News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:macOS 11’s hidden security improvements by hdjjhhvvhga on Friday August 20, 2021 @05:24PM (#28251574)
On the other hand, Linux is getting better and better. And with the prevalence of web apps, the main obstacle to running non (MS | Apple) systems is getting smaller. With Linux, you can adjust the level of security you need and you keep the key. Security improvements appear also in BSDs, especially OpenBSD, but honestly I wouldn't recommend people used to macOS to switch to OpenBSD (yet).
Re:macOS 11’s hidden security improvements by GekkePrutser on Friday August 20, 2021 @05:54PM (#28251843)
Indeed. I switched to FreeBSD myself.

Reasons were the excellent jails system, the ports collection, the ZFS on root (though Ubuntu is starting to offer that) and the great documentation. I also don't like the scale of corporate involvement in Linux development. In the end that leads to companies trying to insert their own IP with a view to monetisation (like Ubuntu with Mir, Upstart, now snaps). It's also the most suitable for a desktop system of all the BSDs I think.

But it's not for everyone. For one the hardware support is limited. I didn't even bother trying to get the WiFi or bluetooth going (I run this on a pure desktop). For laptop use I'd use a flavour of Linux, though I'm not entirely sure which I'd use :) It also doesn't hold your hand as much as most Linux distros, though it's not nearly as barebones as arch either! I'd consider it something a bit in the middle like Manjaro. Overall I'm really happy with it though.

I still use Macs for work though and I administered them for a long time. It's always a struggle if you need to do something that Apple doesn't really want you to do. You may get it working, but there's a good chance it'll get broken in whatever minor patch that's coming along without warning :) Unfortunately in a business with less than 1% Macs you can't always do things the Apple way.

Re:macOS 11’s hidden security improvements by hackshack on Friday August 20, 2021 @09:39PM (#28253287)
A bit off-topic, but as a FreeBSD newbie: This summer I switched my ~6 home servers from CentOS to FreeBSD and absolutely love it. Trigger event was trying to set up a dedicated Linux VM for Ubiquiti's UniFi controller software. I was really fighting various dependencies in CentOS, then Ubuntu Server, then Debian... and saw that FreeBSD had an up-to-date package. Newbie FreeBSD user, from ISO install in a VM, to running Unifi Controller, took maybe 45 minutes. I was impressed and as I dug deeper, I began to appreciate its design.

As a 20+ year Linux user and 10+ year paid Linux admin, BSD has really connected with me as a sysadmin. Besides the clean filesystem structure and updated docs, there's generally "one way to do something" (looking at you, Red Hat...) and surprisingly, the packages are more up to date than I'm used to in CentOS / Ubuntu Server, usually tracking the latest stable releases. For the core system, there appears to be no update churn as with Linux distros.

After I discovered the FreeBSD images for the Raspberry Pi, it scratched my tinkerer itch and now... yeah.

People joke about The Year of Linux on the Desktop, but I believe we've been there since ~2014, when Chromebooks started to really get good. Goes to show a full "desktop environment," as we know it, isn't always needed for a great experience.

Re:macOS 11’s hidden security improvements by breakfastduck on Friday August 20, 2021 @09:02PM (#28253124)
You get that. And about a million tradeoffs in terms of usability. No thanks.

Edit: To those downvoting. If you genueinly think running linux isn't a UIUX downgrade on macOS you are totally deluded. Its more open. Cool. It's also a UX nightmare.

Re:macOS 11’s hidden security improvements by salamandersauce on Friday August 20, 2021 @10:54PM (#28253710)
Nah. It's great. You can view hidden files in the file manager without memorizing a keyboard shortcut or terminal command. Most Window managers don't rely on track pad gestures and so the mouse feels like a first class citizen. Window management in the big DEs is better than macOS. MacOS is a frustrating mess to me.
Re:macOS 11’s hidden security improvements by rsfinn on Saturday August 21, 2021 @12:25AM (#28254177)
To each their own, I guess; in case anyone else is wondering:

"keyboard shortcut": Command-Shift-period

"terminal command": defaults write com.apple.finder AppleShowAllFiles yes

Re:macOS 11’s hidden security improvements by breakfastduck on Sunday August 22, 2021 @07:35PM (#28270781)
The vast majority of users (the U in UX) do not ever need to see a dotfile. In fact, you'd not want them anywhere near one.
Re:macOS 11’s hidden security improvements by salamandersauce on Monday August 23, 2021 @10:49AM (#28276611)
So piss off the users that do? For a while there wasn't even the keyboard shortcut. Throw up a scary warning if you need to but I feel like it's a basic system function that should be included. Some how Windows manages to allow users to toggle hidden files through the GUI and I haven't heard of too many disasters because of it.

I would argue it's actually worse with the keyboard shortcut on OS X because it's completely possible for someone to trigger Cmd+Shift+. accidentally whereas in other OSs it's a clear toggled option in the GUI.

Re:macOS 11’s hidden security improvements by breakfastduck on Tuesday August 24, 2021 @09:10AM (#28288362)
No because 99% of users will never need to look at a dotfile.
Re:macOS 11’s hidden security improvements by salamandersauce on Tuesday August 24, 2021 @07:35PM (#28296358)
99% of users don't need remote SSH login on their Mac yet that has a GUI toggle...
Re:macOS 11’s hidden security improvements by hdjjhhvvhga on Saturday August 21, 2021 @04:16AM (#28255182)
There are many differences between Linux in general and macOS, but I wouldn't name UX as the first advantage of the latter. One of the first things I do on a fresh macOS device is to install Rectangle (previously Spectacle).

I have many gripes with Linux, but not about UX. I use preemptive kernels on the desktop for example, because the vanilla kernel is geared towards more general usage, which practically speaking means servers. Sometimes I need to spend more time when installing some new piece of hardware (and sometimes I don't, it works automatically).

One of the biggest advantages for me personally is that I can diagnose occasional problem myself, down to a single character in the source code if I want/need. I know what is running on my system and why, and if I want, I can remove it. (Or, I can make it very hard to remove.) I know what is getting in and out, and I can block it if I want, without any built-in exceptions for the vendor. When you come to think of it, this should be the default for all systems, but we're heading in the opposite direction.

Re:macOS 11’s hidden security improvements by diragon on Saturday August 21, 2021 @09:20AM (#28256801)
Rectangle is pretty great, thanks for that pointer. I've been trying all kinds of tiling wms on MacOS, but they just don't quite work in this world -- since they're unable to do everything that's needed. But Rectangle allows me to make the decisions, which works a bit better here.

What's still missing with this setup is a shortcut for easily moving a window to another desktop. Any clues how to achieve that?

And finally there's the irritating MacOS UX "feature", that selecting an application with cmd-tab doesn't switch to the desktop where it is, or doesn't unminimize it if it's minimized.

Re:macOS 11’s hidden security improvements by diragon on Saturday August 21, 2021 @02:31AM (#28254762)
I don't think anyone should downvote expressing an opinion, at least when it's done without toxicity like you did. Ok, that "delusion" remark was a bit toxic. But anyway.

Here's my opinion: i3 is vastly superior to anything macos is offering in the desktop space in terms of usability. Sure, wrestling with minutae like proper font rendering and DPI settings is a huge pain, but a) some distros do those things for you and b) if you're not a serial distro hopper / manic reinstaller, those things don't have to be done too often.

I genuinely think it's an UX upgrade. And I've been using macs almost exclusively for 5 years now.

The bad things of Linux are still bad: subsystems get replaced all the time (often with just minimal technical justification), and the replacements are usually (if you compare them to Macs) alpha quality for a long time. And the integration is lacking. Notable contemporary examples: oss/alsa/pulseaudio/jack/pipewire and x11/wayland. This is something I truly don't miss when using macs. Almost everything else I do miss.

Re:macOS 11’s hidden security improvements by journey_16162 on Saturday August 21, 2021 @12:57PM (#28258518)
To me Mac OS has a nicer looking UI, but i3 has better UX. For instance, the animations on Mac OS are annyoing. There is nothing good about adding a delay to basic operations. On i3, I can switch between workspaces in an instant, on Mac OS, I have to wait for a stupid 200ms animation to finish - and that is after already fiddling in system settings to disable fancy animation effects (the default was slide-in, ugh).
Re:macOS 11’s hidden security improvements by breakfastduck on Sunday August 22, 2021 @07:37PM (#28270794)
Fair, but it's not vastly superior for the majority of computer users, whose experience revolves entirely around the mouse. That's what I was getting at with macOS being better - generally, obviously not for every person.
Re:macOS 11’s hidden security improvements by cosmic_quanta on Friday August 20, 2021 @09:04PM (#28253138)
For a new job I've switched to 100% Ubuntu from Windows and I'm not missing much.. What would you be giving up?
Re:macOS 11’s hidden security improvements by breakfastduck on Friday August 20, 2021 @09:09PM (#28253155)
You're not missing anything. Because we're talking about switching from two fundamentally different OS'es.
Re:macOS 11’s hidden security improvements by Pokepokalypse on Friday August 20, 2021 @11:50PM (#28254025)
office365 support? That's about it.
Re:macOS 11’s hidden security improvements by brainbag on Saturday August 21, 2021 @12:20AM (#28254147)
Recently the hard drive in my Mac became inaccessible to MacOS even after formatting and a lot of other things. Somehow it was able to install Linux though, so I did that while waiting on the new drive to arrive. I tried a number of different distributions, and I had the experience you describe. It was death by UX papercuts and I could not wait to get back to MacOS by the second day. I hadn't used Linux in a decade outside of ssh to remote servers, and I really had high hopes for improvements in the UX since I last used it.
Re:macOS 11’s hidden security improvements by GekkePrutser on Saturday August 21, 2021 @08:50AM (#28256570)
Playing with a distribution for 10 minutes and then installing another one is not going to make you understand it. It took me a while to take to KDE too. After you start actually working on it you'll find things that annoy you, start looking and find that there's actually a wealth of configuration options (which macOS absolutely doesn't have).

If you want something more Mac-like, Gnome is a thing of course but it's too opinionated like Mac for me.

Re:macOS 11’s hidden security improvements by brainbag on Saturday August 21, 2021 @09:45AM (#28256968)
Being dismissive of the UX of Linux isn't going to improve the market share of Linux for ex Apple people. I wish Linux was more on par because I don't like where Apple is taking MacOS.

It wasn't ten minutes, and there were way too many configuration options that I couldn't fix (like the terrible trackpad scrolling) despite best efforts that it wasn't worth it, and too many that I didn't want to bother. The point is that out of the box, the UX of the Linux UIs has historically and still does suck compared to tools that have a UX focus, and that's a deal breaker for a lot of people that I know.

Re:macOS 11’s hidden security improvements by livinginfear on Saturday August 21, 2021 @04:39AM (#28255288)
> If you genueinly think running linux isn't a UIUX downgrade....

You've betrayed yourself with this statement. There isn't one Linux. I know this might just seem like more of the complexity non-Linux users want to avoid, however users are free to install whatever desktop environment or window manager they like. You could even opt for a desktop environment that resembles MacOS in most ways.

I use MacOS in my professional life, and Linux in my personal. My Linux PC has my own personalised setup built around the i3 window manager. I can say without question that I'm much faster and more productive on Linux than MacOS.

Re:macOS 11’s hidden security improvements by breakfastduck on Sunday August 22, 2021 @07:40PM (#28270806)
This entire comment proves my point. To you - a developer / tech pro, you feel Linux has a better UX.

My point was generalised, and I think generally the average computer user is going to have a better UX on macOS than linux. If they can figure out how to even set up Linux of course.

Re:macOS 11’s hidden security improvements by ziml77 on Saturday August 21, 2021 @06:17AM (#28255754)
But that's part of the problem. There isn't a single DE which means that any applications that aren't specific to a DE will provide a UX that is inconsistent.
Re:macOS 11’s hidden security improvements by livinginfear on Saturday August 21, 2021 @06:33AM (#28255815)
That's not really true. Outside of tiling window managers, pretty much everything is designed around the same, familiar model of minimise/maximise/close buttons in the corner of the window. Just about every mainstream OS supports different UI toolkits, and for the most part everyone lives with this.

Even tiling window managers don't really have any problems. They provide a very niche UX, which is almost entirely keyboard driven. There's not a single general application I can think of designed for use with this kind of window manager. Still, you get a pretty consistent user experience for the most part.

Re:macOS 11’s hidden security improvements by GekkePrutser on Saturday August 21, 2021 @08:48AM (#28256558)
Apple's own UI is far from consistent either. They're always breaking their own UI guidelines. And many apps are electron which don't integrate well visually either.
Re:macOS 11’s hidden security improvements by robbyking on Friday August 20, 2021 @05:41PM (#28251731)
It's the year of the Linux desktop!
Re:macOS 11’s hidden security improvements by marricks on Friday August 20, 2021 @05:52PM (#28251834)
It always is! (in a good and bad way)
Re:macOS 11’s hidden security improvements by taylorfinley on Friday August 20, 2021 @07:51PM (#28252696)
That's the joke. It's been the 'Year of The Linux Desktop!' at least since my senior year of high school, which was all the way back in 2002.
Re:macOS 11’s hidden security improvements by pram on Friday August 20, 2021 @08:17PM (#28252846)
Although you could literally buy a desktop with Linux at Walmart in 2001 so, maybe that actually was the year.
Re:macOS 11’s hidden security improvements by IncRnd on Friday August 20, 2021 @10:22PM (#28253532)
Except, those quickly disappeared. That's the essence of the joke that was mentioned. Each year was called the year of the Linux Desktop, but it never happened.
Re:macOS 11’s hidden security improvements by pram on Saturday August 21, 2021 @05:55AM (#28255657)
I meant the 'year' had come and gone, 20 years ago.
Re:macOS 11’s hidden security improvements by IncRnd on Saturday August 21, 2021 @10:09AM (#28257129)
Gotcha! Thank you.
Re:macOS 11’s hidden security improvements by dehrmann on Saturday August 21, 2021 @12:25AM (#28254172)
I can't even remember the last year desktop computing was relevant. Professionals absolutely use it, but the market share that has gone to phone, tablets, and chromebooks is incredible.
Re:macOS 11’s hidden security improvements by motoboi on Friday August 20, 2021 @07:51PM (#28252692)
It has been Linux desktop year for at least 15 years now.

The state of Linux Desktop has actually being getting worse, not better.

From a top with Ubuntu in the first 5 years, to the sad state we see now.

Re:macOS 11’s hidden security improvements by kdtsh on Friday August 20, 2021 @10:00PM (#28253402)
Strongly disagree. The experience of Linux on desktop computers has never been better, and has been steadily improving for years. ‘Year of the Linux Desktop’ is of course a meme so it doesn’t really matter how long it has been current year, the fact is that every DE is improving and it has never been easier to be a Linux user.

If there is any criticism that can be made, it’s that the amount of choice can be overwhelming - there are dozens of highly polished, functional distributions - but once you get past that there is no practical limit except the way that Microsoft products like Office are locked away (even this is improving, since you can use Office online).

Re:macOS 11’s hidden security improvements by journey_16162 on Saturday August 21, 2021 @10:59AM (#28257531)
For a developer / power user Linux Desktop is years ahead of Mac OS. I recently bought a Macbook for testing and given how shiny it is, I had the thought to consider using it as a daily computer, but I could not switch because of the obstacles below and I continue being a happy Linux user:

1. Security. On Linux you can setup mandatory access control - i.e. AppArmor, SeLinux, and even if you don't want to fiddle with that, you can create mutliple users for multiple purposes to sandbox your data from untrusted apps. Running a program as another user is no problem on Linux - try it on Mac OS... (I did try it and it almost worked but things like select file dialog won't work, which makes it useless). By the way, Apple introduced some sandboxing capabilities in Catalina, but it's almost insulting because it only allows to restrict Desktop, Downloads and Trash directories, and not allowing the user to restrict other custom directories to certain apps only. And even for Desktop/Downloads it does not work reliably - i.e. I could not isolate a web browser from accessing desktop.

2. Privacy. I accidentally came upon article from a few years ago where it was revealed that Mac OS sends usage data to Apple or a third party on an unencrypted channel. Then there's the recent issue with client side scanning.

3. Desktop experience. This may be cosmetic but I don't like that Mac OS forces a slow 200ms fade animation when switching between desktops. You can't even switch back and forth too fast because the switching mechanism won't catch the hotkey if the slow fade animation is in progress.

The hardware is good though. Really hoping M1 on Linux will become a thing.

Re:macOS 11’s hidden security improvements by livinginfear on Saturday August 21, 2021 @04:44AM (#28255316)
I understand that there are still some pain points for casual users. I first started using Linux on a daily basis in university in the mid 2000s. Back then, even distributions designed for casual users like Ubuntu had problems with everyday tasks like configuring multiple monitors. These days, I don't see any of those problems. I'm pretty confident I could give my parents a computer with Ubuntu 20 on it and they could probably figure out how to do their everyday tasks without any issues.
Re:macOS 11’s hidden security improvements by thevagrant on Friday August 20, 2021 @10:19PM (#28253502)
Give KDE a try on Opensuse Tumbleweed or perhaps KDE Neon. Desktop on linux has improved a lot.
Re:macOS 11’s hidden security improvements by smoldesu on Friday August 20, 2021 @06:32PM (#28252143)
This, a million times. Now that Mojave is starting to get dropped, Linux is exactly what the doctor ordered for me. I feel a lot safer in a system where I can check the locks instead of being told "the door's closed, you're fine."
Re:macOS 11’s hidden security improvements by bdamm on Friday August 20, 2021 @09:29PM (#28253251)
Make no mistake, there are back doors into Linux as well.
Re:macOS 11’s hidden security improvements by livinginfear on Saturday August 21, 2021 @04:48AM (#28255335)
I'm a very privacy conscious Linux user. I'm not doing anything illegal, so I have no active concern about security. I'm not unrealistic. When it comes to my threat profiling, I don't expect my desktop to withstand attack by alphabet-soup US federal agencies. I just want to know that I have complete ownership of my hardware, and my data. I'm satisfied just knowing that a shadowy company like Google, or Apple, is not profiling me. If someone was going to be concerned with security from the government, Linux is still much more preferable than Windows, Android, or MacOS.
Re:macOS 11’s hidden security improvements by anthk on Saturday August 21, 2021 @04:35AM (#28255268)
Very difficult to do so as anyone can create (and distros do) a customized kernel and userland with severally different compiling options.

OpenSSL vs LibreSSL, Glibc vs Musl, X11 vs Arcan (or just the framebuffer/KMS), and so on.

Also, on exploits realize Linux and BSD run in devices very different from X86 right? NetBSD today runs even on Alpha, and 0days won't work with ease there.

Even more with the new RISC-V arches here.

Re:macOS 11’s hidden security improvements by hdjjhhvvhga on Saturday August 21, 2021 @06:17AM (#28255758)
When you think about the utility of such backdoors, the ones in Windows like in Bitlocker are much more useful to intelligence agencies than a similar thing in Linux. As Linux is mainly installed on a server, we are talking about a backdoor that allows defined or arbitrary code execution based on a given signal such as specific connection data. What happens next is also important (a connection is established, a hidden process is created and so on). When you take all this into consideration, hiding a backdoor in the Linux kernel is not the most efficient way to proceed, especially when you normally deal with specific targets. So instead of a full backdoor you would prefer introducing a feature that would play nicely with a zero day you already developed.
Re:macOS 11’s hidden security improvements by PYTHONDJANGO on Saturday August 21, 2021 @12:52PM (#28258469)
You could avoid looking like a clown by adding some URLs to relevant sources to your post.
Re:macOS 11’s hidden security improvements by smoldesu on Friday August 20, 2021 @11:42PM (#28253991)
Care to point out a few that I might accidentally have installed?
Re:macOS 11’s hidden security improvements by h4x0r12345 on Friday August 20, 2021 @09:39PM (#28253285)
Back doors in the Linux kernel source code? No. Back doors in GNU/Linux distribution repositories? Maybe.
Re:macOS 11’s hidden security improvements by taylorfinley on Saturday August 21, 2021 @12:07AM (#28254083)
You don't think, with all the resources available to them, the intelligence community would spend just about whatever it took to sneak a vulnerability or two into the most-run piece of code on the planet? The core devs don't even have to be corrupted--there are 28 million lines of code in the kernel, you don't think a motivated adversary could sneak something past the gate keepers?
Re:macOS 11’s hidden security improvements by anthk on Saturday August 21, 2021 @04:31AM (#28255248)
Any middleware Linux/BSD router could detect suspicious traffic.
Re:macOS 11’s hidden security improvements by PhantomGremlin on Saturday August 21, 2021 @08:03AM (#28256295)
I don't think this is realistic any more. There's just too much noise, too many chatty processes, too much traffic.

A while ago I tried to track the start of a single application, a new install of Firefox. IIRC the first start generated traffic to about a dozen endpoints.

Also, macOS and Windows generate enormous amounts of traffic (others here have noted that).

The amount of background traffic is simply overwhelming. Perhaps security companies can make sense of it all, but it's far too much for most technical people.

I run my own OpenBSD firewall and I've long since given up trying to understand what my Macbooks are doing.

The beauty of OpenBSD itself is that it starts very few daemons, and all source code is available. So it's easy for me to understand what my firewall is doing.

   user@catalina ~ % ps aux |wc -l
        542
vs

   openbsd_user$ ps aux |wc -l                                                                    
         42
Re:macOS 11’s hidden security improvements by anthk on Sunday August 22, 2021 @02:25AM (#28263374)
tcpdump on pflog0 and then use wireshark.
Re:macOS 11’s hidden security improvements by h4x0r12345 on Saturday August 21, 2021 @12:51AM (#28254308)
It's well known that they've already tried to insert back doors many times. On the other side is a huge amount of resources auditing and reviewing the kernel. Many reviewers, auditors, security analysts.
Re:macOS 11’s hidden security improvements by Hackbraten on Saturday August 21, 2021 @02:22AM (#28254715)
Re:macOS 11’s hidden security improvements by Tijdreiziger on Saturday August 21, 2021 @08:32AM (#28256452)
TIL Linus Torvalds' father is a Member of European Parliament.