News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Live electricity production/consumption CO2 map by soperj on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @03:22PM (#28225940)
It only looks amazing because they have never investigated whether or not their hydro power produces emissions.

Based on studies where they've flooded areas without removing trees, hydro plants could be producing more GHGs than even the dirtiest coal plants. Quebec and BC could actually be the dirtiest provinces and we just don't know.

Long story short, when trees decompose in an anaerobic environment, it produces methane instead of CO2, and also takes 4 times longer to decompose.

Re:Live electricity production/consumption CO2 map by AnotherGoodName on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @04:10PM (#28226439)
That'd be a once off though. The dam may exist for such a long timescale that those decomposing trees under the waterline are irrelevant.

I always feel we need to simplify the carbon emissions to the point of "Carbon that was buried and is now in the atmosphere".

This generally removes life in the carbon equation and reasonably so. The carbon in life was in the air relatively recently. Trees absorbed it from the air and other organisms will eat it and re-release it. In general that alone won't revert the earth to the state it was in billions of years ago.

The carbon underground however hasn't been in the atmosphere for billions of years. That's the carbon that's going to return earth to the state it was in billions of years ago. That's what we should focus on.

Re:Live electricity production/consumption CO2 map by soperj on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @05:21PM (#28227341)
No it won't. Trees can take 100 years to decompose in an aerobic environment. Show me a 400 year old dam.
Re:Live electricity production/consumption CO2 map by 908B64B197 on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @05:53PM (#28227644)
[Citation needed]
Re:Live electricity production/consumption CO2 map by soperj on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @06:00PM (#28227702)
Please take your crass comments elsewhere. Instead of consistently questioning my motives, you could try contributing something positive.
Re:Live electricity production/consumption CO2 map by 908B64B197 on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @04:16PM (#28226514)
> hydro plants could be producing more GHGs than even the dirtiest coal plants. Quebec and BC could actually be the dirtiest provinces and we just don't know.

Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidences.

> Long story short, when trees decompose in an anaerobic environment, it produces methane instead of CO2, and also takes 4 times longer to decompose.

Assuming that's true, the GHGs for all the existing dams have been emitted already... making them 0 emissions now and for the rest of their lifetime. And now, if the methane hypothesis is true, this means there are now ways to mitigate that for future dams.

Re:Live electricity production/consumption CO2 map by soperj on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @05:48PM (#28227606)
There are ways to mitigate it for future dams. No, they aren't all emitted, it takes decades for trees to break down in an aerobic environment. Anaerobic is 4 times longer. Most trees in the BC/Quebec areas that were flooded take at minimum 40 years to decay in an aerobic environment.

Here's one about the Curuá-Una dam in Brazil: https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11027-005-7303-7

Key phrase: In 1990 (13 years after filling), the Curuá-Una Dam emitted 3.6 times more greenhouse gases than would have been emitted by generating the same amount of electricity from oil.

Re:Live electricity production/consumption CO2 map by liketochill on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @04:14PM (#28226483)
I don’t think it was that common to flood reservoirs without removing valuable timber first. No matter how long it takes there was a fixed volume of trees that got flooded one time - you are suggesting that those trees underwater produce more warming gases than the dirtiest coal plants, MW per MW? A coal plant continuously burning enough coal to get 1000 MWe produces the same amount of warming as a hydro reservoir flooded once that has a dam that produces 1000 MWe?

It seems like an outlandish claim to me.

Re:Live electricity production/consumption CO2 map by maxerickson on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @05:58PM (#28227687)
There's a cottage industry using remote operated submersibles to extract timber from reservoirs.

The decision about what to do with it before flooding the reservoir would depend on things like the timber market at the time and the reason for the dam (many are flood controls that also produce electricity).

Re:Live electricity production/consumption CO2 map by soperj on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @05:55PM (#28227664)
The reservoirs in BC and Quebec that were flooded were not logged. They're also the largest in NA. Williston Lake is 7th largest in the World. Manicouagan Reservoir is the 5th largest in the World.

>you are suggesting that those trees underwater produce more warming gases than the dirtiest coal plants, MW per MW? A coal plant continuously burning enough coal to get 1000 MWe produces the same amount of warming as a hydro reservoir flooded once that has a dam that produces 1000 MWe?

That's exactly what the research is saying yes. You're talking about 700 sq miles of forest here that was flooded. Not a few trees.

Re:Live electricity production/consumption CO2 map by 908B64B197 on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @04:18PM (#28226535)
> It seems like an outlandish claim to me.

Wonder if such claims aren't made for political motives instead of environmental ones.

Re:Live electricity production/consumption CO2 map by belval on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @04:53PM (#28226993)
They usually are, Québec is borderline hated in Canada for various legitimate and illegitimate reasons and unfortunately that usually makes it hard for people to have an opinion on hydro-québec that is not rooted in their own biases.
Re:Live electricity production/consumption CO2 map by soperj on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @05:58PM (#28227685)
Honestly, this isn't even about Quebec. This came from research into my own province, BC. J'aime le Quebec. Montreal est une de mes villes preferees.
Re:Live electricity production/consumption CO2 map by belval on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @06:34PM (#28227996)
In that case I am sorry I discounted your post, do you happen to have some links I could read? I know mercury can contaminate the reservoir's water and that it has been an issue for some northern communities, but I never heard of the methane thing.
Re:Live electricity production/consumption CO2 map by soperj on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @10:02PM (#28229511)
I've posted one.

https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11027-005-7303-7

I'm happy to be completely wrong on this, but I don't see why it would be true for a dam in Brazil vs. a dam in Canada. BC Government has never studied it. There's absolutely zero incentive for either province to do the research on it.

Re:Live electricity production/consumption CO2 map by liketochill on Thursday August 19, 2021 @03:17PM (#28238084)
This source [0] shows 34 tonnes of CO2 per GWh from hydro and specifically mentions the releases from reservoirs and 820 tonnes per GWh from coal.

The springer link unfortunately doesn’t have any numbers for tonnes to compare but mentioned lush Amazon rainforest being flooded and the vegetation at the bottom producing the most methane which is 25x more potent ghg than CO2, resulting in 3.6x equivalent warming than due to burning coal which primarily results in CO2.

0: https://www.visualcapitalist.com/uranium-powering-the-cleane...

Re:Live electricity production/consumption CO2 map by 908B64B197 on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @05:56PM (#28227669)
Oil and Gas lobbies must love it. These folks are doing their (paid) lobbying... for free!
Re:Live electricity production/consumption CO2 map by soperj on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @06:15PM (#28227824)
I feel like I'm doing myself a disservice here even responding to you, but pointing out that Hydro is contributing massively to released GHGs isn't lobbying for oil and gas. It's saying that people need to get their head out of the sand if they actually want to positively impact the environment. There are clean energy generating technologies, hydro can be one if done right, in BC and Quebec it wasn't.

That being said, Hydro has a lot of negative externalities even without creating an GHGs, it has poisoned whole ecosystems with mercury for instance, and then there's the impacts on salmon migration.