News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by qeternity on Saturday September 18, 2021 @08:50AM (#28575811)
As another commenter notes, housing is unaffordable because marginal demand is greater than marginal supply. We can either decrease demand, or increase supply.

Housing demand is pretty sticky, so that leaves us with one option.

Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by HappyTypist on Saturday September 18, 2021 @08:59AM (#28575880)
Without regressing to another ad-infinitum housing discussion, real estate involves two markets: rentals/living, and ownership.

Some people want to own their own home and live in it (owner occupiers); these people however compete with investors who are seeking to rent it out. While investors don't directly affect the rentals market (as you'd expect an owner-occupier to not be a renter), they do push the price of housing, because housing becomes more of an investment (competing against everything else with zero / negative interest rates).

Progressive taxes on investors can mitigate this and make home ownership more affordable. First property, no tax. Second property, 1% of its land value charged annually. Third property: 2% of its land value, etc...

Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by mnd999 on Saturday September 18, 2021 @09:06AM (#28575933)
You’re forgetting investors who don’t want to rent property. They just by new properties, keep them empty and pristine and profit of the rising market value of the asset. Sounds crazy but it’s definitely a thing in London. It should attract very high taxes to make it unviable but of course it doesn’t.
Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by asdfasgasdgasdg on Saturday September 18, 2021 @09:38AM (#28576170)
These evil bogeymen are something people believe are very common, but I can't find any solid data on their prevalence in London. People also claim these guys are ruining NYC real estate, but our vacancy rates are below 5%, and most of the places that are vacant are not long term vacant.
Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by antiterra on Saturday September 18, 2021 @11:05AM (#28576804)
The evidence is all circumstantial because it’s difficult to definitively prove someone owns a property with absolutely no intent to live in it or rent it.

Further, the properties held purely as assets are generally very expensive ones. The effect ripples down, well heeled people move into cheaper housing and those people moving in turn.

This is nearly 8 years old, but generally describes the issue with some specifics:

https://www.theguardian.com/society/2014/jan/31/inside-londo...

Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by anchpop on Saturday September 18, 2021 @11:17AM (#28576897)
> The evidence is all circumstantial because it’s difficult to definitively prove someone owns a property with absolutely no intent to live in it or rent it.

Vacancy rates are extremely low. That puts an upper limit on the amount of people that could be doing that. Is it not easy to tell if a home is vacant?

Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by TeMPOraL on Saturday September 18, 2021 @11:21AM (#28576927)
How are vacancy rates calculated? I have a feeling it's a statistic that doesn't correspond to reality well.
Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by antiterra on Sunday September 26, 2021 @07:02PM (#28665444)
I’m pretty sure vacancy rates pertain to available rentals not owned property that is off the market.
Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by bombcar on Saturday September 18, 2021 @10:44AM (#28576650)
It’s much more common in commercial real estate but people confuse the two.

Some very select markets may have an actual problem if foreign money laundering is a thing (as I’ve heard is true of Vancouver).

Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by asdfasgasdgasdg on Saturday September 18, 2021 @12:48PM (#28577540)
Yeah, I have noticed lots of commercial vacancies in NYC. My understanding is that this is because the leases are so long and thus the prices are not as adaptive.
Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by bombcar on Saturday September 18, 2021 @01:34PM (#28577854)
And commercial loans are VERY dependent on "building income" which is calculated based on lease rates, even if not "leased" in some cases.

Lowering rates can cause loan problems.

Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by asdfasgasdgasdg on Saturday September 18, 2021 @01:37PM (#28577877)
Makes a body wonder why buildings don't just sell their ground floor real estate to get it off the books. There must be some reason, otherwise they would, but it seems like a neat solution to the problem.
Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by Aunche on Saturday September 18, 2021 @11:02AM (#28576781)
Yeah. I was looking to rent a NYC luxury apartment recently and noticed that any reasonable deal gets snatched up very quickly. These apartment complexes do feel empty because the residents tend to be childless, so maybe that's where the confusion would come from. It's sad to see more and more people these days are in denial of basic economics. It's strictly better to rent an apartment out because otherwise you're getting nothing from paying management and taxes.
Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by reallydontask on Saturday September 18, 2021 @02:10PM (#28578110)
>It's strictly better to rent an apartment out because otherwise you're getting nothing from paying management and taxes.

Renters can choose not to pay rent, can cause untold damage to the property and can use it for illegal purposes to name but a few reasons why it might be rational not to rent a property out, specially if it's an appreciating asset.

I suspect that the majority of these empty properties are owned by wealthy people from countries like China or Russia.

Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by proxyon on Saturday September 18, 2021 @03:26PM (#28578570)
This is a conspiracy theory that financially illiterate people love to parrot. There is no benefit to keeping a property vacant on purpose. It incurs opportunity cost, which is the cost of rent. The only reasons a property may remain vacant is either due to regulations, incompetent management or maybe money laundering (an actual crime) in which case collecting rent would impose a burden on the money laundering operation. By no means is this common, it is an extreme exception and bringing it up in these conversations is a goofy platitude by people who know nothing about real estate. It'd be like talking about the supply of automobiles and bringing up "but what about cars destroyed at monster truck rallies or used on movie sets? it's limiting the supply of automobiles!"
Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by theli0nheart on Saturday September 18, 2021 @09:10AM (#28575967)
This goes right back to supply. Real estate prices don’t exist in a vacuum; ultimately someone will buy said property who wishes to live there and will have decided so due to it being the best of all options.
Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by Ginden on Saturday September 18, 2021 @09:54AM (#28576290)
Is it actually a thing? When I checked vacancy rates for several cities, all of them were really low.
Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by leppr on Saturday September 18, 2021 @09:31AM (#28576125)
It's common in my city as well. The reason is tenants can stop paying and are protected by law enforcement from being evicted. That's not even talking about straight up squatters. This makes renting out often non-economically viable, when adjusting for risk.
Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by notanzaiiswear on Saturday September 18, 2021 @09:21AM (#28576049)
It surely is already very expensive to leave an apartment empty as it is. There also seem to be special circumstances and laws in London.

But lets assume the worst, that it is all just pure evil capitalist speculation: even that is not necessarily bad. They try to anticipate future demand. So they anticipate that in the (near) future, somebody will need that apartment even more urgently than the people looking for housing right now. So it is better to keep it available for those people in the future. Think about keeping ICU units ready for future Covid patients for an analogy.

So what if the speculators are right, and the future buyers really have a higher need than the current ones?

Also I think if there really is just speculation, especially foreign investors, why not build cheap houses and sell them to the speculators for a lot of money? Nobody will ever live there (according to the anti-capitalists), anyway. Seems like a good way to make money for a country.

Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by qeternity on Saturday September 18, 2021 @01:03PM (#28577651)
It’s not two markets. It’s one market with two different models (like cars: buy vs lease).

There is an arb between the two markets which should hold them in tandem on a risk adjusted basis.

Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by mattmanser on Saturday September 18, 2021 @09:04AM (#28575918)
Then you just get thousands of holding companies.
Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by postingawayonhn on Saturday September 18, 2021 @09:15AM (#28576005)
You can just use a simpler land tax system.

Owner occupier properties exempt. Investor owned properties X% per year.

Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by Ekaros on Saturday September 18, 2021 @09:22AM (#28576057)
I wonder wouldn't it be just simpler to ban private land ownership in cities.
Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by mattmanser on Saturday September 18, 2021 @01:02PM (#28577643)
A significant number of people need, for various reasons, to rent.
Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by imtringued on Saturday September 18, 2021 @10:48AM (#28576677)
This idea is slightly better than a land value tax but implementing it is a financing nightmare. You'll have to spend the entire government budget on buying all private plots of land.
Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by iso1210 on Saturday September 18, 2021 @10:06AM (#28576370)
Or just have a simple X% per year no matter who owns it
Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by postingawayonhn on Saturday September 18, 2021 @10:52AM (#28576717)
That should work to lower prices but will also increase costs for home owners. If the goal is to increase home ownership rates then giving them an advantage in the market can help.
Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by iso1210 on Monday September 20, 2021 @06:05AM (#28592043)
You could distribute the money raised as either tax cuts to income tax, or just as a flat dividend to every citizen. If a person owns an average house and pays $10k in tax, their dividend would return $10k - so no loss.

If they own 5 average houses and pay $10k per house in tax, they'd pay $50k and their dividend would return $10k, so would have to pay $40k more

Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by wizzwizz4 on Saturday September 18, 2021 @09:06AM (#28575935)
So be really aggressive about associating holding companies with their owners for the purposes of this tax.
Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by imtringued on Saturday September 18, 2021 @10:43AM (#28576631)
The point of a progressive land value tax is to relieve individuals not corporations. Corporations can simply get the maximum rate.
Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by sagichmal on Saturday September 18, 2021 @09:46AM (#28576232)
> Progressive taxes on investors can mitigate this and make home ownership more affordable

In Germany home ownership is not seen as strictly positive in the same way it is in the US for example. Many, perhaps even the majority, of Germans go their whole lives as renters.

Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by sudosysgen on Saturday September 18, 2021 @03:27PM (#28578573)
That's just not true. Many people just want to live. They will rent or buy.

Housing supply is housing supply. There is scarce distinction in real life between rental and occupier owned housing.

Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by notanzaiiswear on Saturday September 18, 2021 @09:17AM (#28576018)
I don't follow your logic. In both cases, home ownership or rental, you need one house per interested party. Why should one be more expensive than the other?

And why should politics decide for people whether they should rent or buy, I mean, why push them in one direction or the other?

Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by HappyTypist on Saturday September 18, 2021 @09:55AM (#28576292)
If you make residential investment more expensive (through taxes), you will have less interested investors. This reduces the number of interested parties for home ownership, which means that the remaining parties (i.e. owner occupiers) pay cheaper prices.

Taxes are often used to discourage behaviour society believes to have negative externalities. For example: tobacco excise taxes; and also in the other direction (e.g. concessions for long term capital gains; which is supposed to encourage 'investment').

Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by imtringued on Saturday September 18, 2021 @10:46AM (#28576661)
Yeah in this case investors are punished for investing into space inefficient single family homes. Multiple apartments on a plot reduce the tax burden of the land value tax. So big investors will primarily invest in multi family housing.

In general taxes are regressive and people want to avoid them. If you tax regressive behavior the most, people will stop doing it.

Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by TeMPOraL on Saturday September 18, 2021 @08:58AM (#28575872)
That may be technically true, but it misses the fact that the demand pool is larger than it should be - it consists of many other actors than just people who want to live in a given location. Those other actors tend to have more money.
Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by notanzaiiswear on Saturday September 18, 2021 @09:22AM (#28576053)
Who exactly are you talking about?
Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by TeMPOraL on Saturday September 18, 2021 @11:17AM (#28576894)
Investors who do not rent out locally - including those renting out to tourists, those keeping empty homes for occasional vacation use, those keeping empty homes because they're playing financial shenanigans (moving money offshore, money laundering, keeping some properties empty to prevent depressing rents from nearby properties). Probably some other groups I'm not even aware of.

Point being, it's not true that all supply of homes ends up being used by people to live in. A lot stay empty most, or all, of the time. People owning those tend to have more money than locals looking for a place to live, so the latter get priced out.

Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by qeternity on Saturday September 18, 2021 @01:04PM (#28577663)
This is a really really small part of demand. And unlike dwellers, investors have alternatives to invest in if prices get too high.

But investors are really not the main problem. If you banned housing investment, prices would hardly budge.

Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by bo0tzz on Saturday September 18, 2021 @11:00AM (#28576769)
Investment types
Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by parasight on Saturday September 18, 2021 @09:01AM (#28575894)
Buying the apartments is a short term solution to take pressure off of low income tenants. This is not about supply and demand. Increasing supply is a mid to long term solution.

By the way, land is also limited in Berlin and therefore expensive. Makes building cheap apartments difficult.

Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by daverol on Saturday September 18, 2021 @09:58AM (#28576319)
Sometimes there is no intention to build, just use the German market as a cover for a ponzi scheme, see <https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-55077709>
Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by qeternity on Saturday September 18, 2021 @01:07PM (#28577681)
> By the way, land is also limited in Berlin and therefore expensive. Makes building cheap apartments difficult.

This is the other reality of free markets and scarce resources: if there is only so much land in Berlin, and lots of people want to live in Berlin, then it means some people won’t be able to. That’s just the reality. Unfortunately that means people who can’t afford have to move. As sad as that is, we don’t have a better system for allocating scarce resources sustainably.

Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by djbebs on Saturday September 18, 2021 @09:45AM (#28576219)
Land is limited for political reasons.
Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by hezag on Saturday September 18, 2021 @09:55AM (#28576299)
Unless you are talking about borders or about the concept of property, land is not limited for political reasons. It's limited for physical reasons.
Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by iso1210 on Saturday September 18, 2021 @10:41AM (#28576622)
The number of apartments per square metre is limited by political reasons (ban on high buildings, minimum size etc)

20 years ago when I moved to London I'd have loved to find a tiny self contained Japanese style 10 square metre apartment[0], which is cheaper (in actuality, not just inflationwise) and far nicer and featureful than the HMO I ended up in.

https://www.livingbiginatinyhouse.com/tiny-house-tours/tiny-...

Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by brigandish on Saturday September 18, 2021 @11:50AM (#28577138)
> Thankfully, some clever design elements allows the micro apartment to be a very functional and cosy home.

Does anyone who has lived in Japan and abroad think there is anything "cosy" about Japanese housing?

It's cramped, of poor quality, and manages to be colder than the outside in winter and warmer than the outside in summer. I've seen some crap properties in London but Japan takes the biscuit.

Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by iso1210 on Sunday September 19, 2021 @06:38AM (#28583225)
A dingy bedsit with a shower in one corner, a sink in one corner, a bed in one corner and a door in one corner, with a shared toilet down the hall. That cost me £520 a month in 2003 (similar places are £800 today)

A Japanese micro apartment for less than half that price [0] would have been far better.

Same with hotels. I still go to London fairly frequently, in fact I had 3 nights there this week. I turn up to the hotel, sleep in a bed, have a shower, then leave, maybe with breakfast. For that I'm charged £90 plus.

[0] https://www.nippon.com/en/news/fnn20200211001/tokyo%E2%80%99...

Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by brigandish on Monday September 20, 2021 @11:25AM (#28594821)
I'm not sure how your comparison of personal experience against prices you pulled off the internet makes the standard of Japanese building any better?

You can find cheap rooms in either city, you can find bargains in either city, what you won't find en masse in Tokyo (nor any other city in Japan as far as I'm aware) is housing with walls that seem like walls and not paper, with insulation, and you certainly won't find central heating.

Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by pantalaimon on Saturday September 18, 2021 @04:35PM (#28579074)
Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by bjackman on Saturday September 18, 2021 @12:39PM (#28577478)
Demand for _homes_ is sticky. Demand for property ownership is not at all! It is influenced by speculation and rent-seeking. We can easily cripple both those things and reduce housing cost.

(Edit: I do agree with your conclusion though. We need more homes)

Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by Valakas_ on Saturday September 18, 2021 @12:53PM (#28577570)
Yes but there are 2 main types of demand in there. Demand coming from institutional and extremely wealthy investors and demand from regular folks. Who do you think is more likely to be the responsible for such an increase in price?

So i disagree with the solution you propose. The better solution is to reduce the type of demand that is responsible for this failure in housing prices.

Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by qeternity on Saturday September 18, 2021 @01:01PM (#28577639)
> Who do you think is more likely to be the responsible for such an increase in price?

They of course are contributing factors and if you want to regulate that, fine, go ahead. But they absolutely are not driving prices higher. Investors have tons of alternatives to invest in if prices are too high. People don’t have alternative forms of shelter, so they will tend to pay whatever the price is. And society facilitates and exacerbates this through well meaning efforts like “affordable housing” policies that artificially reduce interest rates and drive demand higher.

The bigger issue is that housing and property should never have become a de facto investment class. You should not earn inflation adjusted returns for owning a house. But of course, most wealth in the world is due to housing. And the next generations just increasingly get screwed over.

Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by thazework on Saturday September 18, 2021 @03:08PM (#28578454)
Berlin's population hasn't increased significantly since the end of WW2. There may be desirable areas that are experiencing demand spikes but the price increase seems city wide. Why is supply more of an issue right now? It is a question of (money) supply.
Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by KoenDG on Sunday September 19, 2021 @08:37AM (#28583838)
Commercially backed mortgages. The reason it doesn't work the way you're describing.

Supply and demand do not exist in a vacuum.

There's no _immediate_ response to people not being willing to pay a certain amount.

Owners, and especially individuals or companies that own large amounts of housing, will refuse to lower prices, regardless of demand dropping. Be it actual demand, or people staying away because the price is too high.

Because they have the power to do that.

I invite you to watch these little documentaries on new york city: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zjd1WNhGliY&list=PLkVbIsAWN2...

Where store spaces have not been rented out for sometimes a decade, because owners consistently refuse to lower prices. Just refusing to lower rent, for years on end, and being empty that entire time.

And if you ask why, the answer is: commercially backed mortgages.

It's simply: you take a loan with a bank for, say, 10 million USD. You're required to pay this loan back over a period of 10+ years. The bank, meanwhile, sells this as an investment product. The bank uses their own funds to guarantee the profit this loan is going to generate, and attracts investors to take a part of it. Thus gaining them a % increase after X years.

However, this means that you can't ever lower the amount you have to pay back, if the value of the physical good your property is based on, drops.

Price isn't dynamic in a pure sense. There's a person on the controls and if they refuse to move them, even if you think it's illogical to do so, they're not going to budge.

Because they have a loan to pay back. Over a finite amount of years. And lowering rent means longer time to pay back the loan, meaning breach of contract.

There are far more systems in place than many are even willing to consider. For it assaults their idealized worldview.

Be it shop or regular housing, this is a system that artificially stops prices from dropping.

Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by qeternity on Sunday September 19, 2021 @08:46AM (#28583904)
Yes and no. Yes, property investment and speculation and inflate prices beyond their consumptive utility.

But no in the sense that commercial real estate investors are a small chunk of the global RE market. The vast majority of residential property are owned by the tenants. We have turned housing into the largest retirement fund and don't have a way of undoing that. And we have exacerbated this by deciding to push interests rates artificially low so that all sorts of people who otherwise would be priced out of home ownership, are now part of the demand curve competing against the same supply curve.

Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by dorgo on Sunday September 19, 2021 @01:49PM (#28586324)
>Because they have a loan to pay back. Over a finite amount of years. And lowering rent means longer time to pay back the loan, meaning breach of contract.

I don't get it. Refusing to rent out the property means even longer time to pay back the loan, doesn't it? It can't be the reason.

Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by mupuff1234 on Saturday September 18, 2021 @09:04AM (#28575916)
Only if you think that the demand for real estate is mostly driven by housing needs, and not speculation & monopoly style hoarding artificially driving prices higher.
Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by qeternity on Saturday September 18, 2021 @01:08PM (#28577688)
Without a doubt, it is not mostly driven by those things. Investors have lots of choice about what to invest in. People don’t have any choice about needing shelter. They will pay whatever the price is.

I get that wealthy investors driving up housing prices gets people angry and is a good rallying cry. But it’s such a small piece of demand.

Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by mupuff1234 on Saturday September 18, 2021 @05:26PM (#28579472)
Define small? Even an additional 2-3% increase in supply can have quite a large affect on prices.

For example, pre-covid, there was a vast number of vacant apartments in NYC.

https://www.6sqft.com/nearly-250000-nyc-rental-apartments-si...

But also being in NYC during COVID and watching the real estate market react, it feels far from an efficient market, as one side has more information, resources and time.

https://www.businessinsider.com/new-york-city-rent-deals-lan...

Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by littlecranky67 on Saturday September 18, 2021 @09:30AM (#28576121)
Housing in Berlin is not unaffordable, else the occupancy of those houses wouldnt be so high.
Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by dathinab on Saturday September 18, 2021 @10:49AM (#28576687)
It's not that simple.

Affordable housing in Berlin means:

- "Normal" people working in Berlin can afford it (e.g. prices are still below e.g. Munich but you ear much more in Munich).

- You are not forced to spent so much money on housing that you not can't really afford anything else.

- We are speaking about apartments available now, there are a lot of people with older rental contracts which as such still pay much lower rents. (I.e. the price of entering a new rent contract is basically always noticeable above the average rent price, often as much as legally possible).

You can totally have "unaffordably" priced housing and high occupancy, because housing is in general not a think people can choose to "simply not have".

Also if you decrease the supply of "affordable" housing and make the remainder more expansive you totally can have an effect where occupancy stays high and people and up on the street (decrease the supply => convert rented apartments to owned ones, which don't count into "rented apartments occupancy").

So what you see is:

- More WGs i.e. people sharing a apartment and the rent, and this is not just young people.

- A lot of "natives" moving away from Berlin.

- A lot of rented Appartments being converted to owned ones, some being actually used other not.

- A lot of people with non-high wage jobs spending so much money on rent that they have no money left to put aside for emergencies and potentially even have to cut corners in their daily live.

- Some more wealth people coming to Berlin.

One major difference to some of the more expensive cities in Germany is that people people tend to earn much less money and thinks like "moving to a cheaper metro area around Berlin" are often not really viable (as there isn't that much to move to, it might actually be more expansive then living in Berlin it also is legally seen another German state and commute times can become a problem, too. I mean they can be a problem in-side of Berlin, it's a pretty wide city.)

Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by littlecranky67 on Saturday September 18, 2021 @12:16PM (#28577294)
I understood, but the claim "unaffordable" makes no sense because obviously, there are enough people that can afford it. But yes, low-income households have more and more difficulties making ends meet when the prices rise.

The issue is that Germany does not have a housing crisis, there are at least 600k uninhabited housing units. Yes, those are mostly rural and especially in the former GDR. Usually you get a commission if you FIND somebody willing to rent long-term.

People are drawn into cities, especially Berlin has become "hip" - even though the job market is not even close to Munich or Stuttgart. So I think (and most people I know who moved there) people move for the lifestyle. I am pretty mad at the Berlin government now using taxpayers money to buy back pricy appartments - especially since Berlin is one of the poorest states in Germany and heavily subsidied by the other states (through "Länderfinanzausgleich"). And this will in no way help with the high demand/low supply problem, that actually exists.

Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by dathinab on Saturday September 18, 2021 @04:07PM (#28578867)
> "unaffordable" makes no sense because obviously, there are enough people that can afford it.

Doesn't mean thinks didn't become unaffordable for other people. If a lot a people which grow up do or are considering leaving because they can't afford rent it's a social problem.

> The issue is that Germany does not have a housing crisis, there are at least 600k uninhabited housing units.

Just because there are housing units in some places doesn't mean there is no housing crisis. Because what point are housing units in the wrong places.

Because what point is a housing unit in a area where there is no work, no hospitals (close by), no supper market (close by), no public transport (which goes frequently), no restaurants, bars or people to meet, probably bad internet, etc.

I mean if that places would be nice countryside nature places it might be interesting, but they often aren't even that. They often are areas where in the past there had been a lot of manual work (car industry, coal mining, heavy industry, etc.) and it went away, as well as small villages.

> People are drawn into cities

Often out necessity, due to the points mentioned above.

Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by luckylion on Saturday September 18, 2021 @11:58AM (#28577187)
> One major difference to some of the more expensive cities in Germany is that people people tend to earn much less money

I don't know. According to a somewhat recent study[1], Berlin is pretty average, only 10-20% below e.g. Hamburg, North Rhine-Westphalia, Bavaria and Baden-Württemberg (where the rents for comparable flats in the larger cities tend to be much higher than in Berlin, and not just 10-20%, while cost of living (utilities, meals, services) is generally 10-20% lower in Berlin).

It's true that the current prices do get obscured by looking at averages, especially in Berlin where old contracts are absurdly cheap. Comparing the usual real-estate sites in Germany (granted, most markets aren't exactly showing many offers, so it's always a small sample, but it remains the same over time), you'll find that Berlin's rents are still considerably lower than those in Hamburg, Munich, Dusseldorf etc. Berlin is in a very special situation in Europe in that the capital of the country is not anywhere close to being the most expensive population center.

As for "natives" moving out of Berlin: not so sure either, many Berliners weren't born in Berlin, but that has been going on for the longest time (it's been a thing a hundred years ago, has settled during the GDR, and has been reignited in the last two decades; today, slightly over half of Berlin residents were not born in Berlin). It's a city where young people move to study and party and then stay for the life style and lower cost of living. Coincidentally, these are often the same people complaining about the high rents and asking for collectivization.

[1] https://www.bz-berlin.de/berlin/berliner-liegen-mit-42-525-e...

Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by dathinab on Saturday September 18, 2021 @12:15PM (#28577288)
Berlins avg. rent level (15,39€/m²) is above that of Hamburg (14,35€/m²) and Dusseldorf (12,80€/m²).
Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by dathinab on Saturday September 18, 2021 @12:23PM (#28577346)
Through there seem to be massive differences between the sources for Berlin...
Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by qeternity on Saturday September 18, 2021 @01:12PM (#28577709)
Haha yes, a commenter after my own heart.

Of course, the only unaffordable price is one which the market will not bear. Any price at which a market transacts is by definition affordable.

And herein lies the issue: everyone wants to live in Berlin, but not everyone can live in Berlin. Price is the mechanism by which we determine who values living in Berlin most.

You might not think it’s fair, but this is the reality.

Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by littlecranky67 on Sunday September 19, 2021 @05:19AM (#28582881)
The issue is that actually the prices are transparent and fair - at least I know and understand why I don't get an apartment that I can afford. The issue with government imposed rent control/caps is, that now instead of 50 applicants for an apartment which is priced at market rate, there will be 250 applicants to an appartment with capped rent - and there is no way for me to understand why I didn't get it. Do I need to be in the right party as the owner? Do I have the wrong skin color, gender, religion, country of birth to please the landlord?

High prices are only unfair at first look, but actually allocating scarce resources through market prices is a very fair and transparent mechanism.

Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by qeternity on Sunday September 19, 2021 @08:48AM (#28583919)
I am in agreement with you. I think free markets are the fairest.

But most people conflate "fairness" with some emotional feeling about the outcomes (which of course, has nothing to do with being fair).

Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by djrobstep on Saturday September 18, 2021 @08:58AM (#28575871)
Please stop saying this - house prices in Australia have recorded record growth in the same year as record low immigration due to covid restrictions. The primary driver is low interest rates enabling cheap debt, not "supply".
Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by Spooky23 on Saturday September 18, 2021 @09:07AM (#28575945)
Many HN posters are California based, and apply the weird nuances of that market with everyone.

The demand side of capital is underrated because it’s hard to see. Normal folks don’t realize that managers of large funds are doing previously impractical things like buying suburban subdivision homes because they have access to unlimited capital and can offload/distribute risk.

Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by rce on Saturday September 18, 2021 @09:06AM (#28575932)
Thanks for mentioning interest rates as well. Though I don't know that it counters the original point. Things can have multiple causes. Both limited supply and low interest rates can be major contributing factors.
Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by fighterpilot on Saturday September 18, 2021 @09:55AM (#28576300)
Lack of supply due to zoning restrictions is undoubtedly a huge part of it.
Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by Thuggery on Saturday September 18, 2021 @02:17PM (#28578169)
Undoubtedly? I've never seen any real proof of it. It's just kind of a mantra. Housing pricing continues to be a problem in every first world country's urban center. Do they all have the exact same "zoning?" And why now? Did this evil zoning just get enacted now for presumably pointless evil reasons?

"Zoning" to me seems to be a modern version of "kulaks" for neoliberal types that just can't grok that there is something fundamentally rotten in the entire system. And have no real practical solutions to fix it.

Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by fighterpilot on Saturday September 18, 2021 @09:58PM (#28581043)
If you haven't seen any proof then it's because you haven't looked. Just google any of the research on this topic.

https://www.abc.net.au/news/2018-03-08/zoning-regulations-ad...

It's not surprising that every major urban centre has inflated property prices. Restrictive zoning laws such as the ones studied above are more common than not. San Fran, London, Australia, Berlin, what have you. NIMBYism is the default. Homeowners aren't going to willingly vote away their profits.

Not only is there solid empirical evidence, but it makes evident sense. There is no cap on supply due to the ability to build vertically. Rapidly inflating prices significantly above cost over a multi decade time frame makes zero sense in a market economy without an artificial cap on supply. Gold would be cheap (at cost) if more supply could be invented/constructed, irrespective of how many people wanted to invest.

Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by foobar33333 on Saturday September 18, 2021 @09:07AM (#28575949)
The prices in Australia are based on forecasted demand. Since there is almost a 100% chance that the population of tomorrow will be greater than today, that means you can buy on higher prices than current demand. Unfortunately that means houses can be considered worth almost infinite dollars since the population will keep going up.
Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by axiosgunnar on Saturday September 18, 2021 @10:01AM (#28576340)
> Since there is almost a 100% chance that the population of tomorrow will be greater than today

This is of course already priced in today

Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by mmerlin on Saturday September 18, 2021 @09:57AM (#28576315)
Let's not forget the Liberal Party recently throwing out the fairly-newly-enacted loan suitability consumer protection laws, so that the mortgage brokers could reduce compliance and go back to the boomtime days of being the legal human shields (plausible deniability buffer) for the banks to allow larger and larger liar loans, which are 1 in 3 source... abc.net.au and anectodally, I subleased my office from a mortgage broker for years, saw how much they fiddled the figures for people to get MASSIVE loans they will never pay off.

I also recoded a lot of their compliance CRM for them when these now-discarded consumer protection laws first came into effect.. and was shaking my head in disgust at Frydenberg... no wonder Hayne would not shake that man's hand...

https://www.theguardian.com/global/video/2019/feb/01/awkward...

[dead]
Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by helge9210 on Saturday September 18, 2021 @10:28AM (#28576531)
> Deport illegals and halt immigration?

Halting immigration will result in shrinking economy.

Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by bombcar on Saturday September 18, 2021 @10:45AM (#28576656)
A shrinking economy will drop house prices.
Re:Berlin buys thousands of apartments from corporate landlords by jlokier on Saturday September 18, 2021 @02:50PM (#28578365)
And reduce average incomes. I wonder which one drops faster.