News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:In 2009, Two Nuclear Submarines Collided Under the Sea (2... by nradov on Monday August 30, 2021 @12:10PM (#28357152)
There are no parking spots. Ballistic missile submarines conducting deterrence patrols are assigned to large areas covering hundreds of square nautical miles. The sub then maneuvers inside that patrol area to remain as hidden as possible. They almost never stop as it's easier to maintain depth control with at least a few knots of steerageway. So a collision in open ocean is theoretically possible but highly unlikely.

The real risk of collisions comes with transiting through constricted navigational channels, typically when leaving or entering port. Those channels force a lot of vessels into a small area. There have also been a few incidents where submarines failed to do a thorough surface search before surfacing and collided with smaller boats.

During the Cold War there were supposedly a few incidents where NATO attack submarines were following Soviet submarines too closely and ended up colliding.

Re:In 2009, Two Nuclear Submarines Collided Under the Sea (2... by baobabKoodaa on Monday August 30, 2021 @12:20PM (#28357296)
> There are no parking spots. Ballistic missile submarines conducting deterrence patrols are assigned to large areas covering hundreds of square nautical miles ... So a collision in open ocean is theoretically possible but highly unlikely.

It's misleading to describe collisions as "theoretically possible" when we have evidence that these collisions have occurred. The fact that collisions have occurred makes me think that these submarines are not randomly located in a large area where it would be difficult to locate them.

Re:In 2009, Two Nuclear Submarines Collided Under the Sea (2... by nradov on Monday August 30, 2021 @12:44PM (#28357652)
You missed the point. The collision covered in this article occurred relatively close to port, not during an open ocean patrol.

A ballistic missile submarine's position isn't completely random, but they do move around somewhat randomly to reduce the risk of detection. They intentionally avoid repeating movement patterns or lingering in the same spot. And this also reduces the risk from spies on land. If a spy sees the patrol orders he'll only know a large general area but won't precisely know the submarine's position at any time.

Re:In 2009, Two Nuclear Submarines Collided Under the Sea (2... by baobabKoodaa on Tuesday August 31, 2021 @04:55AM (#28365438)
> You missed the point. The collision covered in this article occurred relatively close to port, not during an open ocean patrol.

So you're saying the collision _didn't_ occur at a time when the sub was trying to stay hidden, you're saying that the operators could have / should have used active sonar? Is that it?

Look, either the sub was trying to stay hidden at the time it accidentally collided with another submarine, or it wasn't trying to stay hidden. In either case it didn't do a good job. If it wasn't trying to stay hidden, then it shouldn't have collided. If it was trying to stay hidden, then its location was not as unpredictable as it should have been.

Re:In 2009, Two Nuclear Submarines Collided Under the Sea (2... by ttepasse on Tuesday August 31, 2021 @11:10AM (#28369089)
That the collision happened close to port is weird in itself. France has its SSBNs stationed south of Brest; the UK to the west of Glasgow. One would assume the individual routes to the patrol areas would be rather different. What would the HMS Vanguard do less than a days travel from Brest?
Re:In 2009, Two Nuclear Submarines Collided Under the Sea (2... by dragonwriter on Monday August 30, 2021 @12:25PM (#28357360)
> large areas covering hundreds of square nautical miles.

That's...not very large.

> The sub then maneuvers inside that patrol area to remain as hidden as possible.

Given that the same concerns will drive “as hidden as possible” concerns in any sub, that further narrows the space. And unless the decisions made within that space are made in a truly random manner which approaches all equally good options equally (and tolerates a loose enough sense of “equally good” not to excessively narrow the space to start with), common cognitive biases, etc., will result in common decisions.

Re:In 2009, Two Nuclear Submarines Collided Under the Sea (2... by sealeck on Monday August 30, 2021 @07:41PM (#28362282)
Royal Navy subs have been known to surface directly underneath sailing boats in the Firth of Clyde (in Scotland).