Re:Apple's hold on metal chassis supply chain hinders compet...
by gallerytungsten on Thursday August 04, 2011 @09:01PM
(#2848522)
First of all, the proper term for the tool in question is a CNC mill, or "CNC machining center" as it's sometimes termed by the manufacturers of such machines. A solid block of material enters, and the finished product emerges.
Inside the CNC mill, a variety of rapidly spinning milling cutters (think of an intelligent Dremel tool) cut out the part. The work piece is stationary (for the most part) and the tool head moves. A typical CNC machining center will have an automatic tool changer so that it can cut with a variety of different milling cutters (bits) as it performs various cutting operations.
In contrast, a lathe (manual or CNC) rotates the work piece (typically a cylindrical piece of metal, or bar stock, such as square or hex stock) and a non-rotating cutting tool trims excess material.
Now with that out of the way, the story is a bit suspect. What's to prevent the competition from buying their own factory with 10,000 CNC machining centers? Or bankrolling their preferred vendor to do so?
Re:Apple's hold on metal chassis supply chain hinders compet...
by hannibalhorn on Thursday August 04, 2011 @09:12PM
(#2848556)
I remembered this from "The Man Who Makes Your iPhone":
When Apple's iPhone4 was nearing production, Foxconn and Apple discovered that the metal frame was so specialized that it could be made only by an expensive, low-volume machine usually reserved for prototypes. Apple's designers wouldn't budge on their specs, so Gou ordered more than 1,000 of the $20,000 machines from Tokyo-based Fanuc. Most companies have just one.
Could very well be that the machines are exactly these, designed only for prototyping and not exactly something you can easily get ahold of in a large quantity for mass manufacturing.
Re:Apple's hold on metal chassis supply chain hinders compet...
by delackner on Thursday August 04, 2011 @10:25PM
(#2848723)
Thank you for digging up that quote. I was thinking after reading all the preceding comments that I'd have to go dig it up myself. Apple is on record as pouring billions of dollars into pre-paying for their suppliers to purchase incredibly expensive machines to produce apple products, so obviously apple ends up with priority access to the output: they made it possible!
Re:Apple's hold on metal chassis supply chain hinders compet...
by zdw on Thursday August 04, 2011 @08:42PM
(#2848465)
I wonder how many of those metal lathes were originally bankrolled by Apple's billions, as a part of their organization plan to help suppliers build capacity.
Re:Apple's hold on metal chassis supply chain hinders compet...
by econgeeker on Thursday August 04, 2011 @08:58PM
(#2848511)
Well, I am suspicious about an article that talks about lathes with regard to making Macbook parts. A Lathe is a machine on which parts are spun at great speed. It is good for making things like the legs of tables, etc.
Apple's unibody technology uses CNC machines which are more appropriately called mills. They are not that uncommon, and are widely available to everybody... and have been for years. Maybe Apple uses machines from a particular segment of the market that has dried up supply, but it is rare that a company has too much demand for a product and isn't interested in building more.
EG: There's no evidence Apple has cornered the market on CNC machines, which can come from a wide variety of companies.
However, companies like Foxconn, do invest billions in buying large quantities of such tools and then dedicate them to manufacturing apple products, because Apple's specifications require them to do so. (This from an article I read interviewing Foxcon's founder.) The Band on the iPhone 4 required 1,000 custom metal machines, for instance. No doubt many of those billions invested in those machines come from Apple.
Re:Apple's hold on metal chassis supply chain hinders compet...
by smarmius on Thursday August 04, 2011 @08:48PM
(#2848482)
Unless I'm misreading something, this has prompted the competition to work with a different material (some kind of fiberglass). So even though the competition can't use the same material they have an alternative that is cheaper and readily available. I don't see the problem.
Re:Apple's hold on metal chassis supply chain hinders compet...
by econgeeker on Thursday August 04, 2011 @09:04PM
(#2848530)
As a mental exercise, consider the thought process behind the perspective that this is "anti-competitive".
1. Apple has taken a technology- metal milling- that has existed for at least half a century, and used it to make a nicer laptop case.
2. Apple uses the modern manufacturing method to do this, requiring expensive CNC machines.
3. Apple introduced popular products that, when you open them, look like they were hand crafted by master metalworkers in the 1940s (I'm serious!) while their competition is still shipping cheap plastic cases.
4. Even though there are dozens of suppliers of CNC Mills of all type, Apple's requirements contain the market for a particular type (this is speculation on my, and the articles part.)
5. Therefore, this is "anti-competitive" because Apple's competition can't just copy the unibody case idea and order machines and make their own unibody cases?
6. So, what could possibly be the remedy? To fine Apple for being successful with an innovative new case design? To institute some government board of allocation to allocate the (currently, and only temporarily) limited supply of CNC machines?
If Apple hadn't been competitive-- that is, if Apple hadn't innovated and come up with a new case design-- there would be no demand for these machines from non-Apple people. So, this is a result of competition on Apple's part.
Sometimes I imagine that people think that if Apple is successful by doing something better, that this is "unfair" and that Apple should be punished.
Hell, I wish I could make a crapy video editor and then force Apple to give me some of their final cut profits, because, really, it is so unfair that apple makes such a good video editor, I'm just one guy and I can't hope to compete with that, right? (Just kidding, forcing Apple to do that is aggression, and is immoral. I'm just being illustrative. While I've thought about making a video editing app, I've not done that, actually.)
Re:Apple's hold on metal chassis supply chain hinders compet...
by cal5k on Thursday August 04, 2011 @10:33PM
(#2848737)
I don't think the article is suggesting that this activity is anticompetitive... I think, rather, it's being held up as an example of the genius of Tim Cook and Apple's lesser-appreciated operational excellence.
Re:Apple's hold on metal chassis supply chain hinders compet...
by psykotic on Thursday August 04, 2011 @09:32PM
(#2848598)
The name for lathe in the Scandinavian languages translates literally into English as turning-bench. It's hard to forget its purpose and meaning with a name like that.
Re:Apple's hold on metal chassis supply chain hinders compet...
by e28eta on Friday August 05, 2011 @12:46AM
(#2848986)
I don't know if this particular instance qualifies, but I was reminded of an interesting article [1] about how Apple is a monopsony (the only buyer) in some markets. Thus, they provide lots of upfront capital to pay for the machines and factories, and receive either exclusive access or discounted pricing over competitors.
Re:Apple's hold on metal chassis supply chain hinders compet...
by duck on Thursday August 04, 2011 @09:41PM
(#2848622)
As others have pointed out, it should be a milling machine, not a lathe... unless, iPen is coming out next month. I can see the writing on the wall. :)
Inside the CNC mill, a variety of rapidly spinning milling cutters (think of an intelligent Dremel tool) cut out the part. The work piece is stationary (for the most part) and the tool head moves. A typical CNC machining center will have an automatic tool changer so that it can cut with a variety of different milling cutters (bits) as it performs various cutting operations.
In contrast, a lathe (manual or CNC) rotates the work piece (typically a cylindrical piece of metal, or bar stock, such as square or hex stock) and a non-rotating cutting tool trims excess material.
Now with that out of the way, the story is a bit suspect. What's to prevent the competition from buying their own factory with 10,000 CNC machining centers? Or bankrolling their preferred vendor to do so?
They also use a laser cutter to do the speaker holes and the incredibly fine holes on the front that you only see when the light is on.
When Apple's iPhone4 was nearing production, Foxconn and Apple discovered that the metal frame was so specialized that it could be made only by an expensive, low-volume machine usually reserved for prototypes. Apple's designers wouldn't budge on their specs, so Gou ordered more than 1,000 of the $20,000 machines from Tokyo-based Fanuc. Most companies have just one.
http://www.businessweek.com/magazine/content/10_38/b41950584...
Could very well be that the machines are exactly these, designed only for prototyping and not exactly something you can easily get ahold of in a large quantity for mass manufacturing.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lathe
Apple's unibody technology uses CNC machines which are more appropriately called mills. They are not that uncommon, and are widely available to everybody... and have been for years. Maybe Apple uses machines from a particular segment of the market that has dried up supply, but it is rare that a company has too much demand for a product and isn't interested in building more.
EG: There's no evidence Apple has cornered the market on CNC machines, which can come from a wide variety of companies.
However, companies like Foxconn, do invest billions in buying large quantities of such tools and then dedicate them to manufacturing apple products, because Apple's specifications require them to do so. (This from an article I read interviewing Foxcon's founder.) The Band on the iPhone 4 required 1,000 custom metal machines, for instance. No doubt many of those billions invested in those machines come from Apple.
1. Apple has taken a technology- metal milling- that has existed for at least half a century, and used it to make a nicer laptop case.
2. Apple uses the modern manufacturing method to do this, requiring expensive CNC machines.
3. Apple introduced popular products that, when you open them, look like they were hand crafted by master metalworkers in the 1940s (I'm serious!) while their competition is still shipping cheap plastic cases.
4. Even though there are dozens of suppliers of CNC Mills of all type, Apple's requirements contain the market for a particular type (this is speculation on my, and the articles part.)
5. Therefore, this is "anti-competitive" because Apple's competition can't just copy the unibody case idea and order machines and make their own unibody cases?
6. So, what could possibly be the remedy? To fine Apple for being successful with an innovative new case design? To institute some government board of allocation to allocate the (currently, and only temporarily) limited supply of CNC machines?
If Apple hadn't been competitive-- that is, if Apple hadn't innovated and come up with a new case design-- there would be no demand for these machines from non-Apple people. So, this is a result of competition on Apple's part.
Sometimes I imagine that people think that if Apple is successful by doing something better, that this is "unfair" and that Apple should be punished.
Hell, I wish I could make a crapy video editor and then force Apple to give me some of their final cut profits, because, really, it is so unfair that apple makes such a good video editor, I'm just one guy and I can't hope to compete with that, right? (Just kidding, forcing Apple to do that is aggression, and is immoral. I'm just being illustrative. While I've thought about making a video editing app, I've not done that, actually.)
A mill makes mostly flat 3D parts like laptop chassis. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Milling_machine
A lathe makes turned (round) parts. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lathe
[1] http://tech.fortune.cnn.com/2011/07/05/how-apple-became-a-mo...