News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We Hire Old People by fossuser on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @02:10PM (#28304891)
I've also thought this would be an interesting approach, even explicitly.

The laws on age discrimination are about discriminating against old people, but not about discriminating against young people.

If age discrimination is real, that means that people are not valuing older people properly - they're undervaluing them. You could have roles that are explicitly only hiring people 40+ and that restriction would be legal (at least as I understand it).

I think this would be interesting to try.

Re:We Hire Old People by Alex3917 on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @02:23PM (#28305051)
> If age discrimination is real, that means that people are not valuing older people properly - they're undervaluing them

While age discrimination is certainly real, I think it's also conflated with the fact that there just isn't a lot of demand for people who are good at their jobs in general.

I'd liken it to how, if you take up baking, then on pretty much your first try you can make a pie that's better than the pie from almost every commercial bakery. The reason for that isn't because home bakers have more knowledge of baking techniques than professional bakers -- they don't, not by a long shot. It's because if only 1 in 100 people is willing to actually pay enough to make it profitable to make properly made baked good, then there just aren't many situations where you can build a business around doing that.

In other words, older people might not be less employable in spite of the fact that they're better at their jobs, but because they're better at their jobs.

Re:We Hire Old People by jfengel on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @04:01PM (#28306194)
I think you chose a slightly funny example. Pie crust is a bit of a challenge to get right. Your first one is definitely going to be ugly, and there's a very good chance that it will be tough. Filling is easy, but crusts require experience to know how much is the right amount (of water, of kneading, of rolling).

Most home bakers get better results with frozen pie crust. A great home baker can do better, but not on the first try.

Cookies, on the other hand... yeah, if you can read and follow instructions at the level of a third grader, you can make great cookies.

Re:We Hire Old People by MattGaiser on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @03:20PM (#28305729)
Yep. I had to demonstrate competence in system design and scaling for my current role. We haven't touched that stuff at all as nobody has wanted to pay for that upfront and when scale has been needed, they have just added compute.
Re:We Hire Old People by Alex3917 on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @03:24PM (#28305776)
Right, and that's not even the difficult part of doing a startup. I did a software dev interview where they asked me if I had any questions, and I said something along the lines of "I notice that if you look at Mark Zuckerberg's reading list, he's reading books about things like the history of the Islamic golden age, whereas you're asking me questions about javascript syntax. Do you actually think the latter is more important?" And then they kicked me out halfway through the interview.
Re:We Hire Old People by MattGaiser on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @03:35PM (#28305905)
DO they really want the opinions of developers for anything non-technical?

My current startup hired me partially on account of product experience. I’ve been an exclusively technical resource.

Re:We Hire Old People by marcosdumay on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @02:23PM (#28305042)
If the entire market is discriminating against old people, you don't need any discrimination to fill those roles with them. You just need to ignore age and filter for competence.
Re:We Hire Old People by fossuser on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @02:26PM (#28305090)
Ideally yes, but if the discrimination is there in the process (by recruiters/interviewers intentional or not) then that's hard to do. People will think they're 'ignoring age and filtering for competence' when they're not totally.

If you tell recruiters "this role can only be filled by someone 40+" it immediately forces that competence filter within those bounds. If there is a lot of under valued talent there that could be a strategic hiring advantage.

Obviously don't do this for all roles, but some age restricted 'tribal elder' roles or something for each team would be interesting imo.

Re:We Hire Old People by marcosdumay on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @03:02PM (#28305533)
Oh, sure, when the entire society is discriminating, not discriminating may require active initiative. Things like this one "we don't care if you are old" announcement surely help.

But you don't need to discriminate on the reverse direction, and doing that is probably harmful.

Re:We Hire Old People by fossuser on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @05:12PM (#28307074)
I definitely agree with this sentiment in nearly every case - goal of society should be one where these kinds of characteristics are irrelevant and discriminating in some other way to correct is generally a bad idea.

It was mostly a thought experiment about how a software company could gain a hiring advantage in a clever way (if old people are undervalued by the market for dumb reasons). At least in the case of age the categories are clear (as opposed to more nebulous socially defined groupings of people).

Re:We Hire Old People by ritchie1270 on Friday August 27, 2021 @02:14PM (#28331200)
Seems to me that "we prefer older workers for this position" looks a lot like affirmative action. Do you feel the same about that?
Re:We Hire Old People by marcosdumay on Friday August 27, 2021 @03:18PM (#28331905)
Depends on how you communicate "prefer". I would not write that in an ad without context, and it would fell like a very assholey thing to say in a rejection (similar to "you don't have culture fit").
Re:We Hire Old People by foobarian on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @02:21PM (#28305018)
How awkward would it be to have the 35+ requirement be outlawed. Would certainly be interesting to read those legal arguments.

Edit: I meant 35+ not 40+. Updated.

Re:We Hire Old People by TheDong on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @02:24PM (#28305067)
It would be quite tricky to outlaw.

It's perfectly legal to have "years of experience" requirement, so for example you could have a requirement of: "Communication with spoken language is a valuable part of the job. We require all applicants to have 35+ years of experience speaking one or more languages".

That's practically a requirement that you're 40/45+ without ever mentioning age.

Re:We Hire Old People by gmadsen on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @03:03PM (#28305547)
That seems like a court case at least. You would need to prove there is any difference in language skill from someone with 15 years versus 35 years, otherwise it is just an age requirement superficially disguised as a needed skill requirement
Re:We Hire Old People by bachmeier on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @03:59PM (#28306170)
> That seems like a court case at least.

For what? Youth is not a protected class. Discriminate against them all you want.

> You would need to prove there is any difference in language skill from someone with 15 years versus 35 years, otherwise it is just an age requirement superficially disguised as a needed skill requirement

Age discrimination is different from other discrimination cases. It's really hard to win, for instance[1]. The company doesn't have to prove anything. The worker would have to prove that it was explicit age discrimination. For other types of discrimination, like race, the only thing that needs to be shown is differences in outcomes.

[1] https://www.nextavenue.org/what-it-takes-win-age-discriminat...

Re:We Hire Old People by freeopinion on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @04:26PM (#28306474)
Are you referring to the constitutional requirement for USA presidential candidates?