News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Noam Chomsky – Startup Culture (2015) [video] by nkmnz on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @01:56AM (#28298447)
If governments are such good bodies of innovation, then why are countries with relatively more powerful governmental sectors less innovative? Why do deregulation and privatization almost always lead to more innovation? Not saying there are no downsides to weak governments, but Chomsky’s “cum hoc, ergo propter hoc” is not backed by any kind of thorough investigations of things that move - if the “cum” changes it’s nature over time from state-like to private entities, success grows. As always, interdependent systems are much more complicated - especially if you knew how little government actually did for Sicilian valley and MIT except for putting shit loads of money on the table. Incentives, ideas, Innovations - none of them came from parliaments, ministries or other governmental bodies, if they were not heavily emulating private structures.
Re:Noam Chomsky – Startup Culture (2015) [video] by tehjoker on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @02:06AM (#28298488)
I would posit that Chomsky has performed far more research on this question than you have. Your assertions require citations, but even if true, they ignore the role of wealth and power in the world that allows highly advanced rich countries to dominate science and technology. Furthermore, the obvious counterexample of the USSR showed that state finance of science allowed it to compete toe to toe with the US for quite some time.
Re:Noam Chomsky – Startup Culture (2015) [video] by nkmnz on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @02:31PM (#28305156)
Maybe the burden of proof is on you/Chomsky to show that governmental bodies - parliaments, ministries and alike - did provide more than just money.
Re:Noam Chomsky – Startup Culture (2015) [video] by tehjoker on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @02:55PM (#28305462)
In fairness, I have difficulty finding a book where he discusses this but he has a good interview: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Av96iIRa0f8
Re:Noam Chomsky – Startup Culture (2015) [video] by cycomanic on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @05:08AM (#28299417)
If you look at who innovates in the "hardware" space, it's often not US companies. I mean worldwide manufacturing is build around machines build and designed in Germany for example. I think what SC is particularly good at is growing very quickly to immense scale, because there is so much money floating around. That is also the reason why they put this into software, because the risks and timescales are much shorter. In hardware you likely have to put in years of R&D before you might see a RoI. In software that goes much quicker and because evaluation is based on "reach" you don't really need to make a profit, you just need to develop enough reach that someone else will pay you back your investment. Often much of the startup scene especially in software seems like a giant ponzi scheme, i.e. you never actually need to make a profitable business, it's always just about selling to the next investor at a higher price (see Uber for example).
Re:Noam Chomsky – Startup Culture (2015) [video] by nkmnz on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @02:36PM (#28305227)
Germany is a relatively free country, especially if you compare the last 50 years of economic policy to it’s neighbors such as France or the GDR. While the latter example is self evident, the former has a long history of governmental mandated innovation as well - did not ensure a lot of competitiveness...
Re:Noam Chomsky – Startup Culture (2015) [video] by cycomanic on Thursday August 26, 2021 @07:04AM (#28313212)
If you think France is not a free country and does not have a lot of innovation, you need to do some serious reading. France is the 3rd largest economy in Europe, has essentially the same GDP per capita as Canada (slightly below Germany).
Re:Noam Chomsky – Startup Culture (2015) [video] by nkmnz on Friday August 27, 2021 @03:07AM (#28325136)
The issue seems to be in the term “relatively”. I never said France was an unfree or poor country. I just said that Frances policies _in the past_ were heavily in favor of huge national corporations. Even though Germany had to adopt the GDR, it’s GDP per capita is >18% higher than Frances.

Edit: sorry, the ussr commented was someone else.

Re:Noam Chomsky – Startup Culture (2015) [video] by actually_a_dog on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @02:10AM (#28298512)
You realize you're using the descendant of a computer network created by the US government so that military command and control could survive a nuclear attack, right? I could give lots more examples of things you use every day that were developed or funded by the US government, if you like.
Re:Noam Chomsky – Startup Culture (2015) [video] by tored on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @04:34AM (#28299230)
That is all true, but the government is incapable of commercialization, so there isn't an alternative reality where we would have consumer wide spread state network if it wasn't privatized. And I think it is there Chomsky is wrong when calling it parasitic, when it is actually a symbiosis.
Re:Noam Chomsky – Startup Culture (2015) [video] by actually_a_dog on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @04:45AM (#28299297)
The government is only incapable of commercialization because we put artificial limits on it doing so. While we're spinning up hypotheticals, isn't there an alternative reality where we have an even better, free to access (because it's funded by everyone's taxes), ubiquitous internet? Wouldn't that be better than the status quo?
Re:Noam Chomsky – Startup Culture (2015) [video] by tored on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @05:20AM (#28299467)
What is status quo? Why is it bad? Why would it be free just because it is funded by taxes?

It is true that it does exist some limitations on what kind of commercial interest the government can execute. Some by law (in Sweden for what a Kommun (city) can do, can't own property abroad), and some by agreement with other states (e.g. EU).

Some of these limitations are necessary because there is a huge risk that politicians start gambling with tax payer money on high risk enterprises, we have many examples of that is Sweden, especially on the Kommun (city) level.

That is usually why subsidies are preferred, because you transfer a large part of the risk to the private sector, the drawback is of course the the government doesn't share the earnings of that private company if successful, however because the government has the right to tax it does but indirectly.

In Sweden the government subsidies broadband expansion but it is private companies that does the actual digging and then other private companies runs the broadband connection. The private consumer still needs to pay some sum to connect to the house, but heavily subsidized, that way you avoid unnecessary connections.

There does exist a risk that state subsidies can create corruption, tax payers buys unwanted things from private companies, that is why it is important with a structured and transparent process regarding subsidies.

However there is limitation on subsidies by agreement, with the membership in EU Sweden can no loger subsidy sectors to the same extent it could do previously and that is bad.

I don't think Sweden's large broadband expansion would be possible if it was state run only. It would be like the old Televerket (the previously state run telecommunication company), slow, sleepy and not interested in solving problems for the consumer. But with the government injecting capital to the private sector the broadband expansion is mostly succesful.

Re:Noam Chomsky – Startup Culture (2015) [video] by actually_a_dog on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @07:33AM (#28300269)
Before I answer what is the status quo, I'll just ask: why wouldn't internet access be free to access if it's taxpayer funded? Remember, we were constructing hypotheticals here, and there's no reason the government needs to make a profit on something like this, any more than it makes a profit on roads and bridges [0].

Now, on to the status quo. In what follows, I'm going to consider broadband only. Dialup exists, but isn't particularly interesting because, well... it sucks.

Among the problems the US has with broadband is that only 25 million out of around 330 million of us actually access the internet at broadband (25Mbps+) speeds [1]. The reasons for this are up for debate, but the most logical explanations would seem to be lack of access, lack of affordability, or a combination of both.

Another problem we have is a lack of competition among broadband providers. According to [2], 83 million Americans only have a single broadband internet provider available to them. If that's, say, Comcast, a company not well known for its stellar customer service, to put it mildly [3], then your choice amounts to either deal with the devil and take whatever they offer you, or just don't have broadband.

So, how did we get here? I'm not one to just reflexively say "blame the gubmint," but, in this case, it's true. There was competition in the cable industry in the mid 1990's, until the Telecommunications Act of 1996, an astoundingly complex piece of legislation, scrambled the regulatory environment that was present, ultimately allowing all the regional cable providers that existed before then to consolidate and form the giants we have today: AT&T, Comcast, Charter, and the rest.

Well, great! There are lots of cable companies, so that means there's lots of competition, right? Wrong. These companies co-evolved together and created a situation where each one has lots of local monopolies [4], leading to the situation today, where, paradoxically, there are quite a few cable companies, but consumers frequently only have one to choose from.

And, so, we reach the end of our journey, in which the country that literally invented the internet has extremely slow and expensive broadband internet [5].

In a broader sense, one may ask "how did we get into such a situation?" And, if I may speculate a bit, I believe it's because we have not regarded broadband internet access as a utility.

Before I get into that, I want to quickly mention that since starting a broadband ISP involves huge capital costs in the form of last mile infrastructure [6] (e.g. if Comcast and AT&T want to compete in a certain area, both need to lay down their own cable infrastructure to do so, because neither one wants to share), and significant economies of scale. This leads to them being what's called "natural monopolies." And, surprise, surprise, this is exactly what I mentioned happened!

Now, monopolies can tend to be bad for consumers, but, in the case of natural monopolies, competition is either impractically expensive or fairly impossible. For instance, you don't want more than 1 municipal water company, because then you need to have twice as much water pipe and twice as much purification and pumping infrastructure, and that's just plain wasteful. For something like cable/telecom, it's more that duplicating that last mile is just silly, and would generally be ridiculously expensive, so, the companies just don't do it.

So, you're left with this monopoly sitting here and your consumer over there in need of some kind of protection from it, lest otherwise the water company raise the price of water to $1000/l or something, because it's decided that would be the most profitable thing to do.

There are really only a couple things you can do here:

* Regulate the monopoly by, for instance, limiting price increases and mandating a certain quality of service, minimum coverage areas, that they sell access to their networks for a reasonable cost, or whatever.

* Or, take it over and make it a municipal utility, thus eliminating the profit motive to raise prices to ridiculous levels.

But, we've done none of these things. So, I'm stuck with Comcast, and life sucks. THE END.

Now, tell me, do you think we might be able to improve upon this system just a little bit, or no? ;-)

---

[0]: Yes, toll roads and bridges exist, but those are generally either run by private companies, or the tolls go toward paying off bond issues taken out to fund them, not to make a profit.

[1]: https://www.allconnect.com/blog/americas-broadband-divide-re...

[2]: https://ilsr.org/report-most-americans-have-no-real-choice-i...

[3]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criticism_of_Comcast#Low_custo...

[4]: https://www.npr.org/transcripts/899472976

[5]: https://www.broadbandsearch.net/blog/internet-costs-compared...

[6]: I'm kinda ignoring satellite and cellular for now, so bear with me.

[7]: https://www.investopedia.com/terms/n/natural_monopoly.asp

Re:Noam Chomsky – Startup Culture (2015) [video] by taffer on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @07:54AM (#28300461)
> why wouldn't internet access be free to access if it's taxpayer funded?

For the same reason that electricity isn't free: it's a scarce resource that needs to be allocated in a sensible way. And yes, you are of course right that Internet access is a natural monopoly, but if you look at which countries are really good in this area (like Sweden, Finland or South Korea), it is never a state monopoly, but well-regulated private companies.

Re:Noam Chomsky – Startup Culture (2015) [video] by actually_a_dog on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @08:01AM (#28300533)
Free at the point of use. Funded by taxes. You left that part out. There's no reason that instead of paying $80/month to Comcast that the municipal government can't tax me, say, $600/year for broadband.
Re:Noam Chomsky – Startup Culture (2015) [video] by taffer on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @08:16AM (#28300669)
I don't understand what point you are trying to make. Why should the municipality be better at providing Internet access than any other company?
Re:Noam Chomsky – Startup Culture (2015) [video] by zoolily on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @01:53PM (#28304615)
Look at Chatanooga, TN's munipcal broadband for an example of how a government can be better. As for why, broadband is typically a monopoly or duopoly (phone + cable), which private companies take advantage of by raising prices and spending less money upgrading their networks. Since the municipality isn't limited by shareholders to focus purely on profit, it can invest in infrastructure that's not profitable, such as by providing Internet access to low population areas.
Re:Noam Chomsky – Startup Culture (2015) [video] by actually_a_dog on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @08:41AM (#28300891)
Why should they be any worse? If it's a municipal utility, you eliminate a profit motive, which naturally helps control prices and promote access.
Re:Noam Chomsky – Startup Culture (2015) [video] by taffer on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @10:00AM (#28301791)
Ideally, there is some competition between multiple providers to drive innovation and efficiency, and that's what regulators are trying to achieve. So you get the best of both worlds.
Re:Noam Chomsky – Startup Culture (2015) [video] by actually_a_dog on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @10:05AM (#28301846)
You did notice the bit about ISPs being a natural monopoly, though? What material difference is there between a privately owned, but well regulated monopoly, and a government owned enterprise, except the lack of profit motive on the part of the latter?
Re:Noam Chomsky – Startup Culture (2015) [video] by taffer on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @10:49AM (#28302362)
The goal of regulation here is to create competition between multiple providers. Remember that only the last mile to your home is a natural monopoly which can be awarded through public tenders. Everything else, such as the backbone and actual sales to the end customer, is not a natural monopoly, and monopolizing these areas would actually be detrimental to the customer.
Re:Noam Chomsky – Startup Culture (2015) [video] by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @01:24PM (#28304259)
> While we're spinning up hypotheticals, isn't there an alternative reality where we have an even better, free to access (because it's funded by everyone's taxes), ubiquitous internet?

France's Minitel?

> Wouldn't that be better than the status quo?

It wasn't.

Re:Noam Chomsky – Startup Culture (2015) [video] by nkmnz on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @05:16PM (#28307137)
You realize that you use speech, which was invented before there where governments?

You see, your argument is of very little use - while it’s still not shown that funding wasn’t the most important task. AFAIK the processes by which grants have been provided for military research have been highly competitive, i.e. market-based.

Re:Noam Chomsky – Startup Culture (2015) [video] by diordiderot on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @02:37AM (#28298611)
> why do deregulation and privatization always lead to more innovation

This is called shiny object capitalism. Look at who produces novel therapies and drugs.

The success of the 21st was built on piles and piles of cold war government handouts

https://podcasts.google.com/feed/aHR0cHM6Ly9jaXRhdGlvbnNuZWV...

Re:Noam Chomsky – Startup Culture (2015) [video] by turbinerneiter on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @02:48AM (#28298676)
This.

Innivation is fueled by money. Innovation is risky. Private investors need a return on their investment. Public doesn't need a direct financial return.

Hence innovation thrives wherever there is money with little strings attached. For smaller sums, private investors can do that (think about an accelerator that gives 1 million to 10 startups). For bigger sums, you need a space race against a foreign power funded by the gov.