News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Steve Jobs: Let's force Amazon to use our payment system ... by ethbr0 on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @03:28PM (#28543300)
I'm not an Apple fanboy, but Jobs deserves all the credit that goes his way for killing Flash.

It was a great product, but Macromedia / Adobe demonstrated subsequently that they were in no way a security-responsible long-term maintainer.

Re:Steve Jobs: Let's force Amazon to use our payment system ... by kmeisthax on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @04:58PM (#28544257)
I'm going to disagree that Jobs killed Flash. It's more like Adobe neglected and abused the Flash platform, and as part of that, they failed to actually get it working on mobile.

Remember, Apple actually begged Adobe to get build a version of Flash Player that wouldn't burn iPhone users' batteries. They did the same thing when the iPad came out. They knew not having Flash was a weakness. Adobe utterly failed to "get" mobile and shipped plugin builds that were about as buggy as the desktop version was.

Getting Flash to work on iPhone would have taken a huge commitment of resources on Adobe's part, similar to how Apple spent lots of time and money getting Safari/WebKit to render mobile sites correctly. It's not impossible, it's just something that you need executive-level buy in on. Google thought Jobs was bluffing and decided to allow Flash on Android; and it was so terrible that Adobe dropped it a year later.

As an example of what Adobe's real priorities were; two years after "Thoughts on Flash" Adobe decided to gate off certain Flash APIs behind a revenue sharing agreement so they could charge Unity developers to cross-compile to SWF. No, really, that happened. Adobe conjured up a whole licensing scheme and everything for it, because they wanted to make sure someone was there to pay for AS4 development. The thing about platforms is that their value is in the money that the platform owner leaves on the table. The more that you claim for yourself, either by charging more fees or neglecting maintenance, the less reason there is to use the platform.

I genuinely feel Apple may be unlearning this lesson.

Re:Steve Jobs: Let's force Amazon to use our payment system ... by jldugger on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @05:17PM (#28544494)
>The thing about platforms is that their value is in the money that the platform owner leaves on the table. The more that you claim for yourself, either by charging more fees or neglecting maintenance, the less reason there is to use the platform.

In other venues, I've seen this described as "becoming 50 percent richer by being 10 percent less greedy."

Re:Steve Jobs: Let's force Amazon to use our payment system ... by ethbr0 on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @05:34PM (#28544670)
90s Microsoft realized this, which is how Windows became Windows (making developers and partners lots and lots of money).

And how 90s Apple decomposed, and only really turned it around by creating enough demand via consumer device market share that developers had to come back.

Re:Steve Jobs: Let's force Amazon to use our payment system ... by blihp on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @08:24PM (#28546293)
Adobe had it working on mobile... arguably badly. See Flash on Android. Apple said 'no, you're not going to run that on our platform'. With Flash no longer being ubiquitous, it effectively died rather quickly after that.

It can be argued that this probably would have happened anyway with Javascipt engine performance improving rapidly and web standards beginning to provide media functionality that had been missing etc. However, it was Apple who stopped them cold and greatly accelerated its demise rather than hanging in there for another decade or more.

Re:Steve Jobs: Let's force Amazon to use our payment system ... by nabakin on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @08:47PM (#28546481)
I remember you could get flash to work on iOS through Cydia. I don't know how that was done though.
Re:Steve Jobs: Let's force Amazon to use our payment system ... by blihp on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @11:11PM (#28547509)
Cydia exists outside of Apple's control. The inability to run Flash on iOS was never a technical issue, it was a policy issue.
Re:Steve Jobs: Let's force Amazon to use our payment system ... by yarcob on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @03:56PM (#28543617)
Poor performance on Mac was also an issue. Web browsers on the Mac were held back by the fact that Adobes plugin was extremely slow on the Mac, and Adobe didn't care. Apple could write the fastest web browser in the world, but it wouldn't matter if Flash on the Mac had only a fraction of the performance of the Windows version.

It was a very smart move to not enable that dependency on the iPhone.

Re:Steve Jobs: Let's force Amazon to use our payment system ... by rrrrrrrrrrrryan on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @05:05PM (#28544329)
I think his hands were somewhat tied on the iPhone honestly - flash apps were borderline unusable on the flagship Android headsets of the day. You had to install an alternate browser, the apps were designed for mouse-keyboard input rather than touchscreens, they were non-responsive, they lagged with the Qualcomm chips, and they absolutely ravaged your battery.

It's no wonder Steve Jobs just decided not to straight up not the tech. The security concerns were just a convenient scapegoat.

Re:Steve Jobs: Let's force Amazon to use our payment system ... by Apocryphon on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @04:36PM (#28544038)
Ironically, that fastest web browser engine now determines the fates of apps on Apple's platform. At least, it prevents the building of alternative browsers like an iOS Firefox Gecko browser.
Re:Steve Jobs: Let's force Amazon to use our payment system ... by bityard on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @04:44PM (#28544125)
Jobs deserves credit for a lot of the way things went in the computing world but I don't think "killing flash" is one of them. Apple and Flash only (publicly) crossed paths when the iPhone was released in 2007. Even then, Flash was widely disliked by users for a bunch of very good reasons:

* It was yet another thing to install. (Most non-tech-savvy users didn't know how to install a web browser, let alone a browser-specific plugin.) I was an "expert" computer user and I still had trouble getting it to work quite often.

* Flash apps were very resource-hungry on the slow machines at the time. Not quite as bad as Java, but still pretty bad. You had to wait for them to load, and when they consumed an outsize amount of CPU and memory compared to the value delivered.

* A lot of enterprise software started getting written in Flash (vSphere 6, anyone?). I feel bad for every IT department that had to put up with this. Of course, before and alongside that it was Java.

* The Flash runtime was a huge source of computer-pwning exploits. "Click to play" flash was a good idea but about a decade too late to make any difference.

No, Flash was never particularly well-liked by ANYONE except animators, web video game companies, and web ad companies. It was going to die eventually. Even if we were to accept "Jobs killed Flash" as true, that would make it one of his _least_ successful endeavors since Flash only went EOL this year, 14 years later!

Re:Steve Jobs: Let's force Amazon to use our payment system ... by ethbr0 on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @05:29PM (#28544617)
Java and Flash are great comparisons, as web / applet Java is pretty much the same market.

My point being that Java felt like they were stewarding a platform seriously (admittedly, mostly towards enterprise priorities).

Whereas Flash felt like they were saying yes to whatever their designer customers asked, and worrying about the details later.

And IE is just being deprecated in many places. 14 years to EOL is a snap of the fingers on enterprise timescales.

Re:Steve Jobs: Let's force Amazon to use our payment system ... by mrkramer on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @03:31PM (#28543330)
How many bugs Flash had? Hundreds? Thousands? Anybody knows?
Re:Steve Jobs: Let's force Amazon to use our payment system ... by bell-cot on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @03:40PM (#28543446)
From a quick CVE search, less than 1,200 bugs ( https://cve.mitre.org/cgi-bin/cvekey.cgi?keyword=adobe+flash ).

For practical purposes, ~Aleph-nought.

Re:Steve Jobs: Let's force Amazon to use our payment system ... by mrkramer on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @03:49PM (#28543549)
Over 300 Flash bugs were discovered (and fixed) in 2015 alone:

https://www.gsmarena.com/over_300_flash_bugs_were_discovered...

Re:Steve Jobs: Let's force Amazon to use our payment system ... by fortran77 on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @06:41PM (#28545332)
But Jobs didn't kill it because of "security." He didn't like it because it allowed another way for people to write "applications" that could run on his phone, and a related issue of it being bad for battery life.
Re:Steve Jobs: Let's force Amazon to use our payment system ... by dkonofalski on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @08:39PM (#28546403)
That's not true. The original iPhone didn't have an App Store. Jobs was all in on Progressive Web Apps and thought the future was going to web applications that ran natively in Safari. That's why he initially wanted things like Flash to work on iPhone. He didn't give up on that until Adobe called his bluff and major developers refused to move to mobile. He very begrudgingly introduced the App Store in the next iOS version after he realized that they needed it.
Re:Steve Jobs: Let's force Amazon to use our payment system ... by 0x456 on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @04:29PM (#28543983)
A contrarian might ask "How many bugs were there in the HTML5 APIs that replaced it?" Probably fewer considering HTML5 is an open/modern code base? Some high profile ones in Audio though...
Re:Steve Jobs: Let's force Amazon to use our payment system ... by dwild on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @05:16PM (#28544467)
> It was a great product, but Macromedia / Adobe demonstrated subsequently that they were in no way a security-responsible long-term maintainer.

The amount of zero-days zero-click remote code execution that came out of iOS on the past few months...

Zerodium had to stop buying zero-days for iOS last year, as they had too many of them.

I means I won't say that Adobe did a great job on security, just that it wasn't a good justification to kill the whole product.

Flash didn't get taken down because of security issue, but because of Jobs manipulative tactics.

Re:Steve Jobs: Let's force Amazon to use our payment system ... by snowwrestler on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @05:49PM (#28544807)
Flash just could not run well on power-constrained environments. Folks were allowed to run it on Android, but it sucked.

Flash was not killed, it committed suicide. All Jobs did was keep the death throes off iOS.

Re:Steve Jobs: Let's force Amazon to use our payment system ... by dwild on Thursday September 16, 2021 @01:22PM (#28554525)
> Flash just could not run well on power-constrained environments. Folks were allowed to run it on Android, but it sucked.

It was running pretty well 10 years on my LG Optimus One at the time, which was a cheap 200$ phone (not subsidized, I got it for 50$ because of a promotion that gave 100$ while it was 50$ off).

Still remember a few years ago, a bunch of friends started to play on our group conversation on the cheap HTML5 games of Facebook... theses games were so simple, yet most were complaining of performance issue. That was on phones that was now few generations better, and not the entry-level ones either...

Jobs knew how to control markets, we are on a thread about this. Flash was killed because he needed it to be killed to control the market.