Any they're all 30 minutes. What the heck do you expect to accomplish in 30 minutes? You spend 20% of the time waiting for someone to show up.
For the daily team coordination meeting I run, we had a problem with that. So after one especially egregious delay, I asked how people felt about that. They didn't like it, of course. I then said I wanted a consistent start time, but was open as to when it was. At the hour? 1 minute after? 5 minutes after?
To my surprise, they picked 1 minute after. And everybody has stuck to it. A couple months in we'll occasionally have somebody turn up late, but the meeting starts without them, so they know not to do it again. It's great!
We also build an agenda on the fly, keeping the pace brisk. Usually we finish a few minutes early, and sometimes the meeting will be a zippy 10-15 minutes. It's possible to have good, useful meetings!
Part of this is because I'm also fine with interrupting and telling people to take something async if a group meeting is becoming a hyper-specific 1:1.
Soon enough, meetings remain direct and rabbit-hole free. Unless the entire purpose of the meeting was to collectively burrow into it.
All it takes is a little discipline, and clear expectations.
Needless to say when I just recently did that with the two program managers in a fortune 500 I got punished.
It leaves you wondering why these big corps have program and project managers when they:
- consistently don't have an agenda
- completely ignore scope
- don't even try to define scope
- keep talking about being productive
- keep getting promoted for creating powerbi dashboards of other people's work
Not that all managers are bad or anything; plenty of them are people just trying to get things done. It's a structural problem.
I don't know how you went about it in this case but, I've never called out.
All I've ever said is, hey...do we need to do this now?
But that tends to spin off longer discussions, and there are often short things people want to raise with the team. So after we've gone through our kanban board, we'll have an optional period called "post". Long items go into Zoom chat as "Post: thing to discuss" and we give a few minutes to each.
I totally agree with blocking rabbit holes. Things that interrupt the fast run-through of the board get booted to post. Items there that are longer than a few minutes get booted to async or a topic-specific meeting, generally a smaller group than the team meeting.
One other trick I recommend: rotate leadership of the meeting once people have the hang of it. I ran mine myself for the first couple months. Then I ran it every other week, with somebody new swapping in. The weeks when people are responsible for keeping the meeting on track make them much better participants when they're not in charge.
Before everyone kind of expected ~3 minutes of lateness to be the norm, dependent on elevator and stairway congestion. And god forbid one person is traveling from another meeting in another building a bit of a walk away.
Way too many 39 minute things get scheduled for 60. While there logistics issues at physical events with multiple tracks I feel most conference talks should be 30 minutes too.
Text is good or bad. It’s an attention thief, and you never know what you are getting. Also, I find that platforms like Teams are great for the present, but awful for history and context.
"Standups" that are really PM status calls that constantly go down rabbit holes. My update is 30s or less, but the meetings are always 30 minutes long and usually run over.
"Code reviews" that are really run/monopolized by one person. The entire team is required to attend even if you have no code, but in practice no one other than the runner is allowed to provide feedback.
The calls started out shorter but over time they've become a hybrid of:
- "Here's the outlay for today." The shortest are just this which only happens when things are going smoothly and everyone's tackling things of moderate difficulty.
- "Here's something that's been giving me trouble" which prompts a few minutes discussion. Usually someone has a idea to pitch in which gets the person unstuck, but it can bleed into...
- "I wanted to bring up this thing I noticed" which pulls us into a bigger half-hour discussion with some possible followups scheduled with the more senior members.
So at the extremes, any given instance of this meeting could last from 10 minutes to 45 minutes.
We usually refer to this as a "stand-up" but I could see how someone from a more regimented team would understand it to be something with a more tightly defined purpose.
Obviously this gets a little slack if you're a super senior position (nobody's telling the company President they're not circling back on something already discussed) but for the most part meetings are much more efficient if you're absolutely ruthless with the clock. It's literally the only thing that nobody can control.
On the flipside you have to be equally ruthless about not going over time. At 5 min before the scheduled meeting end time we start cutting off discussions that have become circular and start determining if we need to have a follow-up or clarification meeting for something. My biggest rule for this is that it can't be the exact same group, you'll just end up having the same meeting again. These follow-up meetings are most effective if it's a subset of the original group trying to clarify some specific point.
30 minute meetings can be useful if you stick to these rules.
Write up everything first for education and background, distribute that, then have a short meeting when there’s something actionable to do.
That explains a lot of things though. It sounds like most of your meetings are terrible. Actually, if most of people's meetings in this thread are terrible experiences, that seems like it would explain their sentiments. In other words, meetings are mostly time loss, which you're of course trying to minimize.
(It really helps that we have a culture of "I don't think I can contribute to this meeting, I'm gonna head out.")
Almost all of my in-person meetings are technical debates - or group debugging sessions, where progress depends on randomly noticing something. In both cases, they scale well with number of members up to a point of four or so, where adding another participant generates more ideas than it costs time.
That's the main thing I come across. Most meetings are well over four people. And personally, I already don't deal well with more than 3 people as most people work on a vastly different wavelength than myself.
Now consider all the "Agile" meetings are already 5+ people and often contain management types and people who are both higher on the chain of command and have no technical background either hogging the attention. Suddenly, most meetings I see become either a hybrid announcement + roll call, a "meeting" with ulterior motives (e.g. managers trying to measure "participation" as a way to grade employees) or a very rushed design-by-committee approach to solving something.
Meanwhile in my “Sent” (aka “CYA”) folder…you can guess where this is going.
If voice/video meetings could have no more than 4 participants unless (insert somewhat burdensome exception process), all participants would presumably consider more carefully who should be added.
It's just like of the signup process on your landing page. Make things you want to happen as effortless as possible -> make things you want to happen less more effortful.
An average week is 2.5 hours of "core" meetings
* 1.5 hours - 30 minute "standup" 3 days per week. Skip the BS status updates. Planning, team discussions, etc all happen in this timeframe.
* 30 minutes of retro (1 hour biweekly)
* 30 minutes of 1:1
We generally keep planning meetings pretty light. A _really_ heavy week will be 10 hours of planning. A light week will be 1 or 2 hours talking about an upcoming feature.
Everything else happens by individuals, asynchronously.
And this ain't no startup either: EA DICE can probably safely be described as a rather large company these days..
Of course, it might well be different in other teams, being a backend web developer I'm part of a somewhat unusual team in the context of a gaming studio.
It’s an extraordinary week when I get as many as 40% of my working hours for focus time.
* Weekly cross functional syncs for the products I’m involved in, 2 hours.
* Weekly design and SLA/postmortem reviews for the org, 2 hours.
* Three interviews and associated debriefs, 4.5 hours.
* Standup, planning, and retro, 2.5 hours.
* Tech talks, knowledge sharing sessions, org and company all hands, 2 hours.
That’s before anything as-needed to work on a specific issue.