Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ...
by raducu on Thursday September 23, 2021 @01:24PM
(#28632264)
The problem with generation ships is we assume we can just "zip" all knowledge and technology and ship it via a generation ship and "unzip"/bootstrap at destination.
I'm sure we are absolutely not capable to do that now. Maybe with AI.
But we haven't done that with our Moon and that's not even a few lightseconds away.
Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ...
by PeterisP on Thursday September 23, 2021 @05:25PM
(#28635660)
We certainly can "zip" enough knowledge and technology to match Earth as it was in year 1000 (and almost certainly year 1900) and as experience shows, it's sufficient to build up in a millenium or two i.e. very tiny amount of time on that scale.
Re:If Loud Aliens Explain Human Earliness, Quiet Aliens Are ...
by betwixthewires on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @09:21PM
(#28624195)
Well, you're assuming that technological advancement is linear and one way. We simply have not been technologically advanced in any notable way that we know of to be the least bit certain that this is true. A lot can happen within 5000 years.
So to explain the fact that the aliens aren't swarming everywhere because they can't afford it means accepting that either they launching a single generation-ship every 5000 years is a huge expenditure (which IMHO it wouldn't be even with our current economy size, definitely not an issue with the tech of 2100 or 2200 assuming at least some growth because at that point a Musk-type figure with a wish to "make humanity interstellar" would be able to afford it from private funds) or that we're the first (only?) life in galaxy or that all the aliens before us didn't try to expand, like, at all - because getting just one single rich eccentric every 5000 years (like a bunch of billionaires here are) would be sufficient to make the galaxy swarm with juuust a bit higher tech level than ours now.