News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Scientists create matter from pure light, proving the Bre... by jcims on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @09:09AM (#28524191)
I have had this mental question about 'what time is it when photons collide'. Given that a photon could have been travelling for a million years colliding with one that has only been travelling for a microsecond, and from the photon perspective there is no passage of time and no distance.

I then kept reading things that tell me photons don't interact, which saddened me because I like the question. This now appears to not be the case, is there a specific condition under which photons can interact like this?

Re:Scientists create matter from pure light, proving the Bre... by jdbburg on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @09:29AM (#28524483)
In classical electromagnetism photons (light) do not interact, period. But in quantum mechanics the photons can briefly fluctuate into electron + positron pairs which allow them to interact with each other. But the probability for interacting is very small AND you need enough energy to make the electron positron pair (for the Breit-Wheeler process), so it is very rare in practice.

I am not sure about the "time" the photons collide, but the interesting thing is that the Breit-Wheeler process is what determines the opacity of the universe - since high energy photons traveling through the universe can hit low energy photons from the cosmic microwave background and convert (disappearing) into an electron positron pair.

Re:Scientists create matter from pure light, proving the Bre... by jerf on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @10:07AM (#28525030)
This is a good example of one of the errors that I often see in what is otherwise the best scientific writing, which is either forgetting to specify what a certain model says, or simply straight up forgetting/confusing that a certain model isn't reality.

Maxwell's equations say that light doesn't interact. Maxwell's equations are known to be wrong in that way. They're still a very good simplifying case that you can do very well with using, by all means, just like Newtonian physics in the right conditions, but they aren't the way reality works. Maxwell's equations also have no place to put a gravity term, yet gravity clearly affects light.

The one I probably see the most often is articles about black holes confidently speaking about "what goes on below the event horizon" from an Einstein relativity point of view, which is where you get all the singularities and ring singularities that lead to different universes somehow, etc, again either forgetting to point out or simply forgetting entirely that those are the specific predictions of Einstein relativity, which is known to be inadequate to describe the inside of a black hole. It is certainly fair to discuss that theory's predictions, and whatever really is happening in there, relativity will certain shine some sort of light on it, but it is a mistake to present it simply as "what happens on the inside". The model is known to be broken here.

I am working out how to phrase this in a way that makes sense to the HN crowd because this tends to ruffle feathers when I say it, but this is all what should be well-known stuff. It's not like I'm "denying science" when I say this; quite the contrary! It's "denying science" when you insist the known-by-science-to-be-broken models are in fact not broken where the science is pretty clear that they are.

Re:Scientists create matter from pure light, proving the Bre... by whatshisface on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @10:52AM (#28525742)
>Maxwell's equations also have no place to put a gravity term, yet gravity clearly affects light.

The place to put the "gravity term" is in the coordinate system that Maxwell's equations take place in, and the definition of the derivative which is implicitly brought in via the curls, divergences, etc. That's general relativity, and Maxwell's equations are already fully compatible with it.

>[this tends to ruffle feathers when I say it] ... It's "denying science" when you insist the known-by-science-to-be-broken models are in fact not broken where the science is pretty clear that they are.

People are probably taking issue with your use of the words "broken" and "wrong," because you're describing a car that says 90mph on the dealership's sticker but can't go 900mph as "broken," or a one pound lump of beef as "wrong," because although the butcher said it weighed a pound, and you were charged for a pound, it'd be nice if it were two.

Re:Scientists create matter from pure light, proving the Bre... by jerf on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @12:13PM (#28526950)
Yes, if you add relativity to Maxwell's equations, you get relativistic Maxwell's equations. Ultimately not particularly relevant here anyhow since it's QM describing what's going on here, not relativity.

I don't deal in automotive metaphors because they rarely enlighten, so I'll just stick with, yes, they are broken in those places, and are not suitable for unqualified claims about the nature of reality. This isn't about what would be nice if it were true or slight exaggerations, it's about the models being broken by being applied outside of their domain in an unqualified manner. That's exactly not how they are wrong. They are wrong in a much stronger manner.

And what's more, their strong brokenness is scientific consensus, not some sort of whacky theory. Whack theorization is what you're doing when you take these models, apply them in a domain they are known to be broken in, then claim this is the absolute truth about what is going on.

Re:Scientists create matter from pure light, proving the Bre... by ChrisLomont on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @02:00PM (#28528371)
> relativity to Maxwell's equations, you get relativistic Maxwell's equations

Maxwell's equations imply (special) relativity, so there's nothing to be added. Maxwell's equations imply the speed of light is the same in all reference frames, which is all you need to derive special relativity.

That is why people of the time were trying to understand how this can ben so, why the did things like Michaelson-Morely to look for invariance/ether, and why so many of the terms used in relativity predate relativity, since they were invented to handle that Maxwell's Equations had this invariance.

Basically, Maxwell's equations, as written were relativistically invariant, thus compatible.

Re:Scientists create matter from pure light, proving the Bre... by tsimionescu on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @03:12PM (#28529547)
Special relativity is (partially) predicted by Maxwell's equations, and they are fully compatible. They are instead incompatible with classical mechanics.

GP claimed that Maxwell's equations are missing a term for gravity/mass, which would be the domain of General Relativity. This is more complicated, as it's true that they didn't predict gravitational lensing. But, they are still compatible with GR, as GR modifies the coordinate system, and Maxwell's equation in the GR curved space-time coordinate system do predict gravitational lensing.

GP also pointed out that Maxwell's equations are not compatible at all with QM, as they incorrectly predict that photons can't interact. Here there is no way to save them - Maxwell's equations are just an approximation, and the actual laws governing the behavior of light are substantially different, only reducing to ME in certain approximations (just like classical mechanics is not compatible with either QM or SR/GR, except as an approximation of either of the two others).

Re:Scientists create matter from pure light, proving the Bre... by radicalbyte on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @12:36PM (#28527275)
> or simply straight up forgetting/confusing > that a certain model isn't reality.

That's partly to do with the way that high school science is taught. If we made the context clear at all times then people would have a better grounding.

Re:Scientists create matter from pure light, proving the Bre... by tgb on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @01:30PM (#28527974)
I find your comment confusing. What exactly is the "good example" you're referring to? The person you are replying to appears to have done exactly what you are saying to do, by my reading, so I'm wondering what you're referring to.

'The map is not the territory' is the phrasing I've heard: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Map%E2%80%93territory_relati...

Re:Scientists create matter from pure light, proving the Bre... by rootbear on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @11:55AM (#28526673)
Thank you! I was curious about exactly this. But now I have a new question. If a photon is sufficiently energetic to be capable of briefly fluctuating into an electron-positron pair, does that imply that it would, over a long distance, be slower than c, since the e-p pair can't travel at c for the brief moment it exists?
Re:Scientists create matter from pure light, proving the Bre... by jdbburg on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @02:40PM (#28529011)
The structure of the photon (here meaning the fact that it can fluctuate into an electron positron pair) is what leads to the speed of light being c and not something even larger. So your intuition is somewhat correct, except that the effect is "already taken into account" when we first learned what the speed of light was. Also, a photon can do this fluctuating even if it doesnt have a lot of energy, since the electron positron pair can be virtual - i.e. they have almost no mass and live only for an instant before annihilating back into a photon
Re:Scientists create matter from pure light, proving the Bre... by vlovich123 on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @03:10PM (#28529507)
Hmm... is the right mental model then that the photon has a speed higher than C in its photon state but on average it's C due to the fluctuation into an electron/positron pair? I would imagine that's the wrong model because there's contradictions that arise (e.g. the speed of light would vary with the energy of the photons so that those not fluctuating would have a higher speed but that's not the case AFAIK). Is this just "quantum mechanical weirdness" or do we have an "intuitive" explanation for how the speed of light and this fluctuation interplay?
Re:Scientists create matter from pure light, proving the Bre... by tsimionescu on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @03:20PM (#28529647)
I don't think this is right at all. C is a universal constant, and it is not in fact known for sure whether light travels at c or just below (whether photons have a mass). However, individual photons in certain conditions can absolutely move at speeds lower than c. If photons of different energy move at different speeds, this would be detectable by firing the photons at the same far-away mirror, and measuring how much time it takes for each photon to return (on average).
Re:Scientists create matter from pure light, proving the Bre... by shoemakersteve on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @03:26PM (#28529753)
That's really interesting. What's this effect called? I'd love to learn more about it. This topic fascinates me to no end!
Re:Scientists create matter from pure light, proving the Bre... by earthscienceman on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @10:09AM (#28525067)
Wait. I did a physics undergrad but I never asked myself this question. How is it possible that the EM fields from photos can't interact with each other? Doubly funny, I did my undergrad research for the PHENIX experiment.
Re:Scientists create matter from pure light, proving the Bre... by whatshisface on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @10:58AM (#28525852)
Phillips gave you a good answer, but another good answer is that Maxwell's equations are linear; forbidding any interaction between solutions f and g because if L is a linear operator, L[f+g] must = L[f] + L[g].
Re:Scientists create matter from pure light, proving the Bre... by jdbburg on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @02:45PM (#28529080)
This is what we are taught in high school / college as the super-position principle
Re:Scientists create matter from pure light, proving the Bre... by earthscienceman on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @11:18AM (#28526153)
Oooo. Wow. This is a great answer, thanks for explaining it that way.
Re:Scientists create matter from pure light, proving the Bre... by acchow on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @01:03PM (#28527650)
Where do they teach physics like this? Anywhere?
Re:Scientists create matter from pure light, proving the Bre... by whatshisface on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @02:25PM (#28528708)
I feel like this would be mentioned in a typical undergraduate wave mechanics course taught in a typical American university, but I have not been to enough undergraduate wave mechanics courses in enough American universities to know, really.
Re:Scientists create matter from pure light, proving the Bre... by leephillips on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @10:22AM (#28525268)
Fields are abstractions that ease the calculation of the forces on charges caused by the positions and motions of other charges. The charges interact, but the fields don’t; there is nothing “there” to interact. (This is classical EM.)

If you are in a room with two charges, the electrostatic field at any point is the addition of the fields from each charge. There is no extra interaction term.

Re:Scientists create matter from pure light, proving the Bre... by at_a_remove on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @01:33PM (#28528019)
Photons are EM fields -- self-propagating ones, like a glider in the Game of Life. The electric field changes, creating a magnetic field, but the magnetic field changes, creating an electric field. Use sines for the functions and you can see how the function just keeps re-appearing.

Now, combine that with the superposition principle ... photons pass through one another under most circumstances because of this (unlike gliders).

Re:Scientists create matter from pure light, proving the Bre... by vlovich123 on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @10:28AM (#28525362)
Stupid question I’m sure, but do our estimates for the total amount of matter in the universe account for this effect? Could this effect end up being the source of dark matter? Or is too infrequent to generate enough matter to explain the discrepancy?
Re:Scientists create matter from pure light, proving the Bre... by whatshisface on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @11:02AM (#28525918)
If by "this effect" you mean particles fluctuating so that every field has at least some role to play in every interaction, it also applies to empty space, which has a nonzero energy density due to its own fluctuations. In fact, empty space has an enormous energy density due to this stuff. It is so enormous that it's implausible, and that's considered to be one of the major unsolved problems in physics.

If by "this effect" you mean radiation occasionally interacting to produce particles, that actually doesn't change the amount of gravity in the universe when it happens, because energy is what gravitates and it's conserved in particle interactions.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cosmological_constant_problem

Re:Scientists create matter from pure light, proving the Bre... by jdbburg on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @10:48AM (#28525689)
Not a stupid question. However, I think that this process (whether it is included in calculations or not) shouldn't contribute to the dark matter issue. Electrons and positrons are "normal" matter and if they are anywhere near e.g. a star, they will contribute to the plasma around the star and therefore be visible. Also, even if it were not visible, my intuition is that the process is too rare to produce enough mass to account for the dark matter
Re:Scientists create matter from pure light, proving the Bre... by simonh on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @11:54AM (#28526658)
Best estimates are that photons only make up about 0.005% of the energy density of the universe. There's just not enough of them.
Re:Scientists create matter from pure light, proving the Bre... by bbarnett on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @12:30PM (#28527194)
Don't feel sad. If you look at a set of all ever existing humans, the number that ever interact is incredibly small.

Even if in the same vicinity, and time, eg same apartment building, subway, street, driving down the road, there is often zero interaction.

Really, humans interact very rarely too. Yet, humans do interact, in meaningful ways. Thus, it is likely the same for photons.

This theory also explains why, with the rarity of human interaction, I am unmarried. In fact, it probably explains it on multiple levels.

Re:Scientists create matter from pure light, proving the Bre... by alde on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @09:32AM (#28524513)
Photon - photon scattering in vacuum is a known process, they can interact through virtual particles. The problem is that the probability of such an event is very low and requires very high photon energies.
Re:Scientists create matter from pure light, proving the Bre... by aero-glide2 on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @09:51AM (#28524782)
"From the photon perspective there is no passage of time" What exactly happens when light travels through denser medium? Speed is less than c, so does that mean it experiences time?
Re:Scientists create matter from pure light, proving the Bre... by whatshisface on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @11:08AM (#28526002)
There are two pictures that you could take of the situation. Classically, where the medium is smooth continuous stuff with a permeability and a permittivity, there are no photons, only waves. Quantum mechanically, where the medium is made up of lots of little particles, there are photons indeed, but no smooth medium, and no region where the speed is less than C (because there is no "region," only lots of separate particles). So there's one picture missing "photons," and the other missing "speed less than c," so you can't capture "photons in a region where the speed is less than c," in a single image.

I guess if you wanted to pose that question in a framework where a medium where the speed was less than c, and photons, could exist simultaneously, you would want an effective field theory (maybe). But you will have to get someone else who knows more than me to explain that. :-)

Re:Scientists create matter from pure light, proving the Bre... by eptcyka on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @10:03AM (#28524970)
It bounces around, thus not travelling in a straight line, thus covering more distance whilst still moving at c.
Re:Scientists create matter from pure light, proving the Bre... by jcims on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @10:29AM (#28525376)
My understanding, which could be wrong, is that it doesn't 'bounce around' as much as it is absorbed and re-emitted. This process isn't instantaneous and accounts for the net propagation delay through the medium.
Re:Scientists create matter from pure light, proving the Bre... by wruza on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @04:29PM (#28530640)
Both ideas are incorrect. Bouncing around would be random and the outgoing light would be scattered (as in matte reflections) in all directions. Absorbtion simply destroys the original light. If photons are mostly absorbed, we call that “a wall” or ”a fog”, not “a transparent medium”, which to be transparent shouldn’t have electrons whose energy level differences correspond to a photon’s wave length. The transparency and slowdown effect is a complex interaction between fields in the medium, which I honestly don’t have enough courage to retell.

https://youtube.com/watch?v=CiHN0ZWE5bk

Re:Scientists create matter from pure light, proving the Bre... by monocasa on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @04:05PM (#28530317)
Sort of. Refraction it better looked at from a wave perspective than a particle one, IMO. The wavefront expands at the speed of light, but the wave bounces off of the medium it's traveling through and self interacts in a way that means that the highest probability area moves slower than C despite the edge of the wavefront still moving at C. That smearing is also why the wavelength changes upon refraction. (And obviously leaving concepts like time dilation off the table for simplicity's sake).
Re:Scientists create matter from pure light, proving the Bre... by cygx on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @10:58AM (#28525860)
That would imply light getting scattered willy-nilly as it crosses any medium, which it isn't in case of transparent media...
Re:Scientists create matter from pure light, proving the Bre... by monocasa on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @04:00PM (#28530248)
There's no perfectly transparent media other than pure vacuum.
Re:Scientists create matter from pure light, proving the Bre... by aaaaaaaaaaab on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @10:02AM (#28524954)
Re:Scientists create matter from pure light, proving the Bre... by gumby on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @10:43AM (#28525592)
> Speed is less than c, so does that mean it experiences time?

There is no absolute clock in the world; we can only know about what happened where and when by looking.

A way to understand this (and special relativity) is from an information-theoretic perspective, and to think of c as the “Mach number” of free space, nothing more and nothing less.

So imagine that you couldn’t see but could only know about what happened where and when by hearing. All those phenomena (foreshortening, frequency shift, apparent time dilation) would be exhibited though the speed of information travel would be much lower. You have probably experienced the equivalent of blue shift/red shift yourself by listening to a high speed vehicle.

Change the medium from ordinary air to something with a different density and all these phenomena will be detectable, even though the speed of sound will be different.

Re:Scientists create matter from pure light, proving the Bre... by im3w1l on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @09:30AM (#28524494)
Rest mass is conserved. So the "system" of the photons has to have sufficient rest mass to support the particle production. Rest mass depends on the energy of the individual photons, and the angle they are colliding with (head on is best, nearly parallell photons grazing is worst).
Re:Scientists create matter from pure light, proving the Bre... by hpcjoe on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @09:52AM (#28524789)
Photons are not generally thought to have a rest mass, unless something has changed in the last 25 years or so. The conversion of energy into 2x electron masses (positron + electron). So the photon pair needs at least 2 x 911 MeV of energy. This would be around 1.82 GeV of photon energy. To give a sense of the frequency of this, a 911 MeV photon (colliding with another of the same energy) would have a frequency of 911 x 10^6 ev/(4.14 x 10^-15 ev/Hz) or 2.2 x 10^23 Hz, with a wavelength of 1.4 x 10^-15 m. That is, very hard gamma.

But the photons really shouldn't have rest mass.

Re:Scientists create matter from pure light, proving the Bre... by im3w1l on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @10:09AM (#28525065)
If you have two photons, then neither of them will have rest mass. But the system of both of them does. This happens because |p_system| < |p_1| + |p_2|.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy–momentum_relation

Re:Scientists create matter from pure light, proving the Bre... by hpcjoe on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @11:07AM (#28525981)
I'd suggest looking at the Invariant mass page. What you are talking about isn't rest mass of a photon, rather the center of mass invariant mass[1]. This arises from the equivalence principle, the relation between mass and energy, not because a photon (a massless particle) has a rest mass (it doesn't).

It might be a pedantic argument on my part, but still, it is worth being clear on this point.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Invariant_mass#Collider_experi...

Re:Scientists create matter from pure light, proving the Bre... by im3w1l on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @12:09PM (#28526880)
(Center of mass) invariant mass is synonymous with rest mass.
Re:Scientists create matter from pure light, proving the Bre... by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @12:51PM (#28527478)
Is it? It sounds like you are explicitly disagreeing with hpcjoe's position, but just a bare "no, I'm right" isn't informative. Can you give some reason or argument that supports your position over hpcjoe's?
Re:Scientists create matter from pure light, proving the Bre... by im3w1l on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @02:29PM (#28528787)
> In physics, the energy–momentum relation, or relativistic dispersion relation, is the relativistic equation relating total energy (which is also called relativistic energy) to invariant mass (which is also called rest mass) and momentum. It is the extension of mass–energy equivalence for bodies or systems with non-zero momentum

Those are the first few sentences in the article I already posted.

> The invariant mass, rest mass, intrinsic mass, proper mass, or in the case of bound systems simply mass, is the portion of the total mass of an object or system of objects that is independent of the overall motion of the system. More precisely, it is a characteristic of the system's total energy and momentum that is the same in all frames of reference related by Lorentz transformations.[1] If a center-of-momentum frame exists for the system, then the invariant mass of a system is equal to its total mass in that "rest frame".

Those are the first few sentences in the article he already posted.

Re:Scientists create matter from pure light, proving the Bre... by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @03:09PM (#28529490)
In the last sentence of the article he posted, it's unclear to me how that applies to a system with two photons in it. If I have two photons heading off in opposite directions, I'm in the center-of-momentum frame for that system. Then the invariant mass is equal to the system's "total mass" in that frame. For two photons, is that 0, or E/mc^2?

I know what your position is. I'm just not sure that the quote from his article supports your position.

I will grant you that if you take the energy-momentum equation and apply it to such a system as a whole, and plug in the total energy (non-zero) and the total momentum (zero), then out comes a non-zero mass. I just am unclear on whether that's a valid thing to do. (I also don't know that it's not valid.) Can you make a convincing case that it's reasonable to apply that equation in that way?

Re:Scientists create matter from pure light, proving the Bre... by im3w1l on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @04:17PM (#28530479)
Well there are a couple of things to address here. The first is that the invariant mass is invariant - it's the same in any reference frame. So the invariant mass of a system will either equal the sum of the masses of the particles or it won't, irrespective of frame. And equality will only hold if there is no internal movement.

> Can you make a convincing case that it's reasonable to apply that equation in that way?

Even hpcjoe did not object to that, only to the name "rest mass" for the result. We saw that the number you get out was useful upthread, because it allowed predicting if pair production can occur or not.

Re:Scientists create matter from pure light, proving the Bre... by jfengel on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @11:10AM (#28526031)
Rest mass is not conserved. Total energy is conserved, which includes both rest mass and momentum (E^2=m^2+p^2). Photons have momentum but no rest mass; ordinary matter has rest mass but (usually) little momentum.
Re:Scientists create matter from pure light, proving the Bre... by api on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @07:50PM (#28533164)
Fun question: if photons do not experience time as they travel at the speed of light, do we know that photons are stable? Maybe they would decay if they were subject to time. Or maybe the concept is meaningless as they are massless.