News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:When patents attack Android by jerf on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @04:46PM (#2842994)
Is this why we're seeing a sudden burst of anti-patent news? Is Google in the early phases of drumming up grassroots support for a direct assault on software patents in general, without their name being on the effort? Is this post actually move 3 instead of move 1?

Honest questions, BTW, if there's anybody with answers who are allowed to give answers...

Re:When patents attack Android by georgemcbay on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @06:21PM (#2843433)
I wouldn't be surprised if Google is pushing this story along as a PR effort, but they can't be the only thing behind it. Lodsys suing iOS developers was one of the major catalysts in turning this into a relatively hot topic and I don't see how Google could have realistically have had much of a hand in that.
Re:When patents attack Android by JunkDNA on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @05:01PM (#2843074)
Astute observation. Reminds me of this pg classic on PR:

http://www.paulgraham.com/submarine.html

The timing is certainly convenient for Google.

Re:When patents attack Android by nitrogen on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @05:07PM (#2843107)
Software developers, and Open Source developers in particular, have been adamantly against software patents for a very long time. It seems equally as likely that independent developers are taking advantage of Google's predicament to further their own goal of abolishing software patents.

Edit: I will add that I personally have done exactly this in conversation. But, in the worst case, Google is exploiting a sentiment that already exists, rather than creating it from nothing.

Re:When patents attack Android by econgeeker on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @05:52PM (#2843311)
"Software developers, and Open Source developers in particular, have been adamantly against software patents for a very long time."

This is exactly as true as the claim that all scientists support AGW theory.

Reality-- most scientists don't support that theory.

But proponents of the theory say that they all do, all over the place. And since there is nobody who actually speaks for all scientists, there's nobody to prove them wrong.

So they repeat it over and over and over and over again, even though it isn't true.

Logically, your statement is easily disproven. I have been developing software for two decades, including open source, and I support software patents.

Now you can never make that statement again. Well, you can't if you're honest.

Re:When patents attack Android by nitrogen on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @07:05PM (#2843610)
"Software developers, and Open Source developers in particular, have been adamantly against software patents for a very long time."

This is exactly as true as the claim that all scientists support AGW theory.

Reality-- most scientists don't support that theory.

But proponents of the theory say that they all do, all over the place. And since there is nobody who actually speaks for all scientists, there's nobody to prove them wrong.

So they repeat it over and over and over and over again, even though it isn't true.

Logically, your statement is easily disproven. I have been developing software for two decades, including open source, and I support software patents.

Now you can never make that statement again. Well, you can't if you're honest.

At the risk of sounding like I'm retroactively changing my argument, I didn't say "all software developers." My intended meaning of "software developers" and "Open Source developers" was many, not all, which I believe is a common and valid grammatical interpretation of a pluralized noun without a specified quantity.

Sites like Groklaw and organizations like the FSF (though FSF is a bit more extreme on most things than I am) show that there is a sizable group of people against software patents, and whether you yourself are for, against, or neutral, your position does not disprove the harm done to OSS/FS, small companies, and general innovation by software patents.

Finally, though this is off topic, do you have evidence that most scientists don't support the theory of anthropogenic global warming? From the perspective of a non-climate-scientist, non-politician such as myself, it seems like most climatologists do consider anthropogenic greenhouse gases a problem. It also seems that claiming that most scientists disbelieve in AGW is a hallmark of conservative arguments (as in preserving the legal status quo, not as in right wing), as is claiming that patents help the small inventor.

Re:When patents attack Android by davorak on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @08:21PM (#2843880)
For what it is worth I read your pervious comment as you intended and good job in your response.
Re:When patents attack Android by aristidb on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @07:17PM (#2843645)
Most of the software developers I talk to don't like software patents. Certainly not all, and I don't have precise numbers, but it's almost certainly the majority.
Re:When patents attack Android by nitrogen on Sunday August 07, 2011 @03:04AM (#2856052)

  powerje 3 days ago | link [dead]

  >> Reality-- most scientists don't support that theory.

  Citation needed.

  Anecdotally I think the statement about software 
  developers in general being anti-software patent is true, 
  but especially OSS developers - you really think this is 
  incorrect?
Note to powerje: it looks like your account is dead, apparently because your first post was strongly downvoted.
Re:When patents attack Android by ericb on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @05:11PM (#2843125)
I get the sense that Google plays chess while most companies play checkers. The cellular auction with Verizon comes to mind. I hope you're right!