News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GoDaddy is cutting off Texas Right to Life’s abortion ‘wh... by paulgb on Saturday September 04, 2021 @09:06AM (#28414752)
As far as I can tell, GoDaddy did not add the section to the ToS that prohibits services from “violat[ing] the privacy or publicity rights of another User or any other person or entity [...]” in response to this site, so unless you either think that this site did not do that, or that GoDaddy does not have the right to have and enforce a ToS, I don't see what the problem is.

The idea that GoDaddy should need to make an exception to their ToS when a case is politically charged is scarier, IMHO.

Re:GoDaddy is cutting off Texas Right to Life’s abortion ‘wh... by pseudo0 on Saturday September 04, 2021 @09:21AM (#28414846)
GoDaddy also hosts crimestoppersusa.org, a site that has functioned as a similar "snitch line" for years, yet they have not been terminated for violating the ToS. The exception seems to be this enforcement action. Also, it's definitely not clear that reporting a perceived violation of Texas statute would be a violation of privacy rights.
Re:GoDaddy is cutting off Texas Right to Life’s abortion ‘wh... by Brybry on Saturday September 04, 2021 @03:08PM (#28418100)
I don't think crimestoppersusa.org actually has direct tip submission on its site? It looks to me like it links primarily to other crime stoppers programs (which do have tip submission).

Your argument definitely stands though: there's not much difference in private information that's requested on a crime stoppers form[1] vs the right to life form[2].

[1] https://www.p3tips.com/tipform.aspx?ID=458

[2] https://archive.is/zspjG

Re:GoDaddy is cutting off Texas Right to Life’s abortion ‘wh... by irq-1 on Saturday September 04, 2021 @02:40PM (#28417854)
Does crimestoppersusa.org DOX the people reported? That's the clear intent of the abortion website.
Re:GoDaddy is cutting off Texas Right to Life’s abortion ‘wh... by cdot2 on Saturday September 04, 2021 @02:47PM (#28417928)
Someone who is charged with a crime doesnt have a right to keep that private. That information is publically available through the courts for a reason
Re:GoDaddy is cutting off Texas Right to Life’s abortion ‘wh... by rootsudo on Saturday September 04, 2021 @03:12PM (#28418130)
What about someone who had an illegal abortion in Texas that was aborted through Crimestoppers?
[dead]
Re:GoDaddy is cutting off Texas Right to Life’s abortion ‘wh... by pseudo0 on Saturday September 04, 2021 @09:34AM (#28414942)
It looks awfully similar to me. In both cases these are private entities that allow users to confidentially submit tips about potentially illegal behavior. And the "medical procedures" bit discussed below seems like a pretty blatant deflection. If someone were doing back-alley kidney transplants, would anyone really object to that being reported to Crime Stoppers? Or perhaps more plausibly, someone illegally performing FGM on their child?

https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/detroit-emergency-room-doctor...

Re:GoDaddy is cutting off Texas Right to Life’s abortion ‘wh... by notahacker on Saturday September 04, 2021 @09:43AM (#28415007)
The whole point of the website is that the stuff being reported isn't criminal, because Texas and the Supreme Court have decided that the state setting civil penalties and letting private vigilantes sue is a convenient way of circumventing instead of reversing the constitutional precedent that the state has no business excessively restricting abortion.
Re:GoDaddy is cutting off Texas Right to Life’s abortion ‘wh... by pseudo0 on Saturday September 04, 2021 @10:17AM (#28415299)
Violating a state statute is still illegal by definition, even if the remedy provided is civil rather than criminal. That makes the Crime Stoppers comparison still pretty fair, in my opinion.

And no, the Supreme Court didn't decide that, the people bringing the suit failed on procedural grounds and will get a chance to argue the merits when they re-file properly. My guess is that this whole thing will be a tempest in a teacup that will get sorted out in short order.

Re:GoDaddy is cutting off Texas Right to Life’s abortion ‘wh... by magicalist on Saturday September 04, 2021 @11:16AM (#28415841)
> Violating a state statute is still illegal by definition, even if the remedy provided is civil rather than criminal.

You wouldn't be "violating" anything, but if we sidestep that issue, you appear to be arguing that all behavior that someone has standing to sue over should be called "illegal". That seems like a semantic game most everyone should have a serious problem with.

Re:GoDaddy is cutting off Texas Right to Life’s abortion ‘wh... by wizzwizz4 on Saturday September 04, 2021 @11:24AM (#28415910)
> you appear to be arguing that

Careful: you wouldn't want to be unfairly misrepresenting somebody else's views! That would be libellous. (You don't want to say something illegal, now, do you?)

But yeah: not all torts are crimes, and there's good reason for that. Lumping them together under the same “illegal” banner is how IP-as-control got started.

Re:GoDaddy is cutting off Texas Right to Life’s abortion ‘wh... by verall on Saturday September 04, 2021 @01:30PM (#28417079)
You are misunderstanding the Texas law. There is intentionally not a criminal statute being violated because Texas does not want the law to be overturned in court.
Re:GoDaddy is cutting off Texas Right to Life’s abortion ‘wh... by pixl97 on Saturday September 04, 2021 @11:22AM (#28415887)
So I should be able to make a civil law in my state that says pseudo0 cannot post on the internet under the threat of civil suit? The issue here is you don't have the right to steal, but we do have the right both to communicating on the internet and to an abortion.
Re:GoDaddy is cutting off Texas Right to Life’s abortion ‘wh... by jollybean on Saturday September 04, 2021 @04:39PM (#28418918)
Legally they are similar, from a public PR perspective they have nothing to do with one another.

This is a situation of Optics, Communications and PR.

The lawyers would be tasked with finding the grounds necessary.

GoDaddy is not at risk of public outrage over CrimeStoppers, but with the very raw politics of Abortions in Texas hitting the front page ... I can see the Marketing team just sweating bullets over this, wanting to just 'get out' of the path of a fast moving vehicle.

Re:GoDaddy is cutting off Texas Right to Life’s abortion ‘wh... by s5300 on Saturday September 04, 2021 @09:51AM (#28415081)
You're missing a massive distinction in your attempts of comparison.

Yes, your two examples are of a person commiting a crime.

The issue at hand is about the privacy of healthcare/medical status. You cannot say somebody aided in abortion if you cannot prove whomever they were around was pregnant. You cannot ask in a legal sense if somebody is pregnant, was pregnant, or is now not pregnant, and force them to give a truthful answer/disclosure, that's against pre-existing medical privacy laws. Does that make more sense to you?

And in an attempt to make slight sense of that to one of your answers - yes, the act of commiting FGM on a child, or perhaps an adult who was somewhat forcibly taken somewhere to have the procedure done against their will, is a crime committed by whoever did it. However - to convict this person of the crime, the person mutilated would have to testify. As it deals with medical privacy - they do have to and can choose not to testify. Especially with a child, it gets more tricky - the parent to a certain age can choose not to testify per their rights to their child's medical privacy. If somebody was hellbent on trying to make a child testify against the perpetrator, they could attempt a massive legal battle to get state custody of the child, who can then somewhat legally force the child to testify or face some sort of legal recourse. Otherwise, you're basically going to need video evidence of the crime being committed, or an eyewitness account from a law enforcement agent/FBI/etc for any chance of legal prosecution.

Re:GoDaddy is cutting off Texas Right to Life’s abortion ‘wh... by kyrra on Saturday September 04, 2021 @09:54AM (#28415106)
The courts haven't failed. If you are referring to the SCOTUS emergency relief ruling, that was entirely procedural.

Important thing to know is that via emergency relief, judges cannot strike down a law, they can just stop people or groups from enforcing said laws. The case that went to the supreme Court was asking for a group of eight different people that have them blocked from enforcing the law. 7 of them were state employees of various positions, one was a private citizen. For the private citizen the plaintiff asked the court to consider the that person as a group, but they did not have time to get that through the courts (I think). The private person ended up signing an affidavit saying they would not try to enforce the law.

If you go search the news, you will find a pro life group has already had a temporary restraining order placed against them from applying this law or assisting other people and applying this law.

You can also bet as soon as anybody brings a lawsuit about this, it'll be immediately dismissed as being in violation of Casey (Roe).

Re:GoDaddy is cutting off Texas Right to Life’s abortion ‘wh... by SaltyBackendGuy on Saturday September 04, 2021 @11:01AM (#28415706)
> there's at least some basic decency in companies

I would exercise caution with this perspective. They stand to gain a bit of mind share from this action as it's a popular position to take. I am not saying virtuous companies don't exist. In general they act in the best interest of their bottom line (in this case public image).

Re:GoDaddy is cutting off Texas Right to Life’s abortion ‘wh... by maerF0x0 on Saturday September 04, 2021 @01:16PM (#28416922)
> and BDSed

What does this acronym mean?

Re:GoDaddy is cutting off Texas Right to Life’s abortion ‘wh... by tomp on Saturday September 04, 2021 @01:22PM (#28416988)
Probably “Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions”, which is often promoted as an appropriate response to Israel’s occupation of Palestine.
Re:GoDaddy is cutting off Texas Right to Life’s abortion ‘wh... by krona on Saturday September 04, 2021 @09:21AM (#28414848)
Reporting someone of a crime is a violation of their privacy and/or publicity rights?
Re:GoDaddy is cutting off Texas Right to Life’s abortion ‘wh... by smnrchrds on Saturday September 04, 2021 @09:33AM (#28414931)
What crime? The new Texas law is civil, not criminal.
Re:GoDaddy is cutting off Texas Right to Life’s abortion ‘wh... by iNate2000 on Saturday September 04, 2021 @09:26AM (#28414884)
But the site is not a law-enforcement official.

Also, a person’s health-care information is quite private.

Re:GoDaddy is cutting off Texas Right to Life’s abortion ‘wh... by kevin_thibedeau on Saturday September 04, 2021 @01:54PM (#28417386)
HIPAA doesn't apply to ordinary people, only entrusted medical personnel.
Re:GoDaddy is cutting off Texas Right to Life’s abortion ‘wh... by mintplant on Saturday September 04, 2021 @02:41PM (#28417867)
No one mentioned HIPAA.
Re:GoDaddy is cutting off Texas Right to Life’s abortion ‘wh... by s5300 on Saturday September 04, 2021 @09:28AM (#28414901)
If you've not read, it's not about that.

GoDaddy had a ToS that includes statements about inquiry of medical conditions

Crimestoppers or whatever isn't asking you to submit things regarding people's medical status, it's asking for crime reporting.

There's been a large amount of privacy with regards to healthcare in the US in general for the longest time. The fact anybody is surprised by this is somewhat unsettling.

Re:GoDaddy is cutting off Texas Right to Life’s abortion ‘wh... by pyuser583 on Saturday September 04, 2021 @01:53PM (#28417374)
What the TOS says is:

“violates the privacy or publicity rights of another User or any other person or entity, or breaches any duty of confidentiality that *you owe* to another User or any other person or entity.”

Most people don’t owe any privacy rights in regards to others medical care.

GoDaddy can say “we don’t want to be involved in this sort of thing.”

But they should not pretend their clients are breaking the law.

There is lots of caselaw involving whether anti-abortion groups can gather this sort of information.

They can.

GoDaddy doesn’t have to be involved in it. But they shouldn’t pretend there is an obligation or duty being violated by the site owner.

Re:GoDaddy is cutting off Texas Right to Life’s abortion ‘wh... by kemayo on Saturday September 04, 2021 @02:59PM (#28418027)
There's the other part of their TOS though:

"You will not collect or harvest (or permit anyone else to collect or harvest) any User Content (as defined below) or any non-public or personally identifiable information about another User or any other person or entity without their express prior written consent."

That seems way stronger in forbidding the exact purpose of this site. (With the privacy/publicity/confidentiality rights sometimes applying, but only to specific reports.)

Re:GoDaddy is cutting off Texas Right to Life’s abortion ‘wh... by pyuser583 on Saturday September 04, 2021 @03:32PM (#28418309)
In summary, the part being violated is:

“You will not collect any PII about any entity without their consent.”

There’s probably an implied “You will not use this service to collect …” at the start.

So basically, you can’t host a portal to gather PII on non-consenting parties.

It would be pretty easy for the website to get around that.

The website asked for the contact info of the user and then had a textarea field with the caption “If applicable: Do you have information about potential violations of the Texas Heartbeat Act?”

All they would have to do is change that textarea into a Yes/No radio button.

Edit: confusingly, it said, “we will not follow up or contact you” but also asked the best time to contact you.

Re:GoDaddy is cutting off Texas Right to Life’s abortion ‘wh... by kemayo on Saturday September 04, 2021 @03:40PM (#28418370)
Having not read the full TOS and all its definitions, I'll agree that would likely get around GoDaddy's objection.

GoDaddy could maybe argue that the fundamental purpose of the website was still to facilitate gathering that data, but that seems more of a stretch. "You are using our servers to gather this forbidden data" vs "you are using our servers to gather this allowed data, which will later be used to gather forbidden data elsewhere"...

I'd guess that the reason the website doesn't want to make this change would be that it'd greatly increase their own costs in terms of followup they'd have to perform. Makes it a more high-touch operation.

Re:GoDaddy is cutting off Texas Right to Life’s abortion ‘wh... by pyuser583 on Saturday September 04, 2021 @04:05PM (#28418591)
I get the impression the website isn’t being run by professionals.

As I mentioned, it promises not to contact you, and then asks the best time to contact you.

Not exactly high caliber user research going on there.

I also get the impression it’s more about get names they can hit up for donations.

Notice how it asks if the “reporter” is already involved in anti-abortion movement.

That’s probably to avoid duplicates when they add the name to their mailing list asking for money.

Re:GoDaddy is cutting off Texas Right to Life’s abortion ‘wh... by pyuser583 on Saturday September 04, 2021 @04:07PM (#28418609)
On another matter, I doubt GoDaddy cares if you collect PII, just not on its infrastructure.

The last thing it wants is a security breach, followed by an obligation to inform all of the affect parties who reside in California and the EU.