News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mastodon now a non-profit organisation by detaro on Tuesday August 17, 2021 @04:56AM (#28207667)
What gives you the impression that "maximized free speech" is the goal of Mastodon?
Re:Mastodon now a non-profit organisation by Vinnl on Tuesday August 17, 2021 @05:26AM (#28207835)
And as a hint about whether that is a goal, take a look at Mastodon's instance picker [1], which says:

> We only list communities that are committed to active moderation against racism, sexism and transphobia.

[1] https://joinmastodon.org/communities

Re:Mastodon now a non-profit organisation by snthd on Tuesday August 17, 2021 @05:59AM (#28208060)
Re:Mastodon now a non-profit organisation by asutekku on Tuesday August 17, 2021 @05:53AM (#28208003)
That’s just basic human decency right there.
Re:Mastodon now a non-profit organisation by user-the-name on Tuesday August 17, 2021 @06:02AM (#28208085)
You will find that a lot of people crying about free speech do not place much value on basic human decency.
Re:Mastodon now a non-profit organisation by FeepingCreature on Tuesday August 17, 2021 @07:38AM (#28208774)
You are correct - as a person who cares deeply about free speech, I certainly place less value on basic decency.

To my mind, the correct response to violations of decency is giving people strong tools to screen and filter out content they don't like. The wrong response is centralized enforcement. Inasmuch as centralized enforcement would be better at enforcing "basic decency", I will confirm that I place its priority at a lower level than avoiding centralized enforcement.

I hold this view because in my opinion, I am far more likely to be harmed by attempts to enforce some unilateral definition of "basic decency" than the very indecency they aim to prevent. (I believe this is called the "paradox of tolerance", though few know it in that formulation.)

Re:Mastodon now a non-profit organisation by wizzwizz4 on Tuesday August 17, 2021 @09:23AM (#28209550)
Then you'll like the Fediverse, then. (Though the tools aren't particularly good, yet… perhaps you could help?)
Re:Mastodon now a non-profit organisation by FeepingCreature on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @12:21AM (#28217760)
Not sure - I think federation and defederation is the wrong approach. I think a network should decouple routing and moderation, and make both independently subscribable.
Re:Mastodon now a non-profit organisation by wizzwizz4 on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @04:44AM (#28218928)
It does, for the most part! Defederation is the last resort, when you've got an instance that nobody wants to deal with (e.g. the people there are tracking down and harassing your users, and you want them to “win” and therefore stop). User-level moderation tools are much more common, though they're currently a bit lacking.
Re:Mastodon now a non-profit organisation by legostormtroopr on Tuesday August 17, 2021 @06:24AM (#28208242)
This is a really bad faith comment
Re:Mastodon now a non-profit organisation by user-the-name on Tuesday August 17, 2021 @06:45AM (#28208401)
Why? "Active moderation against racism, sexism and transphobia" is, indeed, just basic human decency.

And people keep saying, over and over and over, that doing this is against "freedom of speech".

Re:Mastodon now a non-profit organisation by stjohnswarts on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @12:09AM (#28217693)
Exactly there is nothing stopping them from taking mastodon source code and making their own little hate parade off in another niche of the internet. Basically "your rights end at the tip of your nose" when it comes to what I want on my own network.
Re:Mastodon now a non-profit organisation by nsizx on Tuesday August 17, 2021 @07:01AM (#28208501)
It is, actually. Once you restrict what others can say there's no freedom of speech anymore. It's like China saying you can't talk about the regime - I'm sure they consider that "basic human decency" as well.
Re:Mastodon now a non-profit organisation by dgb23 on Tuesday August 17, 2021 @07:29AM (#28208709)
It's not a restriction of freedom of speech. This is just exercising freedom of association.

"If you're an asshole, I won't broadcast your stuff."

People are still free to be assholes, but the platform is free to not associate themselves with the assholes.

Very simple.

Re:Mastodon now a non-profit organisation by Kye on Tuesday August 17, 2021 @07:50AM (#28208858)
It's even open source. Anyone who disagrees with the project's listing policy can make their own list.

https://source.joinmastodon.org/mastodon/joinmastodon

Re:Mastodon now a non-profit organisation by M2Ys4U on Tuesday August 17, 2021 @07:08AM (#28208559)
>Once you restrict what others can say there's no freedom of speech anymore.

If you go by that definition then there is no country on Earth that has freedom of speech.

And that's a good thing because that definition is completely and utterly insane; Absolute freedom of speech would be a catastrophe.

Re:Mastodon now a non-profit organisation by Kaze404 on Tuesday August 17, 2021 @07:09AM (#28208573)
Freedom of speech isn't freedom to be a bigot. You can say whatever you want, but that doesn't mean the rest of the world has to listen.
Re:Mastodon now a non-profit organisation by JadeNB on Tuesday August 17, 2021 @09:14AM (#28209470)
> Freedom of speech isn't freedom to be a bigot. You can say whatever you want, but that doesn't mean the rest of the world has to listen.

To be clear, it is freedom to be a bigot, or at least to say bigoted things, just not freedom to have anyone else listen to those things (or, as hopefully goes without saying, for any action based on those bigoted things that goes beyond words).

Re:Mastodon now a non-profit organisation by wizzwizz4 on Tuesday August 17, 2021 @09:26AM (#28209572)
> just not freedom to have anyone else listen to those things

This implies freedom to remember you say bigoted things and proactively avoid you.

Re:Mastodon now a non-profit organisation by JadeNB on Tuesday August 17, 2021 @10:43AM (#28210377)
> This implies freedom to remember you say bigoted things and proactively avoid you.

Certainly. Freedom of speech, not freedom from consequences, as they say.

Re:Mastodon now a non-profit organisation by dane-pgp on Tuesday August 17, 2021 @04:37PM (#28214564)
“There is freedom of speech, but I cannot guarantee freedom after speech.”

― Idi Amin

https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/9082497-there-is-freedom-of...

Re:Mastodon now a non-profit organisation by JadeNB on Tuesday August 17, 2021 @06:28PM (#28215526)
That's not the company into which I'd prefer to be lumped as a believer in free speech with consequences. I'm not sure whether or not that was your point ….
Re:Mastodon now a non-profit organisation by dane-pgp on Tuesday August 17, 2021 @10:01PM (#28217001)
I'm saying that unless you're really careful to specify what sort of "consequences" you're talking about, it's hard to separate your beliefs from his.
Re:Mastodon now a non-profit organisation by JadeNB on Tuesday August 17, 2021 @10:21PM (#28217128)
> I'm saying that unless you're really careful to specify what sort of "consequences" you're talking about, it's hard to separate your beliefs from his.

Since you refer to them as "my beliefs", I assume that yours are different. With no sarcasm, what are your beliefs? If you argue against the claim that freedom of speech does not entail freedom from consequences, is your position that freedom of speech should come with freedom from consequences? Surely it's not hard to imagine how that, too, can be a dangerous position to take.

Re:Mastodon now a non-profit organisation by FeepingCreature on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @12:19AM (#28217741)
Different poster, but I believe that freedom of speech not just does, but must come with freedom from consequences to be at all meaningful. Of course, there is nowhere that actually has that level of freedom of speech, but seen as a spectrum it makes sense.

Freedom of speech is freedom from consequences:

- of government reprisals

- of corporate reprisals

- of criminal reprisals

- of employment risks

- of relationship risks.

Pick and choose which matter to you. To me, freedom of speech applies to all, but other rights such as freedom of association sometimes override it. (And sometimes not.)

Re:Mastodon now a non-profit organisation by shadowgovt on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @08:17AM (#28220108)
The only speech that has no impact on that entire spectrum of human interaction is things never said.

I don't think people generally want a lack of response to their speech (if they did, they're saying nothing... Just making babbling noises best ignored). People want freedom from negative consequences. In short, people want to eat their cake and have their cake.

This is why every country ends up with laws that carve out some spectrum of consequences as inappropriate, but those laws are not all-encompassing... It is functionally impossible to eliminate all the consequences you've listed from the table while still giving listeners freedom to be their own independent agents and modify their behavior in reaction to speech. In particular, the last category you listed is a huge infringement on personal liberty of generally applied... I assume you don't expect a person in a committed relationship, hearing their partner say "I hate everything about my partner and I wish we'd never met," to not modify or end the relationship? Any legal infringement on their right to do so is an obvious curtailment of their rights.

In short, sometimes freedom of speech and freedom of association collide. One is a freedom of the speaker, the other freedom of the listener.

Re:Mastodon now a non-profit organisation by JadeNB on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @01:05PM (#28224149)
> Freedom of speech is freedom from consequences: … of relationship risks.

Wait, seriously? If I choose whether to have a relationship with someone based on the things they say, then you regard that as an infringement on their freedom of speech? You do later say:

> … other rights such as freedom of association sometimes override it. (And sometimes not.)

… but I don't really understand this as a statement of position. It seems to be saying that freedom of speech should not have consequences, except when it does, except when it doesn't, and I wind up not really sure what position is being espoused.

Re:Mastodon now a non-profit organisation by FeepingCreature on Thursday August 19, 2021 @01:10AM (#28230559)
I'm saying freedom of speech should not have unwanted consequences, and in that sense it cuts far beyond what anyone considers reasonable. However, that doesn't make the definition wrong; it just means we better get comfortable with balancing conflicting interests.
Re:Mastodon now a non-profit organisation by stjohnswarts on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @12:11AM (#28217704)
Exactly it's why I send money to ACLU and EFF. I'll spend money to help defend your right to say what you want, but I'll be damned if I have to listen to your BS on my own time. I'm just there to stop the government from outlawing freedom of speech.
Re:Mastodon now a non-profit organisation by sneak on Tuesday August 17, 2021 @07:27AM (#28208687)
Human decency involves not telling other adults what they are allowed to peaceably publish or read.

I find imposing censorship on others a denial of their basic rights to free expression, and is itself an indecent act.

Re:Mastodon now a non-profit organisation by swiley on Tuesday August 17, 2021 @07:55AM (#28208902)
You'll note quoto.org is at the top of the technology oriented instance list. I know the admin to some degree (he followed me almost immediately after I joined) and while he won't tolerate you using his instance to harass people he's vocally tolerant of good faith arguments in favor of unpopular ideas and won't prevent you from following any account publishing legal content.

While free speech is not a goal of Mastodon the technology is very conducive to it and many of the admins are reasonable people.

[1]https://joinmastodon.org/communities/tech

Re:Mastodon now a non-profit organisation by sneak on Tuesday August 17, 2021 @08:59AM (#28209344)
That's nice to hear. A lot of instance admins will defederate other instances based only on rumor or suspicion of wrongthink, preventing all of their users from following accounts on those instances even if they want to. This has happened to my single user instance simply based on my political beliefs (primarily the right to free peaceful expression, you'd think that would be less controversial), not any content actually posted.

It's a big problem in the fediverse, because one has to be a little bit of an activist in the first place to exit twitter, and these days popular activism and censorship overlap a lot.

Re:Mastodon now a non-profit organisation by swiley on Tuesday August 17, 2021 @09:11AM (#28209434)
I remember seeing a defederation list a while ago that was supposedly for "alt-right/nazi" instances.

It of course contained qoto and fosstodon due to their being pro free speech.

Re:Mastodon now a non-profit organisation by Kye on Tuesday August 17, 2021 @07:29AM (#28208705)
>> "Human decency involves not telling other adults what they are allowed to peaceably publish or read."

So you agree the Mastodon project should be able to decide not to publish certain instances in the list it maintains. Cool.

Freedom is not meaningful without the freedom to not do something. If they're compelled to publish things they don't agree with, then they don't really have free speech.

Re:Mastodon now a non-profit organisation by sneak on Tuesday August 17, 2021 @07:55AM (#28208905)
Yes, I do. I also believe in my right to criticize them for appointing themselves censors.

This need to paternalistically protect other adults from online content "for their own good" is authoritarian and rude and I hope it goes out of fashion right soon.

It's extra bothersome when instance admins (unrelated to the mastodon project) decide for their users what they should be allowed to read.

Imagine if your email service decided you couldn't send or receive email to certain domains they decided were "bad people".

Re:Mastodon now a non-profit organisation by cortesoft on Tuesday August 17, 2021 @11:30AM (#28210971)
> Imagine if your email service decided you couldn't send or receive email to certain domains they decided were "bad people".

Almost every email provider does something like this - it is called a spam filter. If email of a certain type comes in, it doesn’t go into your inbox. Is that censorship?

Sure, you can go into your spam folder and see it, just like mastodon users can connect to an instance not listed on the main mastodon list.

Curating content is not a sin.

Re:Mastodon now a non-profit organisation by novok on Tuesday August 17, 2021 @01:37PM (#28212592)
You can turn off your spam filter if you want to, you can't turn off the defederation disconnect. One is opt-in curation, the other is not. I hope we get smart opt-in curation on a user by user basis soon, and you could subscribe to certain curators as you want.
Re:Mastodon now a non-profit organisation by cortesoft on Tuesday August 17, 2021 @02:55PM (#28213476)
How is spam filtering an opt-in curation? I never enabled it on my gmail account, it was just on.

Can Mastodon servers not choose to federate with other servers outside the central Mastodon service?

Re:Mastodon now a non-profit organisation by FeepingCreature on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @12:20AM (#28217749)
I wish I could turn my Yahoo spam filter off.