News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by joshuamorton on Sunday August 22, 2021 @05:47PM (#28269977)
> In the lawsuit against Trump for blocking people on Twitter, the court ruled that Twitter was a public square for the express reason that government policy was discussed and promoted there. Therefore, Trump (as a government figure) could not block people.

No it didn't. It ruled that trumps account was acting as an official government account, and so trumps account fell under stricter regulations that govern how the government can communicate. Twitter was still able to ban his account though, because Twitter isn't the government!

> Further, the current Press Secretary Psaki has described how they're directing Facebook to monitor and remove both people and content which was otherwise legal but simply unacceptable to the Administration.

No, Facebook used the government as a source of official information. They then chose to remove other information. The government wasn't telling Facebook to remove stuff. The choice to make the CDC authoritative was Facebooks choice. They aren't acting as an arm of the government.

Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by caseysoftware on Sunday August 22, 2021 @06:26PM (#28270290)
The White House claims to be an active participant and directing their attention to things to be removed. In case you missed that press conference, here's a transcript and video:

> QUESTION: Thanks, Jen. Can you talk a little bit more about this request for tech companies to be more aggressive in policing misinformation? Has the administration been in touch with any of these companies? And are there any actions that the federal government can take to ensure their cooperation? Because we've seen from the start, there's not a lot of action on some of these platforms.

> PSAKI: Sure. Well, first, we are in regular touch with the social media platforms, and those engagements typically happen through members of our senior staff, but also members of our COVID-19 Team.

> Quote continuing: Given as Dr. Murthy conveyed, this is a big issue of misinformation specifically on the pandemic. In terms of actions, Alex, that we have taken or we're working to take, I should say, from the federal government, we've increased disinformation research and tracking. Within the Surgeon General's Office, we're flagging posts for Facebook that spread disinformation.

Unless you believe Psaki is lying which I hadn't considered.

Ref: https://www.realclearpolitics.com/video/2021/07/15/psaki_wer...

Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by throwawaygh on Sunday August 22, 2021 @08:25PM (#28271067)
I kind of lost the thread with this comment.

The White House can make pretty much any request of Twitter and Facebook.

Twitter and Facebook, in turn, can decide whether to act on those requests.

The social media aspect is new, but otherwise, this is bog standard big corp <-> fed gov politics. Every prior president has used the bully pulpit to encourage very large companies to do things, and followed up/paired those requests with a concert of relevant activity within the executive branch.

FB/Twitter are not "acting as an arm of the federal government" except in the most sensational and hyperbolic foaming-at-the-mouth-talking-head sense; in the same sense as, for example, saying that Carrier was an arm of the federal government during the Trump years.

Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by caseysoftware on Sunday August 22, 2021 @10:46PM (#28271851)
sigh

I did not say there were "acting as an arm of the federal government" to quote myself: "makes a case that Facebook was acting as an arm of the government"

"Makes a case" means literally "make an argument in favor of" and not "definitively is"

Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by joshuamorton on Sunday August 22, 2021 @06:49PM (#28270471)
Unless you're claim here is that Psaki is threatening Facebook, there's nothing remotely illegal happening here. Facebook is like "hey, tell us about misinformation" and the government is like "hey we think this is misinformation". And then Facebook reviews the posts they flagged and removes some of them.

The argument you're making is akin to "Its illegal for Psaki or a white house staffer to ask for airtime on CNN, because that violates CNN's first amendment rights" (or perhaps more subtly "because then CNN is acting as an arm of the government", but that's still wrong).

Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by caseysoftware on Sunday August 22, 2021 @07:42PM (#28270823)
My claim was simply that the White House directed information/accounts to be removed. Your response was "The government wasn't telling Facebook to remove stuff." which - according to the video I cited - is clearly untrue.

I'd love to understand your point but I'm not going to engage further with someone pedaling misinformation.

Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by joshuamorton on Sunday August 22, 2021 @07:49PM (#28270854)
Your claim was that Facebook was "acting as an arm of the government." That's simply untrue.

And they weren't telling it to remove stuff. They were asking it to, after fb set up a way for the government (among other groups) to flag misinformation. You're glossing over those difference, but they matter.

Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by caseysoftware on Sunday August 22, 2021 @06:33PM (#28270361)
> No it didn't. It ruled that trumps account was acting as an official government account, and so trumps account fell under stricter regulations that govern how the government can communicate. Twitter was still able to ban his account though, because Twitter isn't the government!

Again, I suspect you missed a bit:

"U.S. District Judge Naomi Reice Buchwald in Manhattan ruled on May 23 that comments on the president’s account, and those of other government officials, were public forums and that blocking Twitter Inc users for their views violated their right to free speech under the First Amendment of the U.S. Constitution."

Ref: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-trump-twitter-idUSKCN...

When governments use social media as a way to communicate, it changes their standing as at least one court has ruled so far.

Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by joshuamorton on Sunday August 22, 2021 @06:47PM (#28270461)
The key part being "under the presidents account." The president using twitter does not change twitter. The president is held to standards of the government, which is not allowed to block people. But the rules that affect the government don't affect twitter, they only apply to government officials using twitter.

Twitter is still allowed to block people who reply to the president, or, as they did, ban the president.

Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by caseysoftware on Sunday August 22, 2021 @07:48PM (#28270853)
The Internet Association - quoted in the article - is concerned about the implications of that case but glad to hear you are not.

Was there a more recent case+ruling that is more relevant and clarifying? Can you share a reference on that? Thanks.

Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by joshuamorton on Sunday August 22, 2021 @07:54PM (#28270881)
> The Internet Association - quoted in the article - is concerned about the implications of that case but glad to hear you are not.

Yes, hence they provided a brief asking the court to rule a certain way, and the court did, by keeping the ruling particular to Trump's government account.

There isn't any newer or better ruling, you're just misunderstanding this one.

Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by caseysoftware on Sunday August 22, 2021 @10:33PM (#28271780)
> by keeping the ruling particular to Trump's government account.

From the article I cited:

"The Knight First Amendment Institute at Columbia University on August 10 sent the Justice Department a list of 41 accounts that had remained blocked from Trump’s @RealDonaldTrump account. The seven users who filed suit had their accounts unblocked in June."

aka Not his government (@POTUS at the time) account. Once again, misinformation from you. :(

Re:Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech by joshuamorton on Sunday August 22, 2021 @11:25PM (#28272039)
The thing you're still missing is that the ruling was that the @RealDonaldTrump account was being used in an official government capacity, and therefore would fall under said government specific regulations.

If you look at the actual ruling[0], you'll see that on page 9-11 of the ruling, they outline ways in which the @RealDonaldTrump account was used in an official capacity, and on pages 42 and 43, they outline how this is governmental control of the account (but not of twitter as a whole).

Quoting the ruling:

> First, to potentially qualify as a forum, the space in question must be owned or controlled by the government...Here, the government-control prong of the analysis is met. Though Twitter is a...company that is not government-owned, the President and Scavino nonetheless exercise control over various aspects of the @realDonaldTrump account...The President and Scavino’s control over the @realDonaldTrump account is also governmental...the President presents the @realDonaldTrump account as being a presidential account as opposed to a personal account and, more importantly, uses the account to take actions that can be taken only by the President as President

So please, stop crying "misinformation" when you're just wrong about the legalities of the situation. You may disagree with the ruling, but my description of it is factual.

[0]: https://www.politico.com/f/?id=00000163-8e16-dd91-abe7-8f3f5...