of directors aren't even "hired"; they aren't employees. So it's not even clear what, if any, Federal anti-discrimination laws about hiring and employment would apply to them.)

> Given that these boardrooms don't diversify themselves, what is the actual problem with it?

There are two actual problems. One is that you can't have a government that only exercises its power wisely. For every mandate the government makes that happens to move things in the right direction, there will be many more that move things in the wrong direction. The people who are attracted to government jobs where they get to tell other people what to do aren't benevolent helpers; they're people who like power. All history shows that such people are precisely the people you don't want telling other people what to do.

The second problem is that dictating that people of certain races must belong to corporate boards is just as wrong as dictating that people of certain races can't belong to corporate boards. Both are looking at something that is irrelevant to the actual job, which means they aren't actually improving the corporations; the corporations can still do just as much damage as they did before, just now they'll be doing it with a "diverse" board.

The only real way to fix corporate governance is for people who would do better jobs than the board members of current corporations to form their own corporations and out-compete the current corporations.

Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by kenjackson on Friday October 01, 2021 @07:07PM (#28724397)
> No, that's not what Federal anti-discrimination law says.

I wasn't referring to Fed Discrimination Laws. I was referring to the California law. Sorry if that wasn't clear.

> The people who are attracted to government jobs where they get to tell other people what to do aren't benevolent helpers; they're people who like power. All history shows that such people are precisely the people you don't want telling other people what to do.

Why do you think that's not already the world we live in? Police officers are the epitome of this. I'm just not convinced things get much worse with this.

> The second problem is that dictating that people of certain races must belong to corporate boards is just as wrong as dictating that people of certain races can't belong to corporate boards.

I disagree with this. They are vastly different. One is completely excluding a group from the table. The other is ensuring that a group has a spot at the table. And boards, in particular, are the type of position where there are many qualified people. If we did a controlled study I'd be shocked if there was a negative difference in performance of companies with Black board members.

> The only real way to fix corporate governance is for people who would do better jobs than the board members of current corporations to form their own corporations and out-compete the current corporations.

In order to do that you have to fix a bunch of other stuff in society as well. Companies don't live in a meritocratic bubble.

Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by nerbert on Friday October 01, 2021 @07:22PM (#28724515)
Honestly there is not right angle to race. Saying "black people cant be at the board of companies" is just as wrong as saying "some black people have to belong to it". That being said, when only white people are at the board of companies without that being a calculated strategy, there is also a problem. If only white people come out on top where - allegedly - the smartest people belong, wouldn’t it be the place of the state to ensure that a fair chance is given to everyone from birth up to professional life, instead of trying to force an artificial standard upon companies?
Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by belltaco on Friday October 01, 2021 @07:42PM (#28724641)
> is just as wrong as saying "some black people have to belong to it".

Umm you can have an all white board with the new law.

Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by kenjackson on Friday October 01, 2021 @08:05PM (#28724743)
The problem is that the only real solution is a lot more extreme. I think once women are pregnant they go into managed care and babies are immediately taken at birth into academies (with no knowledge of parents) until adulthood. But that will never happen. Unfortunately short of that we’re likely to never have real equality.
Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by pdonis on Friday October 01, 2021 @09:38PM (#28725248)
> I think once women are pregnant they go into managed care and babies are immediately taken at birth into academies (with no knowledge of parents) until adulthood.

In other words, you've just reinvented Plato's Republic. Historically, the closest things to this have been societies like the Puritans or Geneva under John Calvin, or in the 20th century, Nazi Germany and the Soviet Union. How well did those experiments in "managed care" work out?

The closest thing to it in today's world is probably China or North Korea. If you think that's a good idea, you're welcome to go live in one of those countries.

> Unfortunately short of that we’re likely to never have real equality.

We won't have "real equality" even with such a draconian plan, because the inconvenient truth is that every human being is a unique individual. There is no such thing as "real equality" because human beings are all different. You can't pigeonhole human beings into boxes. You can't "manage" their care so they fit into whatever preconceived utopian fantasy you happen to have. Human beings are free individuals and we all have to figure out for ourselves how best to use whatever we have been given. And since we all get given different things, we are going to end up wanting different things, needing different things, and making different choices. No central planner can possibly comprehend all that. And every time it has been tried, it has ended up costing a lot of lives and a lot of misery even for those who managed not to be killed outright.

Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by kenjackson on Saturday October 02, 2021 @08:31AM (#28728085)
I’m not advocating such a plan. Just pointing out that pretty much anything we do short of that plan created a society that will favor whites people. When laws like those in a California get passed whites get up in arms about fairness. Blacks look around and think ”this is what gets you upset about fairness?”
Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by haswell on Friday October 01, 2021 @08:26PM (#28724848)
That’s some pretty extreme all-or-nothing thinking. Why do you believe this is the only solution?
Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by kenjackson on Friday October 01, 2021 @08:52PM (#28725003)
How else do you remedy the compounding advantage throughout various parts of the society?
Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by pdonis on Friday October 01, 2021 @09:40PM (#28725255)
You don't. "Compounding advantage" is a fact of life. Historically, the societies that have dealt with this unpleasant fact of life the best have been those that had some concept of "noblesse oblige"--if you are one of the fortunate ones with "compounding advantage" on your side, you have an obligation to use those gifts to help others less fortunate than you. But trying to erase the advantage doesn't work; every time it has been tried, it has just ended up causing even more misery (and in many cases lots of deaths).
Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by aaaaaaaaaaab on Saturday October 02, 2021 @11:04AM (#28729114)
Wow. That escalated quickly!

I hope you’ll never be in any position of power to realize this “solution”.

Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by pdonis on Friday October 01, 2021 @09:33PM (#28725228)
> I wasn't referring to Fed Discrimination Laws. I was referring to the California law. Sorry if that wasn't clear.

It wasn't since you explicitly said "Federal government" in your previous post. I agree that state laws can say different things.

> Why do you think that's not already the world we live in?

I didn't say it wasn't. If you already agree that what I said is the case, then you should be all the more opposed to more of the same.

> I'm just not convinced things get much worse with this.

Any extension of government power makes things worse. If the increment of "worse" seems small with some particular change, well, the phrase "frog-boiling" wasn't coined for nothing.

> One is completely excluding a group from the table. The other is ensuring that a group has a spot at the table.

You are misunderstanding my point. The current state, where many corporate boards are all of one race and one gender, is not a product of government fiat; it's a product of private decisions. But there have been cases in the past where similar states were products of government fiat. Those past government fiats are now pretty much universally agreed to have been very bad things. My point is simply that this is the same kind of thing, and should be considered bad for the same reasons. The issue is not "spots at the table". The issue is government fiat.

> In order to do that you have to fix a bunch of other stuff in society as well.

Like what? If you mean, like certain corporations having huge advantages because they have privileged access to things like loans with government printed money, lobbyists with the ear of government officials, and so on, yes, I agree all those things need to be fixed--and they're all just more examples of government power being misused. As the saying goes, the root problem is not that politicians can be bought but that they have something valuable to sell. That is what needs to be fixed.

> Companies don't live in a meritocratic bubble.

In a free market, where the government did not play favorites at all, they would--they would either have to make and sell something people want to buy, or go out of business. That's the only kind of "merit" that matters to us as consumers. But we can't exercise that ultimate control if the government keeps getting in the way.

Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by humanrebar on Friday October 01, 2021 @06:51PM (#28724263)
At a practical level, it means you end up with particular slots reserved for particular demographics. What happens when the person from $demographic_one retires from the board? Do you use an impartial search process? Or are you legally obligated to reject certain applicants based on their demographics?

I understand the appeals to equity vs equality. I'm saying this is a subtle distinction hinging on who is making choices and how. I don't want the government deciding who is diverse enough or historically oppressed enough or underrepresented enough. It will get it wrong far too often.

Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by nverno on Friday October 01, 2021 @06:49PM (#28724240)
This is starting to sound similar to equity laws established in South Africa, which have not had good outcomes. Preferential treatment like this, not based on merit, is unfair and could breed a lot of resentment.
Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by hn_throwaway_99 on Friday October 01, 2021 @06:53PM (#28724280)
A national government requiring that hiring decisions be made on the basis of gender or race, and the response is "what is the actual problem with it?"
Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by kenjackson on Friday October 01, 2021 @06:58PM (#28724330)
You seem to think that hiring decisions aren't already largely made on the basis of race and gender.
Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by hn_throwaway_99 on Friday October 01, 2021 @07:01PM (#28724359)
I'm baffled how one could think that statement is any sort of defense for allowing a government to dictate racial quotas for private company hiring.
Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by _hilro on Friday October 01, 2021 @07:12PM (#28724435)
Great, where's the California bill that outlaws all Black boards or all Hispanic boards?
Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by belltaco on Friday October 01, 2021 @07:43PM (#28724652)
Where are the laws that ban monkeys driving cars.
Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by radisb on Friday October 01, 2021 @06:47PM (#28724216)
The problem is that someone must be fired because he is a white male
Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by larkost on Friday October 01, 2021 @06:51PM (#28724254)
These are board members. They are not hired in the first place, and generally need to be re-appointed every few years. This law has been slowly ratcheting up, so either people have simply been not re-appointed to the board, or they have increased the size of the board to include new members who were chosen from more diverse backgrounds.

No one was fired.

Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by BrianOnHN on Friday October 01, 2021 @06:50PM (#28724245)
Edit: deleted because original comment has changed.
Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by radisb on Friday October 01, 2021 @07:01PM (#28724358)
"he" because the article says "all-white-male"
Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by kenjackson on Friday October 01, 2021 @06:49PM (#28724237)
It doesn't mean that at all. You can hire a black person and not fire anyone. They may choose to fire someone, but given these are board positions, and it literally takes just one person -- they can easily accommodate simply hiring someone.
Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by radisb on Friday October 01, 2021 @07:03PM (#28724372)
Oh, so if, hypothetically, someone did have to be fired to be replaced by a non-white-male, would you be against it?
Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by kenjackson on Friday October 01, 2021 @07:10PM (#28724419)
If that was the literal rule (you had to fire a white male) then yes, I would be against it. The intent isn't to be spiteful against white males. It's to give space at the table for other groups that are intentionally excluded due to their race.
Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by RickJWagner on Friday October 01, 2021 @11:14PM (#28725624)
I walked around my neighborhood today, there are several houses under construction. The framing and roofing crews are staffed entirely by hardy people of only one gender and with little ethnic diversity.

I sometimes watch professional sports, in particular basketball. There is very, very little diversity.

My son is in his first year of teaching elementary school. He tells me he is almost alone in the school, gender-wise.

I think this is a very complex topic, with lots of nuances.

Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by newfriend on Friday October 01, 2021 @07:08PM (#28724410)
If you have an open board seat, and your other five positions are currently held by "white males", you are now forced to discriminate based on race/gender. By law you would not be allowed to appoint a qualified potential candidate because they have the "wrong" physical attributes. It's abhorrent.
Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by 8ytecoder on Friday October 01, 2021 @06:58PM (#28724329)
It’s not just CA though. Nasdaq is doing it. US chamber of commerce has thrown its support as well.
Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by threatofrain on Friday October 01, 2021 @07:16PM (#28724474)
NASDAQ rule in question, with SEC approval.

https://listingcenter.nasdaq.com/assets/Board%20Diversity%20...

Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by maxerickson on Friday October 01, 2021 @08:10PM (#28724780)
The requirement for corporations to have a board of directors at all is imposed by the state.

You have to argue that the state shouldn't be able to impose requirements on the situations where it relaxes individual liability, not complain about about the natural rights of corporations (they don't have any).

Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by LeoPanthera on Friday October 01, 2021 @06:41PM (#28724152)
This is about equity, not equality, and it's increasingly clear that a lot of people don't know the difference.
Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by TimTheTinker on Friday October 01, 2021 @06:57PM (#28724317)
Equity by its normal dictionary definition is great.

But as the critical race theory worldview defines it, "equity" involves unequal treatment of people and discrimination (decisions made about how to treat people) on the basis of race.

The idea is to retroactively create equal outcomes, not equal opportunities in the present.

The problem is: a society can't create either equal outcomes or equal opportunities by intentionally discriminating one way or another, since doing so (1) fails to solve problems at their source and (2) creates new problems.

In other words, love is the answer, not hate.

Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by nsonha on Saturday October 02, 2021 @05:15AM (#28727218)
> The problem is: a society can't create equal outcomes or equal opportunities by...

Society can't create equal outcomes, period. People don't want the same things in life. Some want to be of service to other people, some want to be rich so they can buy a yacht. You can't just give yachts to everyone and call that equality.

We do need safety net and equal opportunities

Personally I think the whole idea of equality is stupid because it just makes people compare their life to others instead of thinking about what they want in life. But again if we have to have equality then it's equal opportunities and more importantly, safety net.

Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by GenerocUsername on Friday October 01, 2021 @06:44PM (#28724188)
Literally impossible to provide equitable outcomes to all possible segmentations of humans since those segments can be gerrymandered as easily as our geographic definitions used in the past. For instance, the most hyper-modern views of gender vs sex.
Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by captainredbeard on Friday October 01, 2021 @06:47PM (#28724218)
The difference is clear and equity is unwanted by many people. It is anathema to those who desire freedom.
Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by kjksf on Friday October 01, 2021 @06:45PM (#28724200)
Educate us?

What do stocks have to do with it?

Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by haswell on Friday October 01, 2021 @06:45PM (#28724204)
Will you expand on how you see this distinction and how the distinction matters here?

I understand the difference between equity and equality, but I don’t know what exactly you mean to imply here, and don’t want to draw any hasty conclusions about this comment.

Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by ctdonath on Friday October 01, 2021 @06:45PM (#28724196)
Punishing someone based on “wrong” color/gender is evil.
Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by ramesh31 on Friday October 01, 2021 @06:49PM (#28724234)
Yes it is. And that's what we've done as a society for hundreds of years in the US. That we are now attempting to fix that will obviously be seen as an attack, because losing privilege is never easy.
Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by ctdonath on Friday October 01, 2021 @06:58PM (#28724332)
“Privilege” is getting a job over a better candidate just because of inclusion in an artificial social construct.
Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by ramesh31 on Friday October 01, 2021 @07:50PM (#28724681)
>“Privilege” is getting a job over a better candidate just because of inclusion in an artificial social construct.

Yes, exactly. Which is what has happened to women and minorities in this country forever.

Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by aeturnum on Friday October 01, 2021 @06:54PM (#28724289)
The road to hell is good paved with good intentions, but I don't really see hell over the horizon on this one.

Demographics are funny because they're really easy to satisfy. People come from many backgrounds.

This is just one of many restrictions on individual choice we make for the sake of social cohesion. All of us might choose to work for below minimum wage, but there are real risks there, so we ban it. All of understand how one might end up with a board of all white men, but there are risks there as well, so now it's banned. It does not seem like a meaningful restriction for any serious enterprise.

Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by gentoo on Friday October 01, 2021 @06:55PM (#28724296)
I'm not sure whether I agree with the CA policy. But this argument against it is extremely unconvincing. It's almost word-for-word what segregationists argued against the 1964 Civil Rights Act.

e.g. https://delong.typepad.com/sdj/2014/06/barry-goldwater-decla...

"The two portion so this bill to which I have constantly and consistently voiced objections, and which are of such overriding significance that they are determinative of my vote on the entire measure, are those which would embark the Federal Government on a regulatory course of action in the area of so-called "public accommodations" and in the area of employment--to be precise, Titles II and VII of the bill. I find no constitutional basis for the exercise of Federal regulatory authority in either of these areas; and I believe the attempted usurpation of such power to be a grave threat to the very essence of our basic system of government..."

Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by hn_throwaway_99 on Friday October 01, 2021 @07:04PM (#28724381)
But this CA law is basically the exact opposite of the 1964 Civil Rights act, which says you can not discriminate based on gender or race in areas like housing and hiring.

This law is saying that you must take into account race and gender in your hiring decisions.

Re:California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping... by gentoo on Friday October 01, 2021 @07:19PM (#28724497)
I was responding to

> The state shouldn't have a say in who gets a job at a private (non owned by state) company.

that's exactly what the Civil Rights Act does. The state has been telling you how you are allowed to make hiring decisions for a while now.

edit:

And here's Strom Thurmond on the Civil Rights Act:

"This bill would take away the rights of individuals and give to government the power to decide who is to be hired, fired and promoted in private businesses."

https://teachingamericanhistory.org/document/debate-on-the-c...