Re:Nauka's Troubled Flight–Before It Tumbled the ISS
by breput on Thursday August 26, 2021 @09:57PM
(#28323480)
Scott Manley's video[0] is interesting because he (among others) realized that the rotation was way more serious while the official 45° rotation story was still the news.
Re:Nauka's Troubled Flight–Before It Tumbled the ISS
by duxup on Thursday August 26, 2021 @09:51PM
(#28323443)
Considering the tensions surrounding NASA and other Russian space events I'm not surprised NASA might avoid pointing the finger a great deal, especially if Russians are going to reveal what happened on their own as described in this article.
Re:Nauka's Troubled Flight–Before It Tumbled the ISS
by breput on Thursday August 26, 2021 @10:13PM
(#28323586)
They won't.
By all accounts, Roscosmos is completely corrupt and NASA can't afford to lose Russia as an ISS partner.
You'll note that even though a SpaceX Crew Dragon was also attached to the ISS at the time, it was not used to counteract Nauka's thrust and the only mention of it was that it could be powered up quickly as an escape pod.
Part of that is due to the low lever-arm position of it, but I also believe it was probably never programmed to provide pitch and yaw support, and maybe not even altitude reboost. I am willing to bet that software is being written right now, though.
Re:Nauka's Troubled Flight–Before It Tumbled the ISS
by sephamorr on Friday August 27, 2021 @12:08AM
(#28324192)
Generally, capsules that burn up in the atmosphere rather than landing are useful for boosting, but if you have to have a heat shield on the bottom of your spacecraft (and the docking port generally on the top), you can't have thrusters that point along the center of mass line of the station. Dragon's thrusters aren't quite so well pointed due to this problem, so boosting with dragon would be very inefficient.
Re:Nauka's Troubled Flight–Before It Tumbled the ISS
by breput on Friday August 27, 2021 @01:03AM
(#28324463)
You're probably not wrong but there are Draco/Super Draco engines all around the Dragon capsule and some combination of those could probably be used to for any thrust vector.
Re:Nauka's Troubled Flight–Before It Tumbled the ISS
by mlindner on Thursday August 26, 2021 @07:13PM
(#28322221)
Really good summary of a lot of details from the Russian language side of what happened with the module. Though the author seems to use a bunch of what appears to be poorly machine translated quotes.
Re:Nauka's Troubled Flight–Before It Tumbled the ISS
by toss1 on Friday August 27, 2021 @09:43AM
(#28327708)
With that long list of problems and failed sensors & software on the Nauka module, the Russian team's hands-on real-time efforts to keep the thing functionally flying seem quite impressive - sharp save-the-day work.
That said, allowing the thing to dock before they could implement more stable fixes seems quite unwise - and especially just before a flight path out of communication with the team. Why couldn't they just wait a few orbits or days?
Seems as unwise as launching a shuttle in out-of-spec cold conditions, they just barely got away with it this time. I recall seeing a recent high level criticism of NASA losing (again) its safety culture - seems like another supporting data point for that thesis.
Re:Nauka's Troubled Flight–Before It Tumbled the ISS
by trhway on Thursday August 26, 2021 @08:53PM
(#28323049)
you would hesitate to download and install a Russian app, yet it seems ok to attach a Russian module to ISS :) Supposedly because Russian module for ISS passed stricter checks. According to whom? Russian team has just participated in Olympics without state flag and symbols because of doping testing scandal. The sport and space are among the main pillars of the Russian state self-glorification, and everything goes when it comes to face-saving there.
In the second half of the 199x i had an acquaintance who was director of a department building some electronic systems for Russian space. He told me a lot of backstories of how the Russian space sausage was being made. From sourcing parts for the Mir station at the local flea market ("Avtovo" who still remembers) to "what do you want, the whole year the salaries weren't paid and nobody was working, and a month before the launch they pay the salaries and the satellite is hastily built, no testing to speak of, and launched, of course it quickly failed". These days the situation with salaries is a bit better while the rest is pretty much the same, and the surfacing story with Nauka sounds just like one of those backstories. And that is on top of that hole in a Russian module sometime ago - one can see the progression from the hole affecting ISS's air to the badly behaving Nauka affecting ISS's position to ...
Re:Nauka's Troubled Flight–Before It Tumbled the ISS
by diskzero on Thursday August 26, 2021 @11:29PM
(#28324012)
It is hard to comprehend how many of the space-related feats of engineering were accomplished by the Soviet Union. On a trip to the Baikonur Cosmodrome, I was stunned by the size of the test stand for the Energia rocket. It is massive, with numerous support buildings, lighting, pipelines and support vehicles. The amount of poured concrete is mind boggling. This stand was only used once.
The actual launch stand for Energia is similar in scope and it was only used twice. Of course, during the first Energia-Polyus launch, Polyus seperated from Energia, did a 360 degress rotation and burned up in the atmosphere. It is difficult to reconcile this mixture of competence and incompetence.
Re:Nauka's Troubled Flight–Before It Tumbled the ISS
by LeoPanthera on Thursday August 26, 2021 @09:28PM
(#28323285)
The "I" in "ISS" stands for International. It is a collaboration between the USA, Russia, Japan, Europe, and Canada, with the USA and Russia being responsible for most of its initial construction.
It is one of the crowning achievements of humanity so far and helps to prove that we don't all suffer from the same petty xenophobia that your comment demonstrates.
Re:Nauka's Troubled Flight–Before It Tumbled the ISS
by quacked on Thursday August 26, 2021 @10:01PM
(#28323505)
I worked as a cog in the ISS program for three years and every ex-Soviet or Russian employee we had working for us would agree with the comment you're responding to- I totally understand how it seems like a rude comment but it's grounded in reality.
Re:Nauka's Troubled Flight–Before It Tumbled the ISS
by PhantomGremlin on Thursday August 26, 2021 @09:49PM
(#28323419)
petty xenophobia
Was it facts? How does stating the facts of how things were done in the late stages of the USSR space program and are done in the current Russian space program translate to petty xenophobia?
If you want xenophobia, didn't the Russians accuse us of drilling holes in their space station module? Or was that just domestic propaganda?
Re:Nauka's Troubled Flight–Before It Tumbled the ISS
by iaml on Friday August 27, 2021 @12:01AM
(#28324160)
Not sure why you are downvoted, this whole situation was making rounds in media and resurfaced recently, seemingly connected with this whole Nauka module drama. They've been insinuating[0][1][2] pretty hard through the government controlled media that "someone" drilled a hole in russian module so that they would send them to Earth because they are depressed? Pretty wild if you ask me, especially considering they checked the hole from outside and it turns out it was covered with some material afterwards and probably was there at the point of launch.
Re:Nauka's Troubled Flight–Before It Tumbled the ISS
by hnbad on Friday August 27, 2021 @04:02AM
(#28325390)
Just to make sure we're all aware that the US also engages in absurdist finger-pointing (even post-war), let's remember the time the US embassy in Cuba claimed that it was being attacked with scientifically impossible sonic weapons or even microwave radiation.
Re:Nauka's Troubled Flight–Before It Tumbled the ISS
by m0zg on Thursday August 26, 2021 @11:58PM
(#28324144)
Up until May of last year the United States didn't even have human launch capability. Not a hell of a lot you can do with an orbital station if you can't send people up there.
> From sourcing parts for the Mir station at the local flea market
They use mil-spec parts for that, and you can't buy them at a "flea market".
> the whole year the salaries weren't paid and nobody was working
This, on the other hand, is plausible. 90s were a shitshow, hence Putin and "order".
Re:Nauka's Troubled Flight–Before It Tumbled the ISS
by trhway on Friday August 27, 2021 @01:45AM
(#28324665)
>They use mil-spec parts for that, and you can't buy them at a "flea market".
you probably just don't know what you're talking about. I've used mil-spec parts in my teenage hobby electronic projects in 198x.
The parts in the Mir story were already not available from manufacturer, nor there were any spare parts stores as most of the stuff was already stolen like many things back then in Russia (and many of those things ended on flea markets or sold for scrap). Fortunately, they were able to find those parts on that large flea market ("na razvalah" of old electronics, back then Avtovo was the place https://sudonull.com/post/160488-St-Petersburg-radio-market-...) in particular because the parts were already outdated for consumer use by that time.
Re:Nauka's Troubled Flight–Before It Tumbled the ISS
by m0zg on Friday August 27, 2021 @02:00AM
(#28324751)
Not _those_ parts. We're talking ceramic cased hardened ICs with gold plated leads and stuff like that (see https://habr.com/ru/post/156049/). Stuff that goes into space and to nuclear power stations in particular is the very highest grade available, no expense spared. You may still find it at flea markets from time to time (surplus or desoldered), but you're unlikely to find it in quantity. Russia does not build its weapons and space tech from "flea market" grade parts. It never did. It's one of the very few areas of the economy that haven't completely fallen apart during the 90s, long delays in payroll notwithstanding.
Re:Nauka's Troubled Flight–Before It Tumbled the ISS
by trhway on Friday August 27, 2021 @02:19AM
(#28324846)
>Not _those_ parts.
well, one of the source of our parts were missile guidance modules from a used hardware dumps in our Navy base town :)
>Russia does not build its weapons and space tech from "flea market" grade parts.
don't worry, the parts were real deal, just not available through official channels anymore, and they bought on the flea market much more parts than was needed, tested all of them and sent to the Mir those which tested best. After all they were old school professionals. The people like this was that part "that haven't completely fallen apart during the 90s", and which brought the country through the 90s.
And wrt. weapons - nobody probably told you about electronic bays completely gutted in 90s for the "gold plated contacts" electronics even on active duty military systems like Navy ships for example. The things did fall apart during 90s much more than you seem to be imagining.
>Stuff that goes into space and to nuclear power stations in particular is the very highest grade available, no expense spared.
and that reminded me about the nuclear powered cruiser "Petr the Great". At some point i worked together with 2 accountants who had before been accountants at that Navy yards which was building "Petr the Great" and they worked on that project. They told me a lot, in particular about the state the cruiser was launched and delivered at (like completely missing almost all electronics as it was stolen each time despite having been ordered several times). Anyway, publicly available, that is just a minor item compare to the whole picture - rupture of the steam pipe of the ship's power plant killing 5 because the pipe had thinner walls and was of worse quality metal than what was specified in the design doc. https://lenta.ru/articles/2004/03/24/petr/
Re:Nauka's Troubled Flight–Before It Tumbled the ISS
by m0zg on Friday August 27, 2021 @02:42AM
(#28324986)
It's you who's "imagining" things. I actually was _there_ in the 90s, getting through university with a specialization in weapons design (rocket guidance systems mostly). My summer practice (aka "internship" in the West, I suppose, except you don't get to choose where to go) was at weapons design bureaus, which were somewhat decrepit at the time, but most definitely did not have the need to shop for surplus parts of unknown quality. In fact, even if you wanted to, at those places you couldn't bring anything in or out. Not even notes.
Yeah, yeah, man. As we all know pipes never rupture in the West, and there are never any crappy O-rings in Shuttle boosters. Ceramic tiles never fall off, either.
Re:Nauka's Troubled Flight–Before It Tumbled the ISS
by monkeycantype on Friday August 27, 2021 @05:40AM
(#28325855)
So my personal anecdote is from 1990, but yes in the nineties you can buy milspec gear at the flea market
(I really wanted the tank periscope with night vision but couldn’t afford it)
Re:Nauka's Troubled Flight–Before It Tumbled the ISS
by relativ575 on Friday August 27, 2021 @01:26AM
(#28324569)
> Up until May of last year the United States didn't even have human launch capability
NASA could have kept the Shuttle after 2011 if there were no other options. They figured they could rely on Soyuz for a few years until Starliner and Crew Dragon were ready. It's worth noting that during this time Roscosmos, like a true capitalist, jacked up Soyuz seat price to $90 million from the low of $21.3 million - [0]
Re:Nauka's Troubled Flight–Before It Tumbled the ISS
by m0zg on Friday August 27, 2021 @01:57AM
(#28324729)
Coulda, woulda. They didn't. And Shuttle cost $1B per launch. That is nuts even by US government standards. That's also why the USSR abandoned theirs, even though theirs was much cheaper - no need for three dozen subcontractors to each make a hefty profit.
[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dDBt9rZhMb4
By all accounts, Roscosmos is completely corrupt and NASA can't afford to lose Russia as an ISS partner.
You'll note that even though a SpaceX Crew Dragon was also attached to the ISS at the time, it was not used to counteract Nauka's thrust and the only mention of it was that it could be powered up quickly as an escape pod.
Part of that is due to the low lever-arm position of it, but I also believe it was probably never programmed to provide pitch and yaw support, and maybe not even altitude reboost. I am willing to bet that software is being written right now, though.
Dragon has a very minimal trunk with no thrusters. As a result, the best thrusters it has are 30 degrees off.
That said, allowing the thing to dock before they could implement more stable fixes seems quite unwise - and especially just before a flight path out of communication with the team. Why couldn't they just wait a few orbits or days?
Seems as unwise as launching a shuttle in out-of-spec cold conditions, they just barely got away with it this time. I recall seeing a recent high level criticism of NASA losing (again) its safety culture - seems like another supporting data point for that thesis.
In the second half of the 199x i had an acquaintance who was director of a department building some electronic systems for Russian space. He told me a lot of backstories of how the Russian space sausage was being made. From sourcing parts for the Mir station at the local flea market ("Avtovo" who still remembers) to "what do you want, the whole year the salaries weren't paid and nobody was working, and a month before the launch they pay the salaries and the satellite is hastily built, no testing to speak of, and launched, of course it quickly failed". These days the situation with salaries is a bit better while the rest is pretty much the same, and the surfacing story with Nauka sounds just like one of those backstories. And that is on top of that hole in a Russian module sometime ago - one can see the progression from the hole affecting ISS's air to the badly behaving Nauka affecting ISS's position to ...
The actual launch stand for Energia is similar in scope and it was only used twice. Of course, during the first Energia-Polyus launch, Polyus seperated from Energia, did a 360 degress rotation and burned up in the atmosphere. It is difficult to reconcile this mixture of competence and incompetence.
It is one of the crowning achievements of humanity so far and helps to prove that we don't all suffer from the same petty xenophobia that your comment demonstrates.
Was it facts? How does stating the facts of how things were done in the late stages of the USSR space program and are done in the current Russian space program translate to petty xenophobia?
If you want xenophobia, didn't the Russians accuse us of drilling holes in their space station module? Or was that just domestic propaganda?
[0] https://www.rbc.ru/rbcfreenews/6115d42b9a794727d1266340
[1] https://www.gazeta.ru/science/news/2018/09/04/n_11990893.sht...
[2] https://www.gazeta.ru/science/news/2018/09/03/n_11988091.sht...
> From sourcing parts for the Mir station at the local flea market
They use mil-spec parts for that, and you can't buy them at a "flea market".
> the whole year the salaries weren't paid and nobody was working
This, on the other hand, is plausible. 90s were a shitshow, hence Putin and "order".
you probably just don't know what you're talking about. I've used mil-spec parts in my teenage hobby electronic projects in 198x.
The parts in the Mir story were already not available from manufacturer, nor there were any spare parts stores as most of the stuff was already stolen like many things back then in Russia (and many of those things ended on flea markets or sold for scrap). Fortunately, they were able to find those parts on that large flea market ("na razvalah" of old electronics, back then Avtovo was the place https://sudonull.com/post/160488-St-Petersburg-radio-market-...) in particular because the parts were already outdated for consumer use by that time.
Mir has been decommissioned 20 years ago, your information on "how the sausage is being made" is from a different century.
well, one of the source of our parts were missile guidance modules from a used hardware dumps in our Navy base town :)
>Russia does not build its weapons and space tech from "flea market" grade parts.
don't worry, the parts were real deal, just not available through official channels anymore, and they bought on the flea market much more parts than was needed, tested all of them and sent to the Mir those which tested best. After all they were old school professionals. The people like this was that part "that haven't completely fallen apart during the 90s", and which brought the country through the 90s.
And wrt. weapons - nobody probably told you about electronic bays completely gutted in 90s for the "gold plated contacts" electronics even on active duty military systems like Navy ships for example. The things did fall apart during 90s much more than you seem to be imagining.
>Stuff that goes into space and to nuclear power stations in particular is the very highest grade available, no expense spared.
and that reminded me about the nuclear powered cruiser "Petr the Great". At some point i worked together with 2 accountants who had before been accountants at that Navy yards which was building "Petr the Great" and they worked on that project. They told me a lot, in particular about the state the cruiser was launched and delivered at (like completely missing almost all electronics as it was stolen each time despite having been ordered several times). Anyway, publicly available, that is just a minor item compare to the whole picture - rupture of the steam pipe of the ship's power plant killing 5 because the pipe had thinner walls and was of worse quality metal than what was specified in the design doc. https://lenta.ru/articles/2004/03/24/petr/
Yeah, yeah, man. As we all know pipes never rupture in the West, and there are never any crappy O-rings in Shuttle boosters. Ceramic tiles never fall off, either.
NASA could have kept the Shuttle after 2011 if there were no other options. They figured they could rely on Soyuz for a few years until Starliner and Crew Dragon were ready. It's worth noting that during this time Roscosmos, like a true capitalist, jacked up Soyuz seat price to $90 million from the low of $21.3 million - [0]
[0] - https://spaceflightnow.com/2020/10/13/nasa-uses-final-purcha...