News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Why do companies take 2 months to send job reject... by gregjor on Thursday September 30, 2021 @04:25AM (#28704231)
Why? Any number of possible reasons.

“Companies?” Certainly not all. There’s no standard hiring process that all companies use.

“2 months?” Some tell candidates right away. Some never contact rejected candidates.

You are looking for a pattern or reason that doesn’t exist.

Until a company shows interest in you go about your job search.

If you are submitting your CV to a lot of companies and then waiting for replies you have landed on one of the least productive ways to get a job. Complaining about things you can’t control doesn’t help.

Your experience doesn’t match mine and I’ve been in the software business for 40 years, both finding jobs and filling them.

Re:Ask HN: Why do companies take 2 months to send job reject... by theyx on Thursday September 30, 2021 @08:54PM (#28713203)
> Your experience doesn’t match mine and I’ve been in the software business for 40 years, both finding jobs and filling them.

OP could say the same. Their experience does not match yours, making your experience irrelevant to them, since they are facing a problem you did not face. 40 years ago, when you were entering this market, things were different. 30 years ago, different. 10 years ago, different. Last year, different.

It is not so hard to understand how someone entering the job market would face the issues described there, have some sympathy. That is all people expect from others.

Re:Ask HN: Why do companies take 2 months to send job reject... by gregjor on Friday October 01, 2021 @02:28PM (#28721902)
The OP needs actionable and helpful information, not sympathy. I posted some below. Even if I agreed that OP is the victim of some industry-wide dysfunctional process and posted my own job-hunting sob story that wouldn’t help. Our experiences don’t match for a variety of reasons, sure, but one reason is different approaches to finding a job.
Re:Ask HN: Why do companies take 2 months to send job reject... by jstx1 on Thursday September 30, 2021 @04:57AM (#28704373)
> If you are submitting your CV to a lot of companies and then waiting for replies you have landed on one of the least productive ways to get a job.

What alternatives do you have?

Do you think that you consider sending a CV to be unproductive exactly because the process is dysfunctional (in the way OP points out and in other ways)?

Re:Ask HN: Why do companies take 2 months to send job reject... by gregjor on Thursday September 30, 2021 @02:02PM (#28709168)
There’s no one “process” that companies follow. The OP describes a process but it’s one they initiated — sending out CVs and applying online and then waiting. Some employers probably have dysfunctional hiring processes, but you can find alternative routes that have better chances of success.

The alternatives have been understood for a long time. Look at What Color Is Your Parachute? by Bolles and Who’s Hiring Who? by Lathrop, for example. I haven’t applied for a job in decades but I have found continuous employment. I know plenty of other people in this business who do the same.

A person with little or no actual experience will find it difficult to get attention from employers, but that’s not a broken system nor is it specific to software dev jobs. There’s no shortage of inexperienced applicants, which is why they get little response from employers.

Anecdotally, when I listen to young inexperienced developers I think they have an inflated idea of their prospects and value in the software dev job market, which is something we programmers do to ourselves. I don’t know if the OP is new to the business or has years of experience, but someone with years of experience should have contacts and friends and connections to leverage.

Re:Ask HN: Why do companies take 2 months to send job reject... by afarrell on Thursday September 30, 2021 @07:06AM (#28705003)
> What alternatives do you have?

Talking to people in-person at meetups, being curious about what they are working on, listening attentively and following up.

> Do you think that you consider sending a CV to be unproductive exactly because the process is dysfunctional (in the way OP points out and in other ways)?

Yes. Thats why the parent comment is suggesting that you not spend much time engaging in it.

Re:Ask HN: Why do companies take 2 months to send job reject... by jstx1 on Thursday September 30, 2021 @07:44AM (#28705239)
> Talking to people in-person at meetups, being curious about what they are working on, listening attentively and following up.

What if the company you're interested in doesn't present at meetups? What if you don't attend meetups? What if you do but you're rarely interested in the speakers? What if you're interested but you don't establish rapport? If all things align well, how many relationship like this can you realistically maintain and rely on when you need a job? How many people can realistically do this in parallel for the same contact at the company?

It really sounds like the advice is to be constantly schmoozing so that you have contacts when you need them. I don't get how that's a more productive way to match company with employee than sending your details to companies that are looking for people. Getting a job through your network clearly works for many people. I just don't think it works for everyone and wish that we had something more honest and efficient.

Re:Ask HN: Why do companies take 2 months to send job reject... by afarrell on Thursday September 30, 2021 @08:15AM (#28705443)
> What if the company you're interested in doesn't present at meetups?

Options:

A. Reach out to one of their recruiters on linkedin

B. Ask someone you already know (classmate, TA, professor, etc) if they know anybody at the company.

C. Release your attachment to this particular outcome. There are other fish in the sea.

> What if you don't attend meetups?

Go to other social events. If you are still in uni then definitely work on problem sets together. If you are not in uni then find some other community of people trying to learn something.

> What if you do but you're rarely interested in the speakers?

If the particular speaker is boring, then sigh and take notes on how not to give a boring talk.

If the topic is habitually super scattered and unclear, find a more focused meetup.

If you cannot muster curiosity about the topic, then consider improving your sleep patterns or changing to a different subfield.

> be constantly schmoozing so you have contacts when you need them.

Nope. When you are not actively job searching, you should be occasionally nerding out about something with people so that you explore your shared interest in category theory or good API docs or whatever. Also, with a small small circle of those people you like for weird reasons, you should be playing League of Legends or Settlers of Catan and talking about colonoscopies and the shittier parts of life.

> I just don't think it works for everyone and wish that we had something more honest and efficient.

The goal of networking at its worst is just to quickly get a job and make money. The goal of networking at its best is to create the conditions for honesty so that you build teams with healthy trustful working relationships. The latter is much harder and requires courage from all involved.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W5qQJhe7sLE

Re:Ask HN: Why do companies take 2 months to send job reject... by going_ham on Thursday September 30, 2021 @05:01AM (#28704394)
Sorry about putting it that way. I have no idea how to get answers at all. I have tried rewriting my CV, writing cover letter, doing projects, etc. but nothing is helping at all.

How should one apply for a job?

Any suggestions on this one! I don't understand how to land a job. Most people can get one by just applying, but for some reason, I can't. Can you link some resources or write tips on this one! That would be super helpful! I want to start from the basics with internships. Unfortunately, I get a generic reply that I am not even qualified for internships or working student positions.

Re:Ask HN: Why do companies take 2 months to send job reject... by gregjor on Thursday September 30, 2021 @01:45PM (#28709016)
If you want any job then applying for all of them may be the best strategy. Eventually supply & demand should work in your favor. If you want to target a small number of companies you will have to do the work to get your foot in the door.

In the software development business you see lots of companies hiring, but few willing to take on juniors or people they will have to train. You need to present yourself as the person who can get productive quickly, and work as a member of a team. Past work experience sends that message better than a list of languages and frameworks, which is why people with little or no actual work experience have a disadvantage.

Competition is most intense at the low end. Companies get lots of applications from people who don’t have a lot of experience, and people who don’t even match the requirements. You need to get out of that queue.

The best way to get the job you want is through personal contacts. Those can be people you know from school or previous jobs, people you meet at conferences or meetups, friends of friends. Good recruiters (yes, they exist) can open doors and get around automated CV screening. You don’t have to fake schmooze or build up LinkedIn “connections,” but you do have to put in some effort beyond clicking Apply on a web site.

I have some articles on my web site typicalprogrammer.com you might find helpful. I recommend the book Who’s Hiring Who by Richard Lathrop.

Re:Ask HN: Why do companies take 2 months to send job reject... by going_ham on Thursday September 30, 2021 @03:02PM (#28709938)
Thank you for the tips!
Re:Ask HN: Why do companies take 2 months to send job reject... by afarrell on Thursday September 30, 2021 @07:08AM (#28705020)
> Can you link some resources or write tips on this one!

https://www.kalzumeus.com/2011/10/28/dont-call-yourself-a-pr...

Re:Ask HN: Why do companies take 2 months to send job reject... by kubanczyk on Thursday September 30, 2021 @05:33AM (#28704546)
> Most people can get one by just applying

You are a victim of your own selection bias. As you didn't ask 1000 random developers, think what selection process happened before you got that confusing info from some developers (I guess there were between one and five of them).