Re:To catch a paedophile, you only need to look at their han...
by treesprite82 on Sunday August 29, 2021 @01:30PM
(#28348691)
Assume we're starting with a 1% prior of some person being the the perpetrator of a crime.
Consider some completely static characteristic. If the suspect is the perpetrator then there's an 100% chance they still have this characteristic, whereas if the suspect is innocent then there's a 10% chance they have this characteristic just by coincidence. Therefore if the suspect turns out to have this characteristic, you should update your prior to (1*0.01)/0.1 = 10%.
Compare to some dynamic characteristic. If the suspect is the perpetrator then there's an 20% chance they still have this characteristic, whereas if the suspect is innocent then there's a 10% chance they have this characteristic just by coincidence. Therefore if the suspect turns out to have this characteristic, you should update your prior to (0.2*0.01)/0.1 = 2%.
At the extreme, a completely dynamic characteristic. If the suspect is the perpetrator then there's a 10% chance they still have this characteristic, whereas if the suspect is innocent then there's a 10% chance they have this characteristic just by coincidence. Clearly in this case you shouldn't update your prior at all.
Consider some completely static characteristic. If the suspect is the perpetrator then there's an 100% chance they still have this characteristic, whereas if the suspect is innocent then there's a 10% chance they have this characteristic just by coincidence. Therefore if the suspect turns out to have this characteristic, you should update your prior to (1*0.01)/0.1 = 10%.
Compare to some dynamic characteristic. If the suspect is the perpetrator then there's an 20% chance they still have this characteristic, whereas if the suspect is innocent then there's a 10% chance they have this characteristic just by coincidence. Therefore if the suspect turns out to have this characteristic, you should update your prior to (0.2*0.01)/0.1 = 2%.
At the extreme, a completely dynamic characteristic. If the suspect is the perpetrator then there's a 10% chance they still have this characteristic, whereas if the suspect is innocent then there's a 10% chance they have this characteristic just by coincidence. Clearly in this case you shouldn't update your prior at all.