The decision about what to do with it before flooding the reservoir would depend on things like the timber market at the time and the reason for the dam (many are flood controls that also produce electricity).
>you are suggesting that those trees underwater produce more warming gases than the dirtiest coal plants, MW per MW? A coal plant continuously burning enough coal to get 1000 MWe produces the same amount of warming as a hydro reservoir flooded once that has a dam that produces 1000 MWe?
That's exactly what the research is saying yes. You're talking about 700 sq miles of forest here that was flooded. Not a few trees.
Wonder if such claims aren't made for political motives instead of environmental ones.
https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11027-005-7303-7
I'm happy to be completely wrong on this, but I don't see why it would be true for a dam in Brazil vs. a dam in Canada. BC Government has never studied it. There's absolutely zero incentive for either province to do the research on it.
The springer link unfortunately doesn’t have any numbers for tonnes to compare but mentioned lush Amazon rainforest being flooded and the vegetation at the bottom producing the most methane which is 25x more potent ghg than CO2, resulting in 3.6x equivalent warming than due to burning coal which primarily results in CO2.
0: https://www.visualcapitalist.com/uranium-powering-the-cleane...
That being said, Hydro has a lot of negative externalities even without creating an GHGs, it has poisoned whole ecosystems with mercury for instance, and then there's the impacts on salmon migration.
It seems like an outlandish claim to me.