News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Excision's CRISPR HIV therapy is heading into human testi... by datameta on Saturday September 18, 2021 @05:47PM (#28579634)
This body of research is expanding far quicker than I would have imagined pre-pandemic. A true silver lining, I have to say. mRNA vaccine breakthroughs are occurring in cancer research, too. Human trials happening soon! https://www.futuretimeline.net/blog/2021/09/13-mrna-future-c...
Re:Excision's CRISPR HIV therapy is heading into human testi... by esturk on Saturday September 18, 2021 @11:44PM (#28581508)
Competition between 2 different approaches is great. It will only push each other to be more effective in the long run.
Re:Excision's CRISPR HIV therapy is heading into human testi... by bamboozled on Saturday September 18, 2021 @09:18PM (#28580853)
I have to say that we’re all being pretty highly optimistic since the first production grade mRNA vaccine looks like it doesn’t really give resistance for a long time to Covid.

It’s cool tech but it’s not magic.

Re:Excision's CRISPR HIV therapy is heading into human testi... by zulban on Saturday September 18, 2021 @10:31PM (#28581212)
>looks like it doesn’t really give resistance for a long time to Covid.

Easy to measure correlates of protection like antibodies wane over time, as expected from any vaccine. T-cells say a lot more about long term protection but are harder to measure. Generally, alarmist antibody research makes the headlines instead. I recommend the TWiV podcast by virologists and immunologists, which notably existed before covid.

Re:Excision's CRISPR HIV therapy is heading into human testi... by avsteele on Saturday September 18, 2021 @10:53PM (#28581300)
There are numerous bodies of data supporting waning immunity at this point. This data is based on real-world breakthrough rates, not antibody counts.

Two examples:

1) Israel data shows high level of breakthrough infection. This is the basis for their booster policy:

https://www.reuters.com/world/middle-east/israeli-doctors-fi...

2) Moderna just released their own study showing reinfection rates at 2x at 13+ months relative to <8 months post second dose.

https://investors.modernatx.com/news-releases/news-release-d...

Re:Excision's CRISPR HIV therapy is heading into human testi... by idiotsecant on Sunday September 19, 2021 @07:50AM (#28583599)
Its worth noting that a 2x reinfection rate of a very,very,very small number is still a very,very,very small number. The difference between the high dose modern a approach and the low dose approach of other manufacturers seems to be pretty strongly significant, moderna appears to be working quite a lot better for longer.
Re:Excision's CRISPR HIV therapy is heading into human testi... by ls612 on Sunday September 19, 2021 @03:51PM (#28587343)
It’s also important to note that for a first try, on an accelerated dosing schedule, 95% efficacy was incredible and blew all of the estimates out of the water. Falling to ‘merely’ 80% efficacy after several months and a major mutation still leaves you in a very good position.
Re:Excision's CRISPR HIV therapy is heading into human testi... by mrtesthah on Saturday September 18, 2021 @11:59PM (#28581583)
Reinfection/breakthrough is exactly in line with what the parent poster is claiming, which is that it is due to antibodies waning naturally, either from vaccines or from natural infection. However, the B-cells remain and continue to recognize SARS-CoV-2 antigens, causing a rapid production of neutralizing antibodies within hours, as opposed to close to a week in the natural infection case. This leads to greatly reduced hospitalizations.
Re:Excision's CRISPR HIV therapy is heading into human testi... by taylortbb on Sunday September 19, 2021 @12:36AM (#28581736)
> There are numerous bodies of data supporting waning immunity at this point.

Why that happens is less clear though. Is it a fault of mRNA tech itself? Or the dosing schedule? 21 days is very close together for a 2 dose vaccine, most are 6 months or years apart.

Using 21 days was a good way to get the trials done fast, if they'd used 6 months we'd be where we were 5 months ago, but this was one of the risks. Canada, which spaced doses out further, isn't seeing nearly as high of a rate of breakthrough cases.

I'm not saying we can conclude definitely that dosing is the problem, but it's a question worth investigating before coming to any firm conclusions that mRNA vaccines aren't good enough.

Re:Excision's CRISPR HIV therapy is heading into human testi... by catdog on Sunday September 19, 2021 @02:51AM (#28582243)
Agree it seems likely that dosing plays a fundamental role.

Moderna while still seeming to suffer from this problem seems to be suffering less than Biontech, they are very similar in general, biggest difference is Moderna having already a longer minimum waiting period between the shots and a way bigger dose of mRNA per shot. So this may already be a hint.

Also currently it looks like a third shot is giving a really great boost compared to the second one, at least in the short term. Same with using mRNA as a booster shot after a vector based vaccine.

Re:Excision's CRISPR HIV therapy is heading into human testi... by ummonk on Saturday September 18, 2021 @11:11PM (#28581361)
It’s weird that there is so little mention of natural immunity as a cause of declining measured “effectiveness”. The vaccine effectiveness should trend towards 0 as the unvaccinated population acquires natural immunity. That doesn’t mean the vaccine isn’t working.
Re:Excision's CRISPR HIV therapy is heading into human testi... by throwuxiytayq on Sunday September 19, 2021 @06:01AM (#28583068)
I don't understand this mechanism. Can you elaborate? How does the unvaccinated population influence measured vaccine effectiveness?
Re:Excision's CRISPR HIV therapy is heading into human testi... by avsteele on Sunday September 19, 2021 @07:17AM (#28583422)
Imagine a study where half gets vax and half doesn't. If population is pristine at outset at end of study VE is 1-ratio between people who get COVID in the two arms.

Now, if there is any prior exposure to the disease among participants (this isn't always known, esp. for something like COVID), and if there is any natural immunity that accrues, this will pull that ratio towards 1 (VE=0)

Re:Excision's CRISPR HIV therapy is heading into human testi... by bayesian_horse on Sunday September 19, 2021 @05:11AM (#28582850)
Protection from severe disease is still strong.

Probably the worst part about Covid-19 is that Sars-CoV-2 was a totally new Virus with a high attack rate, on top of the danger to the individual patient. If most of the population has seen "something like" it, even very distant variants will not be as bad.

Re:Excision's CRISPR HIV therapy is heading into human testi... by steve_taylor on Saturday September 18, 2021 @09:52PM (#28581016)
COVID-19 vaccines’ long term efficacy has nothing to do with this.
Re:Excision's CRISPR HIV therapy is heading into human testi... by schleck8 on Sunday September 19, 2021 @03:42AM (#28582472)
The mRNA vaccines have proven to be more effective than the traditional ones (J&J, AstraZeneca) no?
Re:Excision's CRISPR HIV therapy is heading into human testi... by rjzzleep on Sunday September 19, 2021 @06:24AM (#28583169)
J&J and AZ aren't really traditional either. They're Adenovirus based vaccines. Research has been out for a while, but I think there have been many production use Adenovirus based vaccines.

AZ is conceptually similar to the mRNA vaccines actually. They all target the Spike protein.

The Chinese vaccine is an inactivated virus kind of vaccine. That's what you would call traditional. Low protection from infection, but supposedly high protection from dangerous disease onset.

Re:Excision's CRISPR HIV therapy is heading into human testi... by neuronic on Sunday September 19, 2021 @06:41AM (#28583243)
The last point is all that counts. Nobody cares about Corona infections if they don’t fill up hospitals or cause Long COVID.
Re:Excision's CRISPR HIV therapy is heading into human testi... by yakshaving_jgt on Sunday September 19, 2021 @08:56AM (#28583971)
Not necessarily. As I understand it, several common viruses cause more serious disease further down the line. Even if you didn't develop warts, you wouldn't want HPV because some strains can develop into cervical cancer, for example.
Re:Excision's CRISPR HIV therapy is heading into human testi... by neuronic on Sunday September 19, 2021 @10:37AM (#28584668)
Yes, but we won't shut down society for 15 years to figure that one out.
Re:Excision's CRISPR HIV therapy is heading into human testi... by uncoder0 on Saturday September 18, 2021 @10:11PM (#28581116)
Yeah, true the mRNA SARS-COV vaccines aren't all that effective after many months however, it could work better for things that don't mutate as much as Coronaviruses. It could still be magic. We just don't know yet it's all relatively new tech medically speaking and this is the current vaccines using the tech are the first ever widespread usage of the tech. We'll see how it goes long-term No one really knows how well or not it's going to go.
Re:Excision's CRISPR HIV therapy is heading into human testi... by catdog on Sunday September 19, 2021 @03:06AM (#28582302)
Yes it's way too early to draw conclusions. Think currently mRNA vaccines still stand strong compared to what else is on the market. Also one of the big promises of the mRNA technology is increased development speed so it might especially be helpful for things which mutate fast.
Re:Excision's CRISPR HIV therapy is heading into human testi... by laurent92 on Sunday September 19, 2021 @04:55AM (#28582785)
Can it pose a risk of making other mutations? and adding too much variation that ecosystems are not ready to defend against? All the arguments of the GMO, repeated (although it seems the GMO argument is settled).
Re:Excision's CRISPR HIV therapy is heading into human testi... by webreac on Sunday September 19, 2021 @06:37AM (#28583223)
The GMO argument is settled ? This surprise me. AFAIK, it is settled in Europe, but not in America where it is still authorized. Maybe I am wrong, I am not american.