News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by mayankkaizen on Sunday August 22, 2021 @03:22PM (#28268604)
I am 41 years old. And I feel like in last 6-8 years, people have become far more intolerant regarding free speech. It is just not possible to say anything which is unpopular without inviting vicious attacks or even real threats. In part social media platforms are to be blamed. They somehow bring the worst out of everyone. The guy who is/was willing to listen to me patiently is now issuing death threats to anyone on Twitter. Somehow these trends are now transgressing to real life. These days people just don't think. They only react.
Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by throwawaygh on Sunday August 22, 2021 @04:23PM (#28269235)
> I am 41 years old.

We are pretty similar in age.

> I feel like in last 6-8 years, people have become far more intolerant regarding free speech.

Which people, and what speech?

I grew up in a smaller town (but not tiny), where teachers who were fired or otherwise quietly left town after coming out as gay.

My parents stressed about petty church politics because good standing in the local church had a direct effect on their ability to get and keep (completely secular) jobs.

They put out yard signs for candidates they secretly voted against.

If you weren't a white right-of-GOP-center conservative evangelical christian, life was an exercise is constant self-censorship.

From my perspective, "cancel culture" doesn't really seem particularly new. On average, people enjoy more expressive freedom today than they did in the 1980s.

So, again: which people, and what speech? Perhaps a few major metro areas enjoyed true liberalism re: speech in the 80s; I wouldn't know. But in most of America, your golden age of free speech never actually existed.

Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by TeeMassive on Sunday August 22, 2021 @07:35PM (#28270774)
> Which people, and what speech?

I find very peculiar how the proponents of various version of Critical Theory and Cancel Culture simply argues that they do not exist when confronted with criticism; this reminds me of one of my college philosophy professor trying to confuse his students with "nothing really exist" instead of answering the critiques of his teachings.

To give a few high profile examples:

* People arguing that private companies should be able to do anything with their public platforms regarding politically motivated censorship

* Jordan Peterson getting warned by the University of Toronto's lawyers for making a video about how he wouldn't cooperate about being forced to use certain pronouns.

* Lindsay Shepherd got disciplined by Wilfrid Laurier University's staff for merely showing a video of Jordan Peterson.

* Brett Weinstein was confronted by a hostile mob for criticizing the College for asking White student to stay away from college this day.

* Gregg Patton from the University of Southern California was replaced for saying the very usual Chinese expression "ne ga"; while teaching a Chinese Mandarin course.

> I grew up in a smaller town (but not tiny), where teachers who were fired or otherwise quietly left town after coming out as gay.

It's almost as if things have changed.

Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by throwawaygh on Sunday August 22, 2021 @09:14PM (#28271357)
I genuinely can't figure out what thought your first paragraph is trying to convey.

Other than an admittedly convincing demonstration that your Philosophy professor wasn't a great teacher, what is your point?

> proponents of... Cancel Culture

What in my blistering critique of 1980s Cancel Culture gave you that impression?

> proponents of... various version of Critical Theory

You have me there. I will fess up to a fondness for the elementary theory of dynamical systems. The identification of critical points is a particularly important piece of mathematics. I have no clue what my fondness of the theory of the identification of critical points in dynamical systems has to do with this thread, though.

>> I grew up in a smaller town (but not tiny), where teachers who were fired or otherwise quietly left town after coming out as gay.

> It's almost as if things have changed.

https://www.orlandosentinel.com/opinion/scott-maxwell-commen...

Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by profunctor on Sunday August 22, 2021 @07:46PM (#28270836)
There has been politically motivated academic censorship forever. See what happened to communist academics throughout the 20th century.
Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by TeeMassive on Sunday August 22, 2021 @09:09PM (#28271314)
And?
Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by throwawaygh on Sunday August 22, 2021 @09:31PM (#28271480)
The thesis of the top-most comment was:

>>> And I feel like in last 6-8 years, people have become far more intolerant regarding free speech

That's the proposition that this particular subthread is discussing.

Perhaps you don't care, but in that case I'm a bit confused about why you're commenting this far down-thread.

Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by TeeMassive on Sunday August 22, 2021 @11:38PM (#28272114)
I was answering to "Which people, and what speech?"

Which I gave prominent examples of.

The reply of which was simply examples from the USSR era (as opposed to right now in the Western World) without any other argument other than what seems to be whataboutism.

Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by joshuamorton on Monday August 23, 2021 @02:47AM (#28272936)
But that's a valid argument! "Here are tons of other examples from before the past decade" is a perfect response to "I've noticed this new thing in the past decade".
Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by TeeMassive on Monday August 23, 2021 @10:27PM (#28284494)
Except I was responding to "Which people, and what speech?" which referred to current event and people.
Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by joshuamorton on Tuesday August 24, 2021 @11:23AM (#28290067)
It doesn't though. The point of that statement is exactly what I said, to point out that "people have become far more intolerant regarding free speech" is only true if you look at specific people and specific speech. If you look at all speech about everything, it probably isn't true.

Concretely, the far stronger social reaction to slurs against gay people go hand in hand with people now being able to say "I'm gay" without repercussions.

Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by TeeMassive on Thursday August 26, 2021 @12:55AM (#28310861)
I was responding to:

> > I feel like in last 6-8 years, people have become far more intolerant regarding free speech.

> Which people, and what speech?

I responded with people and their speech that faced intolerance with total disregard for free speech. I doesn't even look like you are following the conversation anymore.

> Concretely, the far stronger social reaction to slurs against gay people go hand in hand with people now being able to say "I'm gay" without repercussions.

You are mixing up causation. People didn't accept homosexuality because certain words were banned, people stopped using words because they didn't like what they represented. And then it has gotten to another level where even statement of facts or simply making a point involving those words, in entirely different context causes outrage can cancellation.

The idea that words should get banned to make certain ideas or concept disappear à la 1984 is a very immature notion as other words can be forged.

Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by joshuamorton on Thursday August 26, 2021 @07:25PM (#28322337)
> I was responding to:

Yes, I'm perfectly aware.

> I responded with people and their speech that faced intolerance with total disregard for free speech. I doesn't even look like you are following the conversation anymore.

Yes, I'm fully aware of how you responded. My point is that "people facing intolerance with total disregard for free speech" is not a new thing, as evidenced by the examples given from earlier times.

Breaking this down, you seem to think that giving examples of intolerance is enough to prove the initial claim, "people have become far more intolerant regarding free speech.", but it isn't. If someone else shows equal intolerance prior to the last 6-8 years, all your examples show is that the intolerance has not changed. You haven't shown that they've gotten worse, only that they haven't gotten better.

> You are mixing up causation.

You're once again misunderstanding my comment. I'm making the opposite causality argument than the one you appear to think I'm making.

As acceptance of gay people goes up, acceptance of slurs against gay people goes down. The question is, then, did we have "freer" speech when people faced criticism for saying "I am gay" as they did in the past, as compared to now where you face criticism for calling someone a slur?

Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by VelkaMorava on Monday August 23, 2021 @03:31AM (#28273147)
> Which people, and what speech?

cAn U PrOv1d3 s0urc3 pLeAsE fOr YoUr AnEcDoTaL eV1DeNcE?

Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by lal on Monday August 23, 2021 @06:43AM (#28274093)
Well, yeah, sure, we can pretend that's what parent was saying, or maybe the top comment could just bother actually providing said anecdotal evidence. Saying you have anecdotal evidence is not the same thing as providing anecdotal evidence. Nothing is even communicated by just vaguely gesturing at all of the poor melty peaches except that you spend far too many hours on YouTube, and on one specific region of YouTube in particular. Nobody can interact with your anecdotal evidence if you haven't actually said what your anecdotal evidence is.

Edit: It's worth noting that when the commenter actually did name the examples they were thinking of, it was entirely related to right-wing YouTube personalities, so it looks like I was on to something there.

Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by VelkaMorava on Monday August 23, 2021 @12:27PM (#28278324)
Right wing is a legit political stance. If you want to see what world would look like without people with political views differing yours, my woke comrade, move to North Korea or Eastern Europe circa 1948-1989. You'll see what an amazing world leftist-only ideologies create. Especially when you won't be able to study at university because one of your parents is not member of the Party and listens to Free Europe.

Forwards, left and not a step back! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hLAAprIN6S4

Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by taylodl on Monday August 23, 2021 @03:00PM (#28280426)
Misinformation and calls to violence (we'll apply the 2nd amendment to them) is not a legitimate political stance. Politics is debating the merits of a progressive tax system, for example. Politics is not calling for violence toward your political opponents and their supporters or arguing that the world is flat or interfering with the function of the organs of government.
Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by TeeMassive on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:08AM (#28311246)
> Misinformation and calls to violence

Which is not limited to the right

> we'll apply the 2nd amendment to them

What does it have to do with anything? Radicals from the Left are very pro 2nd amendment too by the way.

> Politics is debating the merits of a progressive tax system, for example. Politics is not calling for violence toward your political opponents and their supporters or arguing that the world is flat or interfering with the function of the organs of government.

Politics are simply the way people govern or are governed for better or for worse. "Politics is not what I consider evil" is a great political slogan but also doesn't make sense outside your own personal values.

Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by marcinzm on Sunday August 22, 2021 @05:37PM (#28269877)
>Perhaps a few major metro areas enjoyed true liberalism re: speech in the 80s

The 80s and early 90s were the time of police riots in many cities and heavy gang activity. Neither of those indicates a good result if you said the wrong thing to the wrong people.

Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by throwawaygh on Sunday August 22, 2021 @05:38PM (#28269888)
Well then, I guess his golden age of free speech never actually existed anywhere. Go figure.
Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by 3grdlurker on Sunday August 22, 2021 @05:29PM (#28269807)
I've seen people deliberately seek to offend marginalized groups with their language, though, and then they cry out about being cancelled and how speech is no longer free when the people they provoked naturally respond to and fight back against their posts.

I don't believe that people have become less tolerant. I think that the reality of disagreement as a fact of life has just been amplified by the constant connectivity afforded to us by social media, and people (especially those who like to provoke debates) have a hard time accepting that not everyone is going to agree with them, and that there are real social costs to deliberately positioning oneself as edgy or unpopular or hateful, as there has always been.

[dead]
Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by UncleMeat on Sunday August 22, 2021 @05:42PM (#28269930)
I'll second the poster that this is not "trying to engage in debate".

There are some members of TPUSA at the university my wife teaches at. They specifically chose to, as a group, take a course taught by a transgender teacher. They, clearly through some training, determined that they'd be able to write deliberately transphobic hate speech in very specific portions of the course because their writing in these locations is protected by privacy laws and other such things. When called out on this, they responded by claiming that their intellectual freedom was being snuffed out and proposed lawsuits.

That's the shit I see. Organized attempts to use the levers of the law to harass and intimidate people from groups they don't consider to be worthy of their respect. And as soon as people resist, an unpaid army of free speech advocates leap to their defense.

Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by atok1 on Monday August 23, 2021 @08:35PM (#28283848)
The 'intimidated people' are not forced to interact with the 'abusers' though.

It's that kind of whining that takes away from their arguments.

Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by cjensen on Sunday August 22, 2021 @03:52PM (#28268920)
Your claim that people have become intolerant of free speech is unclear. For example, speech which generates "vicious attacks" in response is still free speech. The responses are also free speech.

True threats should be reported to the police. That's not intolerance, that's just plain illegal. On the other hand if by "real threats" you mean hyperbolic threats, those are also free speech.

Free speech is not a guarantee that others must listen, or that they must listen patiently. That is not now, nor has it ever been, the definition of free speech.

Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by beervirus on Sunday August 22, 2021 @04:00PM (#28269015)
The big platforms will silence you for saying things that clearly fall under free speech.
Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by cjensen on Sunday August 22, 2021 @04:53PM (#28269509)
Platforms have a First Amendment right to silence voices they don't like on a platform. The First Amendment protects both a person's ability to say things, and the person's ability to not say things. As a general rule, both people and the government cannot compel someone to say or reproduce an opinion they don't want to.
Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by horseradish on Sunday August 22, 2021 @05:23PM (#28269767)
Free speech is a far larger concern than what the First Amendment covers.

Platforms that have grown into de facto public squares are large enough that there is a public interest in how they regulate speech, given that the vast majority of people are on the big tech platforms while the alternatives are negligible and choked out by network effects. They are now a gray area between state and what is typically understood by private entity.

There are massive and obvious dangers in letting Google, Facebook, Twitter decree for millions/billions of people what counts as "science" or "misinformation", and they've already demonstrated getting it spectacularly wrong. It's vital to a free society to have a culture of open debate, and these platforms are now our media for such debate.

It's not clear yet what the best mechanism or remedy for this will be, but citing the First Amendment alone is not sufficient to resolve the concern. The First Amendment only applies to government, and the cultural and social issues around free speech have always been much broader than that.

There are older precedents for regulating speech on private platforms in an earlier technological period: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FCC_fairness_doctrine. Perhaps we need an updated version of that. I wouldn't be surprised if the platforms themselves were ok with it, since I don't believe they wanted to get into the truth-regulation business in the first place. They're doing it because they're subject to intense, inner and outer, political pressure.

Without getting into rightness or wrongness of views, I think it's factually the case that those pressures are coming from a fairly narrow band of political opinion which is far from being the entire spectrum and excludes many mainstream views, so in that sense what we're seeing is something analogous to "regulatory capture" of the big platforms. This gives enormous leverage to one cluster of political opinions over all the others. It's a distorting factor which I think is against the public interest (even though I personally agree with some of their views).

We need debate and persuasion, not hard use of power. This understanding was commonplace, in fact bedrock, for so long that many of us are shocked at how quickly it could be abandoned, and not just abandoned or even forgotten but replaced with a narrative in which it was never that way to begin with!

Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by OrvalWintermute on Sunday August 22, 2021 @06:30PM (#28270326)
> There are massive and obvious dangers in letting Google, Facebook, Twitter decree for millions/billions of people what counts as "science" or "misinformation", and they've already demonstrated getting it spectacularly wrong. It's vital to a free society to have a culture of open debate, and these platforms are now our media for such debate.

I'm highly concerned about BigTech regulating the speech of others particularly when the others are experts in their respective fields, and BigTech has none, but is merely parroting an authoritarian government perspective.

When we normally debate a view, people present data from opposing viewpoints and we sort it out over time. Sides present data. Sides explain relevancy and over time, we determine greater accuracy. That cannot happen in an environment where gatekeepers control the speech and dictate the tone and content of it.

> Without getting into rightness or wrongness of views, I think it's factually the case that those pressures are coming from a fairly narrow band of political opinion which is far from being the entire spectrum and excludes many mainstream views, so in that sense what we're seeing is something analogous to "regulatory capture" of the big platforms. This gives enormous leverage to one cluster of political opinions over all the others. It's a distorting factor which I think is against the public interest (even though I personally agree with some of their views).

> We need debate and persuasion, not hard use of power. This understanding was commonplace, in fact bedrock, for so long that many of us are shocked at how quickly it could be abandoned, and not just abandoned or even forgotten but replaced with a narrative in which it was never that way to begin with!

I think this is very well written, and can be related to much of the modern authoritarian use of power, of compulsion, by BigTech in cahoots with government.

Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by caseysoftware on Sunday August 22, 2021 @05:38PM (#28269893)
> Platforms that have grown into de facto public squares are large enough that there is a public interest in how they regulate speech, given that the vast majority of people are on the big tech platforms while the others are negligible and are choked out by network effects. They are now a gray area between state and what is typically understood by private entity.

In the lawsuit against Trump for blocking people on Twitter, the court ruled that Twitter was a public square for the express reason that government policy was discussed and promoted there. Therefore, Trump (as a government figure) could not block people.

Further, the current Press Secretary Psaki has described how they're directing Facebook to monitor and remove both people and content which was otherwise legal but simply unacceptable to the Administration.

The first situation demonstrates the gray area but the second makes a case that Facebook was acting as an arm of the government.

Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by joshuamorton on Sunday August 22, 2021 @05:47PM (#28269977)
> In the lawsuit against Trump for blocking people on Twitter, the court ruled that Twitter was a public square for the express reason that government policy was discussed and promoted there. Therefore, Trump (as a government figure) could not block people.

No it didn't. It ruled that trumps account was acting as an official government account, and so trumps account fell under stricter regulations that govern how the government can communicate. Twitter was still able to ban his account though, because Twitter isn't the government!

> Further, the current Press Secretary Psaki has described how they're directing Facebook to monitor and remove both people and content which was otherwise legal but simply unacceptable to the Administration.

No, Facebook used the government as a source of official information. They then chose to remove other information. The government wasn't telling Facebook to remove stuff. The choice to make the CDC authoritative was Facebooks choice. They aren't acting as an arm of the government.

Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by caseysoftware on Sunday August 22, 2021 @06:26PM (#28270290)
The White House claims to be an active participant and directing their attention to things to be removed. In case you missed that press conference, here's a transcript and video:

> QUESTION: Thanks, Jen. Can you talk a little bit more about this request for tech companies to be more aggressive in policing misinformation? Has the administration been in touch with any of these companies? And are there any actions that the federal government can take to ensure their cooperation? Because we've seen from the start, there's not a lot of action on some of these platforms.

> PSAKI: Sure. Well, first, we are in regular touch with the social media platforms, and those engagements typically happen through members of our senior staff, but also members of our COVID-19 Team.

> Quote continuing: Given as Dr. Murthy conveyed, this is a big issue of misinformation specifically on the pandemic. In terms of actions, Alex, that we have taken or we're working to take, I should say, from the federal government, we've increased disinformation research and tracking. Within the Surgeon General's Office, we're flagging posts for Facebook that spread disinformation.

Unless you believe Psaki is lying which I hadn't considered.

Ref: https://www.realclearpolitics.com/video/2021/07/15/psaki_wer...

Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by throwawaygh on Sunday August 22, 2021 @08:25PM (#28271067)
I kind of lost the thread with this comment.

The White House can make pretty much any request of Twitter and Facebook.

Twitter and Facebook, in turn, can decide whether to act on those requests.

The social media aspect is new, but otherwise, this is bog standard big corp <-> fed gov politics. Every prior president has used the bully pulpit to encourage very large companies to do things, and followed up/paired those requests with a concert of relevant activity within the executive branch.

FB/Twitter are not "acting as an arm of the federal government" except in the most sensational and hyperbolic foaming-at-the-mouth-talking-head sense; in the same sense as, for example, saying that Carrier was an arm of the federal government during the Trump years.

Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by caseysoftware on Sunday August 22, 2021 @10:46PM (#28271851)
sigh

I did not say there were "acting as an arm of the federal government" to quote myself: "makes a case that Facebook was acting as an arm of the government"

"Makes a case" means literally "make an argument in favor of" and not "definitively is"

Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by joshuamorton on Sunday August 22, 2021 @06:49PM (#28270471)
Unless you're claim here is that Psaki is threatening Facebook, there's nothing remotely illegal happening here. Facebook is like "hey, tell us about misinformation" and the government is like "hey we think this is misinformation". And then Facebook reviews the posts they flagged and removes some of them.

The argument you're making is akin to "Its illegal for Psaki or a white house staffer to ask for airtime on CNN, because that violates CNN's first amendment rights" (or perhaps more subtly "because then CNN is acting as an arm of the government", but that's still wrong).

Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by caseysoftware on Sunday August 22, 2021 @07:42PM (#28270823)
My claim was simply that the White House directed information/accounts to be removed. Your response was "The government wasn't telling Facebook to remove stuff." which - according to the video I cited - is clearly untrue.

I'd love to understand your point but I'm not going to engage further with someone pedaling misinformation.

Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by joshuamorton on Sunday August 22, 2021 @07:49PM (#28270854)
Your claim was that Facebook was "acting as an arm of the government." That's simply untrue.

And they weren't telling it to remove stuff. They were asking it to, after fb set up a way for the government (among other groups) to flag misinformation. You're glossing over those difference, but they matter.

Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by caseysoftware on Sunday August 22, 2021 @06:33PM (#28270361)
> No it didn't. It ruled that trumps account was acting as an official government account, and so trumps account fell under stricter regulations that govern how the government can communicate. Twitter was still able to ban his account though, because Twitter isn't the government!

Again, I suspect you missed a bit:

"U.S. District Judge Naomi Reice Buchwald in Manhattan ruled on May 23 that comments on the president’s account, and those of other government officials, were public forums and that blocking Twitter Inc users for their views violated their right to free speech under the First Amendment of the U.S. Constitution."

Ref: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-trump-twitter-idUSKCN...

When governments use social media as a way to communicate, it changes their standing as at least one court has ruled so far.

Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by joshuamorton on Sunday August 22, 2021 @06:47PM (#28270461)
The key part being "under the presidents account." The president using twitter does not change twitter. The president is held to standards of the government, which is not allowed to block people. But the rules that affect the government don't affect twitter, they only apply to government officials using twitter.

Twitter is still allowed to block people who reply to the president, or, as they did, ban the president.

Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by caseysoftware on Sunday August 22, 2021 @07:48PM (#28270853)
The Internet Association - quoted in the article - is concerned about the implications of that case but glad to hear you are not.

Was there a more recent case+ruling that is more relevant and clarifying? Can you share a reference on that? Thanks.

Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by joshuamorton on Sunday August 22, 2021 @07:54PM (#28270881)
> The Internet Association - quoted in the article - is concerned about the implications of that case but glad to hear you are not.

Yes, hence they provided a brief asking the court to rule a certain way, and the court did, by keeping the ruling particular to Trump's government account.

There isn't any newer or better ruling, you're just misunderstanding this one.

Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by caseysoftware on Sunday August 22, 2021 @10:33PM (#28271780)
> by keeping the ruling particular to Trump's government account.

From the article I cited:

"The Knight First Amendment Institute at Columbia University on August 10 sent the Justice Department a list of 41 accounts that had remained blocked from Trump’s @RealDonaldTrump account. The seven users who filed suit had their accounts unblocked in June."

aka Not his government (@POTUS at the time) account. Once again, misinformation from you. :(

Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by joshuamorton on Sunday August 22, 2021 @11:25PM (#28272039)
The thing you're still missing is that the ruling was that the @RealDonaldTrump account was being used in an official government capacity, and therefore would fall under said government specific regulations.

If you look at the actual ruling[0], you'll see that on page 9-11 of the ruling, they outline ways in which the @RealDonaldTrump account was used in an official capacity, and on pages 42 and 43, they outline how this is governmental control of the account (but not of twitter as a whole).

Quoting the ruling:

> First, to potentially qualify as a forum, the space in question must be owned or controlled by the government...Here, the government-control prong of the analysis is met. Though Twitter is a...company that is not government-owned, the President and Scavino nonetheless exercise control over various aspects of the @realDonaldTrump account...The President and Scavino’s control over the @realDonaldTrump account is also governmental...the President presents the @realDonaldTrump account as being a presidential account as opposed to a personal account and, more importantly, uses the account to take actions that can be taken only by the President as President

So please, stop crying "misinformation" when you're just wrong about the legalities of the situation. You may disagree with the ruling, but my description of it is factual.

[0]: https://www.politico.com/f/?id=00000163-8e16-dd91-abe7-8f3f5...

Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by Jtsummers on Sunday August 22, 2021 @05:49PM (#28269993)
It's worth noting that the Fairness Doctrine was applied to things like radio where you had to have a license, and which were more limited. It was not (at least after a couple court decisions) applied to other media like newspapers, which could operate without a license.

Google, Facebook, and others do not require a license to operate. Anyone can establish their own website to counter points made on those platforms. The Fairness Doctrine would seem (even if it still existed) to be non-applicable to the various web platforms.

A more updated version of it might be more expansive, but would probably run into issues with compelled speech. Since the internet is pretty wide open, again anyone can make a website if they want, it's hard to justify compelling a platform to host content.

Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by horseradish on Sunday August 22, 2021 @05:54PM (#28270034)
I agree that's worth noting, and I'm not suggesting a literal revival of the fairness doctrine, just noting that there are past precedents for regulating speech in the public interest. You're no doubt right that it would run into legal difficulty, and actually the corporatist supreme court would be expected, amusingly enough, to side with the illiberal left on this issue.

This is a canard though:

> Since the internet is pretty wide open, again anyone can make a website if they want, it's hard to justify compelling a platform to host content.

Anyone can make a website that no one reads, but not anyone can make a public square. As I said above, the alternatives are choked out by network effects, so the internet is not "pretty wide open" in any way that counts for public debate. It used to be, but that was before it consolidated into an oligopoly. That is why the public interest and free speech questions necessarily shift to these platforms. In the world we now live in, it's distracting to offer the prospect of "anyone can make a website" as if it were a realistic alternative.

Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by Jtsummers on Sunday August 22, 2021 @06:11PM (#28270167)
It's not a canard, it's well-founded by examining precedent. The courts already decided that compelled speech (the Fairness Doctrine) didn't make sense without scarcity of a medium or difficulty to publish through the medium. The precedent is that newspapers (which is a harder field to enter into than starting a website) couldn't be compelled under the Fairness Doctrine because it wasn't licensed and was wide open. That's absolutely not a canard here (do you know what that word means?).

Starting up a website is even easier than publishing a newspaper so it would be very bizarre for that precedent to somehow not be applied in this instance.

Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by dwpdwpdwpdwpdwp on Sunday August 22, 2021 @04:34PM (#28269340)
The big platforms have no ability to silence anyone.

They have the ability to limit your use of their resources, which is well within their rights.

Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by beervirus on Sunday August 22, 2021 @06:09PM (#28270157)
It’s within their rights (currently…) but it’s still problematic.
Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by OrvalWintermute on Sunday August 22, 2021 @06:33PM (#28270356)
I don't know that I agree, because once a thing becomes part of the public square, the rules change.
Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by QuadmasterXLII on Sunday August 22, 2021 @07:23PM (#28270694)
All of the consequences you listed (vicious attacks, real threats, death threats, only reacting) take the form of speech, and are also protected by an absolute free speech position.
Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by RickJWagner on Sunday August 22, 2021 @09:37PM (#28271508)
I'm in my mid-50s. IMHO, racial relations have become drastically worse in the last 10 years or so, most of which is done for political purposes.

I believe the best I saw it was in the 80s. I worked in an environment where people of all races worked and played together, everyone got along well. I had high hopes that racist behavior was mostly in the past and still diminishing. Sadly, it was not to be.

The world would be a much better place if we all took a deep breath and listened to Thomas Sowell, Tim Scott, Ben Carson, Benjamin Watson, and others that seek true reconciliation.

Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by amanaplanacanal on Monday August 23, 2021 @12:00AM (#28272203)
Having public debate about issues around race does not mean that racial relations are worse. Silence on race issues does not mean that relations are better.
Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by RickJWagner on Monday August 23, 2021 @07:57AM (#28274531)
I'm thinking about the accompanying riots, police shootings, increases in crime after the police pullbacks, etc.