HN: "Just use ML, seems pretty easy to me".
I don't meant to disparage you, but that is how your comment came across to me.
Unfortunately prisoners are usually on the losing end of systems designed by their jailers, as they lack strong advocacy and a role in designing the system itself.
"Well, we have reasons to believe that this idea is dangerous and it doesn't actually solve any problems. In fact, the only advantage it does have is to give some pseudo-intellectual who doesn't understand any of the issues the warm, fuzzy feeling that he's smarter than everyone else."
I mean really, he calculated the price of the prisoner's toilet?
The pandemic has provided us with a lite version of what Snow proposed. And despite having better conditions (bigger and comfier apartments, no need to live alone, allowed to leave the place once in a while) this was enough for plenty of people to have nervous breakdowns.
I don't doubt that I would do fine in such a prison, but I also don't doubt that most people would come out completely broken. To quote the modern poet Randall Munroe [1], "I've never been that big of a hug person, but it turns out I'm not quite this small of a hug person either".
What state do you think he’ll be in when he’s let out?
Ridiculous idea
edit: and I mean, they could still use voicechat in the meanwhile, you can build that in the wall so it's pretty hard to break
Well, it's still cheaper and I'm sure eventually VR technology will get better...
but isn't this supposed to be happening in America?
It’s cruel.
There are however an array of medications that could be administrated to force compliance and do not cause a permanent state like a lobotomy would.
But yes, the entire idea is dehumanizing in my opinion.