News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Chia Coin Miners Are Reselling Used SSDs as New by rsync on Monday September 06, 2021 @04:03PM (#28437439)
This is very relevant to our interests - specifically the part where prices of spinning disks more than doubled for a time earlier this year.

As we dove into the chia coin rabbit hole to figure out just what was going on, it came to our attention that people are using firmware tools to reset SMART counters on drives … rolling back the odometer, so to speak.

Just terrible behavior all around.

Re:Chia Coin Miners Are Reselling Used SSDs as New by ksec on Monday September 06, 2021 @06:30PM (#28438847)
HDD price hasn't been lowered for quite some time due to technological bottleneck. Even with OptiNAND only give us the same density as SMR. And EAMR are no where to be seen or tested by consumers.

And now this.

Re:Chia Coin Miners Are Reselling Used SSDs as New by kasabali on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @02:58PM (#28448505)
Technological bottleneck might be passed but HDD manufacturers intend to keep prices up [1]:

> Value-based pricing

> This led Sivaram to discuss pricing; “Disk capacities are scaling beautifully. We want to move towards value pricing.” Customers are getting substantial added value from the linear scaling in disk drive capacity to the current levels, according to Sivaram. They would get even more from future capacities.

> With larger capacity drives the manufacturing cost in $/TB terms comes down. He suggested that, perhaps, it is time to think about moving from manufacturing cost-based pricing centred on $/TB towards value-based pricing: “$/TB is no longer the right metric.”

> A customers gets more value from a larger capacity drive, he said. “They can monetise more data.” This extra value could be larger than the sheer savings of the lower $/TB cost that WD can pass on. In that case WD could pass on only a proportion of that cost-saving to the customer and so charge for some of the extra value

[1] https://blocksandfiles.com/2019/12/17/western-digital-disk-d...

Re:Chia Coin Miners Are Reselling Used SSDs as New by silexia on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @11:15AM (#28458311)
All of these digital coins have failed to fulfill their promise to be used as digital currency, but each has caused serious problems. Bitcoin is wasting a titanic amount of energy, and this coin is destroying SSDs. Maybe we should just use our conventional currencies and elect governments we trust to run those currencies in an intelligent way?
Re:Chia Coin Miners Are Reselling Used SSDs as New by randomhodler84 on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @12:04PM (#28459049)
No thank you. I don’t think you can trust folks seeking power to have your best interests was at heart. Every civilization before has destroyed their fiat currency through debasement. It is inevitable. Bitcoin is the first time in history folks have been able to opt out of this. I’m sorry you don’t get it today, but you will :-)
Re:Chia Coin Miners Are Reselling Used SSDs as New by bserge on Monday September 06, 2021 @04:28PM (#28437703)
Just great. I mean, drives are the only things I'd rather buy new, but how hard can it be to fake the whole packaging these days.
Re:Chia Coin Miners Are Reselling Used SSDs as New by ev1 on Monday September 06, 2021 @04:56PM (#28438024)
Miners frequently retain the full packaging for return fraud/resale purposes.
Re:Chia Coin Miners Are Reselling Used SSDs as New by throwaway9980 on Monday September 06, 2021 @05:05PM (#28438105)
Dumpster divers are also recovering packaging for re-use.
Re:Chia Coin Miners Are Reselling Used SSDs as New by folmar on Monday September 06, 2021 @07:13PM (#28439130)
I've actually read your comment as return/fraud/resale on the first glance.
Re:Chia Coin Miners Are Reselling Used SSDs as New by selcuka on Monday September 06, 2021 @08:25PM (#28439542)
Step 4: Profit
Re:Chia Coin Miners Are Reselling Used SSDs as New by 55873445216111 on Monday September 06, 2021 @04:30PM (#28437723)
Buy direct from manufacturer. Samsung, Western Digital, etc all have their own online stores.
Re:Chia Coin Miners Are Reselling Used SSDs as New by Nexxxeh on Monday September 06, 2021 @06:47PM (#28438969)
Having purchased an "in stock" SSD directly from WD at the end of last year, it's not something I'm keen to repeat.

Their store seemed to operate primarily on incompetence.

I finally got my invoice two weeks later, still with no working shipping information, and the drive turned up days later still.

On top of their scummy behaviour around SMR disks, and their NAS solution, I think I'll be steering as clear as possible.

Re:Chia Coin Miners Are Reselling Used SSDs as New by woofie11 on Monday September 06, 2021 @08:21PM (#28439524)
One of my worst experiences was ordering direct from a little vendor (not HDD) to avoid Amazon scams.

The vendor added a markup to Amazon prices, and fulfilled with Amazon. I'm pretty sure I got a fake, ordering direct from the manufacturer.

I'll withhold names, so as not to embarrass anyone.

Re:Chia Coin Miners Are Reselling Used SSDs as New by Cullinet on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @03:35AM (#28442019)
I'm confused how you seem concerned about the embarrassment to the perpetrators of a fraud you have been victim of. The effect is inevitably damaging to consumer confidence in general by not identifying the criminal company and creating additional unfounded caution wherever else, so your protection is not a free gesture at all.
Re:Chia Coin Miners Are Reselling Used SSDs as New by woofie11 on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @09:13AM (#28444364)
My perception is both the manufacturer and I were the victims of fraud, while Amazon was the enabler. Now, I wish the company didn't fulfill through Amazon, but that's not a crime or a fraud.
Re:Chia Coin Miners Are Reselling Used SSDs as New by loloquwowndueo on Monday September 06, 2021 @08:27PM (#28439559)
Shame away!
Re:Chia Coin Miners Are Reselling Used SSDs as New by ravel-bar-foo on Monday September 06, 2021 @08:42PM (#28439638)
That's actually a brilliant arbitrage plan in the short term. If the trademark-infringing knockoffs on Amazon come from a country where the trademark cannot be enforced and the original manufacturer cannot compete, the original manufacturer could slow the collapse of their business by reselling knockoffs.
Re:Chia Coin Miners Are Reselling Used SSDs as New by bogwog on Monday September 06, 2021 @04:50PM (#28437959)
And sidestep the monopolist at the same time. Its a win-win!
Re:Chia Coin Miners Are Reselling Used SSDs as New by manquer on Monday September 06, 2021 @08:52PM (#28439683)
Or from firms like Bestbuy they won't have the hassle of manufacturers or the cheating/fraud with Amazon.
Re:Chia Coin Miners Are Reselling Used SSDs as New by blibble on Monday September 06, 2021 @07:28PM (#28439244)
I've had obviously used disks "fulfilled by Amazon" before

it was pretty obvious when you've bought 5 disks and one has completely different (crappy) packaging

Re:Chia Coin Miners Are Reselling Used SSDs as New by api on Monday September 06, 2021 @07:14PM (#28439146)
It’s cryptocurrency, what else do you expect?
Re:Chia Coin Miners Are Reselling Used SSDs as New by londons_explore on Monday September 06, 2021 @04:24PM (#28437657)
I bought an SSD on eBay recently that massively underperformed my expectations.

But I have no real proof to send it back for a refund. Instead I'll just have to suffer with super slow writes.

Re:Chia Coin Miners Are Reselling Used SSDs as New by kkielhofner on Monday September 06, 2021 @05:21PM (#28438236)
In my experience the eBay/Paypal resolution process is so heavily weighted to the buyer you shouldn't have any issues returning it and/or getting a refund.
Re:Chia Coin Miners Are Reselling Used SSDs as New by AussieWog93 on Monday September 06, 2021 @06:42PM (#28438939)
This. I sell an eBay for a living and unless I have proof beyond reasonable doubt that the buyer is lying, I am required to provide a refund.

Since I started telling buyers that I log serial numbers for every item I sell, though, a surprising number of them started closing their own cases.

Re:Chia Coin Miners Are Reselling Used SSDs as New by UI_at_80x24 on Monday September 06, 2021 @07:06PM (#28439092)
Count this as another anti-ebay opinion. My company (I) posted a used printer (HP Laser) for sale. In the listing I included the printer report showing the number of pages printed. I even had USED in the description 3 times (and title once).

The buyer filed a complaint that the printer wasn't new. I responded with "Of course it's not, look at the title & description." Ebay made us pay for them to ship it back and refund the money.

When we got it back there were 2,000 more pages printed on it.

I'll NEVER do any business through ebay. You are either braver then I or have a higher tolerance for bullshit then I do.

Re:Chia Coin Miners Are Reselling Used SSDs as New by AussieWog93 on Monday September 06, 2021 @07:20PM (#28439187)
It sucks, but it's a cost of doing business. Physical retailers get shoplifters, we get friendly fraud.

Fortunately, most people do the right thing and with the mitigation strategies we have in place we lose only around 0.5% of revenue to (suspected) fraud.

eBay's ~10% processing fee makes a much, much bigger dent in our bottom line.

Re:Chia Coin Miners Are Reselling Used SSDs as New by Cullinet on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @03:38AM (#28442042)
I've forgotten the source but it was credible that over 50 percent of UK online purchases are returned. No way is this not costing everyone who tries to be a careful customer and choose wisely etc
Re:Chia Coin Miners Are Reselling Used SSDs as New by AussieWog93 on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @06:57AM (#28443242)
I would be shocked if it where anywhere near that high. For us, it's around 2% on both of our businesses, and we have very generous returns policies!
Re:Chia Coin Miners Are Reselling Used SSDs as New by philpem on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @05:02AM (#28442575)
Retail shops have to deal with similar. Basically they used you as a rental service, but used ebay's policies to force it through.

When I worked retail, we used to get people buying cameras or lenses and using them for a weekend, then returning them under the 7-day "no quibble" refund policy.

It wasn't uncommon for a camera or lens to come back with 10,000 shots taken. Best we could do with them is clean them up and sell them on as refurbished. A few went back to the manufacturer and came back as "factory refurbished".

Re:Chia Coin Miners Are Reselling Used SSDs as New by dpweb on Monday September 06, 2021 @08:28PM (#28439561)
eBay is for buyers, Mercari for sellers. Usually get better prices selling on eBay tho.
Re:Chia Coin Miners Are Reselling Used SSDs as New by Cullinet on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @03:42AM (#28442078)
my personal view of the accommodation and compromises made for retail consumer behaviour is that there's a incalculable sociological cost created by pandering to impulse satisfaction creeping into noticeably diminished personal and collective self control and behaviour in the current generation of young adults. /old man grump
Re:Chia Coin Miners Are Reselling Used SSDs as New by AussieWog93 on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @06:59AM (#28443259)
Agreed with you 100% until you said "young adults". The Boomers are just as bad!
Re:Chia Coin Miners Are Reselling Used SSDs as New by dheera on Monday September 06, 2021 @05:55PM (#28438529)
Also, if someone is selling anything on eBay for above MSRP I report them for price gouging. Masks, sanitizer, drives, Ubiquiti cameras, anything. All reported.
Re:Chia Coin Miners Are Reselling Used SSDs as New by avalys on Monday September 06, 2021 @06:18PM (#28438736)
What will you do if the manufacturer increases the MSRP because demand exceeds supply? Report them for price gouging?
Re:Chia Coin Miners Are Reselling Used SSDs as New by dheera on Monday September 06, 2021 @07:00PM (#28439054)
If it's an emergency situation they they're assholes for trying to profit off the emergency and should be reported.

If it's not an emergency situation then I'm okay with them increasing MSRP. They're the ones who make it, they set the price.

I'm talking about the hoarder-resellers. I have zero sympathy for them.

Re:Chia Coin Miners Are Reselling Used SSDs as New by imtringued on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @05:34AM (#28442755)
> If it's an emergency situation they they're assholes for trying to profit off the emergency and should be reported.

But if its an emergency then giving the limited resource to people who already have too much of it is a waste.

How about we meet in the middle? Rather than go full free market or full government why not just let sellers declare the product an "emergency service" which allows the buyer to delay his payment. The invoice is sent to the government who then gets in contact with the seller. The seller presents his costs to provide the emergency service and then the government finally decides upon a fair price and gives the emergency seller a small commission for the trouble of providing an emergency service (this lowers the price the consumer has to pay in the end).

That way the price will still help as a discovery mechanism but have no gouging effect on the wallet of desperate people. Meanwhile people who do not need emergency service will not buy the product because they would be stuck with a large bill as the government would be less likely to negotiate in your favor.

Re:Chia Coin Miners Are Reselling Used SSDs as New by ericyan on Monday September 06, 2021 @07:27PM (#28439236)
You need to revisit Economics 101. High demand -> price rise -> more supply -> price drop. If you set a price ceiling, this will make the shortage worse as the market cannot properly function.
Re:Chia Coin Miners Are Reselling Used SSDs as New by sofixa on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @02:28AM (#28441578)
> You need to revisit Economics 101. High demand -> price rise -> more supply -> price drop. If you set a price ceiling, this will make the shortage worse as the market cannot properly function.

And you need to revisit Economics 102 where they talk about inelastic demand and why some prices are usually controlled at least to an extent ( food, medication, electricity), and Economics 103 where they mention they real world and economy are slightly more complex and have slightly more variables than what Economics 101 started with.

Re:Chia Coin Miners Are Reselling Used SSDs as New by ericyan on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @03:11AM (#28441868)
Your are right about your last point as in real world there is no such thing as inelastic demand.

Food definitely is not as in that case there will be no need to pour the milk into the river during the Great Depression. Basic medication such NSAID are cheap because there's no patent and can be mass produced and things like Novartis’ Zolgensma is apparently a different story. For electricity, don't get me started with Texas... I agree it probably a problem that is it is not controlled there.

The point is, yes there will be more variables in the real world, but the most basic rules still applies.

Re:Chia Coin Miners Are Reselling Used SSDs as New by krageon on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @09:13AM (#28444347)
> Economics 101

Economics isn't a science, so this class is essentially as valuable as any art or philosophy class at prediction reality or informing us of how we are supposed to act: Not at all, unless you put significant amounts of personal effort in.

Re:Chia Coin Miners Are Reselling Used SSDs as New by ericyan on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @10:39AM (#28445430)
I would say economics is more like historical studies. It is not trying to predict anything, it just give you some tools to learn from the past.

It is not supposed to be a crystal ball that you can see thought the future. Actually, I am not sure if such thing actually exists, but probably a physicist can prove that.

Re:Chia Coin Miners Are Reselling Used SSDs as New by dheera on Monday September 06, 2021 @07:31PM (#28439269)
> You need to revisit Economics 101.

Personal attacks not appreciated here.

> If you set a price ceiling, this will make the shortage worse

No. You may perceive the shortage as worse, but in reality, 100% of the supplies will be going to people who need them, as opposed to 30% sitting unused in hoarders' warehouses not helping anyone. Having 70% of the supplies in the field and 30% sitting in a warehouse, appearing for sale, but outside anyone's budget, is not an efficient use of supplies in an emergency.

If there is a mask shortage, I want every single mask strapped to a face, somewhere, somehow, and zero masks in a warehouse.

If you don't regulate it, it means the rich get essential items while the poor don't. Instead of the people who have the greatest legitimate need for the essential items getting access to them.

Re:Chia Coin Miners Are Reselling Used SSDs as New by avalys on Monday September 06, 2021 @08:32PM (#28439585)
> as opposed to 30% sitting unused in hoarders' warehouses not helping anyone. Having 70% of the supplies in the field and 30% sitting in a warehouse, appearing for sale, but outside anyone's budget, is not an efficient use of supplies in an emergency.

If the items are "outside anyone's budget", then the price gouger will not make money and they will lower the price until someone buys them. Thus, your goal of 100% usage of supplies is still eventually achieved.

> If you don't regulate it, it means the rich get essential items while the poor don't.

If the items are truly essential, and there are not enough to go around, what difference does it make if the rich get them and the poor don't? This seems like you just want to find an excuse to stick it to the rich.

> Instead of the people who have the greatest legitimate need for the essential items getting access to them.

How do you propose determining who has the "greatest legitimate need" more accurately than just seeing who is willing to pay the most?

> as opposed to 30% sitting unused in hoarders' warehouses

It's interesting that you started off talking about price gouging but have now switched to using the term "hoarding".

The thing is, "price gouging" discourages hoarding. If the price is not increased in response to a shortage, then everyone (rich and poor) is incentivized to buy as much as they can whenever an item is available for sale (even if it's well in excess of their actual need). This is basically the definition of "hoarding". Whereas, if the price were allowed to increase, people are discouraged from buying more than they need, and more supply is available for all.

This is almost exactly what happened with toilet paper last year. Toilet paper costs about $1 / roll. Most people can afford to buy extra toilet paper, and so very quickly the entire stock of toilet paper was bought up and there was none available for sale. If the price had increased to (say) $5 / roll, people would have been disincentivized from hoarding it. As it was, the people who had the "greatest legitimate need" - those that actually ran out of TP - were unable to purchase any.

Additionally, the fact that people like you demonize manufacturers and retailers who raise prices in emergencies as "price gouging" also provides a disincentive for manufacturers and retailers to invest in spare capacity for these very emergencies. If "price gouging" is illegal, there is no good way for manufacturers and retailers to recoup the cost of temporarily increasing production, or maintaining a buffer of inventory for temporary spikes in demand.

Re:Chia Coin Miners Are Reselling Used SSDs as New by ericyan on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @02:54AM (#28441762)
I am not sure if indicating anyone lack of basic understanding of economics counts a personal attack, but calling people as assholes surely is.

Since you talked about PPEs, you can check what happened in Wuhan during the first outbreak. The Chinese government demands no price increase for PPEs such as face masks... and what happened? The hospitals asked the public for donation of N95 facemasks because they cannot get those from the market. Every one in China are of course entitled for protecting themselves, but the truth is, at that time supply is simply not enough for the whole population and medical workers who needed those most cannot get them even the hospitals have enough dry powder to pay up. The market was awfully inefficient at that time.

Having every single mask strapped to a face and zero masks in a warehouse is far from enough. In a shortage, you need MORE facemasks. You need to make sure there will be enough are being supplied at the market. With a pricing cap, there will be no incentive for putting stock in the warehouse on sale and producing more, and it makes things worse.

Re:Chia Coin Miners Are Reselling Used SSDs as New by Woden501 on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @10:23AM (#28445232)
Apparently you don't understand what the word Suggested means. Do you also report every single classic car that is selling for higher value that it was initially sold for? If not then you're pretty much just being an asshole for no reason.
Re:Chia Coin Miners Are Reselling Used SSDs as New by hsbauauvhabzb on Monday September 06, 2021 @08:10PM (#28439475)
I don’t think SSDs drop in performance after substantial proof.

Linus tech tips YouTube channel has done a few articles on vendors quietly switching components to lower performing parts recently, it’s worth googling around to see if others with the same make/model are reporting vastly different performance from official benchmarks

Re:Chia Coin Miners Are Reselling Used SSDs as New by Cacti on Monday September 06, 2021 @04:34PM (#28437779)
1. verify it against published benchmarks for that model 2. open up the case and see if it’s actually what you bought
Re:Chia Coin Miners Are Reselling Used SSDs as New by derekp7 on Monday September 06, 2021 @08:23PM (#28439530)
A big item is making sure your filesystem partition is aligned properly. For example, by default the first partition begins on sector 63, which causes logical 4K blocks to straddle two different write blocks on the drive (causing both blocks to be read and re-written). Simple thing is to make sure the partition begins on sector 2048 (since it can begin on sector 0 due to the need to reserve the boot sectors).
Re:Chia Coin Miners Are Reselling Used SSDs as New by colejohnson66 on Monday September 06, 2021 @10:42PM (#28440304)
Sector 63 used to be common, but I think every modern OS defaults to 2048 now. I know Windows does when installing fresh.