"The commonly used leading digit of 4 is a historical reference to a sample rate roughly four times the NTSC or PAL color subcarrier frequency; the notation originated when subcarrier-locked sampling was under discussion for component video. Upon the adoption of component video sampling at 13.5 MHz, the first digit came to specify luma sample rate relative to 3 3⁄8 MHz. HDTV was once supposed to be described as 22:11:11! Since then, the leading digit has – thank-fully – come to be relative to the sample rate in use. Until recently, the initial digit was always 4, since all chroma ratios have been powers of two – 4, 2, or 1. However, 3:1:1 subsampling has been commercialized in an HDTV production system (Sony’s HDCAM), so 3 may now appear as the leading digit. By convention, a leading digit of 2 is never used."
And here is lots of detailed history: https://tech.ebu.ch/docs/techreview/trev_304-rec601_wood.pdf , including a lot of debate in the late 70's about "three-times sub-carrier (3fsc) versus four-times sub-carrier (4fsc) sampling." The victory for team "4" is, I think, why that's the leading digit, even though they ended up compromising on not-quite-4 in the end.
Okay, the real reason, as far as the bundles of paper I have* is accurate, is that digital chroma subsampling was first invented for MUSE, a Japanese analogue HD video standard (with pre-broadcast digital components). They chose four for horizontal because it's relatively easy to manipulate using their digital systems at the time and two for vertical so that it's easy to handle interlacing stuff. Unfortunately, I'm not Sony or NHK so I can't say for certain why not eight or any other powers of two. Also, Americans (aka the SMPTE) set the 1,080 lines (the Japanese standard is 1,025), the 16:9 compromise (between the European and Japanese 15:9 and cinema 21:9) and the "limited RGB" dilemma that is experienced in digital video systems (that's literally from the days of NTSC signalling!). Both the Japanese NHK/Sony MUSE system and the British IBA (adopted as European) D-MAC system uses the full-range 8-bit system that is used for JPEG (pre-broadcast to analogue, of course).
Analogous to this, the reason why CD audio is 44,100 Hz is because that's the commonality between NTSC (System M, 525-line 480-visible 60-Hz) and 625-line (576-visible 50-Hz) systems. Digital audio was literally stored on U-matic systems at the time, and it was initially only 14-bit PCM rather than the 16-bit PCM of CDs.
* or rather, my employer's mini-library.
"Now, let's break it down the differences between 4:4:4; 4:2:2 and 4:2:0:
The number of pixels that share color is determined by what type of chroma subsampling it is. Each sample is defined by a block of 8 pixels. The first number refers to the size of the sample and its pattern, which is typically 4 pixels wide. The second number refers to how many pixels in the top row will receive color or chroma sampling. The third number shows how many pixels on the bottom row will receive chroma samples"[0]
The block sizes and sub-sampling methods are also why there are warnings issued when trying to scale an image when the dimensions are not divisible by the block sizes. If you try to scale to an odd number, then the sampling within the blocks is broken. If you scale to a number not divisible evenly by the largest block sizes requested, then you also get issues.
[0] https://blog.westpennwire.com/what-is-chroma-subsampling
I assume it is because with 4 you have 3 different subsampling ratios (if you want to keep factors of two, which you typically want to keep algorithms simple)
I "surely" look forward to your Show HN write up on your new compression algorithm. We've been iteratively getting better at compression for some time now. It seems like everytime it looks like we've wrung every bit out of DCT, someone comes up with some a little more clever. Wavelets looked promising, but never took off.
>why does 480p upsampled ever look better than 1080p at the same bitrate
That's a very vague question. Are you stating that you think 480p upsampled to 1080p at 1.5Mbps looks better than a source at 1080p at 1.5Mbps? I have a hard time believing this to be true.
To understand why the chroma is sub-sampled and not the luminance has to do with how the cones/rods in the eyes work. There's a lot of things you can get away with (or trick if you will) the brain in what it is seeing. Is it better to lose half the height or half the width? Is it better loose more red than green or blue?
The first number represents the luminance.[0] Even if they know the first number represents luminance, the "don't ask me why" is just horrible on its own. The detail in the image is preserved through the luminance channel. The subsampling in the chroma is much less perceptable to humans, but more more noticeable in the luminance. Therefore, some very smart people learned to cheat the data saved for chroma, but not the luminance. "don't ask me why" in detailed write ups is just bad in so many ways.
[0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chroma_subsampling