News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A bike parts company ditched Amazon to support indie shop... by tacker2000 on Monday August 23, 2021 @02:55PM (#28280347)
This doenst surprise me at all. There are more and more sellers that are frustrated with how amazon deals with them.

Amazons top priority is the customer, and thats how they got to this point, but everyone else suffers, from their 3rd party sellers to their suppliers to their own employees.

Here is a list of stuff Amazon does:

-Anti competitive behaviour on the buy box (Amazon doesnt have the product in stock. You have it, but your offer is still not shown)

-Banning sellers for no good reason, and you cant contact anyone helpful

-Screwing over their suppliers with Vendor Central, where they buy from you wholesale. They dont pay, they just say the goods were never delivered and dont accept your proof of delivery. I know sellers who are owed over 30k from amazon.

-Customers are able to send back items 1 year later. If you dont agree, they can file an “AZ claim”. If you get too manu claims, they ban you.

-Support for sellers is the worst combination of overseas call centers using some cookie cutter templates to answer questions. Often you are just copy pasting your question 5 times, until you get somebody with have a brain

-Use data from their sellers to create their own products and then force them out of the market

-creating huge incentives for chinese sellers which flood and undercut the local sellers

Its just a huge behemoth were nobody knows whats going on.

In my opinion this company needs to be split up by gov and reigned in.

But who knows, maybe more sellers will follow suit and the pressure will be increasing to change things.

Re:A bike parts company ditched Amazon to support indie shop... by freeopinion on Monday August 23, 2021 @03:31PM (#28280816)
> Amazons top priority is the customer

This is not and should not be true. If it were true, Amazon would operate completely differently. It should be more true than it is.

Re:A bike parts company ditched Amazon to support indie shop... by munk-a on Monday August 23, 2021 @03:35PM (#28280852)
For at least one specific example - Amazon does an extremely poor job vetting products posted on its site which causes a lot of defective items to end up getting piped through it to consumers. Prioritizing your customer over everything else means delivering a high quality consistent product - which it fails to do with regular listings and fails spectacularly to do with Amazon Basics.
Re:A bike parts company ditched Amazon to support indie shop... by dangus on Monday August 23, 2021 @05:51PM (#28282434)
IMO you’re misunderstanding the customer.

The customer wants cheap. They WANT Amazon to be AliExpress with fast shipping.

That’s why Amazon has free returns and they offer returns in a million different ways.

Amazon doesn’t care that it’s inefficient on resources and that these items end up in a landfill. The manufacturing cost of cheap items is so low that it’s no big deal. As long as the customer has no friction in buying or returning they are happy.

I think there are certain categories of products where many customers would actually prefer counterfeit items as long as the quality is acceptable. Just walk down a cereal aisle.

Re:A bike parts company ditched Amazon to support indie shop... by munk-a on Monday August 23, 2021 @06:34PM (#28282892)
IMO you're misunderstanding this customer. The returns are pretty friction-less but they're still a burden that I'd rather not deal with - and I specifically don't want to order an electrical device off amazon and have it fail in a spectacular way that damages my other equipment.

The most luxurious thing you can tell me as a seller is that you're minimizing the longest potential time until I have a correctly functioning product - shipping is a big part of that, but not having to go through the hassle of getting it shipped out twice and returning one of them is another component.

Also I think AliExpress is a pretty terrible comparison - Amazon does beat it hand over fist. I think Amazon wants to be NewEgg but with less shipping time (and maybe the reputation it had a decade ago - it seems to be struggling lately). And it wants to be every other specialist store as well. I think it's possible for them to do this, but the thing they're lacking right now is the budget or motivation to actually vet products - they rely on peer reviews and manufacturer statements to try and suggest products.

Re:A bike parts company ditched Amazon to support indie shop... by dangus on Tuesday August 24, 2021 @04:35PM (#28294652)
I fully believe that your choices are logical for your own tastes. I myself don’t prefer Amazon for most things I buy for similar reasons to yours.

At the same time, I have absolutely heard multiple people say the words “if it sucks you can always return it.”

Low-friction returns are like business school 101 for retail.

I think the typical Amazon customer doesn’t shop on quality for many product categories, they are price sensitive. They don’t want to pay $50 for the Apple-certified power brick and cable.

I don’t think anyone wants to be NewEgg, if you ask me :-)

Re:A bike parts company ditched Amazon to support indie shop... by bityard on Monday August 23, 2021 @04:03PM (#28281192)
You're taking this to mean something different than the parent intended. The intended meaning is more along the lines of the old trope, "the customer is always right." This means that in any dispute between the seller and the buyer, Amazon favors the buyer 99% of the time. To the point that it's incredibly easy (and common) to be a hobbyist Amazon scammer as long as you stick to scamming marketplace sellers instead of Amazon itself.
Re:A bike parts company ditched Amazon to support indie shop... by ilamont on Monday August 23, 2021 @03:35PM (#28280867)
Amazon follows a core set of Leadership Principles (LPs) that we Amazonians aspire to every day. They are ingrained in our culture, and they guide the behaviors we value. It’s very telling that the first LP is Customer Obsession—leaders start with the customer and work backwards. They work vigorously to earn and keep customer trust. Although leaders pay attention to competitors, they obsess over customers.

https://aws.amazon.com/blogs/industries/an-inside-look-at-th...

Re:A bike parts company ditched Amazon to support indie shop... by ruddct on Monday August 23, 2021 @03:48PM (#28281013)
Would love to hear how a catalog riddled with counterfeits, fake reviews and listing-hijacking is a Customer Obsession.

Not trolling, Ex-Amazon so I'm curious how current Amazonians rationalize these things.

Re:A bike parts company ditched Amazon to support indie shop... by Spivak on Monday August 23, 2021 @04:03PM (#28281196)
Because you’re focusing on small but visible details that are hard unsolved problems for a company that’s Amazon’s size.

If you have the solution to any of these problems you would have a genuinely game-changing business and would be a 100M company selling it to every online marketplace.

Re:A bike parts company ditched Amazon to support indie shop... by freeopinion on Monday August 23, 2021 @05:11PM (#28282005)
There you go. You just prioritized size over solving those problems. It is more important to be big than to get it right.
Re:A bike parts company ditched Amazon to support indie shop... by ozzythecat on Monday August 23, 2021 @08:35PM (#28283842)
Alternatively, you can try to do both. If this issue was systemic, I imagine it would pose a systemic risk to Amazons business? Presumably it isn’t a systemic issue.

(I don’t work in Amazon retail so I don’t know, but I’m trying to frame this logically from a business sense).

Re:A bike parts company ditched Amazon to support indie shop... by travoc on Monday August 23, 2021 @05:40PM (#28282342)
These are not small details to be dismissed flippantly. Counterfeits and tainted listings are dangerous, especially considering how many health-related products are sold on Amazon.
Re:A bike parts company ditched Amazon to support indie shop... by jorblumesea on Monday August 23, 2021 @03:45PM (#28280983)
haaaaah

Anyone who knows Amazon knows there's tons of politics and leeway in those LPs, and they get twisted for nefarious purposes.

Re:A bike parts company ditched Amazon to support indie shop... by Qi_ on Monday August 23, 2021 @03:52PM (#28281071)
Another one: inventory pooling. When a product is “fulfilled by Amazon,” it comes from warehouse stock. However this stock can be contributed to by all sorts of sellers, legit or counterfeit. So sometimes buyers will receive a knockoff when they purchased a legitimate product. I have a relative who designs and sells electronics accessories, and he said this is a serious problem he runs into when selling on Amazon.
Re:A bike parts company ditched Amazon to support indie shop... by bisby on Monday August 23, 2021 @03:59PM (#28281155)
This is one of the things they do that could be spun as "pro seller". As a consumer, I don't like buying from vendors that I can't verify how much I trust them. So "fulfilled by Amazon" convinces consumers to buy with confidence, and even a no-name seller can get sales without having to compete on reputation. This means that consumers actually can't trust where they are buying from.

I very much don't like this as a consumer.

Re:A bike parts company ditched Amazon to support indie shop... by Johnny555 on Monday August 23, 2021 @04:43PM (#28281665)
It's also pro-consumer since it means that you get your order faster. Instead of sending you the widget that was warehoused across the country by your seller, they can sell you the one that was warehoused near your house by a different seller.

(in theory they could always just ship it across the country, but then they'll have to raise shipping prices)

Mingling counterfeit products with genuine products is a problem, but since I rarely know Amazon merchants, I'm not sure that's considerably worse than not mingling at all, I could just as likely try to buy from a merchant that's selling counterfeits.

Re:A bike parts company ditched Amazon to support indie shop... by withinrafael on Monday August 23, 2021 @04:09PM (#28281277)
Sellers can opt in/out of the inventory commingling you describe. But perhaps there are restrictions/conditions that make this harder than it sounds.
Re:A bike parts company ditched Amazon to support indie shop... by analog31 on Monday August 23, 2021 @06:11PM (#28282636)
>>> -creating huge incentives for chinese sellers which flood and undercut the local sellers

In my view, another way of looking at it is that selling on Amazon favors sellers who can figure out how to manage those risks, and one way of doing it is to be basically a "fly by night" business. If you can spin up multiple sellers, make your nut on the first sale, and pull the plug on the seller if anything goes wrong, you've got what it takes.

Or, if your margins are high enough that you can afford to eat the bad sales.

Re:A bike parts company ditched Amazon to support indie shop... by lazyjones on Tuesday August 24, 2021 @01:10AM (#28285314)
As a long-time customer (since the late 90's) I am also frustrated with Amazon these days because it's now impossible to judge the quality of the products as the website is swamped with cheap asian knock-off products, fake brands and fake reviews. It feels like 2/3 of all items are Aliexpress offers, just more expensive. It's probably a good window of opportunity for a competitor with some minimum quality guarantees and otherwise similar functionality.
Re:A bike parts company ditched Amazon to support indie shop... by ozzythecat on Monday August 23, 2021 @04:11PM (#28281298)
>In my opinion this company needs to be split up by gov and reigned in.

I think there are a lot of things Amazon can do better, but your solution is interesting.

“I am not happy with Amazon. The company should be broken up by the government.”

If everything you stated is absolutely true and systemic issues, IMO let the market and consumers punish Amazon.

It sounds like you’re saying Amazon is good enough that it’s impossible to take away their customer base. On the other hand, you’re describing what seems to be a completely broken company not worth a minute of my time.

Which is it?

Re:A bike parts company ditched Amazon to support indie shop... by at-fates-hands on Monday August 23, 2021 @03:21PM (#28280688)
>> Banning sellers for no good reason, and you cant contact anyone helpful.

I must be getting old.

How did these companies get so massive without any meaningful customer service departments? Amazon, Google, Facebook and many, many others where customer service is not even bothered with, yet people continue to use their products and services.

Re:A bike parts company ditched Amazon to support indie shop... by Johnny555 on Monday August 23, 2021 @04:03PM (#28281207)
How did these companies get so massive without any meaningful customer service departments? Amazon, Google, Facebook and many, many others where customer service is not even bothered with, yet people continue to use their products and services.

As a customer, I've had no trouble reaching Amazon customer service when I need help, and they've always been helpful - refunding or replacing the defective product.

Re:A bike parts company ditched Amazon to support indie shop... by JohnFen on Monday August 23, 2021 @04:48PM (#28281722)
As a customer, I only needed customer service from them once (in the over 10 years I've been buying from them). My experience was truly terrible, and I ended up losing my money.
Re:A bike parts company ditched Amazon to support indie shop... by theturtletalks on Monday August 23, 2021 @03:26PM (#28280753)
It's because they make it super easy for the customer, but use dark patterns for the sellers. Amazon can afford to lose sellers since more are popping up everyday and willing to sell items for a loss to gain market share.

The parent also didn't mention that Amazon has a policy of not allowing sellers to sell their products for a lower price on their own website. If only customers knew how much Amazon is screwing over sellers, they would be wary. Many sellers I know themselves don't shop on Amazon themselves due to this.

Re:A bike parts company ditched Amazon to support indie shop... by bushbaba on Monday August 23, 2021 @03:29PM (#28280798)
As a customer why should I care about the seller experience. As a customer I’ve only ever cared about the customer buying experience
Re:A bike parts company ditched Amazon to support indie shop... by fossuser on Monday August 23, 2021 @03:42PM (#28280933)
Agreed - Amazon knows who their real customers are and they have leverage over the sellers.

It does surprise me though that given that there's a lot of counterfeit junk and scam-like sellers on the site (which is a pretty bad customer experience). You'd think they'd shut that down.

In practice it doesn't matter because prime shipping is so much better than any non-amazon option I just deal with that risk (with some exceptions where I'll buy directly from the creator of the product).

Re:A bike parts company ditched Amazon to support indie shop... by thaumasiotes on Monday August 23, 2021 @04:00PM (#28281165)
> In practice it doesn't matter because prime shipping is so much better than any non-amazon option I just deal with that risk

Really? I'm strongly considering canceling my prime subscription specifically because shipping has gotten so awful. Amazon won't even allow you to select a shipping speed anymore. Pretty much everywhere else on the internet is better.

Re:A bike parts company ditched Amazon to support indie shop... by fossuser on Monday August 23, 2021 @04:04PM (#28281215)
My recent experience with non-amazon shipping:

- Ordered a blanket directly from the blanket maker's website, order details were delayed, no shipping notice, no out of stock notice, order took 4 months to arrive (it was supposed to be a gift).

- Ordered some flatware from MOMA was charged and no shipping details updated, I waited six weeks before emailing them - they said the system 'lost the order' I had to have paypal reverse the charges.

There are other examples, but generally non-amazon sucks - even in the best of cases it's twice as long and usually expensive.

With Amazon I often get two day, next day, or even same day shipping for free. Packages arrive typically well packaged and undamaged and the tracking is really good. If there are any issues they are quick to resolve it.

Re:A bike parts company ditched Amazon to support indie shop... by thaumasiotes on Monday August 23, 2021 @04:08PM (#28281263)
> Packages arrive typically well packaged and undamaged

That's another thing. Amazon used to ship things in boxes with appropriate padding. Now they're shipping books in manila envelopes, with predictable damage to the book from the tightness of the envelope.

Re:A bike parts company ditched Amazon to support indie shop... by fossuser on Monday August 23, 2021 @04:14PM (#28281324)
I wonder if there's regional variation depending on warehouses? I'm in SF and have had pretty good experiences.

It's mostly a comparison I'm making to alternatives which I've found to be worse (usually the non-amazon packaging is terrible).

Re:A bike parts company ditched Amazon to support indie shop... by JohnFen on Monday August 23, 2021 @04:52PM (#28281768)
None of that is like my most recent interactions with Amazon.
Re:A bike parts company ditched Amazon to support indie shop... by JohnFen on Monday August 23, 2021 @04:51PM (#28281751)
> prime shipping is so much better than any non-amazon option

This isn't as true as it used to be, and it's getting less true as time goes on.

Re:A bike parts company ditched Amazon to support indie shop... by JohnFen on Monday August 23, 2021 @04:49PM (#28281737)
> Amazon has a policy of not allowing sellers to sell their products for a lower price on their own website.

This is why, when I decided to ditch Amazon, I also decided to avoid buying from companies that sell on Amazon.

Re:A bike parts company ditched Amazon to support indie shop... by andromeduck on Monday August 23, 2021 @03:49PM (#28281032)
I'd buy from vendor sites if it weren't always such a pita between checkouts, shipping and refunds.
Re:A bike parts company ditched Amazon to support indie shop... by blacktriangle on Monday August 23, 2021 @03:42PM (#28280938)
You do sound like my parents. They were mainframe programmers in the 70s and still every time I complain about wierd issues I'm having with programming, they'll keep asking me if I've called tech support.

They can't wrap their head around how you can have useful-ish software with shitty incomplete out of date documentation and tech support via people competing to get noticed on StackOverflow for their resume.

The more time goes on, I'm not sure I can wrap my head around it either...

Re:A bike parts company ditched Amazon to support indie shop... by kelvin0 on Monday August 23, 2021 @03:29PM (#28280793)
The retail customers who end up buying the stuff are lavishly treated. The small businesses which sell their products on Amazon are not really 'customers' and are treated like 5th class citizens. Proof and burden rests on these suppliers shoulders.
Re:A bike parts company ditched Amazon to support indie shop... by pengaru on Monday August 23, 2021 @03:27PM (#28280776)
Short-term convenience wins every time.