I rode a commuter bus for years and saw the exact same thing you describe, and no one would seriously suggest 50-75% of drivers are (equivalently) drunk.
Or drunk driving isn’t as dangerous as previously thought.
Or there’s many more drunk drivers than previously thought.
I don’t necessarily agree with either of those, but the point is there are many possible explanations and we should be careful about jumping to conclusions.
A better way of refuting those claims is to find flaws in their methodology
Inebriated is much different. They are less likely to notice something in the first place because their senses are deadened. If they do notice, their full attention while intoxicated is much less as is their ability to rationally make decisions. There’s no way to un-distract if something gains.
With texting and driving there are other major daily hassles. A common scenario for me as I walk my dog is that I no longer assume a car will yield on a crosswalk - even the ones with a stop sign or a signal. May be the impact is that few people bike or walk? Or walk elsewhere like a trail or a park instead of sidewalk and neighborhoods? End of the day, it’s about what we want as a society. If we decide that people should be allowed to focus on their phone, we have to start redesigning the streets now.
Not just as a pedestrian, even as a driver I don’t assume I can go in green light anymore. People seem to miss red lights on the regular now
I'd also guess most people are not constantly on their phones as they are checking notifications/texts and that kind of thing, so you get more of an on-and-off effect rather than just being consistently drunk for the entire duration.
Not that it makes the practice any better, but it does seem like a complicating factor when trying to frame the problem in terms of drunk driving.
I think this ignores the fact that people can’t actually pay attention to more than one thing at a time, generally. Meaning, they aren’t simultaneously looking at their phone and being vigilant of “weirdness” That switching overhead from one focus to the other may be enough to delay reactions to cause accidents.
So while they’re not offline, the sensory input cycle is slowed enough to be much less useful.
Yep. About 10 years ago, I took a bus from Boston to Hartford and I spent most of my time looking down into cars along the highway.
Aside from drivers looking at their phones, I saw people block their entire field of view by unwrapping burgers and lifting them up to eat, fixing their clothing, makeup, etc.
So if attentiveness is measured as “staring at the license plate in front of me”, my attentiveness went down. But I felt safer since I was looking hundreds of yards down the road for situations I might have to handle or avoid, at a longer timescale.
I've always had the opposite problem, if I'm not maintaining situational awareness to the horizon, I'll inevitably fall asleep after an hour or two out of sheer boredom. I prefer to drive long distances in manual-transmission vehicles (there's more to do!), and commercial vehicles with loads requiring careful management of engine RPM are even better. Those I can drive for 10-12 hours in a day without issue. I never saw myself as anything other than an ordinary driver.
In my case, a Tesla autopilot is the worst possible compromise. It removes enough attention requirements that it feels much harder to stay attentive, but without automating the process completely. Other people I've talked to that operate large pieces of mechanical equipment have often said similar things about automation that it's best to either be a) fully manual or b) fully automated for some duration of time.
I do think that it is very easy for me to spend longer looking at a screen or button when the autopilot is driving for me, since there is no immediate penalty (lane line, rumble strips, etc) for looking away.
I was taught to do this while driving. It was a basic lesson in "Driver's Ed".
Making it a habit though is a different thing. For me that was easier because it was one of the things that pro racers mentioned they did as well.
That is certainly a key to avoiding accidents. Others would be always keeping a safe distance between you and the cars in front of you and what's going on behind and around you.
I made a habit when I first started driving to always stay focused on the task of driving. I almost never turn on the radio or play music. That's because I want to hear what's going on around me.
The best advice I ever got was from a California Highway Patrol officer who told me "Drive like everyone is trying to crash into you".
Where I live now almost everywhere I drive it's on curvy two lane mountain roads. Most have a 55mph limit with curve signs as low as 25mph. We also have deer by the thousands here, and they forage at night. You really have to pay attention to just to stay on the road and not hit deer.
There is no way I'd trust a Tesla to drive me around here (or anywhere for that matter).
That advice (for cyclists) was also in one of Neal Stephenson's early novels, Zodiac... I've found it useful. Now I just get annoyed when drivers insist on yielding to pedestrians and cyclists when they don't need to, it would be faster if they didn't and they aren't blocking any other traffic. The driver feels like they've helped, I guess, but the pedestrians are not safer.
No. That is NOT the question... because... Autopilot and FSD software suite users are required to remain attentive and ready to intervene in case o a software failure (often seen in many YouTube videos). But because they obviously, become inattentive, Autopilot usage is actually much more dangerous than having the drivers drive their cars by themselves.
It creates complacency because the moment a driver physically removes feet from the pedals and hands from the steering wheel, his or her mind cannot maintain focus on two things at the same time.
What are those two things an Autopilot user needs to perform simultaneously? First is watching the car's surroundings, the traffic around the vehicle. Second is watching and trying to understand software behavior in those constantly changing traffic situations.
No average Joe, college kid, grandma or grandpa is capable of focusing on two things at the same time in constant life and death environment.
Airplane pilots are not average Joes and they are constantly trained to understand flying Autopilot software limitations and capabilities in a lot less stressful and busy traffic environments, two of their main job requirements being discipline and responsibility. That is not the case with the average driver on the road.
Let's agree that a normal driver without autopilot (ND) is mostly attentive, with occasional attention lapses (frequency depending on the individual).
That same normal driver according to MIT, is less attentive when using an autopilot system - let's call this autopilot distraction (AD).
However, the Autopilot system, despite its weaknesses, likely offers some extra safety benefit (ASB) - especially if it can somewhat counteract the attention lapses that a normal driver would have.
So the question becomes, does the autopilot's marginal benefit outweigh the autopilot distraction?
Is: ND > (ND - AD + ASB)?
However, determining this would be difficult without real-world testing. In the real world, the factor which matters most is whether accidents happen (kind of the Overall Survival of this experiment) - which is why testing the real-world accident rate is important - and is ultimately the important question.
But the fallacy stands in the numbers where Autopilot “safety report” is presented by Tesla and compared to average drivers performances.
Why a fallacy? Because the human driver drives everywhere, at any time, in any weather conditions and on all drivable roads. The Autopilot goes on and off based on how drivable the environment is by the Autopilot system detection done by the sensors involved. In addition to that, up to this point, almost all of its errors where caught and corrected by its users, so no one could actually estimate what would happen if Autopilot owners would let the software do the driving for 100%, same thing the humans do.
Also, once disconnected from the driving system (feet off the pedals and hands off the steering wheel) the driver would need up to 20 seconds (or even more) to reconnect and fully understand what the car does and what the traffic around is like. That is a recipe for disaster while every second the situation changes inside and outside the car.
> Autopilot creates a false sense of safety, as long as the people that payed for it and are eventually using it, are (by their own standards that made them buy it) not good at driving and not interested to get better at it.
Or... there are people that are good attentive drivers who buy it as a driver aid - to minimise tiredness on long journeys?
> But the fallacy stands in the numbers where Autopilot “safety report” is presented by Tesla and compared to average drivers performances.
Yes, the methodology of the safety report is probably flawed, but that's a totally different subject.
> Also, once disconnected from the driving system (feet off the pedals and hands off the steering wheel)
...which isn't how Autopilot currently works - you are asked to maintain contact with the steering wheel and have to prove it by providing torque on the wheel every few seconds. (Yes,
> the driver would need up to 20 seconds (or even more) to reconnect and fully understand what the car does and what the traffic around is like. That is a recipe for disaster while every second the situation changes inside and outside the car.
...really, just... what?
a) where does this (frankly ludicrous) 20 seconds statistic come from? b) you're not accounting for (the many?) people who might not be actively driving when Autopilot is functioning (that's the point, of course) but are still watching the road, mirrors, maintaining situational awareness, etc.
Based on my own observation, Tesla drivers, despite being supposedly inattentive, catch a fair number of errors in autopilot. So they are part of the system.
That factor (human involvement, even if imperfect) coupled with the overall safety of the tesla approach (which includes safety benefits in a whole range of areas) may mean that despite this supposed "expose" of the "inattentive" driver the system is safer overall.
One thing folks "exposing" tesla drivers seem to assume is that non-tesla drivers are very good drivers. They are not. It's takes minutes looking into cars to see this. I was just next to a non-tesla road rager who nearly caused three accidents trying to get at this truck.
If places like MIT did some more actual studies on system effectiveness I'd be REALLY curious at fatality rates etc for folks driving Teslas in a normal way, yes, in driving in ANY kind of weather.
Same thing with emergency vehicle accidents which made the news. How many first responder fatalities were caused by Tesla's vs non Tesla vehicle? It could turn out that many / most are caused by inattentive gas powered no auto-pilot cars that are the ones actually killing first responders.
You have to compare the worst Tesla drivers to the worst drivers in regular vehicles. Average Tesla drivers to average drivers of regular vehicles, etc.
And I'm not sure a simulator is the best comparison.
Its findings were that drivers paid more attention before engagement and after engagement than when AP was engaged.
I suppose you'd have to compare against only manual driving in good conditions to make a fair comparison. Not sure that data exists anywhere.
Shouldn't Tesla create that data - research the issue - before giving people autopilot?
The question you ask is completely different and thus, not brought into the article.
> That should be the question.
Why should that be the question? If the feature is dangerous, removing it will improve safety. If there are more dangerous features, we can remove those too.
In medicine there is a concept of measuring disease-oriented outcomes instead of patient-oriented outcomes, because it's easier to show an intervention affects the disease-oriented outcomes, and much harder to show a change in patient-oriented outcomes.
So for example, a disease-oriented ourcome for hip-replacement surgery would be "range of movement after 2 weeks", patient-oriented might be "can go up a flight of stairs"
The analogy here seems relevant.
That's bullshit.
I'm sure it's safe to assume both crash more than very attentive drivers, which is the only question that matters when it comes to Tesla's autopilot.
What you're really asking is "who'd you rather have smash into you, someone in a Tesla using autopilot, or someone texting on their phone while driving?
Then, there's http://www.trb.org/Publications/Blurbs/171327.aspx, but I haven't given them my address. (https://pdf.sciencedirectassets.com/271664/1-s2.0-S000145751...)
That should be the question.
"MIT study shows folks drive 5MPH faster with seatbelts on" - doesn't mean we should get rid of seatbelts if overall damage and accidents / injury rates are reduced.
Im serious - do the study. Put someone in a 6 hour drive or simulator for an SF to LA drive or something, one in a car with tesla's drivers aids one without. Then have something happen (sudden braking / someone cutting in front of you etc) on drive in half of the trips.
Who crashes? The "inattentive" tesla driver? Or the other driver.
Based on my own observation, there are drivers in regular cars texting, looking up directions, playing with their phone maybe for music? I've seen people putting on makeup, sitting at a light for 5 minutes on their phone (when it is green) etc. I've seen people drift out of their lanes crazily. These are folks in normal cars. I've seen folks speeding and swerving in and out of traffic, some without using blinkers etc.