News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by throwaway894345 on Monday September 27, 2021 @10:13AM (#28670868)
> The co2 balance of building nuclear power plants will only amortize when we already hit 1,5°C warming and it is questionable if it helps at all considering the unknowns about operating periods and other influences.

This is why it’s sad to decommission existing plants, but I don’t think there’s any legitimate question as to whether nuclear is harmful. It’s a pretty well-understood quantity, but I’m not sure which “factors” you’re describing.

> Overall if we just look at Germany it wouldn't even matter, the nation is too small, it wouldn't even make a dent. It is still necessary to reduce emissions, but if you zero them all, it would be less than 2% of overall world wide emissions, even if it is on place 6. Not for long though and it will be completely dwarfed by the US, China and India.

No Germany alone won’t make a dent directly, but it can model leadership. It’s a lot easier for other countries to get on board when someone has paved the way.

Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by raxxorrax on Monday September 27, 2021 @10:39AM (#28671166)
I agree, I think from a technical perspective most of these plants are fine and they could be used for an additional time. Since the last will shut down next year, I would assume the plans are locked in by now.

Nuclear has some advantages for base loads in some scenarios, but it cannot really compete with renewables down the road.

Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by throwaway894345 on Monday September 27, 2021 @11:28AM (#28671870)
> Since the last will shut down next year, I would assume the plans are locked in by now.

Sadly, I assume you're correct.

> Nuclear has some advantages for base loads in some scenarios, but it cannot really compete with renewables down the road.

To be clear, I would love it if we could power everything off of solar and wind, but we still don't have any scalable technology for storing weeks worth of energy which means that solar and wind cannot be used for base load generation. Hydro simply doesn't have the capacity. Nuclear is the only clean energy option for base load for the foreseeable future. Hoping for a storage tech breakthrough in the coming decades isn't a plan; we should really be investing in nuclear and storage in case one of those two don't pan out.

Even today, there are some interesting Small Modular Reactor (SMRs) which allow nuclear plants to be built more quickly, safely, compactly, and efficiently than traditional nuclear plants. We should build some of these and iterate on them while simultaneously investing in solving the storage problem.

Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by pfdietz on Monday September 27, 2021 @07:24PM (#28677379)
Hydrogen can be made and stored underground using existing technology. This is not currently competitive, but it doesn't involve inventing anything new. Storing hydrogen in underground solution mind salt caverns is very cheap per unit of energy storage capacity, some two orders of magnitude cheaper than batteries.
Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by throwaway894345 on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @01:20AM (#28679603)
It seems like a contradiction to say “it’s not currently competitive” (with what? batteries?) but it’s also “two orders of magnitude cheaper than batteries”. Why aren’t we doing this?
Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by pfdietz on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @05:14AM (#28680738)
It's not currently competitive with fossil fuels unburdened by CO2 charges. There is no reason to make and store hydrogen when natural gas is much cheaper. This doesn't mean that when fossil fuels are banned, it won't be competitive with the remaining alternatives.
Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by cesarb on Monday September 27, 2021 @01:40PM (#28673699)
> but we still don't have any scalable technology for storing weeks worth of energy

Why would we need to store weeks worth of energy? Wouldn't a more realistic amount be just a couple of days, or even less?

Re:Europe’s energy crisis is about to go global as gas price... by throwaway894345 on Monday September 27, 2021 @03:14PM (#28674818)
You have to account for increasingly frequent continent-scale weather patterns which can last for weeks in extreme cases. "Weeks" is a figure I heard a few times in the media, but even "days" is a herculean task considering we're presently at "minutes" or worse. Note also that part of solving for emissions means "electrifying more applications" which means it's not sufficient to store days or weeks of today's energy demands, but rather days or weeks of future energy demands which will be much higher (e.g., today our entire transport industry isn't electrified--in the future our grid will need to supply the energy to move cars and trucks and trains which means the overall demand is much larger and consequently we'll have greater storage demands).