News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by rmah on Friday September 10, 2021 @09:10AM (#28481009)
When I was a youth, most public schools mandated a variety of vaccinations. If you didn't get them, you couldn't go to school. Is that no longer the case?
Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by md_ on Friday September 10, 2021 @09:18AM (#28481106)
In the US, all 50 states have some type of mandatory vaccination for public schools (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vaccination_policy_in_the_Unit...). Most, but not all, allow religious or similar exemptions; some (including California) only allow medical exemptions.

I think your point--which is spot-on--is that a lot of the outraged reactions appear to be from people who are unaware (or unwilling to acknowledge) the very long history of compulsory vaccination (and who probably had such vaccines themselves as children).

That's not to say that any mandatory medical intervention shouldn't be treated with serious consideration, but the unwillingness to acknowledge precedent is bizarre and, I suspect, to some degree dishonest.

Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by kQq9oHeAz6wLLS on Friday September 10, 2021 @10:00AM (#28481675)
This is a bit different. First, the type of vaccine is different - the COVID vaccines don't stop you from getting COVID or -- crucially -- transmitting it to others, whereas the ones that school children require to get do so.

Second, two of the three available are still under EUA, and the one that is approved is of a new type of vaccine that became approved through a very unconventional route, which has some folks cautious. Those other vaccines you mention are well-established and have been proven over time and through clinical testing to be safe and effective. COVID vaccines have proven to be only effective at reducing reactions, but not very effective at reducing spread.

Note that a typical clinical trial lasts years[0] - phase II usually takes 2-3 years and phase III takes an additional 2-4 years. We've had these vaccines for less than one year; if this was a typical vaccine, it'd be only part-way through phase II trials.

And now it's mandated by the government; get this shot, some of which are using new technology, that has had shortened clinical trials or lose your livelihood (because, at $14k per infraction, I don't see many large companies bothering to offer testing as an alternative unless it's for the CEO or other executives; it's just too much liability for an easily-replaceable lower-wage employee).

> but the unwillingness to acknowledge precedent is bizarre

That's because your precedent isn't an exact match, and has had easy alternatives and ways to opt-out.

[0] https://coronavirus.jhu.edu/vaccines/timeline

Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by md_ on Friday September 10, 2021 @11:26AM (#28482889)
Well, this also has easy alternatives: the OSHA rules allow testing as an alternative. They do not mandate vaccination.

To your other point, the vaccines do reduce transmission, as far as I can tell (e.g. https://www.gavi.org/vaccineswork/mounting-evidence-suggests...).

Now, to be perfectly serious, I do think that any efforts at compulsory--or, as in this case, incentivized, since testing remains an alternative--medical measures exist in a tension between the utilitarian and the libertarian point of view. We should certainly be cautious about mandating any medical procedure, and do our best to preserve alternatives (like testing, or mask wearing, or by limiting mandates to as narrow a scenario as necessary).

But I don't think the debate is helped by getting the facts wrong.

Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by giantg2 on Friday September 10, 2021 @09:36AM (#28481333)
It's also possible that the dissenters are aware and knowledgeable of the history of compulsory vaccines. The question in their minds might be how society determines which vaccines should fall into that mandatory category and what level of force the government and others should use to enforce it.

For example, should flu vaccines be mandatory to attend school? Historically they have not been in any large degree (to my knowledge). If you look at the IFR for those age groups for flu (varies somewhat by strain) and covid, then you'll see that they are generally very close. So we have to ask what changed, because it doesn't appear to be the value proposition.

Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by md_ on Friday September 10, 2021 @09:43AM (#28481443)
I don't see the necessary nuance for this debate to be meaningful. As a case in point: the OSHA regulations are for vaccination _or_ weekly testing.

There's probably a reasonable debate to be had about requiring people to disclose vaccination status (but, again, significant precedent)--but I do think the hysterical reactions sound a bit funny when viewed as a reaction to being forced to spit into a cup once a week.

Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by giantg2 on Friday September 10, 2021 @10:29AM (#28482047)
My comment was mostly about the parent stereotyping dissenters as being uninformed. That sort of stereotyping makes tricky topics even worse.
Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by md_ on Friday September 10, 2021 @11:21AM (#28482814)
The parent is me. :)

I think we agree that the debate is, as is, not very good. I might be making it worse by highlighting the least productive comments instead of engaging more selectively with the actually constructive ones, but, well...this is the Internet, right? :)

Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by BackBlast on Friday September 10, 2021 @10:11AM (#28481824)
Is it really accurate to call it mandatory when exemptions have been relatively trivial to acquire and use if one desires to?

People keep acting surprised that other people would say no and also object to not having a choice.

Then there's the immunocompromised people who react poorly to vaccines and programs such as this are trying to corral them into a one-size-fits-all mandatory vaccination program.

Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by logicalmonster on Friday September 10, 2021 @10:03AM (#28481717)
> I think your point--which is spot-on--is that a lot of the outraged reactions appear to be from people who are unaware (or unwilling to acknowledge) the very long history of compulsory vaccination (and who probably had such vaccines themselves as children).

I think this is a strawman argument as virtually everybody is aware of past childhood vaccine requirements and acknowledges that they existed for a long time.

What might make this Covid vaccination and decision process different from those in many peoples' eyes is that:

* Past vaccines took years of development and testing before being applied to the public and were not rushed through any approval process. Covid vaccines in contrast use a new technology, were rushed through the approval process in a political process, and in fact are still technically in clinical trials. To many people, not enough time has passed to see about any possible long-term health impacts, fertility problems, or other issues. And obviously, discussions of short-term health problems in social media are suppressed or minimized too. Personally, I would argue that trying to vaccinate all people (especially the young) for such a low individual risk is one of the most irresponsible risk-management decisions in human history.

* Dr. Fauci and other health experts have spent much of the last 18 months either lying (remember experts insisting that masks are pointless before doing a 180) or being wrong about many things. Is it a wonder that people don't trust them?

* The media is the boy who cried wolf. They spent the last 5 years hyperventilating about Orange Man to the point that anything they say now is viewed through a partisan lens. Sorry, but if public trust is frittered away on political motives, don't cry now that you're telling the truth this time.

* The medical establishment seemed desperately against even trying alternative medical treatments (HCQ, Ivermectin) due to the vaccines emergency use authorization being tied to no treatments being available. How would a normal person react to the idea that there's a possible alternative treatment from a cheap already tested drug? You'd express some hope and be willing to try it, but express doubts about the treatments due to the limited studies available that don't show good enough results. Instead, we get a pile of propaganda labeling a legitimate medical drug as only a "horse dewormer".

* The focus is not on health and safety (which should be the goal), but only vaccination. Millions of people have had Covid and have natural antibodies: why isn't Covid antibody testing a suitable substitute for vaccination? Has even one health leader recommended steps to lose weight and get some sunshine for instance despite the clear worse Covid health outcomes for fat people with Vitamin D deficiencies? Or take NYC's draconian vaccine requirements to visit a ball game as an example. You're not allowed to attend a game if you're not fully vaccinated, but you can walk from the ballpark to a vaccination clinic, get "the jab (TM)", and immediately go attend the same ballgame even though the science says you're not immune. Everything about public policy is oddly specific about urging vaccines and incredibly creepy right now.

Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by manwe150 on Sunday September 12, 2021 @11:48PM (#28507690)
> The medical establishment seemed desperately against even trying alternative medical treatments (HCQ, Ivermectin) due to the vaccines emergency use authorization being tied to no treatments being available.

No, they have always been against use of drugs that have not been shown useful. That is the job of the FDA. It seems you aren’t aware that they did approve some treatments? Didn’t really affect the vaccine development, since the two aren’t really that dependent: their goal is to promote the best option.

> Has even one health leader recommended steps to lose weight and get some sunshine for instance despite the clear worse Covid health outcomes for fat people with Vitamin D deficiencies?

Yes, they are surprising reluctant to engaging in victim-blaming. You aren’t the only person who heard these may be helpful; I think it was pretty widely popularized since the beginning that poor health is a risk factor.

Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by md_ on Friday September 10, 2021 @10:20AM (#28481920)
> why isn't Covid antibody testing a suitable substitute for vaccination?

As I noted elsewhere, in many jurisdictions it is, as is testing.

In fact, as the very article upon which you are commenting notes, under the new OSHA rules those who do not want to get vaccinated can simply take a test once a week instead!

I admit, some mornings I have a bit of dry mouth, but after my morning coffee I always have enough spit to hock a loogie into a cup. For science and the greater good.

Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by anonfornoreason on Friday September 10, 2021 @10:38AM (#28482183)
Nice “praise god” there at the end
Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by kevindong on Friday September 10, 2021 @09:16AM (#28481082)
It's still the case in most (all?) of the US. However, it's generally pretty well accepted that the documentation requirements are lax and that parents can opt out for a variety of reasons.

When I was in school (both K-12 and college), my schools just accepted a paper document (trivially forgeable) that stated what vaccines I had received and when.

Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by pandaman on Friday September 10, 2021 @10:11AM (#28481817)
When I was a youth vaccines gave immunity to their recipients, that doesn't seem to be a case now.
Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by HWR_14 on Friday September 10, 2021 @10:57AM (#28482461)
No, when you were a youth enough people were vaccinated that the RE dropped to almost nothing, meaning there were no breakouts. They never gave 100% immunity.

They were also more numerically effective at keeping people from turning into a carrier, but they had the benefits of decades of tuning.

Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by pandaman on Friday September 10, 2021 @11:11AM (#28482678)
If vaccines never gave immunity how come people who had the natural immunity from having the disease naturally were not required to be vaccinated? Actually even in my older years all I had to present as a proof of vaccination to the US government was my blood with antibodies.
Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by HWR_14 on Friday September 10, 2021 @11:34AM (#28482999)
Your blood with antibodies also doesn't supply 100% immunity.
Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by pandaman on Friday September 10, 2021 @12:42PM (#28484020)
I am not sure where did you get the 100% thing but for the record I am not claiming that. What I am noticing is that it used to be an objective criterion for the inoculation, seemingly based on the concept of immunity.
Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by HWR_14 on Friday September 10, 2021 @02:09PM (#28485150)
I got the "100% thing" when I said it in the first post, and you started responding "if vaccines don't give immunity", yada yada. In response to me saying tehy don't give 100% immunity.
Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by pandaman on Friday September 10, 2021 @02:45PM (#28485562)
You responded to my assertion that vaccines used to give immunity with "no" so I thought you are arguing that, sorry for misunderstanding.
Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by julianlam on Friday September 10, 2021 @09:15AM (#28481077)
There are many exemptions that apply. Religious exemptions are one example.
Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by astura on Friday September 10, 2021 @09:23AM (#28481173)
Some states (including big ones like California and NY and conservative ones like Mississippi and West Virginia) have no exemptions to school vaccine requirements other than medical exemptions.

https://www.ncsl.org/research/health/school-immunization-exe...

Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by khuey on Friday September 10, 2021 @09:27AM (#28481221)
California used to have more exemptions and they were used heavily by new age/hippie types (i.e. not conservatives) to skirt vaccination requirements so the laws were changed recently.
Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by BackBlast on Friday September 10, 2021 @10:16AM (#28481871)
Since the change there have been a number of doctors willing to grant medical exemptions to any who want them. [0] It isn't as much of an impediment as it appears.

[0] https://calmatters.org/health/2020/09/california-doctor-scho...

Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by frumper on Friday September 10, 2021 @11:03AM (#28482563)
The article you linked talks about a new law that invalidated those exemptions from that doctor because they were not supported by clinical guidelines.
Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by BackBlast on Friday September 10, 2021 @12:05PM (#28483493)
It's just an example. There are lots more doctors who will give exemptions just to make parents happy. There is clearly friction between parents/doctors/state over this policy.
Re:OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or... by frumper on Friday September 10, 2021 @12:26PM (#28483798)
It's an example that you provided a source that says the exact opposite of your example. In California there is a new law designed to specifically combat your example and it's been quite effective.