News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Trailerduck is a smart e-bike trailer by choeger on Tuesday September 21, 2021 @07:24AM (#28603934)
I'd say 30kph. I never understood the 25kph rule.

Make 30kph the default speed limit in cities and let e-bikes drive with that speed on most roads, what's problematic with this approach? Are 5kph more really that more dangerous that you need to create a speed difference between even slow cars and bikes?

Re:Trailerduck is a smart e-bike trailer by avianlyric on Tuesday September 21, 2021 @07:34AM (#28603993)
25kph is average cycling speed of a male cyclist, 20kph for female.

The limits there because these devices are just meant to be cycling assistance, not replacements. You don’t want to be mixing two distinct classes of transport together (this is whole reason why protected cycle ways are so important), because overtaking etc is inherently dangerous.

There’s nothing preventing people from just creating electric motorbikes etc and driving them on the road with other road traffic. But having vehicles like that mix in close proximity to pedestrians and un-assisted cyclists just moves the problem we already have with car-bike conflict on to cycle lanes and pedestrian spaces.

Also that extra 5kph is gonna have a pretty negligible impact on transit times, so is it really worth all the extra problems?

Re:Trailerduck is a smart e-bike trailer by mauvehaus on Tuesday September 21, 2021 @08:10AM (#28604216)
"25kph is average cycling speed of a male cyclist, 20kph for female."

Wait, what? I bike commuted for a while in both Cleveland and Boston. I can pretty handily maintain 30kph, and regularly hit over that when either warranted by traffic conditions or on a slight downhill.

I do not consider myself a fast cyclist by any measure.

I am quite confident that even the most casual group ride of semi serious cyclists would drop me in 5 km on a good day.

Is my view of cycling speeds that skewed, or is the distribution very weird in some way?

As for the extra 5kph making a difference, no it's not a huge deal in time. It's immensely important to riding safely in faster traffic. I find that the closer you can ride to the speed of traffic, the fewer boneheaded things people do to get past you.

Being able to do 40kph for short stretches to basically match the speed of cars through a dodgy intersection is a huge improvement in safety. 30 isn't 40, but every little bit helps.

Re:Trailerduck is a smart e-bike trailer by avianlyric on Tuesday September 21, 2021 @08:33AM (#28604391)
> Is my view of cycling speeds that skewed

Yes

> It's immensely important to riding safely in faster traffic

This why it’s skewed.

I agree that riding close to the speed of traffic is important. But over here in Europe we have far better cycle infrastructure compared to North America. In many cities you don't ride with normal traffic, so you don’t need to go that fast. Instead your just cycling with with other bikes.

It sounds like you cycle in a fairly hostile area for bikes, so speed is needed just to be safe. Can totally understand why you would do 30kph+, and indeed I do the same in nastier parts of London.

But a consequence of the hostile environment is that you’ll only be cycling with people who have made an active choice to cycle and are more advanced cyclists who are happy to deal with shitty car drivers.

As you move towards proper cycle infrastructure the average cyclist becomes increasingly casual and amateur. Riding not for sport, fitness or to be green. But rather riding because it’s just easier that other public transport options or using a car. Cyclist in this category cycle slower, and more casually. They just wear normal clothes and cycle nice and slow so they don’t get sweaty.

If you wanna see more, I would recommend the YouTube channel “NotJustBikes”. It can be quite eye opening to see a world where everyone cycles because it’s just cheaper, easier and faster than every other option.

Re:Trailerduck is a smart e-bike trailer by thor_molecules on Tuesday September 21, 2021 @11:38AM (#28606119)
I second the recommendation for "NotJustBikes", very eye-opening in regards to city planning and infrastructure
Re:Trailerduck is a smart e-bike trailer by teekert on Tuesday September 21, 2021 @08:34AM (#28604406)
Make that 10-15 kph (6.2-9.3 mph) for 8-16 year old students with all their school books or people in suits on one of these: [0], which is the majority here in the Netherlands. I think you are confusing what Americans know as "cyclists" (a subculture), with just "people on bikes" (our culture), which is most people, at some point during the day. Bike lanes look like this during rush hour: [1]. Silent, broader, 25 kph electric vehicles are much more disturbing in this setting.

[0]: https://www.wheelerz.nl/fietsen/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2...

[1]: https://www.google.com/search?q=druk+fietspad+nederland&hl=e...

Re:Trailerduck is a smart e-bike trailer by NoGravitas on Tuesday September 21, 2021 @10:55AM (#28605640)
Yeah, when I used to bike commute (in the US), I averaged about 10mph (16kph), wearing my work clothes, and not wanting to sweat. US perspective on biking is skewed because in most places, most adult cyclists are sport cycling enthusiasts.
Re:Trailerduck is a smart e-bike trailer by b3morales on Tuesday September 21, 2021 @03:06PM (#28608604)
I would say even most of us (I am one) who cycle to commute/get around and not for sport tend to be less casual and ride faster.
Re:Trailerduck is a smart e-bike trailer by choeger on Tuesday September 21, 2021 @01:22PM (#28607317)
Ok then how about a speed limit of 20km/h on bike lanes?
Re:Trailerduck is a smart e-bike trailer by avianlyric on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @03:54AM (#28614015)
How are you planning to enforce that?
Re:Trailerduck is a smart e-bike trailer by stdbrouw on Tuesday September 21, 2021 @07:37AM (#28604010)
The 25 kph is on the assumption that people will use these e-bikes on bike lanes. Pretty much everyone who bikes regularly hates race bikes and speed bikes and anything else going over 25 kph, or frankly, going over 20 kph, because it's dangerous and unpredictable for other riders.
Re:Trailerduck is a smart e-bike trailer by masklinn on Tuesday September 21, 2021 @07:47AM (#28604067)
> The 25 kph is on the assumption that people will use these e-bikes on bike lanes.

In fact the 25kph is so they are legally bicycles across europe, no questions asked.

Countries can allow faster or more powerful devices, but the european baseline is that a pedelec is a bicycle period.

Re:Trailerduck is a smart e-bike trailer by carlob on Tuesday September 21, 2021 @07:41AM (#28604040)
As an owner of both a road bike and a shitty commuter, I agree with you: if you wanna race, use the road.
Re:Trailerduck is a smart e-bike trailer by frosted-flakes on Tuesday September 21, 2021 @07:37AM (#28604011)
Cities tend to have speed limits closer to 50 km/h. (Is "kph" an accepted spelling?)
Re:Trailerduck is a smart e-bike trailer by carlob on Tuesday September 21, 2021 @07:40AM (#28604029)
Bike friendly cities are converging towards 30 km/h.

Kph, mt, sec: are all widely used but wrong.

Re:Trailerduck is a smart e-bike trailer by avianlyric on Tuesday September 21, 2021 @07:50AM (#28604087)
As an example (for GP) many London boroughs (city councils/districts) now enforce a global 20mph (32kph) speed limit on all their roads. With recent legislation making it trivially easy for boroughs to do this (I think it used to require consultations etc, but now they can be unilaterally applied with consultation with the public).

Additionally TfL have had the entire of central London (within the congestion zone) 20mph.