News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:The NSA and CIA use ad blockers by cochne on Thursday September 23, 2021 @12:54PM (#28631818)
Not really the same. The implied agreement when you visit an ad based site is that you get the ads. Otherwise if no one got them, the site could not exist. It’s a form of payment for what the site provides to you, not the product itself.
Re:The NSA and CIA use ad blockers by Spooky23 on Thursday September 23, 2021 @01:20PM (#28632202)
There's no implied agreement - a product is offered at no cost, and I'm under no legal, ethical or moral obligation to look at anything. I'm a weirdo who still buys the paper newspaper. I throw out the Thursday auto advertisements and the Sunday ads.

Content producers made a conscious decision to aggregate their screen real estate and outsource ad placement to unrelated third parties. The result is a cesspool of awful, low engagement content. Its so bad that they enter into awful agreements with aggregators to repackage their content for pennies. That's their problem, not mine.

On the flip, I live in a state capital, and when the legislature is in session, interest groups spend 10x what they spend on useless online ad spots to buy full-page or panel ads in the printed newspaper. Presumably they aren't doing that in an effort to set money on fire.

Re:The NSA and CIA use ad blockers by nickff on Thursday September 23, 2021 @02:06PM (#28632821)
>"I'm under no legal, ethical or moral obligation to look at anything"

That would depend on you moral theory of choice; applying Kantian (deontological) moral theory, your behavior violates the principle of 'universalizability'.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kantian_ethics

Re:The NSA and CIA use ad blockers by Spooky23 on Thursday September 23, 2021 @09:02PM (#28637494)
Seems like an absurd leap to me. Am I obliged to read the sports section of a newspaper?

What does it mean when a entire category of commerce is so toxic that government security officials recommend that civilian agencies preclude employees from seeing it?

Re:The NSA and CIA use ad blockers by krisoft on Thursday September 23, 2021 @02:34PM (#28633232)
I’m not following you. In what way would it violate the principle of ‘universalizability’?
Re:The NSA and CIA use ad blockers by nickff on Thursday September 23, 2021 @02:46PM (#28633424)
From the Wikipedia on universalizability:

>"The precise meaning of universalizability is contentious, but the most common interpretation is that the categorical imperative asks whether the maxim of your action could become one that everyone could act upon in similar circumstances."

>"For instance, one can determine whether a maxim of lying to secure a loan is moral by attempting to universalize it and applying reason to the results. If everyone lied to secure loans, the very practices of promising and lending would fall apart, and the maxim would then become impossible."

If everyone were to block ads, the publications that you're reading would not be able to pay for the content they publish. Note that 'universalizability' requires a somewhat static analysis, and usually doesn't look at how systems might adapt to changed circumstances, though this is not a big problem here, as you have voluntarily chosen to interact with ad-supported publishers under the current regime.

Re:The NSA and CIA use ad blockers by mindslight on Thursday September 23, 2021 @03:19PM (#28633919)
Content on the web was much better before the scourge of advertising took over. I very much wish everybody would universally block ads. Appealing to the current situation in a static sense is a cop out that lets you condemn what would be a welcome reversion.
Re:The NSA and CIA use ad blockers by Drew_ on Thursday September 23, 2021 @04:28PM (#28634846)
Much better for privileged geeks maybe not for anyone else.
Re:The NSA and CIA use ad blockers by mindslight on Thursday September 23, 2021 @04:46PM (#28635116)
Say what you actually mean rather than just invoking a nebulous condemnation of "privilege".

The information on the web used to be of much higher quality. Within the first page of search results you'd usually find a no-nonsense website full of painstakingly curated information. Who had the means to access that information is orthogonal to its quality.

Re:The NSA and CIA use ad blockers by Drew_ on Thursday September 23, 2021 @06:37PM (#28636467)
There's nothing nebulous about affording access to information being a privilege.
Re:The NSA and CIA use ad blockers by mindslight on Thursday September 23, 2021 @06:44PM (#28636520)
What's nebulous is that you're not making an argument.

Sure, we can say that affording Internet access (gear) is a form of privilege. What bearing does that have on what I said?

Re:The NSA and CIA use ad blockers by Drew_ on Thursday September 23, 2021 @07:12PM (#28636778)
Take a moment to consider how expensive and exclusive access to the internet was "back in the good ol' days" and maybe you'll be able to connect the dots. If you still can't there's nothing I can do for you sorry.
Re:The NSA and CIA use ad blockers by Dylan16807 on Friday September 24, 2021 @01:27AM (#28638918)
No, you spell it out.

You might be arguing that privileged people make better websites, or implying that the other person is saying that, or some variant, or...?

mindslight is not saying we should revert everything back to those days, such as the internet being expensive and exclusive. They want sites to stop using ad revenue. Those two things are not tied together. Unless you're arguing they are tied together, in which case again you need to explain yourself.

Re:The NSA and CIA use ad blockers by mindslight on Thursday September 23, 2021 @08:34PM (#28637312)
I can infer several arguments that you could hope to be implying. But I'm not going to guess at the specific one you're trying to make just to argue with myself.

In general: Correlation is not causation. As I said, the quality of information was orthogonal to who could access it. And furthermore, even in modern times advertising does not pay for Internet access nor computing devices.

Re:The NSA and CIA use ad blockers by krisoft on Thursday September 23, 2021 @04:16PM (#28634674)
> Note that 'universalizability' requires a somewhat static analysis

Sounds very convenient. You are allowed to make one logical step (everyone blocks adds => publishing companies go bankrupt) but are not allowed to make the equally sound step of (everyone blocks adds => publishing companies will seek other revenue sources such as paywalls).

But if you say i’m not allowed to argue the second one let’s talk about the first kind.

So universal add blocking puts those companies who keep clinging to add supported operation into bankruptcy. Goodridance. It is not like one must have free-as-in-beer services to have a coherent moral compass. They go bankrupt and we will manage without them. Totally consistent.

Similarly you wouldn’t say that the idea of punishing murderers lacks ‘universability’ just because it would shut down the Assasin’s Guild.

Re:The NSA and CIA use ad blockers by nickff on Thursday September 23, 2021 @07:40PM (#28636974)
But you seem to want to read the publications with ads...

If I extend your (unreasonable) murder analogy, I'd have to say that you were hiring the Assassin's Guild, but refusing to pay because you don't like their terms.

Re:The NSA and CIA use ad blockers by JohnFen on Thursday September 23, 2021 @02:36PM (#28633263)
> The implied agreement when you visit an ad based site is that you get the ads.

That's not the agreement that ad companies think is being implied, though. The ad companies think the deal is "Looking at this website gives us permission to spy on you across the web".

Re:The NSA and CIA use ad blockers by godshatter on Thursday September 23, 2021 @03:39PM (#28634186)
> The implied agreement when you visit an ad based site is that you get the ads.

They are putting stuff out on a server for public consumption. The implied agreement is that I'm allowed to view it, or not view it, in whole or in part. Their business plan is their problem.

Re:The NSA and CIA use ad blockers by blitzar on Thursday September 23, 2021 @01:04PM (#28631969)
One should also try out the alternatives as well, regarding the GP, I personally believe there was an equal obligation to experience it without the ads to determine the impact.

Likewise it would be nice for the alcohol producer to experience drinking every day, as well as being the only person at the party not drinking. Even being the allocated driver and seeing the consequences of their product up close. Perhaps they would gain some insight or perspective regarding their product.

Re:The NSA and CIA use ad blockers by jedberg on Thursday September 23, 2021 @12:54PM (#28631809)
I would find it hypocritical if someone who worked at an alcohol producer joined MADD, or someone who worked at a candy company joining a PAC that supports soda bans.

But no, they don't need to consume the product daily.

Re:The NSA and CIA use ad blockers by nkozyra on Thursday September 23, 2021 @01:04PM (#28631971)
> I would find it hypocritical if someone who worked at an alcohol producer joined MADD

Really? Isn't there a pretty big gulf between "drinks alcohol" and "drinks alcohol and then gets behind the wheel of a car?"

Re:The NSA and CIA use ad blockers by CameronNemo on Thursday September 23, 2021 @02:51PM (#28633501)
Yeah I think Phillip morris execs should be forced at gunpoint to smoke as many cigarettes a week as the global median. Might lead them to think twice before advertising poison.
Re:The NSA and CIA use ad blockers by crvdgc on Thursday September 23, 2021 @01:30PM (#28632344)
The reasoning here is not the dissonance in behavior, but dissonance in belief.

A person can believe alcohol is not harmful to humans health without consuming alcohol, therefore it's morally acceptable if an alcohol producer does not consume alcohol.

But if they don't consume alcohol because they believe alcohol is harmful, while advertising (explicitly or implicitly by helping the alcohol company) that it is not harmful, then that is dishonesty. Because in this case, the person purposefully acts like they believe something for personal benefits, but actually they don't.

Re:The NSA and CIA use ad blockers by jagger27 on Thursday September 23, 2021 @12:52PM (#28631771)
Should companies eat their own dogfood? Uh, yeah.
Re:The NSA and CIA use ad blockers by VWWHFSfQ on Thursday September 23, 2021 @12:55PM (#28631841)
I used to work on sports gambling apps and yet I never once gambled using the real production app. Because I saw the data. And behind those data points are real people having their lives ruined by some growth hackers and psychologist PMs trying to increase session length. I know how the sausage is made. I practically have the gambling addiction hotline number memorized because it was required to be on every screen.
Re:The NSA and CIA use ad blockers by CameronNemo on Thursday September 23, 2021 @02:52PM (#28633523)
Maybe businesses like that have no business existing, then.
Re:The NSA and CIA use ad blockers by asdff on Thursday September 23, 2021 @03:48PM (#28634319)
Pretty much everyone I know gambles on sports and for most of these guys its like a $50 bet, not a lot of money. No more than a few beers these days at a bar. People get addicted to anything, lets work on having people receive treatment if things become a problem rather than ban everything that most users are using responsibly. Might as well ban video games of you really want to get some people out of some deep holes.
Re:The NSA and CIA use ad blockers by aaron-santos on Thursday September 23, 2021 @01:15PM (#28632110)
Surely you do not work at Purina.
Re:The NSA and CIA use ad blockers by JumpCrisscross on Thursday September 23, 2021 @01:41PM (#28632480)
> Surely you do not work at Purina

I happen to know a handful of people who started pet food companies, albeit boutique ones. (California.) They all taste their pet foods. I've tried some of the treat biscuits, and they aren't half bad, though I wouldn't necessarily reach for them.

I'm not an expert on cat or dog digestion. But I think anything they can eat, humans can, too. (Just not the other way.)

Re:The NSA and CIA use ad blockers by jedberg on Thursday September 23, 2021 @01:45PM (#28632542)
Growing up in California, one thing we were taught as kids is that pet food is safe for human consumption, and can be used for food after an earthquake as emergency rations.

It won't taste good, but it will prevent starvation!

Re:The NSA and CIA use ad blockers by a1369209993 on Thursday September 23, 2021 @10:04PM (#28637863)
> pet food is safe for human consumption

This is false in general, and dangerously misleading at best. In particular, some dog foods contain ingredients (bone meal IIRC, but don't rely on that) that can pretty much destroy a human's intestines (which are much less hardy than most animals's because coevolution with cooked food allowed cost-cutting). Pet food sold in California might (might) be required to be safe, but that's dangerously unreliable at best.

Re:The NSA and CIA use ad blockers by Dylan16807 on Friday September 24, 2021 @01:36AM (#28638965)
Well, when I search human consumption of bone meal I get results saying it might be good or might be bad. There's a risk of intestinal blockage but that takes a whole lot and would happen in dogs too.

Searching is not suggesting any other particularly dangerous ingredients, other than to say it's not great long term. But on a level like "be careful not to get scurvy", not "will destroy your intestines". And that you should watch out for bad storage and still probably avoid raw meat.

Re:The NSA and CIA use ad blockers by jedberg on Friday September 24, 2021 @01:55AM (#28639071)
Not sure why you say that. The FDA regulates pet food the same way as human food: https://www.fda.gov/animal-veterinary/animal-food-feeds/pet-...
Re:The NSA and CIA use ad blockers by paulryanrogers on Thursday September 23, 2021 @04:56PM (#28635262)
I heard it the other way around. Dogs in particular can eat things that might kill a human.
Re:The NSA and CIA use ad blockers by not2b on Thursday September 23, 2021 @07:48PM (#28637029)
Chocolate is poisonous for dogs and cats, and an amount that would be harmless to you will kill a dog if not promptly treated.
Re:The NSA and CIA use ad blockers by kerblang on Thursday September 23, 2021 @02:27PM (#28633124)
If I work for purina then my _dog's_ gonna eat that dog food, by golly. And maybe I'll at least give it a sniff.

Speaking of the devil, I had to carry somebody's stray dog home (again) when I was on my jog this morning, and man that was a fat dog! Dunno what he eats, felt like krispy kreme and quarter pounders. Maybe I oughta start me a dog food company. Too many fat dogs in this danged town.

Re:The NSA and CIA use ad blockers by tubby12345 on Thursday September 23, 2021 @12:53PM (#28631789)
you're reiterating GP without addressing exactly the counter examples that i allude to.
Re:The NSA and CIA use ad blockers by jagger27 on Thursday September 23, 2021 @12:54PM (#28631816)
Do alcohol makers try their own products to ensure consistency day-to-day? I would hope so. I would certainly hope candymakers do too. Those are particularly bad examples.
Re:The NSA and CIA use ad blockers by bostik on Thursday September 23, 2021 @02:49PM (#28633470)
Master distillers definitely do. Not necessarily every single day, but for every single run of the stills, yes.

Distillery staff will also occasionally test that the caskets being matured are doing okay.

Source: visited 5 out of 7 distilleries on Islay.

Re:The NSA and CIA use ad blockers by jagger27 on Thursday September 23, 2021 @03:33PM (#28634109)
> visited 5 out of 7 distilleries on Islay.

Oh that would be _wonderful_. Some day!

Re:The NSA and CIA use ad blockers by tubby12345 on Thursday September 23, 2021 @12:57PM (#28631869)
ask yourself if you're willfully misconstruing what i'm saying in order to low brow dismiss my point.

jedberg claims he consumed ads every day in order to empathize with this customers. the obvious implication is that everyone at such a company has the obligation to "try their own products".

Re:The NSA and CIA use ad blockers by jagger27 on Thursday September 23, 2021 @01:02PM (#28631945)
Your analogy is weak, so I pointed it out. Reddit created their experience a certain way; why would you go out of your way to avoid seeing your product the way your users do?

You haven't presented a single argument as to WHY an employee of a software company shouldn't experience their product as their users do.

Re:The NSA and CIA use ad blockers by pessimizer on Thursday September 23, 2021 @01:44PM (#28632513)
Talking about product testing is a deliberate red herring, though. Nobody was talking about some web designer using adblock during the process of implementing ads on a site. That would be a very difficult hurdle to put in front of yourself.
Re:The NSA and CIA use ad blockers by kordlessagain on Thursday September 23, 2021 @01:52PM (#28632621)
Jedberg, who I know for a fact ran Reddit's infra singlehandedly for a while, claimed he consumed ads as a matter of understanding the user while holding the job. Apparently he grew a brain and decided to block ads after that job, as smart and well informed users tend to do.

I suggest turning off JavaScript for most sites, which keeps the ad blocking tasks to a minimum. Blocking trolling users is another matter entirely.

Re:The NSA and CIA use ad blockers by lmm on Friday September 24, 2021 @03:38AM (#28639611)
If you couldn't stand to consume your own product, you're probably doing bad things and should stop.
Re:The NSA and CIA use ad blockers by pbhjpbhj on Thursday September 23, 2021 @07:04PM (#28636716)
No, but if an alcohol seller practiced temperance because they felt alcohol was deleterious to people, wouldn't it be rather hypocritical? He was not actively consuming ads, he was just not seeking to avoid them.
Re:The NSA and CIA use ad blockers by daniel-cussen on Thursday September 23, 2021 @02:01PM (#28632750)
Well, about pharma: I believe at least one person with veto power at FDA should try the pill personally. And the pharma company management should be able to take it. This would have helped with OxyContin, among others.
Re:The NSA and CIA use ad blockers by MeinBlutIstBlau on Thursday September 23, 2021 @01:44PM (#28632519)
Crack dealers smoke their own crack to ensure they give out a good supply
Re:The NSA and CIA use ad blockers by no_time on Friday September 24, 2021 @02:21AM (#28639180)
They should listen to Ten Crack Commandments by Biggie Smalls.
Re:The NSA and CIA use ad blockers by PaulHoule on Thursday September 23, 2021 @02:07PM (#28632829)
Tobacco firms were notorious for expecting their employees to be tobacco users.

My mom was a sales clerk for Macy's and one of her friends was a sales clerk there who later became a tobacco company rep who went to convenience stores to manage the marketing displays.

She smoked like a chimney. After my dad died and her friend got divorced, her friend moved in a for a while with my mom and got my mom smoking again. My mom hid it from everybody and we found out only after she died from a cardiovascular event because we found a pack of cigarettes, one half-finished, in the cupboard.