(Note, I’m not advocating for either approach. I think personal automobiles should be banned, in fact. But I’m at least willing to be honest about how such systems would obviously be designed.)
If you have no problem with humans driving by hoping they find the right pixels on their retinas, why would you worry about AI doing the same? If anything, AI has a perfect reaction, is never tired or sleepy or unattentive. It just needs to be taught properly.
Uh no, then you can only use automated driving systems where beacons are installed.
So just like all miracle solutions, .i.e. communism, every time we tried it, we just weren't doing it right.
When we need something that works 99.99999% of the time, it is written in ADA or similar safe language and tested exhaustively. You know how long processing will take to the microsecond, you use a special realtime OS, etc.
AI will have its own failings, some of them totally unpredictable, so yes, boiling it down to 'just needs to be trained properly' is terrifying when peoples lives are at stake
Look at this attack, and tell me how is this goonf to be avoided with 'proper training' https://www.theregister.com/2018/01/11/ai_adversarial_attack...
Same can be said about humans.
None of what you listed matters in the real world. Self-driving systems just have to be better than average humans, on average, to be useful.
> boiling it down to 'just needs to be trained properly' is terrifying when peoples lives are at stake
You have no problem with humans being trained to drive. 38.6 thousand people died in car crashes in the US alone last year.
What you are describing is actually probably the end game - but I think musk and others have correctly identified that if you wait for infrastructure to be ready then you will be waiting a long time, and if you want to see self driving cars anytime soon you have to assume current infra.
It's much, much easier to navigate a lonely highway in the middle of nowhere without much traffic than it is to navigate the perilous labyrinth of the suburbs and downtown traffic.
It can also be done much more simply by laying down copper in the road and making it a part of infrastructure so that the cars can sense it and figure out that it's the road. Stop signs, traffic lights, and interchanges can be marked using changes that the car can detect. The rest can be collision avoidance.
> Biden is proposing a $174 billion investment into electrifying cars and trucks in the United States. It would establish grant and incentive programs for state and local governments and the private sector to build a national network of 500,000 electric vehicle charging stations by 2030.
https://www.nytimes.com/2021/03/31/business/biden-electric-v...
America's infrastructure in such bad shape that there's a good chance that the arteries of US commerce will start having an increase in catastrophic failures leading to death.
But it's being pushed back against, because well, reasons. This spending, to transform America's degrading infrastructure, will come out to $350Bn/yr. The Middle East & Afghanistan wars come out to, $355Bn/yr at - $6.4 trillion over ~18 years. https://www.cnbc.com/2019/11/20/us-spent-6point4-trillion-on... . The tax cuts under the last administration come out to $200Bn/yr. Neither of these - the wars and the tax cuts - have been balanced and are coming out of America's ballooning deficit.
If you would like the Government to do more of this, please call your representatives and vote for people who invest money towards a better future for everyone.
Cities install traffic lights with sensors and an internet connection so that it can be controlled from the city traffic management HQ. There are dozens of professionals in front of giant screens, and a supercomputer at their disposal. Could that information be sent directly to cars?
No, instead we cram a computer and a camera into every car and hope it can find the right pixels on the picture in fog and rain.
Smart approach would be to invest in infrastructure - standard location beacons that tell cars exactly where they are and what is ahead, wireless communication between cars so they know locations and bearing of every vehicle within a square mile, wireless tags could be installed on all bikes and cycles, etc. We have an entire department for traffic management in each city that could suggest a route to every car?
We already installed speed cameras, number plate recognition, pedestrian counting, we have vehicle sensing sensors inside the road that count and weigh cars, and none of this information is being used. If cloud computing makes sence for crappy apps, then it definitely makes sence to assist cars.