Re:Captchas To Keep Idiots Out Of Comment Threads
by corin_ on Wednesday August 10, 2011 @10:38AM
(#2868395)
They are homophones not homonyms - normally I wouldn't be so pedantic, but in a thread around the idea of people having prove they know meanings/spellings/etc, it seems suitible.
Re:Captchas To Keep Idiots Out Of Comment Threads
by moss on Wednesday August 10, 2011 @11:01AM
(#2868519)
It's suitable, not suitible - normally I wouldn't be so pedantic, but in a thread around the idea of people having to prove they know meanings/spellings/etc, it seems apropriate.
Re:Captchas To Keep Idiots Out Of Comment Threads
by corin_ on Wednesday August 10, 2011 @11:05AM
(#2868546)
I see what you did there... genius.
Re:Captchas To Keep Idiots Out Of Comment Threads
by dasil003 on Thursday August 11, 2011 @01:16AM
(#2871508)
No you didn't, it was supposed to be turtles all the way down and you fucked it up!
Re:Captchas To Keep Idiots Out Of Comment Threads
by mirkules on Wednesday August 10, 2011 @10:59AM
(#2868513)
Don't you think it's ironic then that you misspelled "suitable"?
Re:Captchas To Keep Idiots Out Of Comment Threads
by shrikant on Wednesday August 10, 2011 @12:29PM
(#2868973)
See Muphry's Law: http://www.editorscanberra.org/muphrys-law/ :)
edit: Why can't I use an apostrophe in a URL? HN seems to be stripping it out, so couldn't link to the Wikipedia page without a crufty "%27" showing up...
Re:Captchas To Keep Idiots Out Of Comment Threads
by nitrogen on Wednesday August 10, 2011 @06:59PM
(#2870579)
Why can't I use an apostrophe in a URL? HN seems to be stripping it out, so couldn't link to the Wikipedia page without a crufty "%27" showing up...
Interesting. It looks like ASCII character 27 is supposed to be valid within URIs according to both RFC 3986 and RFC 1738 (via [0]). Maybe it's a simple component of a system for preempting SQLi on other sites via links from HN?
[0] http://stackoverflow.com/questions/1547899/which-characters-...
Re:Captchas To Keep Idiots Out Of Comment Threads
by corin_ on Wednesday August 10, 2011 @11:03AM
(#2868526)
Pretty ironic, yeah. Though I'm generally terrible with misspellings, because once I've thought of what to write my mind drifts off, I usually gaze out of the window, and my hands often follow their muscle memories rather than what I want to type. So in fact, I actually often type their/there wrong, although any time I do I catch it as soon as I've done it.
Re:Captchas To Keep Idiots Out Of Comment Threads
by mirkules on Wednesday August 10, 2011 @11:16AM
(#2868603)
No harm, no foul. :) I was amused by it actually, and a thought crossed my mind that you did it on purpose.
Anyway, it just reiterates that, while funny, this method of captcha is pretty much useless.
Re:Captchas To Keep Idiots Out Of Comment Threads
by epo on Thursday August 11, 2011 @05:36AM
(#2872118)
Gosh, a correct use of the term "ironic", can the ghost of Morissette be being laid to rest?.
Re:Captchas To Keep Idiots Out Of Comment Threads
by mirkules on Thursday August 11, 2011 @11:57AM
(#2873397)
Thanks, I was very careful with that one.
Re:Captchas To Keep Idiots Out Of Comment Threads
by Bud on Wednesday August 10, 2011 @11:03AM
(#2868534)
Also ironic that the grandparent used a hyphen instead of the proper em dash. (- vs. —)
Re:Captchas To Keep Idiots Out Of Comment Threads
by DanielBMarkham on Wednesday August 10, 2011 @10:45AM
(#2868437)
I actually doubted that was the correct word -- but didn't take time to look it up. Thanks.
Re:Captchas To Keep Idiots Out Of Comment Threads
by neutronicus on Wednesday August 10, 2011 @11:47AM
(#2868739)
I see an unfair prejudice against the vocal and valuable Indian and Eastern-European HN contingent.
Re:Captchas To Keep Idiots Out Of Comment Threads
by dredmorbius on Wednesday August 10, 2011 @11:05AM
(#2868543)
Good grammar and basic wordsmithery make idiocy much easier to manage.
Say: George F. Will vs. Rush Limbaugh.
Since when?
The assumption here is that you can tell a comment is going to be stupid by testing whether or not the person understands homonyms. The only thing you check with that is language ability. I'd argue you'd be better off searching for common internet memes and cliches instead of original thinking -- since that's a sign of a lazy or uninteresting mind. The author is kind enough to inadvertently supply us with one "...If Fox Nation implemented something like this, they’d have zero commenters..." But you could test stuff like this based on any preconceived viewpoint, such as Obama-socialist, Obamacare, etc. The use of shortcuts and blindly-repeated jokes and phrases is a good sign that you're not going to be getting much from the comment.
Not sure how you'd code it, though, but I'm certain you could come up with some semantic magic given enough input text. I'd imagine you'd use n-grams and some Bayesian logic. You'd have to have a pre-existing corpus of the person's writing, though.