News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Feds Want to Know What the McFuck Is Going on with th... by skeeter2020 on Wednesday September 01, 2021 @08:52PM (#28387450)
One point: the machines aren't "broken" per se; typically the maintenance cycle does not complete and the machine only shows a very cryptic error message. The franchisee then needs to call out a Taylor service rep, wait for them and pay an expensive call-out charge. THe underlying issue is typically easily resolved; something like the hopper was too full of product so the heating cycle didn't get to the required temp; remove some and run it again".

So the reason they're always broken is they're not broken but the restauranteur has no way of knowing or resolving the issue.

Re:The Feds Want to Know What the McFuck Is Going on with th... by hunter2_ on Wednesday September 01, 2021 @08:59PM (#28387499)
I would consider "broken" and "SOP doesn't produce expected result" to be synonymous in most cases including this one.
Re:The Feds Want to Know What the McFuck Is Going on with th... by darkerside on Thursday September 02, 2021 @12:52AM (#28388763)
Intentionally crippled versus broken seems like a fair distinction
Re:The Feds Want to Know What the McFuck Is Going on with th... by iforgotpassword on Thursday September 02, 2021 @05:40AM (#28390184)
> intentionally broken versus broken

Ftfy.

It's definitely a fair or rather relevant distinction for the investigation, but for the end user, it's pretty much the same, especially if you're limited to using only that one specific machine.

Re:The Feds Want to Know What the McFuck Is Going on with th... by darkerside on Thursday September 02, 2021 @08:09AM (#28391083)
It was a reference to https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crippleware

As an end user, I can tell when I'm using it, and it annoys me. Even when I don't have large revenue streams depending on it.

Re:The Feds Want to Know What the McFuck Is Going on with th... by tedunangst on Thursday September 02, 2021 @12:13AM (#28388585)
What's McDonald's corporate's cut of the call out charge, the alleged motivation here?
Re:The Feds Want to Know What the McFuck Is Going on with th... by MichaelZuo on Thursday September 02, 2021 @10:15AM (#28392278)
Perhaps they signed a deal with Taylor to boost some KPI?
Re:The Feds Want to Know What the McFuck Is Going on with th... by sk5t on Wednesday September 01, 2021 @10:29PM (#28388072)
> something like the hopper was too full of product

Shouldn't then there be a guide or actual limiter for maximum hopper fill level based on ambient temperature, or just a TSB, rather than perpetual service calls?

Re:The Feds Want to Know What the McFuck Is Going on with th... by josefx on Thursday September 02, 2021 @02:23AM (#28389215)
Taylor makes money from these service calls and the franchise owners have to use the machines mandated by McDonalds. There is absolutely no motivation for Taylor to kill this cash cow.
Re:The Feds Want to Know What the McFuck Is Going on with th... by dredmorbius on Friday September 03, 2021 @06:06PM (#28409948)
Milking that hopper for all it's worth.

So to speak.

Re:The Feds Want to Know What the McFuck Is Going on with th... by sumedh on Wednesday September 01, 2021 @10:48PM (#28388161)
Does the franchisee know why the machine is not working or can he/she do some basic trouble shooting to fix the issue, if not then it is broken.
Re:The Feds Want to Know What the McFuck Is Going on with th... by floatingatoll on Thursday September 02, 2021 @12:00AM (#28388521)
No, and the company is trying to kill a third-party vendor of a hardware dongle that tells you what is wrong, without needing expensive on-site human support calls.

Previously: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28117164

Re:The Feds Want to Know What the McFuck Is Going on with th... by frombody on Wednesday September 01, 2021 @10:57PM (#28388208)
No, they don't know why it's broken.

The cleaning cycle doesn't complete during the night, usually because the hopper is too full, and when they come in the next day they just run the 4 hour cleaning cycle multiple times until the cryptic error goes away.

As the video showed, when someone invented an add-on for the machines to display human readable error messages, they got attacked with a lawsuit.

Re:The Feds Want to Know What the McFuck Is Going on with th... by jimbob45 on Wednesday September 01, 2021 @11:51PM (#28388470)
>In a recent legal victory, a judge awarded a temporary restraining order against Taylor after Kytch had alleged in a complaint that the McFlurry machine manufacturer had gotten its hands on a Kytch Solution Devices with the express intention of learning its trade secrets. The complaint also alleged that Taylor had told McDonald’s and its franchisees to stop using Kytch machines on the grounds that they were dangerous, and that the company had begun development on its own version of the Kytch system at the same time.

I think you have it backwards. However, you're still right in essence, since Taylor seems to be attempting to break compatibility with the Kytch machines. Sounds a lot like another company we talk about here...

Re:The Feds Want to Know What the McFuck Is Going on with th... by thaumasiotes on Thursday September 02, 2021 @12:27AM (#28388651)
> a judge awarded a temporary restraining order against Taylor after Kytch had alleged in a complaint that the McFlurry machine manufacturer had gotten its hands on a Kytch Solution Devices with the express intention of learning its trade secrets.

This seems like a strong argument that the concept of trade secrets should be done away with.

Re:The Feds Want to Know What the McFuck Is Going on with th... by MobiusHorizons on Thursday September 02, 2021 @12:08PM (#28393821)
I think you have it backwards. Kytch is the company providing a diagnostic tool to fix the machines. The trade secrets were protected by NDA between kytch and someone at McDonald’s. The lawsuit is against someone who broke NDA and leaked information about the diagnostic device to Taylor. The allegation is that the manufacturer wants to prevent the diagnostic device from working.
Re:The Feds Want to Know What the McFuck Is Going on with th... by drewzero1 on Thursday September 02, 2021 @01:03AM (#28388819)
And in turn, the Kytch device is an attempt to crack the trade secrets of the Taylor machines requiring service calls. I have a hard time rooting for either side on this one.
Re:The Feds Want to Know What the McFuck Is Going on with th... by atoav on Thursday September 02, 2021 @02:27AM (#28389244)
Wait do I get this right:

Company A builds a machine that breaks constantly and requires a lot of service — most of which people could do on site, but they can't because the error messages are not communicating anything.

Company B developed a device to read and display those error messages so the owners (?) of the machine can decide whether they fix it themselves or call support.

If I got this right I'd definitly be rooting for company B, because it offers a service that helps, while Company A apparently is afraid of not being able to compete if they just sell a working product instead of milking their customer via resource- and time-wasting service calls.

Which one of the two is that famous "innovation" capitalism is said to be good at producing?

Re:The Feds Want to Know What the McFuck Is Going on with th... by drewzero1 on Thursday September 02, 2021 @09:02PM (#28399331)
Yeah, that's absolutely fair. I was referring specifically to the keeping of trade secrets on both sides here. I really do respect Kytch for breaking into these machines, but I don't like the way they have to fight to keep it to themselves. (Then again, it's really sh---y that Taylor is trying to maintain power by making their own Kytch-like device, or to block it from working at all. So I guess I'm convinced they're the bad guys here.)
Re:The Feds Want to Know What the McFuck Is Going on with th... by lsaferite on Thursday September 02, 2021 @08:46AM (#28391394)
You should add that Company A acquired the device from Company B so they could figure out how to make it not work (we all know that's their objective).