News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Leaded gas was a known poison the day it was invented (2016) by cwp on Sunday September 12, 2021 @05:45PM (#28505304)
Yeah, the analogy between toxic media and toxic chemicals is pretty good. However, I'd put they blame for that somewhere you might find surprising: influencers.

Everybody likes to hate on "big tech" these days, but if there's anyone that knows the dangers and all the ill effects but ignores them to make a profit, it's content creators. They are hyper-attuned to the way people respond to their content, and they'll do anything to get a reaction, the more intense the better. And if that means siccing a mob on somebody, so be it. If it means doing stunts that endanger people in the real world, fine. And polarization is the best technique they've stumbled onto yet: say stuff that enrages people to get them to engage with the post, and then pick up followers among those that watch the rage with glee.

Just about every successful influencer has done a post about how hard it is to be internet-famous. It's almost always about how the negative effects of their work get reflected back at them. They know how the things they say harm people, they just want the negativity to be directed elsewhere.

There's a lot of debate about how social media companies should be regulated, how much censorship should be allowed, how much platforms should subsidize legacy media etc. But none of it will matter if we don't rein in what's considered acceptable in the creator economy.

Re:Leaded gas was a known poison the day it was invented (2016) by CharlesW on Sunday September 12, 2021 @05:52PM (#28505363)
> Everybody likes to hate on "big tech" these days, but if there's anyone that knows the dangers and all the ill effects but ignores them to make a profit, it's content creators.

This is like blaming smokers instead of Philip Morris.

Re:Leaded gas was a known poison the day it was invented (2016) by hazbot on Sunday September 12, 2021 @06:19PM (#28505589)
I think your analogy is pretty apt. However, even though I don't think you can give corporations a free ride just because 'people could choose not to use the product', this is not an absolute! 'People could choose not to use the product' does hold a lot of truth.
Re:Leaded gas was a known poison the day it was invented (2016) by ruytlm on Sunday September 12, 2021 @08:17PM (#28506464)
When social media companies are trying to make the media as addictive as possible to keep you scrolling and viewing ads, and employing psychological exploits to do so, it's not quite as simple as 'people can just choose not to use it'.

It's hardly a free choice when they're actively undermining your ability to choose freely.

Re:Leaded gas was a known poison the day it was invented (2016) by xboxnolifes on Sunday September 12, 2021 @10:07PM (#28507130)
Sounds like you agree with OP then. Content creators have the same motivation as the platform company. They want to make as many people view their content as possible, failing that they would like to make their exiting community see their content as much as possible. Exact same motivation just at a smaller scale, as they are just one part of the system.
Re:Leaded gas was a known poison the day it was invented (2016) by TedDoesntTalk on Monday September 13, 2021 @12:24AM (#28507843)
See also gambling and addictive gambling behaviors in video games, like loot boxes
Re:Leaded gas was a known poison the day it was invented (2016) by cwp on Sunday September 12, 2021 @08:23PM (#28506509)
Yup. It's blaming smokers for second-hand smoke. We need to figure out the social-media equivalent of "no smoking" signs.
Re:Leaded gas was a known poison the day it was invented (2016) by ravenstine on Monday September 13, 2021 @12:13AM (#28507790)
A circle-cross with the Twitter bird in the middle would do.
Re:Leaded gas was a known poison the day it was invented (2016) by midasuni on Monday September 13, 2021 @03:20AM (#28508705)
Pre covid there was a pub chain in london that banned use of electronic devices, presumably to get people talking instead of tweeting.

Went in with a colleague to have lunch and go over some diagrams. Got laptop out so we could see the diagrams and then got kicked out, had lunch down the road instead.

If I’m eating out on my own I’ll read a kindle. That’s not allowed. Read a dead tree is fine though. Pathetic.

Re:Leaded gas was a known poison the day it was invented (2016) by salawat on Monday September 13, 2021 @06:36AM (#28509742)
Sooo... Use a notebook or printouts?
Re:Leaded gas was a known poison the day it was invented (2016) by cascom on Monday September 13, 2021 @06:46AM (#28509820)
I think it’s a little bit more like blaming advertisers and Hollywood for promoting smoking, rather than the producer or consumer
Re:Leaded gas was a known poison the day it was invented (2016) by randomdata on Sunday September 12, 2021 @09:44PM (#28506984)
More like blaming the tobacco farmers instead of Phillip Morris, although it falls apart at the point that I’m not sure tobacco was seen as anything more than a commodity.
Re:Leaded gas was a known poison the day it was invented (2016) by cutemonster on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @05:09AM (#28522099)
Smoking hurts oneself primarily, whilst angry internet mobs hurt others
Re:Leaded gas was a known poison the day it was invented (2016) by adambard on Sunday September 12, 2021 @05:49PM (#28505345)
Sure, it's the influencers pumping the oil, but it's social media networks running the pipelines, and they're splitting the profits.

Unfortunately, toxic content is a lot harder to regulate than toxic chemicals, when one man's truth is another man's fake news.

Re:Leaded gas was a known poison the day it was invented (2016) by version_five on Sunday September 12, 2021 @06:08PM (#28505495)
This may be a "don't hate the player hate the game" type situation. Influencers or aspiring influencers are doing what they do because they are working inside a construct that's set up to reward them for it. They are not blameless, but they are not conspiring to create that damage that social media had done to society, they are in s sense being put up to it by the platforms and users (who by the way I don't think should get a free pass either - PSA: delete twitter)
Re:Leaded gas was a known poison the day it was invented (2016) by cwp on Sunday September 12, 2021 @08:40PM (#28506620)
I guess I put more of the blame on the influencers because they are the ones making editorial decisions. Sure the platforms are optimizing for engagement too, but it's all content-agnostic. The influencers choose their words carefully, and they choose harmful words because it makes them more money.
Re:Leaded gas was a known poison the day it was invented (2016) by foerbert on Sunday September 12, 2021 @09:10PM (#28506786)
I don't think it's quite fair to label it content-agnostic. I mean it sort of technically is, but practically it isn't.

By pushing 'engagement' at all costs, it's essentially inevitable that all the terrible behaviors we see from 'content creators' happen. I agree that they are far from blameless, but when your entire platform is practically globally available to anybody and you only reward unsavory behavior... you're going to get unsavory behavior.

There could be many, many people behaving ethically, and most people may never even see any of them due to the way the platforms are set up.

It's technically content-agnostic in the most technical sense, but practically it's one big system designed to incentivize and surface unethical behavior.

Re:Leaded gas was a known poison the day it was invented (2016) by robertlagrant on Monday September 13, 2021 @06:43AM (#28509805)
> and you only reward unsavory behavior... you're going to get unsavory behavior

They don't only reward that. They reward any engagement, and some content creators have raced to the bottom in terms of creating divisive content.

Re:Leaded gas was a known poison the day it was invented (2016) by CRConrad on Monday September 13, 2021 @03:07PM (#28515424)
Setting up an incentives structure for racing to the bottom is still more blameworthy than reacting to the incentives by racing to the bottom. It's a question of relative power: being in a position to even be able to set up incentives for others is inherently a position of power.
Re:Leaded gas was a known poison the day it was invented (2016) by robertlagrant on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @04:24AM (#28536630)
It's not about power. Making cars doesn't mean you're responsible for people murdering other people with those cars, even though you're in a position to supply cars and they aren't. There is no power involved - no one is being coerced into behaving badly.
Re:Leaded gas was a known poison the day it was invented (2016) by Falkon1313 on Sunday September 12, 2021 @11:40PM (#28507647)
And the reason that it makes them more money is because that is exactly what the algorithm is designed to encourage and what it pays out the most for.

If we were still in the era where feeds were just a chronological list of posts by people you're subscribed to, that might be a little different.

But the feed is manipulated by algorithms that dump any non-toxic things away into obscurity while upranking and featuring the most controversial things in order to get more engagement. That's by design.

Re:Leaded gas was a known poison the day it was invented (2016) by toofy on Sunday September 12, 2021 @10:14PM (#28507168)
Both are absolutely to blame. Both the social media companies and the content creators.

Both are choosing to ignore the damage which is a direct result of their actions and they both ignore long term damage in the name of an immediate profit return.

There no reason we have to choose one or the other when both are clearly willing to destroy.

Re:Leaded gas was a known poison the day it was invented (2016) by mguerville on Sunday September 12, 2021 @10:20PM (#28507200)
I agree, and they both refuse to change (moderate the platforms, make good faith efforts to reduce or disclose bias, etc.) because money trumps ethics.

I’m not sure what solutions exist though, I’m in favor of regulatory action but it’s often just moving the goalposts as there are always loopholes to be found.

Re:Leaded gas was a known poison the day it was invented (2016) by asdff on Monday September 13, 2021 @04:09PM (#28516169)
It's a false notion that these influencers are the ones making these editorial decisions. Imagine you are in charge of ad spend for a large corporation. You majored literally in advertising with a minor in psychology, you don't give a damn about the morality beyond whether or not you leave profit on the table. You simply aren't going to hire influencers who don't play this game how you want it to be played and take advantage of these dark patterns. As a result, the market looks how it is because people who don't play the game aren't landing jobs.
Re:Leaded gas was a known poison the day it was invented (2016) by cratermoon on Sunday September 12, 2021 @09:29PM (#28506891)
> they are the ones making editorial decisions

...

> they choose harmful words because it makes them more money

OK but who is responsible for the fact that choosing harmful words is more profitable?

Re:Leaded gas was a known poison the day it was invented (2016) by rmah on Monday September 13, 2021 @09:24AM (#28511161)
The audience of the stuff that content creators create and the platforms distribute collectively decides what is more profitable. It's a positive feedback system and ignoring any of the parts will result in a failed "solution".
Re:Leaded gas was a known poison the day it was invented (2016) by CRConrad on Monday September 13, 2021 @02:42PM (#28515090)
> Everybody likes to hate on "big tech" these days,

Yeah, because they're the Standard Oil and Aramco of this story.

> but if there's anyone that knows the dangers and all the ill effects but ignores them to make a profit, it's content creators.

That's like blaming the owners of mom-and-pop filling ("gas") stations for the ills of leaded petrol ("gas").

Re:Leaded gas was a known poison the day it was invented (2016) by asdff on Monday September 13, 2021 @04:06PM (#28516134)
Putting the blame on influencers makes no sense. Content creators play this game but they didn't create it, companies participating in the market created this environment and ultimately fund these influencers. A content creator is basically a paid actor.