Re:To catch a paedophile, you only need to look at their han...
by LorenPechtel on Sunday August 29, 2021 @12:46PM
(#28348261)
The size of the dataset sets the maximum odds of a false positive. We are seeing false positive problems with DNA and the FBI won't cooperate into investigating. (The problem comes from relatives--while two random people are astronomically unlikely to false positive close relatives are likely to have many matches anyway, the odds of a false positive are merely low, not astronomical.)
Which means the trust you have in the team is a lot more important than the size of the dataset.
I don't know how checks and balances would look here. Maybe make available each analysis to the defendant and let him/his team check it out?
Like another commenter said in this thread, some people were convicted on DNA evidence of a hair that wasn't even human. A larger sample won't fix that.