News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by raxxorrax on Monday September 27, 2021 @09:32AM (#28670433)
The energy crisis is because of prices, not necessarily because of ressource limits. The ressources are only a tiny amount, the rest is investments.

Gas would be a huge ecological improvement to coal. Nuclear power is too expensive and much of the costs are externalized. It will only be able to compete if you weight co2 beyond any other influence.

I think this is mainly US propaganda to be honest. The pipeline isn't needed for a long time to meet demands.

Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by throwaway894345 on Monday September 27, 2021 @09:39AM (#28670495)
> Gas would be a huge ecological improvement to coal.

Normally I don’t want the perfect to be the enemy of the good, but we need to ramp down emissions quickly and natural gas doesn’t get us near enough to the goal line. This seems like we need to be going for bust on clean energy, but it will be expensive.

> I think this is mainly US propaganda to be honest.

How do you figure? My post didn’t have anything positive to say about the US (because for some reason it reduces one’s credibility to acknowledge anything positive that happens in the US), but only that the result seems to be desirable.

Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by inglor_cz on Monday September 27, 2021 @11:26AM (#28671824)
Given the fact that the market with gas is global, that the EU has almost no local sources of gas under its control and that gas availability / price is fluctuating rather heavily, I would try avoiding reliance on gas too. As of today, it isn't any more reliable than wind.
Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by raxxorrax on Monday September 27, 2021 @09:54AM (#28670651)
I meant the article and its framing, not your post.

We cannot ramp down co2 emission to zero. The co2 balance of building nuclear power plants will only amortize when we already hit 1,5°C warming and it is questionable if it helps at all considering the unknowns about operating periods and other influences.

Overall if we just look at Germany it wouldn't even matter, the nation is too small, it wouldn't even make a dent. It is still necessary to reduce emissions, but if you zero them all, it would be less than 2% of overall world wide emissions, even if it is on place 6. Not for long though and it will be completely dwarfed by the US, China and India.

Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by dtech on Monday September 27, 2021 @10:17AM (#28670918)
> Overall if we just look at Germany it wouldn't even matter, the nation is too small

Every nation is saying this, including US pointing to China. China is then saying they use less per capita and started producing CO2 decades after western nations.

Congratulations, we're not doing anything collectively. I'm sure that'll excuse us to the inhabitants of earth in 50-100 years.

Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by adventured on Monday September 27, 2021 @01:04PM (#28673271)
It doesn't matter what China says, what rationalizations are used. What matters is the total emissions output and the direction.

China's emissions are skyrocketing, while already being drastically greater than the US or EU. While the US and EU emissions have been declining gradually.

If you have 1.4 billion people, you don't get to have the same (high) per capita emissions output as a nation 1/4 your population size. The world didn't force China to have 1.4b people, it's their responsibility. The fair target isn't parity per capita with the US, it's China being allowed to have no more than 1/4 the per capita emissions of the US. And that's still a terrible number, the US is the drop dead line for where we don't want other large countries going beyond. The problem is China is already double that and heading a lot higher yet.

We don't have to urgently care if Estonia were to have the highest per capita output of emissions, they can't destroy the planet with their emissions no matter what they do. China can due to their population. It would be a different context if China's emissions were declining.

With regards to China's CO2 emissions for example, how much more dire can it get?

https://i.imgur.com/B6W1S3q.jpg

Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by soperj on Monday September 27, 2021 @04:16PM (#28675467)
US is the richest nation on earth and is more responsible for the current problem than any other nation on earth. They have the means to reduce their emissions drastically but choose not to.
Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by throwaway894345 on Monday September 27, 2021 @05:11PM (#28676071)
The US should absolutely do more to reduce its emissions, but the actions or inaction of one country doesn't impugn or absolve others. Otherwise any country can and will point to some other country and use some contrived rationale like yours to justify inaction. At the end of the day, we need all countries to meet their emissions targets, otherwise we'll just be pointing fingers at each other while society crumbles around us.
Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by soperj on Monday September 27, 2021 @05:35PM (#28676319)
US is one of the main countries trying to justify inaction. They've still cumulatively contributed nearly double the amount of Co2 to the atmosphere as China.
Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by throwaway894345 on Monday September 27, 2021 @06:35PM (#28676920)
This is silly. The US isn't trying to justify inaction, and cumulative contributions isn't useful for anything. Of course the United States' total emissions are higher--it industrialized nearly a century before China, long before climate science existed or before technology existed anywhere to reduce emissions.

The relevant metric is the rate of change of emission--are we putting more or less carbon into the atmosphere year over year, and by how much? China is continuing to increase its emissions year over year, while the US emissions are falling (though not quickly enough).

Another interesting metric is the consumptive emissions--how much emissions are generated from trade (e.g., when an American buys something produced in China, the carbon involved in manufacturing that item is emitted in China, but the American benefits from the pollution as well). I actually expected the US to have much higher consumptive emissions relative to China, but it looks like the consumptive emissions pretty closely track the productive emissions while being just a bit higher at 5.77 billion t/yr (falling gradually since 2005), while China's are at 9.86 billion t/yr and climbing.

On the note of consumptive emissions, the United States should not only implement its own carbon pricing scheme, but it (along with other rich countries) should also implement a border adjustment so countries like China don't enjoy unfair competitive advantages because they pollute. This would incentivize China to reduce its Co2 or suffer heavy economic losses. It would also increase manufacturing in countries that are more responsible.

That said, to your point, the Democratic Party pays lip service to environmental concerns (the current $3.5 T budget bill is making expensive token gestures to the environment which will cost polluters virtually nothing) and the Republican Party isn't even doing that. So yes, America has a lot of room for improvement (but at least America isn't arguing that we should be allowed to increase our emissions, contrary to Chinese arguments).

Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by soperj on Monday September 27, 2021 @06:54PM (#28677126)
>The US isn't trying to justify inaction

You guys just signed the Paris Agreement this year.

>cumulative contributions isn't useful for anything

It's the reason we're in the predicament we're in.

>long before climate science existed or before technology existed anywhere to reduce emissions.

You've known about it since the 80s. You haven't reduced emissions since then. Technology has existed for a long time to reduce emissions.

Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by throwaway894345 on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @01:18AM (#28679590)
Friend, you’re the one using historic emissions to excuse everyone’s inaction. Anyway, this conversation has gone stale. I hope you got whatever nationalistic satisfaction you were looking for.
Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by lotsofpulp on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @07:30AM (#28681541)
The lack of meaningful taxes on gasoline to prevent wide swaths of the population from buying F150s and other large vehicles to pick up kids from school clearly shows where the US stands.
Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by soperj on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @01:47AM (#28679729)
I'm not excusing anyone's inactions. I'm saying the US has to do more. Period. Full Stop.
Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by throwaway894345 on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @10:41AM (#28683361)
> I'm saying the US has to do more.

I said this twice up thread but you were unsatisfied and continued your anti-American rant. Whatever, I'm glad that we agree now.

Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by soperj on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @10:59AM (#28683577)
Saying it while also justifying their current policy doesn't make what I'm saying an anti-American rant.
Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by throwaway894345 on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @11:06AM (#28683654)
> Saying it while also justifying their current policy

You're back-pedaling. I was explicitly critical of US climate policy. My two claims have consistently been: "The US isn't doing enough" and "the US is still doing better than China, which continues to increase its emission rate". You brought up cumulative numbers as a rebuttal to those claims.

Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by soperj on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @03:09PM (#28686253)
I'm not.
Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by throwaway894345 on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @05:46PM (#28687914)
If you say so ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by throwaway894345 on Monday September 27, 2021 @10:13AM (#28670868)
> The co2 balance of building nuclear power plants will only amortize when we already hit 1,5°C warming and it is questionable if it helps at all considering the unknowns about operating periods and other influences.

This is why it’s sad to decommission existing plants, but I don’t think there’s any legitimate question as to whether nuclear is harmful. It’s a pretty well-understood quantity, but I’m not sure which “factors” you’re describing.

> Overall if we just look at Germany it wouldn't even matter, the nation is too small, it wouldn't even make a dent. It is still necessary to reduce emissions, but if you zero them all, it would be less than 2% of overall world wide emissions, even if it is on place 6. Not for long though and it will be completely dwarfed by the US, China and India.

No Germany alone won’t make a dent directly, but it can model leadership. It’s a lot easier for other countries to get on board when someone has paved the way.

Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by raxxorrax on Monday September 27, 2021 @10:39AM (#28671166)
I agree, I think from a technical perspective most of these plants are fine and they could be used for an additional time. Since the last will shut down next year, I would assume the plans are locked in by now.

Nuclear has some advantages for base loads in some scenarios, but it cannot really compete with renewables down the road.

Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by throwaway894345 on Monday September 27, 2021 @11:28AM (#28671870)
> Since the last will shut down next year, I would assume the plans are locked in by now.

Sadly, I assume you're correct.

> Nuclear has some advantages for base loads in some scenarios, but it cannot really compete with renewables down the road.

To be clear, I would love it if we could power everything off of solar and wind, but we still don't have any scalable technology for storing weeks worth of energy which means that solar and wind cannot be used for base load generation. Hydro simply doesn't have the capacity. Nuclear is the only clean energy option for base load for the foreseeable future. Hoping for a storage tech breakthrough in the coming decades isn't a plan; we should really be investing in nuclear and storage in case one of those two don't pan out.

Even today, there are some interesting Small Modular Reactor (SMRs) which allow nuclear plants to be built more quickly, safely, compactly, and efficiently than traditional nuclear plants. We should build some of these and iterate on them while simultaneously investing in solving the storage problem.

Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by pfdietz on Monday September 27, 2021 @07:24PM (#28677379)
Hydrogen can be made and stored underground using existing technology. This is not currently competitive, but it doesn't involve inventing anything new. Storing hydrogen in underground solution mind salt caverns is very cheap per unit of energy storage capacity, some two orders of magnitude cheaper than batteries.
Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by throwaway894345 on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @01:20AM (#28679603)
It seems like a contradiction to say “it’s not currently competitive” (with what? batteries?) but it’s also “two orders of magnitude cheaper than batteries”. Why aren’t we doing this?
Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by pfdietz on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @05:14AM (#28680738)
It's not currently competitive with fossil fuels unburdened by CO2 charges. There is no reason to make and store hydrogen when natural gas is much cheaper. This doesn't mean that when fossil fuels are banned, it won't be competitive with the remaining alternatives.
Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by cesarb on Monday September 27, 2021 @01:40PM (#28673699)
> but we still don't have any scalable technology for storing weeks worth of energy

Why would we need to store weeks worth of energy? Wouldn't a more realistic amount be just a couple of days, or even less?

Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by throwaway894345 on Monday September 27, 2021 @03:14PM (#28674818)
You have to account for increasingly frequent continent-scale weather patterns which can last for weeks in extreme cases. "Weeks" is a figure I heard a few times in the media, but even "days" is a herculean task considering we're presently at "minutes" or worse. Note also that part of solving for emissions means "electrifying more applications" which means it's not sufficient to store days or weeks of today's energy demands, but rather days or weeks of future energy demands which will be much higher (e.g., today our entire transport industry isn't electrified--in the future our grid will need to supply the energy to move cars and trucks and trains which means the overall demand is much larger and consequently we'll have greater storage demands).
Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by himinlomax on Monday September 27, 2021 @11:37AM (#28672005)
Nuclear, externalized? that's the exact opposite, as the waste is left in the hands of the users, as opposed to dumped in the atmosphere.
Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by karaterobot on Monday September 27, 2021 @02:40PM (#28674349)
Which elements of nuclear are externalized?
Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by goodpoint on Monday September 27, 2021 @02:48PM (#28674479)
The environmental and economical cost of excavation.

Also the environmental and economical cost and waste management.

Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by throwaway894345 on Monday September 27, 2021 @06:40PM (#28676983)
The environmental cost of excavation is externalized, but it's negligible compared to that of fossil fuels ("economical cost" is nonsense), but the environmental cost of managing waste very much isn't externalized. At least not in the West (less sure about China, but I'm guessing they do roughly what we do).
Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by goodpoint on Monday September 27, 2021 @08:08PM (#28677722)
Sources needed.
Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by throwaway894345 on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @01:36AM (#28679673)
Not sure what you’re looking for specifically, but by far the biggest environmental threat is posed by emissions. Nuclear has the lowest emissions per unit energy of any energy source including the emissions that factor into mining the uranium and building the nuclear facilities, managing the waste, etc. https://ourworldindata.org/safest-sources-of-energy
Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by scythe on Monday September 27, 2021 @11:28AM (#28671854)
>Nuclear power is too expensive

Nuclear plant construction is too expensive, sure. Running existing nuclear plants instead of shutting them down before EoL is not too expensive. What we are talking about in Germany is the latter.

https://www.cleanenergywire.org/factsheets/history-behind-ge...

Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by throwaway894345 on Monday September 27, 2021 @11:29AM (#28671879)
Also, from my sibling comment[0]:

> Even today, there are some interesting Small Modular Reactor (SMRs) which allow nuclear plants to be built more quickly, safely, compactly, and efficiently than traditional nuclear plants. We should build some of these and iterate on them while simultaneously investing in solving the storage problem.

[0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28671870