News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by Jedd on Monday September 27, 2021 @09:47AM (#28670574)
> nuclear is the only clean base load generation we have.

I'm assuming from your phrasing that you're using nuclear to refer exclusively to nuclear fission.

Are you really suggesting that it's 'clean' in the sense of no greenhouse gas emissions, or radioactive (negative health impacts) from the acquisition of the necessary fuel, the building of fission power stations, or the operations of same?

Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by throwaway894345 on Monday September 27, 2021 @10:19AM (#28670945)
It is on par with solar with respect to the emissions per kW. Nuclear power plants emit virtually no radiation when properly operated and maintained (indeed, coal power plants emit more radiation into the environment). In rare cases, accidents happen, but the risk adjusted cost of those accidents is negligible compared to fossil fuel power. I’m not sure what “radioactive impacts” derive from mining Uranium, but I doubt it’s non-negligible compared to the harm imposed my fossil fuels.
Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by Teknoman117 on Monday September 27, 2021 @11:27AM (#28671847)
Nuclear (fission) beats out solar for the most part in terms of CO2 equivalent per kW/h of energy generation. The 6-grams CO2 equivalent per kW/h figure assumes the panel is in ideal conditions (receiving sun for all sun-up hours during the year at equatorial to middle latitudes and operating at a fixed temperature). For a place like Finland, Norway, or Sweden, this goes up 50-grams CO2 equivalent per kW/h (less power produced over lifespan given a fixed manufacturing footprint). Nuclear is at 4-grams per kW/h. Wind is also about 4-grams per kW/h (again, assuming ideal conditions).

Meanwhile, the most efficient coal fired plants are like 700 grams of CO2 per kW/h and most are at 1000-1200 grams per kW/h...

Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by coryrc on Monday September 27, 2021 @12:30PM (#28672766)
Nit: it's kWh (kilowatts × hours), a unit of energy (like joules or calories), not kW/h, which doesn't map to a physical concept
Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by Teknoman117 on Monday September 27, 2021 @02:48PM (#28674477)
Ah! Sorry, it's a nasty habit I picked up from my previous power company's billing statements.
Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by lacksconfidence on Monday September 27, 2021 @12:08PM (#28672489)
I realize you didn't invent these terms, but is kW/h the right metric? A plain reading of the units provided suggests 700 grams of CO2 is released every hour for every kW generated, but that seems unlikely. Where does the per hour figure in?
Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by Teknoman117 on Monday September 27, 2021 @03:04PM (#28674692)
I meant kWh. The units derivation is as follows if I remember correctly:

The SI unit for some absolute quantity of energy is the "Joule".

1 watt = 1 joule per second (1 J/s)

Watts can sort of be thought of as the rate at which some absolute quantity of energy is available or able to be consumed.

Since energy sources are usually rated in terms of their ability to supply an instantaneous amount of power, in order to get back to the absolute amount of energy, you need to multiply by the time in order to get back to just some multiple of joules.

1 watt-second = 1 J/s * s = 1 J.

So the concept holds that if we are going to measure some amount of something (other than power) produced by a power plant, it should be measured against the absolute amount of power produced. Obviously this doesn't take into account the fact that pollution generated by some forms of power aren't linearly correlated with the power produced - e.g. fossil fuel plants produce less particulate pollution the hotter the fire burns, meaning they get dirtier vs the power output the lower the output power is set. Hence why gas turbines burn cleaner that gas-fired steam generators (hand waving over the efficiency differences of direct fired turbines versus steam generation).

Another data point is that natural gas turbines (again, averages from the US) produce 550 grams per kWh, and combined cycle (adding a second turbine that runs off the exhaust heat of the first) are 435 grams CO2 per kWh.

But the numbers I posted are what I meant. In the US, an average of one kilogram of CO2 is emitted per kilowatt-hour of energy (3.6 * 10^6 Joules) generated. Nuclear is two orders of magnitude less carbon emission (versus coal), wind and solar are comparable if deployed under ideal conditions. Even under non-ideal conditions, they still offer an order of magnitude improvement.

Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by throwaway894345 on Monday September 27, 2021 @12:14PM (#28672565)
It's almost exactly 1kg per kw/h, at least in the US: https://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.php?id=74&t=11

But yes, "per hour" is necessary because you can't instantaneously emit a certain mass of co2. You emit over time, just like you generate power over time.

Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by jeltz on Monday September 27, 2021 @12:30PM (#28672755)
I suspect it is a typo and that it should be grams per kWh.
Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by Teknoman117 on Monday September 27, 2021 @02:47PM (#28674462)
yes, I meant kWh. I picked up kW/h as a nasty habit from my previous power company's billing statements.
Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by ajsnigrutin on Monday September 27, 2021 @11:09AM (#28671589)
And compared to solar, they produce power even during cold, winter nights, when you need heat the most.

It's not the most efficiant way to heat your homes (fission -> heat -> water -> steam engine -> electricity -> heater), but it brings autonomy to each country (so global issues don't affect your country), and with heat pumps, it's not even that bad at heating.

Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by bialpio on Monday September 27, 2021 @03:18PM (#28674865)
I was under the impression that the last step can potentially be made pretty efficient if it's "electricity -> heat pump" (but that depends on the conditions). Also - can nuclear power plants operate in combined heat and power mode to provide district heating? That'd probably require them to be close to highly populated areas though.
Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by coryrc on Monday September 27, 2021 @12:32PM (#28672785)
Add in district heating and you get cheap heat too. Europe is often dense enough for this to work...
Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by belorn on Monday September 27, 2021 @10:14AM (#28670881)
In comparison to burning fossil fuels which is the basis of the energy crisis, the emissions, radiation, acquisition of fuel, and operate seems all cleaner for a nuclear reactor than the fossil fuel which it replace.

Per GW/h, a fossil fueled power plant is producing a lot of pollution that goes into the air and poison the people and land around it. The outcome from this can be plainly seen in the death per GW/h produced.

The only "100%" clean base load generation we have is actually hydro, but there are a few problems with it. We have already maxed out, and even if we tried to build more it would cause significant amount of greenhouse gas emissions from topsoil decomposition. It also happens to have one of the highest deaths per GW/h, although thankfully we tend to attribute that to the weather rather than the technology itself.

Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by Teknoman117 on Monday September 27, 2021 @11:29AM (#28671885)
This.

Nuclear fission isn't "perfect" due to the potential risks involved, but it's one of the best things we have going for us right now. The climate crisis is here, and we have to do something pretty much immediately. We don't have time to argue over what's best anymore. Build things we know work and replace those with something else when something better comes along.

Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by nradov on Monday September 27, 2021 @09:54AM (#28670655)
Clean enough compared to the alternatives.