What apple doesn’t understand is that scanning on the device is worse for privacy than scanning on the server, not better.
We don’t have to excuse one of the most valuable corp around. They do understand, but are willing to cash-in some of the “privacy budget”.
Even with a court order, your devices should not cooperate with a search, unless instructed to do so by you, their owner.
I'm your neighbor and I want you to store a box for me. It's tapped up so you don't really want to open it, but would you store it for me without knowing what's in it? You could be like other cloud providers, rip the tape off and rummage through looking for whatever.
Apple has designed a method for me to scan the box at my house only for CSAM (agreed upon by the intersection of multiple databases), then hand it to you with a note that says 'this is not CSAM'. Now you can store the box with some confidence in knowing you're not storing CSAM. It's also more private because you don't need to go rummaging through my box - even though you currently can if you want.
Of course we're starting from the basis that you have decided you don't want to store any CSAM. If you don't care about what you store it doesn't matter.
And you're right that Apple could make a policy change to scan my whole house and upload that somewhere, but guess what? iOS users (smart phone users in general) have always been one policy change away from Apple/Google doing something like uploading/sharing all the face ML data (which IMO is way more valuable than some hash matches). So nothing has really changed.
IMHO, no combination of ones and zeros should ever be illegal. The act of distributing them to others or creating them in the real world should be. The energy stored on a flash drive doesn't harm anybody, human action does.
OP’s analogy is spot on.
Apple is asking that people store their shoe boxes in Apple’s “house” in exchange for money.
If Apple was serious about privacy maybe they'd put some of their lobbying / peer pressure efforts towards that instead of trendy social fads at least this once.
To continue the physical home analogy, let's say you're a renter and your landlord has the ability and access to install something in your home at any time without you knowing. Maybe they include it as part of the terms for your upcoming lease renewal, maybe they don't.
Does that mean you should just accept it when they decide to install one of those devices in your home?
The device they installed is invisible and you will never have any way of knowing they were in there, it's irrelevant what you accept.
But it also doesn't lead to the conclusion that what Apple is trying to do here is good or even neutral.
So after this the governments around the world job is easy, they throw hashes to Apple(and fortunately for Apple they can say they had no idea what original photos content was) where before the government would have needed to ask Apple to write new software and Apple could have said that it can't do it without starting a shit storem.
That would be a better analogy. You don't own your iPhone at all. You own few dozens of grams of steel, glass and silicone. You don't even own parts of it, they're sealed, DRMed and non-functional without proprietary firmware. And of course you hardly own the entire device, as you can't control software which runs on it.
Don't pretend that you own a house.
This is quite the twist. What’s decreasing the privacy of my personal photos, before the neuralhash scanner is deployed?
I’m being disingenuous?
Mean while on a google pixel, google will just scan your entire library.
source: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-apple-fbi-icloud-exclusiv...
It’s pretty common knowledge that most of iCloud (including Photos) is not E2E encrypted; in fact, here’s the proof right from Apple - https://support.apple.com/en-ae/HT202303.
Google doesn’t scan anything on Pixel phones. Only photos and files that you upload to Google Photos or Drive. This is standard industry practice, and apparently Apple wasn’t doing that. So now they built this client side system that nobody else has, and created local surveillance.
This device is your smartphone. It can already watch and listen everything you do. It can already read and write everything that's inside because that's how an operating system works. The fact that it can now scan for CP makes zero difference privacy wise.
If you don't trust your smartphone to do what they advertise, you don't use one.
If you believe Apple can make the iPhone send data to them or the governments without your consent and without even telling you, you shouldn't use Apple software in the first place because you'd have no reason to believe that such a feature hasn't already been implemented.
Your device scanning its content is not a breach of privacy until that information is send without your consent. Wether it is for malware or for child porn. Claiming that this is a slippery slope is like claiming that building a bridge is a slippery slope as the worker could place a bomb inside anytime.
Let's say the police installs a new device in your house. This device could be capable of seeing or hearing anything that happens in your entire home. However, the police claim that the device is only watching a specific door in your house and forwarding encrypted low resolution photos to their servers "just in case" some criteria is met and they need to take a look. Nevermind that it would only take a policy change and an OTA update that you have no visibility into, or chance of blocking, before it's watching your entire house in real-time and sending practically anything to their servers. After all, they did release a carefully worded statement regarding what the device supposedly does.
But hey, you have several other doors to enter or exit your house from so what's the big deal right? You could seal that door and never be subjected to the system _as advertised_.
Would you trust the police in that scenario, regardless of whether you have anything to hide?