Further, the properties held purely as assets are generally very expensive ones. The effect ripples down, well heeled people move into cheaper housing and those people moving in turn.
This is nearly 8 years old, but generally describes the issue with some specifics:
https://www.theguardian.com/society/2014/jan/31/inside-londo...
Vacancy rates are extremely low. That puts an upper limit on the amount of people that could be doing that. Is it not easy to tell if a home is vacant?
Some very select markets may have an actual problem if foreign money laundering is a thing (as I’ve heard is true of Vancouver).
Lowering rates can cause loan problems.
Renters can choose not to pay rent, can cause untold damage to the property and can use it for illegal purposes to name but a few reasons why it might be rational not to rent a property out, specially if it's an appreciating asset.
I suspect that the majority of these empty properties are owned by wealthy people from countries like China or Russia.
But lets assume the worst, that it is all just pure evil capitalist speculation: even that is not necessarily bad. They try to anticipate future demand. So they anticipate that in the (near) future, somebody will need that apartment even more urgently than the people looking for housing right now. So it is better to keep it available for those people in the future. Think about keeping ICU units ready for future Covid patients for an analogy.
So what if the speculators are right, and the future buyers really have a higher need than the current ones?
Also I think if there really is just speculation, especially foreign investors, why not build cheap houses and sell them to the speculators for a lot of money? Nobody will ever live there (according to the anti-capitalists), anyway. Seems like a good way to make money for a country.
There is an arb between the two markets which should hold them in tandem on a risk adjusted basis.
Owner occupier properties exempt. Investor owned properties X% per year.
If they own 5 average houses and pay $10k per house in tax, they'd pay $50k and their dividend would return $10k, so would have to pay $40k more
In Germany home ownership is not seen as strictly positive in the same way it is in the US for example. Many, perhaps even the majority, of Germans go their whole lives as renters.
Housing supply is housing supply. There is scarce distinction in real life between rental and occupier owned housing.
And why should politics decide for people whether they should rent or buy, I mean, why push them in one direction or the other?
Taxes are often used to discourage behaviour society believes to have negative externalities. For example: tobacco excise taxes; and also in the other direction (e.g. concessions for long term capital gains; which is supposed to encourage 'investment').
In general taxes are regressive and people want to avoid them. If you tax regressive behavior the most, people will stop doing it.
Some people want to own their own home and live in it (owner occupiers); these people however compete with investors who are seeking to rent it out. While investors don't directly affect the rentals market (as you'd expect an owner-occupier to not be a renter), they do push the price of housing, because housing becomes more of an investment (competing against everything else with zero / negative interest rates).
Progressive taxes on investors can mitigate this and make home ownership more affordable. First property, no tax. Second property, 1% of its land value charged annually. Third property: 2% of its land value, etc...