News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ... by Gravityloss on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @09:27AM (#28616045)
Interesting points, though the abstract is quite hard to follow. I guess it makes sense:

    1. aliens spread at a certain speed after developing spaceflight
    2. they're not here
    3. there are no spacefaring aliens in the galaxy currently
Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ... by rsynnott on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @10:25AM (#28616639)
I think (1) is probably the main questionable assumption, to be honest. Let's take as given that travel faster than light via some form of cheating isn't possible. Under that assumption, for mass interstellar travel in reasonable time, you would require the ability to produce vast amounts of cheap energy (either via fusion on the starship, or antimatter produced with cheap energy at home and used on the starship, or by some other means).

And at that point, where is the incentive to colonize other star systems? You're still probably not going to be able to move a meaningful part of your population, and if you can produce energy that cheaply you can sustain a large population in comfort at home.

It's not inconceivable that there are advanced aliens all over the place, but that interstellar travel is basically limited to probes for pragmatic reasons.

I think when the Fermi Paradox was brought in, there was still some lingering Malthusian idea that geometric population expansion was inevitable. We now know it very much isn't, at least for us. That changes things.

Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ... by wing-_-nuts on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @10:43AM (#28616875)
We always assume that civilizations expand into space without consideration for benefit, but I don't think that will be the case, honestly.

Should we want a colony on another planet? In another star system? Absolutely. It doesn't take much expansion for us to achieve the goal of having a 'redundant backup' for humanity.

Beyond that, there has to be some sort of economic incentive to drive it. Given there is little chance we can economically trade between planets, much less between star systems, I don't think that incentive is there.

Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ... by brabel on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @12:43PM (#28618536)
Absolutely agree. I think that once you've established your civilization over a few stars and planets your survival is pretty much guaranteed against astronomical destruction (if there's anything huge enough to destroy ALL the stars you've colonized, you probably can tell with billions of years in advance), the incentive changes and you now want to basically go on stealth mode to make sure you don't actually attract any nasty neighbour's attention, because that may be the only thing you can NOT see that may be dangerous.

And notice that people from different star systems in the same civilization will very likely only have extremely rare direct encounters due to the brutally long distances involved... it's highly likely the civilization will split up into completely separate "star nations", with their own internal issues to keep them busy and at some point may lose interest even in communicating with other star systems... without any incentive at all to expand further as the species survival is guaranteed... curiosity wouldn't be strong enough, probably, because after getting to know several star systems, you may decide they are look more or less the same, and to find anything really interesting might take multi-million year journeys and no one would be able to embark on something like that just for curiosity.

Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ... by raducu on Thursday September 23, 2021 @01:30PM (#28632345)
I see no way a species that can technologically spread to a couple of star systems would stop expanding.

If you're scared of nasty aliens, the best defence is to conquer the whole galaxy before them.

There is no way to hide from an interstellar civilization.

Nasty or not, they could always produce self replicating probes and keep track of the whole galaxy.

Also, if you were able to colonize a couple of Star Systems, there's no way you are an anxious/scared species,

Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ... by lrem on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @01:51PM (#28619471)
> if there's anything huge enough to destroy ALL the stars you've colonized, you probably can tell with billions of years in advance

I can't think of any phenomena that could come close to doing such a thing. But if there was one, why couldn't it be like gamma bursts?

Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ... by tobyjsullivan on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @01:00PM (#28618754)
Exactly this. I was thinking about this the other day and using the web as a metaphor (bear with me).

It's easy to know where to go next when we only have one option to pursue (such as travelling to the next nearest planet or star). This is a lot like the early web when there were only a handful of interesting sites and discovering new cool sites was a goal in and of itself.

Today, I think we intuitively understand that there's no longer any value in trying to visit every website on the internet. Most sites offer zero value or even net negative value. The entire problem space pivots to one of knowing which 0.00001% of websites are valuable to a given situation.

When a civilization gains the ability to visit any planetary system, the problem shifts to one of filtering choices and information to minimize the amount of unnecessary travel or world-settling.

I assume this is a well-known concept. I'd love to read more if anybody knows what it's called.

Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ... by netjiro on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @11:03AM (#28617122)
One benefit is reduced risk of extinction by the various nasty ways the grand cosmos might annihilate a local-only civilisation.

Let's consider extinction mitigation as a luxury? I posit that sooner or later, as technology improves, the relative cost of such projects will go down to a point where some group of people think it is a good idea.

Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ... by wing-_-nuts on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @11:17AM (#28617307)
Again, you don't have to expand to more than a couple of self sustaining planets in a couple of solar systems to establish a reasonable redundant backup for mankind.

I don't think new discoveries suddenly change the physics of escaping gravity wells. I question whether interplanetary trade will ever move beyond intellectual property.

Basically, colonization will have to be altruistically funded without any expectation of economic return. We've proven we have limited capacity for that.

Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ... by Loughla on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @02:34PM (#28619981)
>We've proven we have limited capacity for that.

Currently.

In a system where resources are allocated not to cover the needs of all, but instead to ensure that the victor gets their spoils, this is true.

But IF a civilization makes it to a point where self-sustaining planet settlement is even a real possibility, I think you just have to assume they are post-scarcity and post-currency. Economic return isn't really a thing, if everyone can get what they want whenever they want it.

Therefore, any species with a natural propensity to exploration and curiosity as an individual is going to necessarily seek out new places as a whole. The individual will drive the societal, I guess is what I mean there. Because I want to see something new, and there is no scarcity of resources, society as a whole gets to see something new.

>I question whether interplanetary trade will ever move beyond intellectual property.

Honestly, I don't think so. Because, again, I'm of the firm belief that once a society is able to establish off-world colonies successfully, economics stops meaning anything at all, really.

Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ... by rsynnott on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @02:38PM (#28620030)
> Because I want to see something new, and there is no scarcity of resources, society as a whole gets to see something new.

You might _explore_. You're less likely to _colonise_. The only way you get the sort of geometric expansion people love to talk about is if there's a very strong imperative to colonise, and it's just not clear that it exists.

Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ... by anomaloustho on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @11:35AM (#28617562)
I’ve heard it said that if humanity simply maintains its growth pace, there should be enough human bodies to pile up into the entire solar system just by waiting X number of years.
Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ... by bluGill on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @12:05PM (#28617996)
> if humanity simply maintains its growth pace

But humanity is not doing that. The current trend is world population will peak at just over 9 billion in about 30 years. Trends can change, but that is the current one.

Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ... by jandrese on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @02:36PM (#28620006)
Every growth curve is an S curve. Every time you see one of those studies where someone takes a system that is still in an early growth phase and projects it out to infinity at the current growth rate it is always nonsense.
Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ... by PeterisP on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @04:30PM (#28621371)
The big issue here is different understanding of "reasonable time". The galaxy is very large, and the time spans involved are very large, but they are not in the same ballpark of "large", the time gaps involved are so much larger. If one civilization gets their evolution of intelligent life just 1% quicker than us, that's a head start of 50 million years. On that scale, "reasonable speed" required to fill the galaxy (to use round numbers, 10000 "hops" of 10 ly each for 100000ly distance across the whole galaxy) means something like a planet launching a single colony ship to a nearby star once in 5000 years (and the new colony populating the planet and launching another ship in 5000 years, which seems quite reasonable). You don't need FTL, you don't need fast ships, you don't need many ships, just one generation ship in a few millenia moving at 0.01c or even less is amply sufficient to colonize all of the galaxy many times over in that time range. And if someone was 2% or 3% faster than us, then they'd have even more excessive time to swarm the galaxy even if they're doing it at snail's speed.

So to explain the fact that the aliens aren't swarming everywhere because they can't afford it means accepting that either they launching a single generation-ship every 5000 years is a huge expenditure (which IMHO it wouldn't be even with our current economy size, definitely not an issue with the tech of 2100 or 2200 assuming at least some growth because at that point a Musk-type figure with a wish to "make humanity interstellar" would be able to afford it from private funds) or that we're the first (only?) life in galaxy or that all the aliens before us didn't try to expand, like, at all - because getting just one single rich eccentric every 5000 years (like a bunch of billionaires here are) would be sufficient to make the galaxy swarm with juuust a bit higher tech level than ours now.

Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ... by raducu on Thursday September 23, 2021 @01:24PM (#28632264)
The problem with generation ships is we assume we can just "zip" all knowledge and technology and ship it via a generation ship and "unzip"/bootstrap at destination.

I'm sure we are absolutely not capable to do that now. Maybe with AI.

But we haven't done that with our Moon and that's not even a few lightseconds away.

Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ... by PeterisP on Thursday September 23, 2021 @05:25PM (#28635660)
We certainly can "zip" enough knowledge and technology to match Earth as it was in year 1000 (and almost certainly year 1900) and as experience shows, it's sufficient to build up in a millenium or two i.e. very tiny amount of time on that scale.
Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ... by betwixthewires on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @09:21PM (#28624195)
Well, you're assuming that technological advancement is linear and one way. We simply have not been technologically advanced in any notable way that we know of to be the least bit certain that this is true. A lot can happen within 5000 years.
Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ... by Gravityloss on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @04:04PM (#28621119)
Well, maybe "constant speed" is a bad wording.

An example:

We have 1000 stars within the 30 light year radius neighborhood. Traveling at Voyager 1 speed, it takes half a million years to do a 30 light year trip. [1]

Given another half a million years for bootstrapping at the destination for ten more probes, we can send ten more probes, 1 million years from the launch of the first one. At two million years we get 100 probes.

How many probes do we get in a 11 million years? 10^11 probes. We have 10^11 stars in the galaxy.

Dinosaurs roamed the earth aleady 200 million years ago, and died in the mass extinction 65 million years ago. 20 to 5 million years ago was the Miocene, when life was pretty close to modern already. [2]

It's really the nature of exponential growth that makes things seem instantaneous compared to celestial phenomena or evolution. Colonizing the galaxy, even with abysmally slow speeds, is possible, because of the magic of exponentials.

(Certainly this has a lot of assumption, like that you can bootstrap, or that the probe survives the trip. Anyway, optimal probes would be a lot faster and bigger, and there would be more of them. This was just to tie in with something concrete that we know we can do, as Voyager 1 really is out there traveling at 15 km/s, as are Voyager 2, Pioneers and New Horizons probes.)

1: https://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=+30+light+years+%2F+vo...

2: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miocene

Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ... by betwixthewires on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @09:24PM (#28624211)
> And at that point, where is the incentive to colonize other star systems?

Just to put this out there, unless every advanced civilization becomes a hive mind with one unified will, some individual or splinter group or just hodgepodge of determined individuals would probably do it even if there were no incentive, and that's not to point out that incentives are somewhat subjective and differ between individuals and groups. If there are enough individuals on a civilization and the capability exists, some crazy person will do it.

Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ... by kindle-dev on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @10:30AM (#28616702)
Even without FTL travel, just having constant acceleration at 1g is enough to travel the width of the galaxy in 12 years ship-time: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_travel_using_constant_ac....
Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ... by jandrese on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @02:22PM (#28619843)
Try plugging 12 years of 1G acceleration into the Rocket Equation.

If reactionless drives remain science fiction this mode of travel is flat impossible. There literally isn't enough mass in the solar system.

Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ... by rsynnott on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @10:36AM (#28616763)
That is a _huge_ 'just', tho. That's a lot of energy.
Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ... by htrp on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @10:59AM (#28617064)
Welcome to the delta V problem....
Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ... by deepsun on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @10:46AM (#28616909)
> if you can produce energy that cheaply you can sustain a large population in comfort at home

Don't see the reasoning here.

For example, we currently can feed the whole Earth population "cheaply". But the wars didn't end. Same with cheap energy.

E.g. we can try to install vast amounts of mirrors to direct Sun's light towards an accelerating ship. But that won't bring us here more comfort.

Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ... by TheOtherHobbes on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @11:19AM (#28617351)
1. No they don't. Spreading at sub-FTL requires redundant self-correcting technology which can run for thousands of years without breaking down. This is about as achievable as FTL. Nothing lasts for thousands of years in deep space without being abraded, fried, nuked, or physically stressed to breaking point.

1b. Assuming you can solve 1. with some kind of magical alchemical spares-generating technology that never fails, the technology also has to be politically and philosophically stable, with reliable and persistent goals. Otherwise you'll get offshoots competing with each other. Which may mean undermining and perhaps even destroying previous settlements. How much independence is enough? How accurate are your initial models going to be?

2. We don't know that for sure. Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence. (We do know weird things happen, but we're not putting any serious effort into researching them, so we don't know what they are.)

3. There's no need to think about this after 1. and 2.

Edit: to put this in context, you don't need to launch a probe. You need to launch a complete perfectly self-reproducing error-free space program. Which can also adapt to local resources.

This seems... difficult.

Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ... by jandrese on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @02:39PM (#28620037)
If you have #1 you no longer need to go to a distant solar system to survive. By the time you have the tech you no longer have the need.
Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ... by addingnumbers on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @10:08AM (#28616466)
A turtle on the Galápagos Islands in 1450AD could use the same reasoning to conclude that no seafaring civilizations existed.
Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ... by jameshart on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @12:59PM (#28618743)
The turtle would be working with considerably less data, though. Does he know how old his island is? Does he have conclusive evidence of the existence of other islands? Is he aware of the similarity or difference of other islands compared to his own? Would he be able to observe if seafarers were living on a nearby island or does he need to wait for them to actually land on his beach? Does he have a reasonable estimate for the size of the earth? The amount of ocean? For the distribution of islands across the ocean?

Also, since he’s a turtle, he doesn’t, presumably, yet actually know how hard it is to make a boat. The argument for determining whether or not you are the only seafaring species depends, first, on you having attained the ability to travel the seas…

All of that seems necessary before he can conclude whether or not he should consider it ‘surprisingly late’ for his island not to have been reached yet by any seafarers.

But the interesting part of the analogy is maybe that the turtle might fool himself into thinking he understands the parameters well enough to estimate this probability - after all, he’s paddled around off the beach and even made it to a nearby rock - so he reckons he’s got a pretty good handle on how hard it must be to travel between islands.

Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ... by addingnumbers on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @04:33PM (#28621410)
I wonder how I failed to express my position so badly that people who seemingly agree with me think they don't.

Ignorance and misestimation of the true underlying factors isn't a trait unique to these hypothetical turtles.

Or, perhaps you have a much higher confidence than I do in humans' assessment of the factors involved in your questions.

I'm saying we are over-confident in the underlying premises of our understanding, just like the turtles would be. The more of the questions you pose that go partly unsolved, the more unsubstantiated the conclusion. Their probability calculations are pointless -- garbage in, garbage out. As demonstrated by the patent wrongness of their conclusion.

If you are confident that we've got solid answers to the interstellar corollaries of all your questions with the evidence we can gather at this point, then we aren't on the same page at all.

This idea, that our observations of the universe are a properly representative sample from which to form conclusions about the unobserved universe, makes as much sense to me as the thinking-turtles assuming you need a small green island to and a thick shell to enable sentience because that's what their observations show.

Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ... by hansbo on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @10:18AM (#28616562)
Yeah, but if humans keep existing for millions of years, then the probability for a turtle on the Galápagos Islands to live in the time between when humans started seafaring and when humans visited the islands would be extremely small compared to any other time period.
Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ... by addingnumbers on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @10:43AM (#28616874)
Since we know the conclusion to be false, any reasoning that would support this hypothetical turtle's conclusion that no seafarers existed in 1450 is inarguably an example of bad reasoning.
Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ... by gpm on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @11:03AM (#28617115)
No, because the turtle is concluding that it's likely false, not definitely false. There happens to be a cosmic coincidence working against the turtle, but that doesn't mean that it was bad reasoning to conclude that the cosmic coincidence was very unlikely.
Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ... by addingnumbers on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @11:13AM (#28617248)
The turtle is saying with certainty, not likelihood, that no seafarers exist, analogous with the explicit conclusion (3) in the top level comment
Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ... by gpm on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @11:21AM (#28617364)
People are lazy when they speak, it's best to understand basically every claim as probabilistic (and meaning "almost certainly") even when it isn't stated as such.

Certainly no-one would make the claim that "there are (definitely) no aliens in the galaxy" when we can't disprove the idea that aliens traveling at the speed of light just reached the galaxy (with our current understanding of physics). That doesn't mean you can't make the claim "there are (almost definitely) no aliens in the galaxy (because I just created the most amazing telescope ever and looked at every particle of matter in the galaxy and there were no aliens there)". The principle of charity demands that understand the bare claim that "there are no aliens in the galaxy" to mean something that is plausible, such as "there are almost certainly no aliens in the galaxy".

Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ... by addingnumbers on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @12:19PM (#28618214)
A line of reasoning that tells our turtles something totally false doesn't deserve validation for doing it with slight uncertainty.
Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ... by indrax on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @01:29PM (#28619176)
You have to weight the validity of the reasoning across all turtle observers through history. If you reject probabilistic reasoning because it sometimes tell you things that are wrong, then you have no way to reason about uncertainty.
Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ... by addingnumbers on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @03:58PM (#28621044)
If your reasoning about uncertainty tells you there's a 99% chance something is false while it's true, what good is it? All the math in the world won't save you from the specious premises in this no-seafarers argument.
Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ... by epivosism on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @07:38PM (#28623447)
"If your reasoning suggests you shouldn't play the lottery, but playing the lottery actually results in you winning, what use is your math?"

Well, what matters is expectation. The fact that some people win the lottery doesn't prove that playing the lotto is profitable. In fact it isn't money-profitable. The fact that people sometimes win doesn't change the nature of reality, that even for them, the win is unexpected and playing was negative expectation for them.

You seem to be confusing expected value with results.

Do you revise your decision process every time you get unlucky? On a meta level, sure, paying attention to unexpected failures is important to look for systematic errors. But randomly getting unlucky on 99% certainties does not automatically disprove your decision method.

Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ... by RupertEisenhart on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @11:03AM (#28617119)
That is incorrect. Good reasoning can lead to conclusions that are strictly false.

For example, when asked to be more granular, the turtle could say 'I reason that there is only a 1 in 10 chance that seafaring civilizations exist'. The existence of seafaring civilizations doesn't make the turtle wrong in this case.

If the turtle concluded that 'there can not possibly be any seafaring civilizations, because I don't see any' then you could accuse it of bad reasoning.

Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ... by addingnumbers on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @11:15AM (#28617281)
> If the turtle concluded that 'there can not possibly be any seafaring civilizations, because I don't see any'

The hypothetical turtle did exactly that, loyally following suit with the commenter who I replied to.

Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ... by jandrese on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @02:42PM (#28620081)
It's not a matter of limited perspective, it's a matter of the laws of physics. The rocket equation is a harsh mistress. Without FTL or reactionless drives the physics of going to a distant solar system is absurdly unfavorable. It takes many decades/centuries, is a one way trip, and the ability to build a self contained self powered ecosystem that can survive the entire trip without support. Once you have that why bother going to a distant solar system? You have a perfect orbital habitat.
Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ... by Retric on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @10:01AM (#28616397)
#1 has some huge assumptions built in. A civilization can travel a long distance without visiting every star system between it’s origin and destination.

The limitation could be doubling time not travel time. Sure double every 100,000 years or less and in 4 million years you’ve run out of stars in the Milky Way which is an eye blink on cosmic timescales. But, a civilization that’s remote terraforming worlds that might greatly slow things down. How long does it take Cyanobacteria to create an oxygen atmosphere for example?

Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ... by jamesdmiller on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @10:21AM (#28616610)
Hanson doesn't think (2) and (3) follow because of the possibility of panspermia. It's possible that our galaxy is the only one in a billion light years that has given rise to life, but there could, because of panspermia, skill be a high probability that a planet in our galaxy outside our solar system has life. See this podcast Hanson did with me: https://soundcloud.com/user-519115521
Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ... by blfr on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @10:35AM (#28616758)
Your podcasts with Greg Cochran are quite possibly the most interesting (interesting stuff per minute) audio I've ever listened to.
Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ... by jamesdmiller on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @01:35PM (#28619251)
Thanks!
Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ... by AutumnCurtain on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @09:36AM (#28616148)
I felt like I could have used a better articulation of their definition of "loud" and "quiet" aliens, unless these are well known terms in the domain terms and I am just unfamiliar...
Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ... by mannykannot on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @10:22AM (#28616613)
The abstracts of papers are intentionally terse, which usually means they are addressed to people already familiar with the field. The paper itself is often more readable (though by no means always!) and it is often worth taking a look at the introduction and conclusion, at least. Here, we have 'To a first approximation, there are two kinds of aliens: quiet and loud. Loud (or “expansive”) aliens expand fast, last long, and make visible changes to their volumes. Quiet aliens fail to meet at least one of these criteria.'
Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ... by m3kw9 on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @10:09AM (#28616481)
The incentives and disincentives of exploring other systems is largely unknown. There could be huge risks in visiting other systems in which your own system of origin could be revealed if you happen to find another advanced civilization, I would think if a civilization is even predicted to be in a system, it will likely not be visited.
Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ... by 7thaccount on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @09:50AM (#28616307)
The Fermi Paradox (where is everyone) has been debated for decades. There are so many possibilities such as great filters (early or late), prime directive, zoo hypothesis, dark forest hypothesis...etc etc. I'm sure you're aware of this, but I included just in case you wanted to explore in more depth. Some really good stuff.
Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ... by AtlasBarfed on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @01:33PM (#28619233)
I just heard about the dark forest a couple weeks ago. I believe it to be the model we should proceed with for safety.

Assuming FTL isn't possible, the fact that dark energy makes large sections of the visible universe fundamentally inaccessible is probably a good thing.

Otherwise that is a lot more of the universe that may be ahead of us and would stomp us like ants.

Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ... by betwixthewires on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @09:42PM (#28624341)
Unless something about life is fundamentally adversarial I wouldn't expect civilizations to be hostile to one another by default.

You could make the argument that it does appear that life is fundamentally adversarial, seeing as in our one example all life feeds on other life, and to sustain life a creature must kill. I believe that's simple a circumstance of limited biomass in a closed system and so not fundamental, but you could argue that all civilizations probably get bootstrapped in this way and so it doesn't need to be fundamentally adversarial, but that all civilizations are accustomed to it so the distinction "fundamental" does not really matter. I'd disagree with that also, because a change in conditions to post scarcity changes conditioning and therefore behavior.

You might also come up with a prisoners dilemma type scenario where a civilization doesn't want to be adversarial, but it doesn't know the intentions of others and so to protect itself, as a rule, destroys any that it finds. This is somewhat plausible but I don't really think likely because civilizations that evolved from abiogenetic origins separate from one another would likely have very very different behaviors that might not even overlap in many cases, so even if they were aware of each other they may not even be capable of interacting.

It just does not make sense for a space faring civilization to be hostile. A requirement for space faring and a result of it is post scarcity; resources abound in the vast swathes of dead universe. There is no reason to even think competitively, barring some as yet undiscovered unobtanium so rare and so powerful that civilizations fight to extinction over it, but I doubt it. If anything, I'd think that a space faring civilization benefits the more it understands the universe, and learning about biospheres and civilizations with completely different evolutionary paths from abiogenesis would be more valuable than destruction of them.

Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ... by kenjackson on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @12:04PM (#28617986)
Thanks for that simplification. I didn't get that at all from the abstract (as I didn't really follow much of it) :-(

What is "volume appearance" BTW?