I happen to be looking for a dishwasher now. Mine is having problems after 8 years (it's from IKEA, probably a rebranded Whirlpool). It has a grinder, but it the upper deck is no longer getting clean because the upper spinnning thing is no longer spinning and flinging water, I think. Also the plastic bits and gasket are starting to deteriorate.
Any recs for a good dishwasher? I'm looking for something that will last 10+ years.
Bosch/Siemens dishwashers are frankly, garbage.
Dumbass metal/plastic construction (the plastic will crack and leak at the back), smartass inlet sensor that will fail, board at the bottom that will be taken out when it floods, overly sensitive drain and turbidity sensors, and the damn heater is a piece of shit.
They thought they were so smart using a flat wire heater (as found in many bottom heating kettles) but it fails very, very often and is expensive as hell even second hand if you can find one.
This basic construction hasn't changed for over a decade now, just like with most appliances.
Strange, since their washing machines are great and dryers are OK.
I personally like Beko, which many shit on - no frills, no bullshit dishwashers using easily available parts (shared with other brands), really easy to fix.
They work as well as any other brand, the water pressure is one of the most important things and theirs is always good.
Preferably the higher end models with built in fans, screen, they're better built than the cheap models.
Source: worked on thousands of them.
Energy consumption. No grinder means the whole system can be driven by the pump motor alone which uses less power. Simpler (cheaper) construction as well.
the upper spinning thing is no longer spinning
The sprayer arms aren't driven by motors, they're driven by the force of the water coming out. So that means you probably have food particles stuck in the ports where water comes out. I'd remove the arm and clean it by hand. Use a toothpick to open up the ports.
While you're at it, clean the water connection mating surface between the upper drawer and the back of the dishwasher. If there's gunk there water will squirt out and the propeller will have less water pressure.
A gopro is a great tool for checking that both propellers are spinning properly.
Another guess might be noise. Grinders are noisy and Bosch dishwashers are dead silent.
I have a Benchmark series Bosch and it cleans dishes better than any I've ever had. I think a major factor is the built-in water softener. I have hard water, and soft water is key for allowing detergents to properly work.
I'm French, in Belgium, with an Italian dishwater that doesn't have a grinder (didn't even know that this existed) and I simply don't leave anything that could have to be ground on my dishes.
I do have to clean the filter once in a while, but I just don't leave on my dishes anything that could be scrapped beforehand. I don't prewash them or do anything special, but I don't leave solid waste on my dishes either.
If the filter were very easy to reach/remove/clean/replace, I would consider the benefits of a dishwasher without a grinder.
Unless there are actual solids (=bones, remains of stickers on glasses that contain plastics) in there, the combination of heat and extreme alkality of the washing water will dissolve just about anything over time so that it passes through the filter and gets pumped out.
Secondly, the final rinse water is filled into the tub and recirculated over the same filter. It's not directly sprayed from the water supply over the dishes and into the drain.
Really surprised me because dishes get scraped and dog-licked, but there's definitely plenty of solids that go into the wash. Seems like the detergent (basic Powerball solid things) and hot water are doing what it's supposed to.
The main complaints I read about it were how slow it is. At ~2:45 for a cycle that is a while, but it doesn't really matter. If I start it after a meal it's done well before I'm getting ready for the next. Run it overnight, done by morning.
As opposed to my old dishwasher which was ~45 minutes and noisy and sounded super powerful, I think the long wash cycle is key to modern dishwashers. I believe they basically soak/flood everything over time, letting them chemicals do their job, and the less force means it's quieter. Couple that with a bunch of insulation and the result is something more efficient that works well, at the (completely acceptable) expense of time.
I'm a bit more interested in the newer Bosch models that are using a zeolite bed to dry the dishes. The catalyst generates heat and absorbs moisture at the same time, then is renegerated during the wash.
> To clean the food catcher, grab your partner's toothbrush and brush it into the rubbish bin.
I love British humor.
If you have a Bosch, I'd recommend doing it every third or fourth cycle. There's no food grinder/impeller in these machines and the fine filter gathers material way faster than what you're probably used to.
Example: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_M2b9QeiYRo&t=80s
The idea of leaving half-washed food waste in the machine and recirculated for a whole month also doesn't appeal to me. But perhaps that's just me.