News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Adam Smith and Inequality (2014) by gunfighthacksaw on Sunday September 12, 2021 @07:54PM (#28506311)
One of my favourite passages from Adam Smith, I believe it was from the Wealth of Nations, though I don’t remember the chapter. When I was underemployed I took the time to read it (skimming the obsolete chapters on colonial administration: the American revolution is referenced as an ongoing disturbance)

>“We rarely hear, it has been said, of the combinations of masters, though frequently of those of workmen. But whoever imagines, upon this account, that masters rarely combine, is as ignorant of the world as of the subject. Masters are always and everywhere in a sort of tacit, but constant and uniform, combination, not to raise the wages of labour above their actual rate…Masters, too, sometimes enter into particular combinations to sink the wages of labour even below this rate. These are always conducted with the utmost silence and secrecy till the moment of execution; and when the workmen yield, as they sometimes do without resistance, though severely felt by them, they are never heard of by other people…” [In contrast, when workers combine,] “…the masters..never cease to call aloud for the assistance of the civil magistrate, and the rigorous execution of those laws which have been enacted with so much severity against the combination of servants, labourers, and journeymen.”

Re:Adam Smith and Inequality (2014) by BuyMyBitcoins on Sunday September 12, 2021 @08:05PM (#28506394)
I’m not well versed in Smith’s writings and I’m not good at parsing older English. What are your key takeaways or epiphanies from what was quoted?
Re:Adam Smith and Inequality (2014) by heavyset_go on Sunday September 12, 2021 @08:21PM (#28506493)
The ownership class are able to organize and conspire with one another to pool and promote their own mutual interests, and no one notices or bats an eye. When workers try to organize in order to promote their mutual interests, the ownership class uses the power of the state to crush them. They enact laws that make such organization illegal and then enforce the laws harshly and without mercy.
Re:Adam Smith and Inequality (2014) by gunfighthacksaw on Sunday September 12, 2021 @08:37PM (#28506601)
A perfect summary.

It was written 100 years earlier than the Haymarket affair (1886) and 200 years before Thatcherism and the Miner’s strike (1979, 1984).

Re:Adam Smith and Inequality (2014) by CryptoPunk on Monday September 13, 2021 @05:32AM (#28509350)
The UK coal industry was destroyed by the labor movement, so I don't see how you imagine the coal company shareholders won that. Had contract liberty not been destroyed by the UK socialist/labor movement in the decades prior, the coal companies could have fired the strikers, and survived. That would have been better overall for UK workers.

The disappearance of UK Coal, and much of the UK manufacturing sector, played no small part in the stagnation of UK wage growth since the 1970s.

When Adam Smith's maxim, that contract freedom not be infringed upon by government, was in force, in the late 1800s, unions could not single-handedly bankrupt industries, and wages, alongside industry, grew at their fastest rate in both US and UK history.

Re:Adam Smith and Inequality (2014) by CryptoPunk on Monday September 13, 2021 @05:10AM (#28509246)
When workers organize, to lock down the market with the assistance of government intervention, they create exactly the same kind of corruption.

For example, thanks to the dominance of public sector unions, New York now has nearly 300,000 unionized public sector employees receiving over $100,000 a year:

https://www.forbes.com/sites/adamandrzejewski/2020/05/26/why...

NYS public school teachers with 35 years of experience receive a pension of $87,945 per year on average:

https://www.nydailynews.com/news/politics/pensions-retired-n...

When you amortize the average amount paid out in total in pension, over the work years, and add that to the other components of their annual compensation, this puts NYS public school teachers in the top 10% of income earners in the US.

It's also incredibly hard to fire New York state public school teachers:

https://www.the74million.org/article/investigation-nyc-tried...

Why this is so important was explained by Smith:

The real and effectual discipline which is exercised over a workman is that of his customers. It is the fear of losing their employment which restrains his frauds and corrects his negligence.

Without fear of dismissal, fraud and negligence multiplies, and thus we see growing inefficiency in the public sector, even as public sector unions direct an increasingly large share of economic output to their members:

https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/social-spending-oecd-long...

Re:Adam Smith and Inequality (2014) by CodeShmode on Monday September 13, 2021 @05:40AM (#28509394)
I'm not sure the points you've raised demonstrate that there are many New York teachers that should be fired that have not been. The link from the74million.com focuses more on teachers that were successfully let go.

New York city is also one of the most expensive states to live in so any financial comparison would need to be relative to cost of living.

Which is besides the point that perhaps teachers should be remunerated well.

Re:Adam Smith and Inequality (2014) by CryptoPunk on Monday September 13, 2021 @05:50AM (#28509448)
>>I'm not sure the points you've raised demonstrate that there are many New York teachers that should be fired that have not been.

Only 75 public school teachers were fired in all of New York between 2015 and 2016, over a span of 16 months in total, coming to a rate of 56 teachers fired per year, for a work force of ~75,000 teachers. Now unless only super humans apply for teaching positions in New York, that points to an extreme lack of accountability for New York teachers.

In the real world, many people get hired for jobs they are not well suited for, or are not prepared to commit themselves to enough to do the job competently, and shortly thereafter, are let go.

>>New York city is also one of the most expensive states to live in so any financial comparison would need to be relative to cost of living.

Median income in New York is $67,000, and that's dragged up by the very high median income of the large bloc of public sector workers. So the public sector workers are the elite, even in relation to other New York residents. What's troubling is that the entire media is unionized too, so they share a common interest with the public sector unions in perpetrating the ideological narratives that keep unions in power.

Re:Adam Smith and Inequality (2014) by harimau777 on Monday September 13, 2021 @07:25AM (#28510089)
New York City is dramatically different than New York as a whole. I'm not an expert in economics, but I imagine that would distort things.
Re:Adam Smith and Inequality (2014) by CryptoPunk on Monday September 13, 2021 @08:52AM (#28510872)
With respect to the median income, I was referring to New York City, not New York the state.

Median household income is ~$64,000 in New York City:

https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/fact/table/newyorkcitynewy...

Re:Adam Smith and Inequality (2014) by tooltower on Sunday September 12, 2021 @08:15PM (#28506452)
It means the system is asymmetric. The "masters" can collude to reduce wages, can ask for government assistance to weaken worker unions. But workers don't seem to have the same rights.
Re:Adam Smith and Inequality (2014) by AnthonyMouse on Sunday September 12, 2021 @09:07PM (#28506767)
The fundamental problem with labor unions is that they're stuck on negotiating with capital as an employer when the real threat is capital's corruption of the political system.

Consider where the wages of labor go. The major expenses are housing, taxes, transportation and healthcare.

Housing is artificially scarce. Zoning prevents new construction in areas with high demand, benefiting capital (i.e. landlords) who get higher rents. People who can't afford the higher rents have to live further from the city, increasing their transportation expenses (more money for Big Oil). Workers pay taxes but instead of going to some kind of UBI or anything else that would benefit workers, or just letting workers keep more of their money, most of it goes to things like the F-35 and buying the votes of retirees in the important swing state of Florida by enacting benefits which are really handouts to Big Pharma. And healthcare regulations are passed to make healthcare more expensive, i.e. more profitable, because of regulatory capture.

There's nothing in there that a labor union can solve by negotiating employee compensation with Walmart or Amazon. Because the problem is artificial scarcity, corruption and waste. At scale, if you negotiated everyone a raise, prices would just go up. Because everyone is still bidding on artificially scarce housing and paying for wasteful government programs and suffering the effects of regulatory capture.

But even when unions do try to lobby for something, it's typically just things to increase their own institutional power (e.g. trying to get Uber drivers into a union which is once again only negotiating employee compensation) instead of doing anything about the real problems that are sucking workers dry.

Re:Adam Smith and Inequality (2014) by dragonwriter on Sunday September 12, 2021 @11:13PM (#28507499)
> The fundamental problem with labor unions is that they're stuck on negotiating with capital as an employer when the real threat is capital's corruption of the political system

While in the US there has been much work by capital to undermine union political effectiveness to achieve that, it is not true, even in the US, that unions are stuck on negotiating with capital as an employer without engaging with capital’s political influence.

Re:Adam Smith and Inequality (2014) by rland on Monday September 13, 2021 @02:13PM (#28514754)
The cost of living stuff is a different issue.

If you’re operating a factory, you want housing, healthcare, etc to be cheap, so that you don’t have to pay your workers as much. If you’re a tiny group of people coming up with new ways to financialize housing, healthcare, etc. you want exactly the opposite.

I think of this division as something like “Industrial” vs “Financial” capital. Part of the reason the old labor movement isn’t relevant any more is that we don’t actually make stuff any more. “Industrial” capital is not at the seat of power any more.

The real problem with today’s unions is that the counterparty has changed. The people who are making houses expensive aren’t at the table negotiating with the unions; they have no employees! Unions are fighting the shrinking ghost of “Industrial” capital.

The reason for this shift is geographic. The stuff that actually gets made is made (under a yoke of hellish cruelty) at the periphery. There, housing is cheap! But the profits flow back here unevenly, to a tiny group of holders. And hence we are dominated by financial capital.

This is also the origin of the red/blue divide, roughly speaking: One is the local “Industrial” concentration and one is global “Financial” concentration. The third bloc, labor, were only really relevant when labor actually had a relationship (with the leverage inherent to that) with the dominant form capital. Now the two groups have predictably been crushed: the local concentration of capital and the union. They’re both sitting at the wrong table.

Re:Adam Smith and Inequality (2014) by mulvya on Monday September 13, 2021 @01:52AM (#28508220)
> capital's corruption of the political system

Capital is a measure of power. Capital's "corruption of the political system" is use of that power. I'm not sure it's coherent to conceive a world where Capital retains its power but not use it to shape the people and instruments that manage society.

Re:Adam Smith and Inequality (2014) by raxxorrax on Monday September 13, 2021 @10:28AM (#28511948)
Money in politics isn't a homogeneous threat in every country, so its power can very well be contained. So its power isn't an inevitability at all.
Re:Adam Smith and Inequality (2014) by grapist420 on Sunday September 12, 2021 @08:49PM (#28506675)
Employers collude to lower the wages they pay to employees. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-Tech_Employee_Antitrust...
Re:Adam Smith and Inequality (2014) by howaboutnope on Sunday September 12, 2021 @11:26PM (#28507581)
> People of the same trade seldom meet together, even for merriment and diversion, but the conversation ends in a conspiracy against the public, or in some contrivance to raise prices.

-- Adam Smith

Re:Adam Smith and Inequality (2014) by thow-58d4e8b on Monday September 13, 2021 @02:21AM (#28508357)
> Wherever there is great property there is great inequality. For one very rich man there must be at least five hundred poor, and the affluence of the few supposes the indigence of the many [...] Civil government, so far as it is instituted for the security of property, is in reality instituted for the defense of the rich against the poor, or of those who have some property against those who have none at all

-- Adam Smith

Re:Adam Smith and Inequality (2014) by nickik on Monday September 13, 2021 @09:52AM (#28511499)
The whole point of his book is that if there are proper functioning markets is that these conversations are not actually effective. Compared to a system of mercantilism that he was opposing.
Re:Adam Smith and Inequality (2014) by int_19h on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @06:17AM (#28537343)
Sure, but "proper functioning markets" in this case means competitive markets, not laissez-faire as such, as modern libertarians like to imagine. That's kind of the problem of taking the words of someone writing at the time when governments were granting monopolies, and trying to apply them to the time when governments are busting them.
Re:Adam Smith and Inequality (2014) by nickik on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @06:49AM (#28537510)
You vastly underestimate 'modern libertarians' probably because your exposure to them is based on angry twitter or whatever.

In reality during the last 200 years classical liberal tradition has thought more about markets and how they work then anybody else. Constitutional economics, institutional economics, law&economics, market process theory are partly built on Smith work and are explorations of the context of markets.

So I don't really know what you are referencing with 'Sure, but "proper functioning markets" in this case means competitive markets, not laissez-faire as such' as I don't know what definitions you for these words.

People like FA Hayek, Armen Alchian, Ronald Coase and many others have done a lot of work and all look back and build on Adam Smith. The idea of some people in this thread that modern libertarians only read the understand Adam Smith as 'invisible hand' is nonsense. 'Invisible hand' was adopted because it is a good shorthand for the idea of processes that are not centrally guided are very important.

There was also a lot of historical work done on English Common law and its evolution and how modern market relations evolved and actually functioned.

Re:Adam Smith and Inequality (2014) by int_19h on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @02:44PM (#28542756)
My exposure to them is based on having been one. And I know for a fact that most of them believe that whatever a laissez-faire - defined as completely unregulated - market produces, is inherently optimal. Some will argue that it will not have monopolies; but many will argue that when it does, that's because a monopoly is more efficient, and so it's a good thing overall.
Re:Adam Smith and Inequality (2014) by jollybean on Sunday September 12, 2021 @08:16PM (#28506457)
Collusion among capital and leverage using state lobbying power etc..

Don't skip the chapters ... just as Adam Smith is misunderstood, so is the American Revolution by those who have never bothered to examine it from the outside looking in.

Re:Adam Smith and Inequality (2014) by bejelentkezni on Sunday September 12, 2021 @08:24PM (#28506519)
Masters [capitalists/bosses] conspire together with each other. Whoever denies this is naive. They conspire together in lots of ways, but especially to keep wages down. They keep things quiet until they act on lowering the wages or whatever they're doing, and [somehow] do so in such a way that keeps the workers from communicating with each other about it. In contrast, when workers conspire [unionize] the masters will loudly beg for help from the state to keep the workers from achieving anything.
Re:Adam Smith and Inequality (2014) by UncleMeat on Sunday September 12, 2021 @08:15PM (#28506451)
Capitalists will coordinate to pay labor less. When labor is diffuse, this goes unnoticed and unchallenged. When labor organizes, they can fight it.

It calls for unionization.

Re:Adam Smith and Inequality (2014) by guerrilla on Sunday September 12, 2021 @10:43PM (#28507331)
I don't read it as calling for unionization, but half-way through the section titled "Inequalities occasioned by the Policy of Europe," I think he argues that trade unions are inevitable.

> People of the same trade seldom meet together, even for merriment and diversion, but the conversation ends in a conspiracy against the public, or in some contrivance to raise prices. It is impossible, indeed, to prevent such meetings, by any law which either could be executed, or would be consistent with liberty and justice. But though the law cannot hinder people of the same trade from sometimes assembling together, it ought to do nothing to facilitate such assemblies, much less to render them necessary.

Search the text[1] for this and you'll see it goes on a bit more and is preceded by some historical context.

1. https://www.gutenberg.org/files/3300/3300-0.txt

Re:Adam Smith and Inequality (2014) by SAI_Peregrinus on Sunday September 12, 2021 @10:58PM (#28507411)
That's from Wealth of Nations, Book I, Chapter VIII, pg.80.