How do you calculate the tax on that?
They can’t have it both ways. Either crypto is an equivalent to money or it isn’t. If it is, accept it. If it’s not, tax it when the money “appears” out the other end.
Basically the current trade value for the non-dollar item is your income on it.
The current law is bad imo.
The difference between stock and stock options might not seem like enough to matter, but it’s simply the same generic rule applying.
ISOs existed to correct for this failure in options, but the income at which AMT removes that protection hasn't been updated substantially since it was created so this protection no longer really covers exercise. I also don't really understand how it could be abused.
My change would be to have option exercise pay no tax on the spread, with all taxes payed on gains on sale.
As it is, people with massive wealth can exercise when there is no spread (because they have lots of cash already when the shares are granted to them) or they get special early exercise via the 83b election with the IRS and special access from their startup.
The people that get hit hardest by this are regular employees starting out that don't have lots of cash to exercise when the spread is zero.
Just like stocks (you don’t pay for any changes in value to the stock until you sell it for fiat currency).