Compared to the result of having billions over billions of over wastes in the atmosphere, I can't even understand how people pretend it's not a no-brainer question.
That is, frankly, moronic. All you will end up with is your groundwater leeching out the waste. We have exactly this problem in Gorleben, and now have to spend a boatload of money in recovering all the waste from the former mine.
No yo won't, because you will think just a bit before drilling the mine shaft over an aquifer (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deep_geological_repository)
> We have exactly this problem in Gorleben
Looks like the only problems you have in Gorleben are a handful of medical-grade wastes badly conditioned and a very vocal populace.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Onkalo_spent_nuclear_fuel_re...
There is still the issue of how to communicate “Danger: Nuclear Waste” to the people who will encounter the waste storage facility over the next 10,000-100,000 years, but for now we can safely store waste.
> The radioactivity of nuclear waste naturally decays, and has a finite radiotoxic lifetime. Within a period of 1,000-10,000 years, the radioactivity of HLW decays to that of the originally mined ore. Its hazard then depends on how concentrated it is. By comparison, other industrial wastes (e.g. heavy metals, such as cadmium and mercury) remain hazardous indefinitely.
- https://world-nuclear.org/information-library/nuclear-fuel-c...
The above is probably some nuclear power lobby (vested interest and all that), but I think the point is a good one.
An example I'd like to cite is how one of the Sultan's of Egypt tried to dismantle the pyramids and failed horribly because of all the manpower involved. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pyramid_of_Menkaure
This way if something happens to external core, you can cheaply fix it, instead of recover them from deep mines.
We have solutions right now to get rid of coal, atom etc completely in a couple of years, new inventions take too much time to be ready for the market when we need them by 2030.
No we do not. Renewable energy is unreliable and unsuitable for base load generation. Until we can figure out how to store weeks worth of energy, nuclear is the only clean option for base load.
> You don't know if that place on earth will still be there or in the middle of an ocean in the time the waste is till toxic.
We do have a pretty good idea, and to the extent that we don't, it's climate change. Pretty ironic to use climate change as a reason to forestall nuclear considering it's our best shot at mitigating climate change pending a renewable energy storage miracle.
I think you're looking at this the right way. We aren't "on the verge" of climate catastrophe, or "at the edge": we are already over the cliff, and the rocks are getting closer by the second.
Our only chance is to de-carbonize energy now, and the only technology that gets us there is nuclear.
To be fair, this is a possibility, but not established fact. Assuming “the cliff” in question is runaway global warming.
We tried to make nuclear energy a thing for over 50 years, it only shows we aren't able to a) make safe use of it and b) get a solution for the waste.
No, we didn't. Nuclear was and is unpopular for reasons that aren't justified by the evidence.
> we aren't able to make safe use of it
This is entirely untrue. Nuclear is the safest energy source by far, even more so than wind or solar:
https://www.statista.com/statistics/494425/death-rate-worldw...
> we couldn't get a solution for the waste.
We know the solution for the waste, we just have to act on it. And anyway, we have to solve for the existing waste and once you have to dig a big hole for a little bit of waste you can use that existing hole for a whole lot of waste with virtually no economic impact.
Nuclear power was one of the safest energy source in the last century. Even hydroelectrical power, which is quite safe, has been much deadlier than nuclear accidents, and don't get me started on the consequences of carbon-heavy production methods.
> b) get a solution for the waste.
There is a solution for the waste: deep burial in stable geological conditions. The only people saying there are no solution do not have any other argument better “dangerous green-glowing slime makes me afraid, Greenpeace plz help”.
By the time it's still bad for carbon based lifeforms it's as old as todays archaeology!
I'm very pro-renewables, but nuclear power's problems are organizational rather than waste-related, at least in much of the developed world.
The search for waste storage that lasts forever feels like the search for data storage that last forever. In the latter case, no storage medium is reliable enough in the long run, and the better strategy is continuous active management, moving from one storage medium to another as technology evolves and as old media expire.
Trillions of years is the wrong timescale. The earth is only a few billion years old, and anyway the nuclear waste won't be radiotoxic in 1-10 thousand years much less 1 trillion. I'm pretty sure the Earth won't be habitable (as we understand 'habitable', anyway) in 1 trillion years. Anyway, climate change poses an existential threat in decades or centuries.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Formation_and_evolution_of_the...
and from there on under The Sun and planetary environments we're toast in about 600 million years.
Shrug
And while the earth has long forgotten about humans other species will still be endangered by it.
Anyway, far more species are far more endangered by climate change right now than any future species will be by nuclear waste.