News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Gitlab S-1 by ignoramous on Friday September 17, 2021 @02:45PM (#28569364)
Gitlab is one of the pioneers of "remote-first" [0] and "building in public" [1], to the extent of sometimes even live-streaming CEO meetings [2] and sales pitches [3]

Gitlab, I believe, informs the common strategy behind most other source-available ycombinator enterprise startups: the buyer-based open-core model [4]

Congratulations Gitlab. You're far from a copycat and deserve all the success for relentless execution and radical transparency, if nothing else [5]

[0] https://www.youtube-nocookie.com/embed/gOp4lKSCulI

[1] https://www.youtube-nocookie.com/embed/vCiLMLC2Rhs

[2] https://www.youtube-nocookie.com/embed/uUwmlJfim6U

[3] https://www.youtube-nocookie.com/embed/XcqloQezOUg

[4] https://www.heavybit.com/library/video/commercial-open-sourc...

[5] https://about.gitlab.com/handbook/values/

Re:Gitlab S-1 by INTPenis on Friday September 17, 2021 @03:51PM (#28570188)
Yeah I absolutely support Gitlab and love seeing new projects use Gitlab over Github.

But to be fair, they have a massive backlog of issues to fix. Basic issues too, like variables not expanding correctly in CI jobs, or Google not being able to index projects on gitlab.com unless there's another page already linking to it.

I've been using Gitlab.com and Gitlab on-prem since 2013 and over the years I've found many of these bugs that I feel should be top priority instead of new features.

Re:Gitlab S-1 by reilly3000 on Friday September 17, 2021 @05:12PM (#28570946)
With their business model, a constant stream of new features is the only thing that pays the bills. Their paid tiers get the new features, and almost all of them eventually wind up in the open product. With a healthy IPO they should be resourced enough to put some extra hands on the backlog. +1 for prioritizing old tickets!
Re:Gitlab S-1 by sillysaurusx on Friday September 17, 2021 @05:43PM (#28571240)
I don’t really think that IPOing is about acquiring more resources. The point is to get rich. The resources are the means to do that, and everything else is a happy side effect.

Hopefully, yes, they will choose to do as you say. But the tickets didn’t language because they were resource constrained. They languished because they were worthless, in the monetary sense.

Re:Gitlab S-1 by crazy_horse on Friday September 17, 2021 @05:55PM (#28571334)
It'll get worse.

This is a YC site so it's a dick thing to say but look at every YC company that got big. They might start out with nice ideas and bloviate a lot about bullshit (Reddit still has the tagline about staying for empathy - lol).

But every single one of them gets worse after cashing out. They do not give a shit. It's always been about the money. If it weren't they'd have enough pride to make better software then they do and more than that enough pride to actually fix things instead of bloviating.

Their business model ensures that they will continue to add features to a bloated and overmarketed project to people that don't know better. We better off? It's possible. But I know that watching their interactions here over the last past decade, when I had the chance, I made sure we didn't use Gitlab for some unis you've heard of and going forward I always will.

I'll never get over their data loss incident. Not so much that it happened (though they should have had enough expertise around to make sure it never happened), but the reaction to it like it was just a funny mistake. I realized then that these guys haven't been in real small companies that could go bankrupt if they lose a chunk of data or they had and didn't realize how careless they were.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13542587

Re:Gitlab S-1 by sillysaurusx on Friday September 17, 2021 @06:18PM (#28571540)
As a counterpoint, the data loss incident made me a fan. They didn't treat it as a funny mistake, I don't think -- I remember one comment from one of the Gitlab engineers of "everyone is very sad, but we're trying." Something in that spirit.

Anyone who's ever worked with production systems knows how absurdly easy it is to ruin them. Yes, it was careless, but they responded with class: they didn't fire the engineer that made the mistake. That would have turned me into a gitlab enemy.

Recognizing that a process is dysfunctional is one of the hardest things for any company to do. There's an incredible amount of corporate inertia preventing such recognitions from taking hold. Are you sure it wasn't worth applauding?

There's also nothing wrong with getting big, or getting worse. The trick is to get worse in the ways that matter the least.

Re:Gitlab S-1 by klik99 on Friday September 17, 2021 @06:04PM (#28571427)
I think it’s about being the dominant player or not, as a long time employee of a very very well known and large company once complained to me “We care about the user experience, but only when we’re not doing well”. Gitlab will continue to impress as long as GitHub exists - I’d start to worry if gitlab “wins”
Re:Gitlab S-1 by tln on Friday September 17, 2021 @06:19PM (#28571545)
GitHub seems to care about user experience even though they're winning though.
Re:Gitlab S-1 by leeoniya on Friday September 17, 2021 @08:18PM (#28572337)
i've opened multiple, detailed support tickets over the years about different UX wtfs they rolled out that removed vital functionality.

not one of my complaints has ever been addressed. my last complaint was ghosted after i pointed out that they should actually read my lengthy analysis instead of giving a worthless canned response.

still waiting for reply since Jan 4.

Re:Gitlab S-1 by atatatat on Saturday September 18, 2021 @12:23AM (#28573703)
Are you a paid user?
Re:Gitlab S-1 by leeoniya on Saturday September 18, 2021 @12:34AM (#28573733)
no, but i author and maintain some pretty popular projects and now work for a company that does pay, and also has a massive github and OSS footprint.
Re:Gitlab S-1 by webmaven on Saturday September 18, 2021 @01:09AM (#28573839)
> no, but i author and maintain some pretty popular projects and now work for a company that does pay, and also has a massive github and OSS footprint.

Would you say that you (and your projects) and employer are to some degree locked in now? Are either you or your employer likely to move away from hosting your projects on GitHub?

Re:Gitlab S-1 by leeoniya on Saturday September 18, 2021 @02:25AM (#28574167)
my employer uses a lot of paid github features, while my projects use none, so moving away would be simple for me, but difficult for them.

the real lock-in is no different than any other social media platform: network effects. most people who follow you on X rarely bother also having an account on Y. unless you're Taylor Swift, moving away means diminished visibility/reach, and dilution of any reputation accumulated e.g. over a decade of activity, interactions, etc.

Re:Gitlab S-1 by paulryanrogers on Friday September 17, 2021 @08:55PM (#28572591)
GitHub SAAS consumer experience. It doesn't go as far for users who would like to run their own GH instance as open source. And in some areas GitLab has done better, such as CI.
Re:Gitlab S-1 by CameronNemo on Friday September 17, 2021 @09:54PM (#28572865)
GitHub enterprise on prem is an offering I thought? Sure it is not open source, or even source available. But they are still trying to compete against GitLab in that space.
Re:Gitlab S-1 by paulryanrogers on Saturday September 18, 2021 @12:06AM (#28573605)
Right, but I doubt GH let's on prem users modify the source to suit their needs.
Re:Gitlab S-1 by gm3dmo on Saturday September 18, 2021 @03:34AM (#28574401)
Ensuring there are regular backups of the organizations data is the responsibility of the organization and not the responsibility of GitLab.

Disaster recovery did not go away with the advent of cloud providers. It morphed from having a plan to recover when fire takes out a data centre to having a plan to recover when provider X whose free plan we base our business on no longer has our data.

Re:Gitlab S-1 by dreamcompiler on Saturday September 18, 2021 @12:14AM (#28573649)
What makes you think their new shareholders will tolerate bug fixing? It doesn't generate revenue and hence doesn't contribute to constant growth, which seems to be the only thing that matters to investors these days.

And that's why we can't have nice things in for-profit software nowadays.

Re:Gitlab S-1 by josegonzalez on Saturday September 18, 2021 @02:24AM (#28574162)
Bug fixing likely helps with retention, which shareholders _will_ be interested in.
Re:Gitlab S-1 by pushrax on Saturday September 18, 2021 @03:38AM (#28574422)
Especially for products with higher levels of network effect.
Re:Gitlab S-1 by mekster on Saturday September 18, 2021 @02:07PM (#28578097)
Why would I want to use a bug ridden, poor performing tool?

There are alternatives with less features if you don't need them all.

Re:Gitlab S-1 by golergka on Saturday September 18, 2021 @07:49AM (#28575456)
Their paid users also switch to GitHub when they get annoyed by bugs. I did it once myself.
Re:Gitlab S-1 by Lorin on Saturday September 18, 2021 @01:20AM (#28573872)
Took em' about 2-3 years to add the "What's new" link in the top menu bar since the issue was opened.
Re:Gitlab S-1 by bevdecloud on Friday September 17, 2021 @05:16PM (#28570990)
I have been using it for a couple months. You are very correct. I guess when are as open as they are it kind of gets lost in translation. Hopefully becoming a shareholder in a truly public company is the push for us to fix these kinds of issues.
Re:Gitlab S-1 by alvarlagerlof on Friday September 17, 2021 @07:13PM (#28571941)
No notifications on the platform is a deal breaker for me.
Re:Gitlab S-1 by jjeaff on Friday September 17, 2021 @07:24PM (#28572012)
Do you mean no push notifications? Because I get emails for stuff. The rest is integrated into our chat client, mattermost. I actually prefer using that as a centralized place for work notifications.
Re:Gitlab S-1 by rmetzler on Saturday September 18, 2021 @03:34AM (#28574402)
I see notifications for starting Gitlab CI pipelines in Google Chrome on MacOS. What kind of notifications do you want exactly?

I would rather have less notifications, they distract me too much.

Re:Gitlab S-1 by BelenusMordred on Saturday September 18, 2021 @01:37AM (#28573941)
> Gitlab is one of the pioneers of "remote-first"

I once looked at their wages when I was in Asia, they wouldn't even cover my rent working full-time. Until they pay for skill rather than area I'm going to be a sceptic sorry, far better companies to work for.

Re:Gitlab S-1 by keerthiko on Saturday September 18, 2021 @03:08AM (#28574326)
For all the work they have done in getting remote-first culture established for large corps, their salary protocol is pretty backward.

Normalizing on employee locale adds so many assumptions about the life and lifestyle of the employee and their market that are somewhat unfair to incorporate into compensation.

Our company is far smaller, but also been remote-first for almost a decade, and flat salary structure based on role (we pretty much have just IC, lead or junior) and fully independent of location was the best.

Since we have two founders living in the Bay Area and in New York, two of the most expensive cities, a comfortable wage for those founders should be good enough for anyone anywhere.

For our own simplicity, we aligned compensation on gross (pre-tax) pay, so the take-home is slightly different between regions.

Re:Gitlab S-1 by golergka on Saturday September 18, 2021 @07:54AM (#28575485)
There's nothing "fair" or "unfair" about salaries: it's just an open market. And their strategy is not a winning one. On my last remote job search, I encountered a few companies which were mimicking gitlab's approach (they actually said out loud that gitlab was where they got the idea). Needless to say, I accepted the offer from an American company which offered American salary instead. Three times as much as companies with "gitlab-like" policies offered me.
Re:Gitlab S-1 by nine_k on Saturday September 18, 2021 @03:11AM (#28574342)
They apparently can find talent at their current rates. Good for them.

But certainly there will be pressure on them and on all others, as US companies start to hire globally, and offer more-or-less US wages.

Re:Gitlab S-1 by plafl on Saturday September 18, 2021 @03:47AM (#28574457)
Is there so much demand in the US that it will impact global wages? I'm not sure.

As a foreigner is not in my interest but I do wonder if, just for the sake of coherence, shouldn't the import of labor be taxated in the same way goods are taxated.

Re:Gitlab S-1 by nine_k on Saturday September 18, 2021 @05:06AM (#28574741)
If you're a software developer, have you tried to find a job in last, like, 20 years? While doing so, you likely noticed how many recruiters are interested in you.

There is a serious deficit of software developers, the industry is striving to hire much more that currently available. If they can now make up their mind and keep hiring remotely, the will market grow a lot, but equally will grow the desires, see Jevons Paradox.

Re:Gitlab S-1 by amyjess on Saturday September 18, 2021 @11:49AM (#28577125)
> While doing so, you likely noticed how many recruiters are interested in you.

I'd appreciate that more if not for the fact that I regularly get emails and cold calls from recruiters who do the following:

- ...want me for a job that has zilch to do with my skillset. I'm an SRE and a general infrastructure engineer. 90% the jobs I get calls about are for frontend stuff and/or involve languages I've never touched. Want me to maintain a container orchestration platform? Great! Want me to write a bunch of Python scripts to serve as the glue that holds together a complex Rube Goldberg machine? I love doing that! Want me to maintain a set of monitoring systems that alert people according to ever-changing requirements? I can do that. But if you want me to write a UX in JavaScript? Excuse me while I spend the next half hour laughing.

- ...cold call me during work hours. If you do that, I will never do business with you ever again. It's not so bad now that I'm fully remote forever, but when I worked in an office I would straight-up ask some of them "are you trying to get me fired?" before hanging up on them. Usually they cold-call and send an email simultaneously, which is especially ridiculous. With some people I've gotten repeated cold-calls during work hours multiple days in a row, so I spend some time online finding the names of their recruiting firm's head of HR, general counsel, CEO, COO, and any number of executives who look like they might be in this person's reporting chain, use the name format in the email the recruiter sent me to guess their email addresses of said bigwigs, and then send all of them a C&D letter. I've gotten profuse apologies from HR people.

- ...want me for short-term contracts in parts of the US I would never live in if you paid me. Like I'm going to give up my nice house in Dallas and quit my full-time job with fantastic benefits and generous PTO to take a six-month contract with no benefits or PTO in Lansing, MI where there's nothing to do but fentanyl. And I had that problem before I decided I intend to be remote forever and never want to set foot in an office again.

- ...lie to me about jobs being remote. Here's an example: guy cold-called me and sent an email, and normally I would've just hung up on him but I was desparate to find a remote job before my old company made us go back to the office so I listened to him. I told him I'll have to read the email first, and I hung up to read it. He called me back less than five minutes later and asked me if I'd made a decision yet. He told me on the phone the job was remote, but the email said it was just temporary until the end of the pandemic and they insisted that anyone who gets the job relocate to the metro area immediately even before the pandemic is over. I called him on his lie and told him I'll pass because the position isn't full-time remote. He lied again, said "but it's full-time!". I read back the email word for word, and just to get back at him for lying to me I lied to him back and told him I have a medical condition and I'm permanently housebound for the rest of my life. He then said "but what about after the pandemic?". I lied again and said "no, even after the pandemic I'm physically unable to leave my house". He then said "even after the pandemic is completely over?". I had to lie to him further and basically convince him that I'm in an iron lung before he finally agreed I'm not a candidate for the position.

Re:Gitlab S-1 by nine_k on Saturday September 18, 2021 @04:08PM (#28578887)
This all shows a huge underserved market.

Because of its being underserved, we're in a privileged position to ask more money, better hours, longer-term contracts, etc. Compare that to the situation of warehouse workers or ride-hailing drivers, where the situation is opposite.