Where 6 would be the scientific stance for most atheists imo.
>6. De facto atheist. Very low probability, but short of zero. "I don't know for certain but I think God is very improbable, and I live my life on the assumption that he is not there."
Old white loving fatherly figure watching me 24/7 in order to punish me if I don’t obey the orders of some cult? Probably not.
The sum of all laws of physics, known and unknown, along with all causation chains from the beginning off time, in all directions and interpretations of “time”, in all dimensions etc.? Count me in, I do see the sacredness of it all, in a completely impersonal way.
Love this answer on religion by Carl Sagan:
Also I believe in internet debate in general. So yes, it would be strange for me to be commenting if I denied that internet debate was useful
And to be clear, it definitely isn't meant literally - I'd apply the same logic to above poster: He's welcome to post here because he wants to and the community allows it.
I think a better question might be why you, and the above poster, think you're making a better determination about where this person can serve his community then he himself can make?
Full disclosure - I'm not religious either, but I do have family members serving as chaplains at universities.
Maybe all of the people they've ever known have been religious, those are their people.
Maybe they want to make a difference from the inside-out. A sheep in another sheep's clothing.