News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is this proof of lab leak lies? by frereubu on Sunday September 12, 2021 @08:11AM (#28500453)
This really doesn't really feel like it tells the whole story. A central claim in the article quotes Rand Paul's exchange with Anthony Fauci, but read this quote from The Intercept:

'That video was edited by Paul’s staff so that it ends before Fauci responded to the senator’s harangue by saying, "I totally resent the lie that you are now propagating, senator, because if you look at the viruses that were used in the experiments... it is molecularly impossible... to result in SARS-CoV-2."'

https://theintercept.com/2021/07/27/covid-anthony-fauci-rand...

Re:Is this proof of lab leak lies? by JPLeRouzic on Sunday September 12, 2021 @08:28AM (#28500534)
> "it is molecularly impossible... to result in SARS-CoV-2."

That's sound ominous, but I am curious, how could it be "molecularly" impossible?

My understanding is that as there are several other Sarbecovirus (including SARS-COV-1), what could in principle ("molecularly") forbid one of them to mutate to SARS-COV-2?

Yet I am not a scientist.

Thanks!

Re:Is this proof of lab leak lies? by conistonwater on Sunday September 12, 2021 @08:39AM (#28500603)
There was an episode the TWiV podcast a few months ago where they discussed the biology-based evidence for why SARS-COV-2 wasn't made in a lab. I think it was this one: https://www.microbe.tv/twiv/twiv-762/ One nice thing about the podcast is that because they're scientists by personality they tend to focus far more on the biology of it, which I really appreciate. I listened to it at the time, but I don't remember what they said, to be perfectly honest.
Re:Is this proof of lab leak lies? by inciampati on Sunday September 12, 2021 @08:53AM (#28500695)
As a biologist (sorry for the appeal to authority, but it matches the tone of this thread), the evidence against a natural origin appears absolutely staggering.

You have a viral clade that completely descends from a single introduction event inside a major city. The virus does not undergo a period of host adaptation, but instead infects many millions over nearly a year before phenotypic changes are observed. This is simply fantastic. I know of no case where a virus jumped species without a period of adaptation to the new host. The fact that the entire clade has a root in October 2019 (and we can see this even because the first viruses sequenced differed by only one or two mutations from their common ancestor) indicates that there was not slow community spread before the initiation of the pandemic period. There is no weaker progenitor virus.

Considering as well the focus of research labs within the exact city where the pandemic arose makes any argument against the laboratory origin of the virus seem extremely weak. How does a serious and non-conflicted scientist explain all of these ultra-improbable coincidences?

Re:Is this proof of lab leak lies? by bhickey on Sunday September 12, 2021 @11:13AM (#28501880)
> The fact that the entire clade has a root in October 2019... indicates that there was not slow community spread before the initiation of the pandemic period. There is no weaker progenitor virus.

SARS-CoV-2 has an error checking polymerase and a relatively slow molecular clock. Just because observed sequences have little divergence from our first observation does not imply that we actually observed the species jump.

The preadaptation argument doesn't hold much water. SARS and MERS were deadly and high transmissible.

That said, let's suppose we did observe cases shortly after it initially infected humans. Shi's lab regularly went caving in search of coronaviruses in bats. These expeditions have previously been described as reckless. The possibility that a lab worker became accidentally infected in a cave shouldn't be counted out by anyone advancing GoF origin claims.

Re:Is this proof of lab leak lies? by inciampati on Sunday September 12, 2021 @12:45PM (#28502693)
The slow mutation rate helps us date the "spillover". But it isn't relevant to my argument. If we saw one, two, and three mutations per strain in late December, it means their common ancestor couldn't have been more than a few months prior. If we saw tens, or different clades with specific geographic distribution patterns, then we might look at those to understand where the introduction to humans was. My point is that this introduction probably happened in Wuhan itself, or there would have had to be a complex and highly improbable series of transmissions from a host animal (presumably a bat 1000km away from Wuhan) which spawned no daughter strains. And thanks to the high fidelity replication process of the virus, these strains would be exactly the same in phenotype as the one that showed up in Wuhan. Why did we miss them?

SARS-CoV-1 underwent clear adaptation in humans that was observed through sequencing. In observation, the mutation pattern over time wasn't initially driven by a stable molecular clock. There were easily-discoverable mutations which yielded phenotypic gain. The virus is high fidelity, but there is enough of it that it's exploring a wide range of possible options at every infection. For a virus close to optimum, very few of these will yield a benefit, and so we see mutations that are mostly synonymous that occur at a clock like rate. Sound familiar?

Re:Is this proof of lab leak lies? by native_samples on Sunday September 12, 2021 @12:09PM (#28502367)
The distinction between "lab workers got infected whilst physically at a lab" and "lab workers got infected whilst doing remote work intended to benefit the lab" seems quite small.
Re:Is this proof of lab leak lies? by bhickey on Sunday September 12, 2021 @12:35PM (#28502607)
There's a huge gulf between getting sick attempting to make a virus more virulent and getting sick while gathering natural samples in the field.
Re:Is this proof of lab leak lies? by inciampati on Sunday September 12, 2021 @12:55PM (#28502768)
Both involve research that was specifically intended to reduce risk of pandemics. If either is true, our response here should be to conduct this research with extreme care or even stop doing it.

If the lab origin hypothesis is not true, we should actually do more of exactly this kind of work. That's why it's important to understand and come to consensus about it. It's not just a curiosity or a chance to point the finger at countries and politics we don't like. The prescription for how we should behave is completely different depending on what we think happened.

Re:Is this proof of lab leak lies? by orwin on Sunday September 12, 2021 @09:47AM (#28501104)
I agree with you for the begining, but this part:

> The fact that the entire clade has a root in October 2019 (and we can see this even because the first viruses sequenced differed by only one or two mutations from their common ancestor) indicates that there was not slow community spread before the initiation of the pandemic period. There is no weaker progenitor virus.

is hard for me to understand.

Rural China in not rural USA. At all. I've hiked for a month in the Appalachian, another one in the Sierras, and spent two month in rural China. Rural china is as i used to imagine rural Africa.

Rural china have two particularities: young, probably younger than you imagine. You have villages with a median age of 15, with no middle-aged inhabitants. And enclaved. You have villages where you have to use a jeep (that the village do not own) to get to.

Is it possible, in you opinion, to have an early SRAS-Cov2 infecting a village, festing on the people for weeks or even months, then a parent coming back for his yearly vacations, getting infected, then going back to work in Wuhan?

I'm not a biologist, so i don't understand how viruses works, but i _know_ rural China (and rural europe, and rural USA.)

Re:Is this proof of lab leak lies? by inciampati on Sunday September 12, 2021 @12:37PM (#28502617)
This process would leave traces that we would have detected by now. If this happened, we should see viruses that sit outside the Wuhan-rooted SARS-CoV-2 clade but are otherwise the same. The rate that this happens would be low, but it would have been observed. I would expect that the epidemic required to spread from rural to urban regions would be large enough to throw off daughter strains that would have been circulating after the main outbreak was discovered. These would have been detected by the mobilization to find the origins and scope of the pandemic. Of course we can make stories about a perfect chain of transmission leading from a bat cave in southwest China to a major population center, where each step never resulted in obvious illness or community spread. I also enjoy science fiction. Some things make for nice stories but involve staggeringly improbable series of coincidences. And if the same virus (remember: thanks to it's error correcting mechanisms it doesn't change very fast) were let loose in another community, why would it not take up residence there? We would have to explain why people in Wuhan and the rest of the world were so much more susceptible to a virus that was completely wiped out along it's entire chain of transmission from probable animal host to human.
Re:Is this proof of lab leak lies? by orwin on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @07:24AM (#28523046)
>> Of course we can make stories about a perfect chain of transmission leading from a bat cave in southwest China to a major population center, where each step never resulted in obvious illness or community spread. I also enjoy science fiction.

Yes, the part "where each step never resulted in obvious illness or community spread" is where i don't understand. I think i insisted on it enough, but it bears repetition: rural china is _young_ and _enclaved_. I've seen villages with 70 children, 10 adults total. Granted, the adults are "old" (i understand they are between 40 and 60, the life expectancy is not that high). You also have phantom villages. If you ever read Lord of the Flies, you can imagine how a village get abandonned and trashed.

How it works: people get kids early, did not declare them, go to work in the city and let the kids for the remaining farmers (often village chiefs and to ones speaking Mandarin, all the other speak in local dialects) and sometime grandparent. Few of the young adults stay (women that were "shamed" into staying from what i understood, the guide was not very proud and did not expand on this). Most of them come back either once or twice a year, sometime more if they work closer, but not more than once a month. Couples sometime come back to drop a kid or two in the village before going to work again.

> And if the same virus (remember: thanks to it's error correcting mechanisms it doesn't change very fast) were let loose in another community, why would it not take up residence there?

And if he did take residence, how would we know? If a 100-person village was infected, they would be immune by now. If only one external (or even ten, most asymptomatics don't transmit the virus if i understand that well) was infected and transmitted the virus directly in Wuhan, would it be possible?

One more fact: some parts of rural china are way less connected than western Africa. I did not visit Africa yet (my next month-long hike was supposed to be in Ethiopia, stopped for obvious reasons), but the preparation are less stringent, and the path easy to plot. I guess western Africa, with less mountains/hills, would be even more connected.

You see, i agree that a chimera might have escaped, is a possibility that i find more likely (let's say 45 to 80%, depending on the day). But as long as proponents of this theory dismiss the other theories as "science fiction" _when they view rural China as rural Europe_, i will have a bad time getting onboard the theory.

I'm not skeptic of everything, but still, the 2000's outbreak of BDBV or all those novel-ebola where we never find the index case nor the origin village, why couldn't they have been lab outbreak too? There is research in the area, they have to keep Chimeras for some of the EV because else they can't keep those new versions alive long enough, i'm pretty sure there is less security (i imagine, i don't know Africa very well). Were those ebola viruses with no index case lab outbreaks too? Why didn't we talk about it ever?

Re:Is this proof of lab leak lies? by bhickey on Sunday September 12, 2021 @10:46AM (#28501618)
HIV is believed to have first infected humans in the 1920s where it traveled up the Congo before arriving in Kinshasa. From there it radiated across Africa carried by truckers. Like you say, I haven't seen evidence to rule out rural circulation before arriving in Wuhan. Granted, I don't think this is the most likely series of events, but the GoF lab leak hypothesis is lacking support.
Re:Is this proof of lab leak lies? by tim333 on Sunday September 12, 2021 @04:48PM (#28504769)
The documents that the article is based on demonstrate the lab was doing GoF experiments to infect humanized mice with chimeras based on bat coronaviruses and got a grant to do further such research starting in 2019. And lo - we get a break out of something looking like a bat based chimera that infects human cells in 2019. Bit of a coincidence there.
Re:Is this proof of lab leak lies? by belter on Sunday September 12, 2021 @10:42AM (#28501577)
Luc Montagnierd joint recipient of the 2008 Nobel Prize in Medicine for his discovery of the human immunodeficiency virus HIV has argued the virus was created in a lab.

"French Nobel prize winner: ‘Covid-19 was made in lab’"

https://www.connexionfrance.com/French-news/Disputed-French-...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luc_Montagnier

Again, just another appeal to authority, to be analyzed further. I find curious his personal Wikipedia page still characterizes the controversy has him being accused of spreading a conspiracy theory, while today, its looking as one of the most likely causes.

Re:Is this proof of lab leak lies? by bsaul on Sunday September 12, 2021 @11:29AM (#28502045)
luc montagnier has a long list of insane public claims for the past decades (things about "water memory" comes to my mind , but there are others).

He lost credit a long time ago, way before covid, so i would be really cautious about citing anything he has to say about the virus.

Re:Is this proof of lab leak lies? by belter on Sunday September 12, 2021 @11:46AM (#28502199)
After further research...I am inclined to agree with you. I just found he also claimed 5G was helping spread Covid.
Re:Is this proof of lab leak lies? by inciampati on Sunday September 12, 2021 @12:56PM (#28502778)
This phenomenon keep happening with old Nobel laureates. Linus Pauling for instance...

For any public binary question with weak information, you'll find crazy people arguing both sides.

Re:Is this proof of lab leak lies? by arbitrage on Sunday September 12, 2021 @09:11AM (#28500832)
> sorry for the appeal to authority

You don't need to apologize for your knowledge and experience. We are not engaged in a roman-style rhetoric class where the mandate is to build all arguments upon a set of rules we never agreed to.

The wikipedia list of common logical fallacies is not a guideline to rational discourse in the 21st century.

Re:Is this proof of lab leak lies? by ddxxdd on Sunday September 12, 2021 @03:51PM (#28504290)
As far as I'm concerned, apologizing for the appeal to authority signalled that he was open to being criticized and challenged by layman, rather than choosing to belittle those who disagree with him without having his knowledge and experience.

In short, he demonstrated that he wasn't an "elitist".

Re:Is this proof of lab leak lies? by ksaj on Sunday September 12, 2021 @01:31PM (#28503068)
Origin of Life is full of ultra-improbable coincidences. How do scientists in that field explain it?

"There is no weaker progenitor virus."

I've never heard a scientist dealing with any level of Complexity declare a negative fact before. Having not discovered a weaker progenitor doesn't preclude its existence. This type of statement ignores all comparisons made to the bat coronaviruses that have very much been part of the discussion.

I read some of your other replies and agree with some, and can at least see the point of a lot of them. But the grander wide-brush statements weaken those points.

Re:Is this proof of lab leak lies? by michaelmrose on Sunday September 12, 2021 @09:38AM (#28501031)
An appeal to authority is only inherently invalid insofar as the authority claimed is irrelevant authority or used to paper over weaknesses in the actual argument. Forums not entirely overrun with imaginary internet doctors and cranks can probably start with the polite presumption that you are actually a biologist and proceed with reasonable discussion from there without further ado.
Re:Is this proof of lab leak lies? by m0llusk on Sunday September 12, 2021 @08:46AM (#28500649)
The lab was working with chimeras instead of the virus in part because they were unable to consistently culture the virus. Neither nature nor humans make a viable viruses out of chimeras.
Re:Is this proof of lab leak lies? by tim333 on Sunday September 12, 2021 @04:52PM (#28504805)
One of the chimeras (in the research the article is based on) reproduced up to 10,000x better than the virus it was based on and caused the mice to lose weight through illness. Sounds viable to me.
Re:Is this proof of lab leak lies? by ddxxdd on Sunday September 12, 2021 @08:31AM (#28500553)
Whether or not NIH funding created SARS-CoV-2 is immaterial to Rand Paul's central point, which was that the NIH illegally funded gain-of-function research.
Re:Is this proof of lab leak lies? by frereubu on Sunday September 12, 2021 @11:19AM (#28501950)
Whatever the truth of the matter is, what I was getting at was the tone of the article, which seems happy with innuendo and partisan talking points. I have an open mind on whether or not it was a lab leak, but not being an epidemiologist I'm left with trying to gauge the tone as a proxy for whether to trust the author, and this article doesn't pass the smell test for me.
Re:Is this proof of lab leak lies? by tim333 on Sunday September 12, 2021 @04:52PM (#28504813)
Though it's possible Fauci may not have known.
Re:Is this proof of lab leak lies? by cryptica on Sunday September 12, 2021 @08:30AM (#28500550)
Rand Paul did not actually say that Fauci's gain of function research led to COVID19 but he didn't really need to. We cannot trust Fauci.

Doesn't it seems like too much of a coincidence that:

- Fauci has been director of NIH since 1984. [EDIT]. Director of NIAID (the branch of NIH which is in charge of infection diseases)

- Fauci initially denied NIH funding coronavirus gain of function research in Wuhan labs.

- It was discovered that NIH did in fact fund coronavirus gain of function research in Wuhan labs.

- Of all the cities in the world, Wuhan happens to be where COVID19 originated.

- Fauci was put in charge of the COVID19 response in the US (why not someone from the CDC? The CDC is the agency responsible for disease control and prevention, not the NIH... Why did Fauci end up getting this role when it's clearly outside of his normal duties and clearly a conflict of interest?)

Put together, it seems extremely far-fetched that these facts are merely coincidental. They paint a very clear narrative with means and motives; doesn't leave much to the imagination.

Re:Is this proof of lab leak lies? by nkozyra on Sunday September 12, 2021 @08:35AM (#28500574)
> Rand Paul did not actually say that Fauci's gain of function research led to COVID19 but he didn't really need to.

This is true. He strongly implied it did.

Fauci continued to deny the funding went to GoF research even in that heated exchange, so he wasn't changing his position. Paul said it did, Fauci said it didn't. What Fauci didn't say was that GoF research wasn't happening there. It undoubtedly was.

I'm assuming the coincidence with 1984 is ... the book?

Re:Is this proof of lab leak lies? by cryptica on Sunday September 12, 2021 @08:47AM (#28500657)
>> I'm assuming the coincidence with 1984 is ... the book?

Haha, nice catch; I didn't even see that one. I only mentioned that date to point out that he's been a director for several decades so the NIH didn't fund this research under a different director; it was Fauci himself in charge. I think the date 1984 is much more likely to be a coincidence; I just don't see how that date fits into the motive. I don't think people like Fauci and his friends care much about symbolism; aside from symbols and numbers displayed in their personal bank accounts and on their trading platforms.

The nail in the coffin for me is the clear motive that Fauci had in being appointed to handle the COVID19 response in the US. Combined with the fact that the US government actually funded this research and that Fauci then lied about it and later tried to fudge definitions in an effort to gaslight everyone into thinking that he did not lie when he clearly did... Rand Paul's arguments were delivered with almost Mathematical precision. Not to mention Fauci's earlier lies about masks not providing any protection against COVID19. There's a point when you just have to draw the line, enough lies, this guy is a liar and a manipulator. How many more times does he have to be caught red-handed for us to accept this?

Re:Is this proof of lab leak lies? by GavinMcG on Sunday September 12, 2021 @08:38AM (#28500598)
Fauci was not put in charge of the response in the U.S. Rather, Mike Pence was, with Deborah Birx as task force chair. And of course Robert Redfield, the CDC director, was indeed on the task force.

You're confusing who had the best communication and stage presence with who was in charge. Redfield was not a good public communicator, and Fauci was, so Fauci got more screen time.

Re:Is this proof of lab leak lies? by cryptica on Sunday September 12, 2021 @09:34AM (#28501007)
I don't understand the need to split hairs when it actually reinforces my conclusion but thanks anyway for pointing it out. Isn't it even more surprising that he would step outside of his role to throw himself into the limelight when it's not even his job? Seems like he was desperate to control the narrative.

That's the thing about Fauci; every time a point is made in his defense, it only seems to implicate him further.

Re:Is this proof of lab leak lies? by GavinMcG on Sunday September 12, 2021 @10:36AM (#28501521)
No, that's the thing about conspiracy theorists: every time a factual claim they made is demonstrably wrong, they claim it "reinforces their conclusion."
Re:Is this proof of lab leak lies? by cryptica on Sunday September 12, 2021 @11:34AM (#28502080)
I didn't deny your argument, I accepted it. I merely pointed out that your argument lead to the same conclusion as my argument except that it provided even more certainty.

On the other hand, this comment is an ad hominem attack trying to categorize me as an irrational conspiracy theorist in the hope that readers would dismiss the logic in my comments.

Re:Is this proof of lab leak lies? by GavinMcG on Sunday September 12, 2021 @11:43AM (#28502165)
Yes, that is precisely the hallmark I was pointing out: when you were right, that proved your conclusion. But when you were wrong, that provided even more certainty.

That "logic" is irrational.

Re:Is this proof of lab leak lies? by cryptica on Sunday September 12, 2021 @02:05PM (#28503362)
You just made a bad argument. You focused on a flaw in my argument to try to discredit me as an expert (which I'm not and never claimed to be, I welcome the correction) but in doing so you made my argument stronger.

I can't believe I have to spell it out TBH.

The fact is that Fauci had managed to put himself in a position to control the narrative and also the COVID19 response at a national level. Whether he did it by securing an official position or he simply jumped into the limelight on his own initiative is completely immaterial to my argument. The conclusion is the same; it is very suspicious when someone who is secretly associated with a problem wants to control the narrative around the problem once that problem becomes of public interest.

Re:Is this proof of lab leak lies? by shlant on Sunday September 12, 2021 @08:44AM (#28500639)
> "They paint a very clear narrative with means and motives"

Only with the help of motivated reasoning. Any singular focus on Fauci is a distraction mostly motivated by political biases and/or the desire to direct frustrations at a public figure. Unless you have some specific and quantifiable actions to take as a result of this "very clear narrative" then this reasoning is just adding to the noise.

Re:Is this proof of lab leak lies? by partido3619463 on Sunday September 12, 2021 @08:37AM (#28500585)
Fauci leads NIAID, focused on infectious disease research. https://www.nationalgeographic.com/history/article/cdc-fda-n...
Re:Is this proof of lab leak lies? by cryptica on Sunday September 12, 2021 @09:04AM (#28500791)
I also forgot some other critical points:

- Several top scientists stepped forward in the early days and claimed that the virus showed signs of being man-made (and they were censored and called conspiracy theorists).

- Some countries have been telling their citizens since the beginning that the virus was likely man-made (this was the official narrative in Russia since the beginning).

- Fauci initially denied the possibility that COVID19 could be man made and said that the 'lab leak theory' was a conspiracy theory.

- Later, Fauci conceded that the lab-leak hypothesis could not be dismissed. Evidence for this has been mounting and the media has done everything it can to avoid discussing this topic.

Re:Is this proof of lab leak lies? by orwin on Sunday September 12, 2021 @10:01AM (#28501220)
> Several top scientists stepped forward in the early days and claimed that the virus showed signs of being man-made

So, if you're talking about the early days: One of them was in my country, and claimed that CRISPR was used on SRAS-Cov2, probably as a biological weapon. This was the human-made theory in the early days. Two day after his delcaration, the virus sequence was available for everyone on the internet, and he deleted his tweet the day after that.

Then the narrative was about a chimera that escaped the lab (which is way more likely). People conflated the two theories

I'm sorry if people who claimed that were called conspiracy theorist, but the CRISPR theory was junky since the beginning (Since the ACE2 is not the optimal key to bind to a human host. Also you need human test subject to make this kind of experiments, i know the oversight is not the best, but this would have leaked if there was human test in Wuhan). And it was not a conspiracy theory, it was honestly just dumb as f*ck, i don't think anybody here bought it.

Now, a lab-escaped Chimera is a good theory, but since the first theory was so jank, some people thought it was just a rehash, and took it with skepticism, especially since the same network/people share this new theory. I'm still not convinced: fool me once, shame on you, fool me twice... But i won't call anyone a conspiracy theorist over this.

Re:Is this proof of lab leak lies? by dragonwriter on Sunday September 12, 2021 @08:49AM (#28500667)
> Fauci has been director of NIH since 1984.

No, Fauci has never held that position.

Fauci has been director of NIAID since 1984, which is one of the institutes of NIH.

> Fauci was put in charge of the COVID19 response in the US

No, under Trump he was a task force member, but the TF coordinator was Deborah Birx. Fauci was one of the more visible spokespeople, but not even approximately in charge.

Under Biden he also got the Chief Medical Adviser to the President title, but on COVID—while.even a more prominent spokesperson than previously—he is a member of the new task force, but Jeffrey Zients is the coordinator.

Re:Is this proof of lab leak lies? by cryptica on Sunday September 12, 2021 @09:23AM (#28500908)
>> No, Fauci has never held that position.

My bad, I was mislead there. Doesn't change the conclusion of my analysis though. If anything, it strengthens it.

So he was director of National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Disease (a branch of NIH). Coronaviruses are infectious diseases. It seems practically certain that he would have been directly involved. Of the 27 sub-agencies of the NIH, NIAID is the one which matches the category for 'coronavirus gain of function research' most closely.

The list is:

National Cancer Institute (NCI), National Eye Institute (NEI), National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute (NHLBI), National Human Genome Research Institute (NHGRI), National Institute on Aging (NIA), National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism (NIAAA), National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases (NIAID), National Institute of Arthritis and Musculoskeletal and Skin, Diseases (NIAMSD), National Institute of Biomedical Imaging and Bioengineering (NIBIB), National Institute of Child Health and Human Development (NICHD[69]), National Institute on Deafness and Other Communication Disorders (NIDOCD), National Institute of Dental and Craniofacial Research (NIDCR), National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases (NIDDKD), National Institute on Drug Abuse (NIDA), National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences (NIEHS), National Institute of General Medical Sciences (NIGMS), National Institute of Mental Health (NIMH), National Institute on Minority Health and Health Disparities (NIMHHD), National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke (NINDS), National Institute of Nursing Research (NINR), National Library of Medicine (NLM), Center for Information Technology (CIT), Center for Scientific Review (CSR), Fogarty International Center (FIC), National Center for Advancing Translational Sciences (NCATS), National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH), NIH Clinical Center (NIH CC)

Within which of the above 27 categories does a 'highly infectious disease with immune-system-evading characteristics' such as COVID19 fit into? The fact that NIAID also deals with allergies (whose treatments typically involve regulating the immune system) is too much...

What you're saying makes foul play even more likely. This virus has got Fauci's signature in it and his face is on the packaging.

Not saying he is guilty, but he should be investigated.

Re:Is this proof of lab leak lies? by dragonwriter on Sunday September 12, 2021 @10:43AM (#28501588)
You are leaving out the other errors in the basis for your initial conspiracy theory, notably your false claim that Fauci was put in charge of Coronavirus response; as noted in my earlier response, no, he wasn't, he was made a member of both Trump’s and Biden’s COVID task forcez, but neither the formal head (the VP in Trump's case, the President in Biden’s) nor the lead member once elected officials are excluded (in both cases, titled “coordinator”, Deborah Birx for Trump and Jeffrey Zients for Biden.)

You also draw your inference of foul play from the claim that Fauci’s role as “director of NIH” has some nexus to gain of function research but, unlike the CDC, nothing to do with preventing the spread of disease, making his (nonexistent) appointment as head of COVID response suspicious. When informed that he was not head of NIH but of NIAID and never appointed as head of COVID response, you apparently double down on that, because NIAID has a closer nexus to gain of function research. But, NIAIDs nexus to gain of function research is precisely that “conducts and supports basic and applied research to better understand, treat, and ultimately prevent infectious, immunologic, and allergic diseases”.

Theret nothing suspicious about the head of NIAID being appointed to a committee planning response to an infectious disease. It would, indeed, be suspicious if the head of NIAID was excluded from such a committee.