I don't know how static vein patterns are, but in the particular case of varicose veins, my understanding is that they're existing veins that start to bulge outward. My guess would be that capillaries are pretty fungible, but the larger you get, the slower they'd change. For the best statistics, you'd probably want to incorporate the amount of time passing between two images, and model how much change is possible/reasonable. But there's plenty of signal to be had if you're careful to not overstate it.
I agree the she or the article are not making any claims. And she eventually got the study done.
But by appearing in court as expert witness and presenting her analysis, she implicitly claimed that it's accurate enough to be taken as criminal evidence, and that was before doing the science.
That's the dangerous part.
Nope. I had surgery one time to deal with a varicose vein of sorts. The key "engineering bug" was that the problem vein hits the collector vein at a 90° angle, instead of a "sliplane" (been playing too much mini motorways), causing congestion. The fix is to simply cut that connection. The body routes around it, increasing throughput through other networks. I don't think any entirely new routes were created, but I'm sure the size, geometry, and paths all changed.
Worked well for about 15 years before the primary issues resumed.
I'm yet to be convinced by the accuracy of this forensic method.
Like, it would be one thing if they could actually provide stats, bayesian analysis, p/r curves, etc.
What does that matter? Imagine some other characteristic that definitely changes over time lets say your clothing. The case in question had an expert saying: “Yes, the person recorded in the video is wearing the exact same clothes that we know the father was wearing the night of the incident, and that he is also wearing to court today. Now mind you, we dont know the exact statistical lilelihood that someone else would wear the exact same pants, shirt, tie, shoes and hat.” Your attempted counter argument is “yes ok, that is definitely the same clothes that the perpetrator was wearing and that the defendant wore that night and today, but he could change his clothes tomorrow, so…”
Consider some completely static characteristic. If the suspect is the perpetrator then there's an 100% chance they still have this characteristic, whereas if the suspect is innocent then there's a 10% chance they have this characteristic just by coincidence. Therefore if the suspect turns out to have this characteristic, you should update your prior to (1*0.01)/0.1 = 10%.
Compare to some dynamic characteristic. If the suspect is the perpetrator then there's an 20% chance they still have this characteristic, whereas if the suspect is innocent then there's a 10% chance they have this characteristic just by coincidence. Therefore if the suspect turns out to have this characteristic, you should update your prior to (0.2*0.01)/0.1 = 2%.
At the extreme, a completely dynamic characteristic. If the suspect is the perpetrator then there's a 10% chance they still have this characteristic, whereas if the suspect is innocent then there's a 10% chance they have this characteristic just by coincidence. Clearly in this case you shouldn't update your prior at all.
While a sample of 1000 to compare against is certainly small, it's in the ballpark where it's valid supporting evidence.
And if you want to make it better, maybe just contact Black and ask if/how you could submit your own sample?
To your point the study is so small it does not attempt to answer the question in whether veins are static.
There appears to be active research in this area in general. It does look like many companies and researchers are looking at ways to use vein patterns for bioinformatics
https://biosmart-tech.com/tpost/megjc72d91-palm-vein-scanner...
https://res.mdpi.com/d_attachment/applsci/applsci-10-03192/a...
Which means the trust you have in the team is a lot more important than the size of the dataset.
I don't know how checks and balances would look here. Maybe make available each analysis to the defendant and let him/his team check it out?
Like another commenter said in this thread, some people were convicted on DNA evidence of a hair that wasn't even human. A larger sample won't fix that.
> "That research had never been done. I could say no more than everything matched, and we couldn't say it definitely wasn't him”
This seems to be exactly correct. It explicits says that it was not possible given the information at time to confidently identify someone from a photo, but that there was enough information to positively rule out identification in some cases - and that that wasn’t the case here.
Except that the (accused, but innocent) "perpetrator" was a member of (ethnic group), as was the actual perpetrator, and it turned out that a high percentage of members of (ethnic group) exhibited this allegedly rare DNA feature.
But we're really sure that vein patterns are unique, and c'mon! he's a pedophile! so really we can stretch the point and appeal to authority and say "the science is settled" even if it is actually more complicated; because this one case justifies it right?
The implication there bugs me.
Edit: Are vein patterns even static? Seems to me "varicose veins" etc show that they change over the scale of years, at least, right?